Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

games-and-information-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Games and Information in Higher Categories

View paper · Download original file

Lines 4441–4540 of 6559. Source text is displayed literally.

4441Finally, let the sender influence the signal by an action that the receiver does not observe.4442 4443\begin{example}[Career concerns]\label{ex:career}\Scl[\cite{Hol99}]4444A manager's output is $y=\eta+a+\varepsilon$, where $\eta\sim N(m,\sigma_\eta^2)$ is her unknown talent, $a$ her4445unobserved effort at cost $c(a)$, and $\varepsilon\sim N(0,\sigma_\varepsilon^2)$. After seeing $y$ the market pays4446her next-period wage equal to its expectation of $\eta$. If the market conjectures effort $a^*$, it computes4447\[ \E[\eta\mid y]=m+\kappa\,(y-m-a^*),\qquad\kappa=\frac{\sigma_\eta^2}{\sigma_\eta^2+\sigma_\varepsilon^2}. \]4448The manager, taking the conjecture as given, gains $\kappa$ in future wage per unit of effort, so with4449discount factor $\delta$ she chooses $c'(a)=\delta\kappa$. In equilibrium $a=a^*$: the market correctly4450subtracts her effort, and her wage is exactly what it would have been had she and everyone else known she4451would not exert it. She works to bias an inference that is not biased.4452\end{example}4453 4454The logic is the lens structure of \cref{ch:open,ch:belief} made vivid. The market's inference is the4455backward pass, and it is computed from the \emph{conjectured} forward pass. A deviation by the manager4456changes the actual forward pass and leaves the backward pass fixed. So although no one is fooled on the4457equilibrium path, the equilibrium effort is pinned down by the return to fooling off it. The same4458structure gives \emph{limit pricing} \cite{MR82b}: an incumbent whose cost is private information prices4459below the monopoly level to signal low cost to a potential entrant; in the separating equilibrium the4460entrant infers the cost correctly and enters exactly when she would under complete information, and the4461only effect of the attempt to deter entry is a lower price before it. In signal-jamming models of predation4462\cite{FT86} the same holds with an unobserved action in place of a private type. In all three, competition4463for the receiver's belief is wasteful or beneficial according to whether the distorting action is, as it4464happens, something third parties value: effort and low prices are; education, in Spence's model, is not.4465 4466\section*{Notes}4467 4468Signalling is due to Spence \cite{Spe73}. The intuitive criterion is from Cho and Kreps \cite{CK87} and4469its strengthenings from Banks and Sobel \cite{BS87}; their relation to strategic stability is discussed in4470both. Strategic information transmission with costless messages is Crawford and Sobel's \cite{CS82}.4471Bayesian persuasion is due to Kamenica and Gentzkow \cite{KG11}, building on the concavification4472technique of Aumann and Maschler \cite{AM95}; the many-receiver generalization is \cite{BM16}. Career4473concerns are from Holmstr\"om \cite{Hol99}, limit pricing as signalling from Milgrom and Roberts4474\cite{MR82b}, and signal jamming from Fudenberg and Tirole \cite{FT86}. The source text4475\cite[ch.~11]{Ras06} treats the education model in several variants and discusses when signalling is4476productive; the distinction between informed-moves-first and uninformed-moves-first models is its4477organizing device and has been kept here.4478 4479\section*{Exercises}4480 4481\begin{exercise}4482In \cref{ex:spence}, find all hybrid equilibria in which the low type randomizes between $e=0$ and the high4483type's signal. Which of them satisfy the intuitive criterion?4484\end{exercise}4485\begin{exercise}4486Suppose education is productive: a worker of type $\theta$ with education $e$ produces4487$\theta(1+\tfrac12\sqrt{e})$. Find the Riley outcome and compare the high type's education with its efficient level.4488\end{exercise}4489\begin{exercise}4490For the cheap-talk model, derive the cutoff equation from the indifference of the boundary type, and4491compute the receiver's expected loss in the $N$-interval equilibrium for $b=\tfrac1{20}$ and $N=1,2,3$.4492\end{exercise}4493\begin{exercise}4494Verify \cref{ex:persuasion}, including the probability $\tfrac27$, and compute the optimal experiment when4495the prior is $0.5$.4496\end{exercise}4497\begin{exercise}4498Show that the map $m\colon\Dist\Dist\Omega\to\Dist\Omega$ is affine and that the fibre $m^{-1}(\mu_0)$ is convex.4499Exhibit two different experiments with two signals each that induce the same $\tau$.4500\end{exercise}4501\begin{exercise}4502In \cref{ex:career} let $c(a)=\tfrac12a^2$. Compute equilibrium effort, and compare it with the efficient4503effort $c'(a)=1$. For which parameters does the manager work too hard?4504\end{exercise}4505%% ---- end ch/15-signalling.tex ----4506\part{Applications}4507%% ---- begin ch/16-bargaining.tex ----4508\chapter{Bargaining}\label{ch:bargaining}4509 4510Two parties can create a surplus by agreeing and must divide it. There are two classical theories of the4511division. Nash's axiomatic theory asks what a solution must look like if it respects the symmetries of the4512problem. Rubinstein's strategic theory writes down a game of offers and counteroffers and finds its4513equilibrium. This chapter presents each in the terms developed in Part~I---the first as an equivariant4514natural map, the second as the unique fixed point of a contraction---and then shows, with the tools of4515\cref{ch:mechanism}, why bargaining under two-sided private information cannot be efficient.4516 4517\section{The axiomatic solution}4518 4519\begin{definition}4520A \term{bargaining problem} is a pair $(S,d)$ of a compact convex set $S\subset\R^2$ of feasible utility4521pairs and a disagreement point $d\in S$, with some $s\in S$ strictly better than $d$ for both. A4522\term{solution} assigns to each problem a point of $S$.4523\end{definition}4524 4525\begin{theorem}[Nash]\label{thm:nash-bargaining}\Scl[\cite{Nas50b}]4526There is exactly one solution that is (i) Pareto efficient, (ii) symmetric, (iii) invariant under positive4527affine transformations of either player's utility, and (iv) independent of irrelevant alternatives: if4528$S'\subseteq S$ contains the solution of $(S,d)$, then it is the solution of $(S',d)$. It is4529\[ \phi(S,d)=\argmax_{s\in S,\ s\ge d}\ (s_1-d_1)(s_2-d_2). \]4530\end{theorem}4531 4532Read the axioms as statements about a category. Let the objects be bargaining problems. Axioms (ii) and4533(iii) say that the solution is \emph{equivariant} under the group generated by exchanging the players and4534rescaling utilities: it is a function on the type of bargaining problems \emph{up to} the equivalences that4535von Neumann--Morgenstern utility imposes, in the sense of \cref{prin:invariance} and \cref{thm:vnm}. They are4536not substantive assumptions about bargaining; they are the requirement that the question be well posed.4537Axiom (iv) is of a different kind. It says that the solution is \emph{natural} with respect to a class of4538non-invertible morphisms, the inclusions $S'\hookrightarrow S$ that keep the solution feasible. This is the4539substantive axiom, and different choices of morphisms give different theories: requiring instead4540monotonicity with respect to expansions of $S$ that preserve each player's best feasible payoff