Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism

View paper · Download original file

Lines 2941–3040 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.

2941\section{What the classification is the \texorpdfstring{$\pi_0$}{pi-0} of}2942 2943\Cref{tab:surfaces} collects the chapter. In each row the first entry is a statement of the source or a2944direct consequence, and the second is the statement about a space or a category of which it is the shadow on2945components.2946 2947\begin{table}[ht]\centering\small2948\begin{tabular}{@{}p{0.43\textwidth}p{0.47\textwidth}@{}}2949\toprule2950classical statement & of which it is $\pi_0$ or the homotopy category\\2951\midrule2952closed surfaces are $\Sigma_g$, $N_h$ & $\mathcal M_2\simeq\coprod B\Diff$; \cref{thm:EE}\\2953$\mathfrak N_2=\Z/2$, $\Omega_2=0$ & $B\Cob_2\simeq\Omega^{\infty-1}MTO(2)$; \cref{thm:GMTW}\\2954generators and relations for $2\cat{Cob}$ & presentation of $\Bord_2$; \cref{thm:SP,thm:CH}\\2955a diffeomorphism of $S^1$ is isotopic to an isometry & $\Diff(S^1)\simeq\Or(2)$\\2956connected sum is well defined & $\Emb(D^2,M)\simeq\Fr(TM)$; \cref{thm:discs}\\2957stable range for $H_*(B\Gamma_g)$ & $\Z\times B\Gamma_\infty^+\simeq\Omega^\infty MTSO(2)$; \cref{thm:MW}\\2958\bottomrule2959\end{tabular}2960\caption{Surfaces: classical statements and the homotopy types behind them.}\label{tab:surfaces}2961\end{table}2962 2963\section*{Notes}2964 2965The classification of surfaces is from the nineteenth century (Möbius, Jordan, Dyck); proofs by Morse2966theory are in Hirsch and in Gramain's notes. The equivalence between two-dimensional field theories and2967Frobenius algebras is folklore from the late 1980s; \cite{Koc04} is a careful account. The unoriented2968analogue is due to Turaev and Turner. For mapping class groups see Farb and Margalit; for the Madsen--Weiss2969theorem and its descendants, Galatius and Randal-Williams.2970 2971\section*{Exercises}2972 2973\begin{exercise}\label{exer:words}2974Identify the closed surfaces given by the words $aba^{-1}b^{-1}$, $abab$, $abab^{-1}$, $aabb$,2975$abca^{-1}b^{-1}c^{-1}$ and $abcabc$.2976\end{exercise}2977 2978\begin{exercise}\label{exer:TP}2979Deduce $T\#P\cong P\#P\#P$ from \cref{thm:classification}, using $\chi(M\#N)=\chi(M)+\chi(N)-2$.2980\end{exercise}2981 2982\begin{exercise}\label{exer:frob}2983Verify \cref{ex:frob}, and show that for a semisimple commutative Frobenius algebra $A=\bigoplus_ik\,e_i$ with2984$\varepsilon(e_i)=\theta_i$ one has $Z(\Sigma_g)=\sum_i\theta_i^{1-g}$.2985\end{exercise}2986 2987\begin{exercise}\label{exer:pants}2988Let $W$ be a compact connected surface with a Morse function $f\colon W\to[a,b]$, $\partial W=f^{-1}\{a,b\}$,2989having exactly one critical point, of index $1$. Show that $\chi(W)=-1$, and that $W$ is a disc with two2990holes if it is orientable and a Möbius band with one hole if it is not.2991\end{exercise}2992 2993\begin{exercise}\label{exer:torusdim}2994Show from the relations of \cref{thm:2cob} that $Z(T^2)=\dim Z(S^1)$ for every two-dimensional field theory2995with values in vector spaces.2996\end{exercise}2997%% ---- end ch/11-surfaces.tex ----2998\part{Assessment}2999%% ---- begin ch/12-coda.tex ----3000\chapter{What the Language Did}\label{ch:coda}3001 3002The two earlier volumes of this series ended with an assessment of how much of their higher-categorical3003vocabulary was doing work. The same question is asked here, and the answer is different in both directions:3004more of the vocabulary is essential, and less of the mathematics is touched by it.3005 3006\section{Where the proofs live}3007 3008\begin{principle}[Four inputs]\label{prin:inputs}\Sob3009The theorems of the source cited in this book are derived there from four analytic facts and the topology of3010function spaces: the inverse function theorem; the existence of partitions of unity; the Morse--Sard3011theorem; and the existence, uniqueness and smooth dependence of solutions of ordinary differential3012equations. The first gives \cref{thm:transpull} and tubular neighbourhoods. The second gives approximation,3013collars, and every passage from local to global. The third gives transversality and so every genericity3014statement. The fourth gives the regular interval theorem, isotopy extension, and the handle description of a3015critical point.3016\end{principle}3017 3018None of the four is proved, shortened, or explained by anything in this book. The categorical statements3019begin where the four inputs end. \Cref{thm:CS} characterizes derived manifolds, but that the transverse3020fibre products exist is the inverse function theorem, and that they are dense is Sard's theorem.3021\Cref{thm:concordance} classifies concordance classes, but its proof uses partitions of unity in an3022essential way. \Cref{thm:palais} says that restriction is a fibration, and the lifting is done by3023integrating a vector field. What the language provides is the form of the conclusions, and the form matters3024for what can be done next.3025 3026\section{The source as a book about components}3027 3028\begin{table}[ht]\centering\small3029\begin{tabular}{@{}p{0.36\textwidth}p{0.52\textwidth}@{}}3030\toprule3031theorem of the source & the statement of which it is the shadow on $\pi_0$\\3032\midrule3033homotopic maps pull back isomorphic bundles; classification (4.2.4, 4.3.4) & $\Pi[M,B\GL_k]\simeq\Map(M,B\Or(k))$ (\cref{thm:concordance})\\3034tubular neighbourhoods and collars are unique up to isotopy (4.5.3, 4.6) & the spaces of them are contractible (\cref{thm:tubcontract,thm:collar})\\3035Hopf's theorem (5.1.10) & $S^n\to K(\Z,n)$ is $(n+1)$-connected; Pontryagin--Thom in $M$\\3036invariance of intersection numbers (5.2.1) & derived fibre products have cobordism classes (\cref{thm:spivak})\\3037$\chi$ by vector fields equals $\chi$ by homology (6.3.8) & a trace computed before and after a monoidal functor (\cref{thm:DP})\\3038regular interval theorem (6.2.2) & families of compact manifolds are classified by $\coprod B\Diff$ (\cref{thm:ehresmann})\\3039Thom's theorem (7.2.3) & $B\Cob_d\simeq\Omega^{\infty-1}MTO(d)$ (\cref{thm:GMTW})\\3040isotopy extension (8.1.3) & $\Diff_c(M)\to\Emb(V,M)$ is a fibre bundle (\cref{thm:palais})\\