Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism

View paper · Download original file

Lines 2821–2920 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.

2821Connected sum is well defined on connected surfaces up to diffeomorphism, by \cref{thm:discs} and the fact2822that every surface admits a diffeomorphism reversing the orientation of a small disc up to isotopy when it2823is non-orientable, and that $\Sigma_g$ admits an orientation-reversing diffeomorphism. Write $T=\Sigma_1$ and2824$P=\RP^2$.2825 2826\begin{corollary}\label{cor:monoid}\Scl[Hirsch 9.1.7]2827Under connected sum, the diffeomorphism classes of closed connected surfaces form the commutative monoid2828with unit $S^2$, generators $T$ and $P$, and the single relation $T\#P=P\#P\#P$.2829\end{corollary}2830 2831A surface is often presented by a word: a polygon with $2n$ sides labelled by $n$ letters, each occurring2832twice, with exponents giving the direction of identification. The quotient has one face and $n$ edges, so2833$\chi=V-n+1$ with $V$ the number of vertex classes, and it is orientable exactly when every letter occurs2834once with each exponent. The script computes $V$ by a union--find pass and identifies $aba^{-1}b^{-1}$ as2835the torus, $abab$ as the projective plane, $abab^{-1}$ as the Klein bottle, and so on (\cref{exer:words}).2836 2837\section{The classification as a presentation}2838 2839Let $2\cat{Cob}$ be the symmetric monoidal category whose objects are finite disjoint unions of circles and2840whose morphisms are diffeomorphism classes of compact oriented cobordisms: the homotopy category of2841$\Cob^{\mathrm{or}}_2$ of \cref{def:cobcat}. By \cref{thm:handle} every cobordism is a composite of the four2842elementary ones given by a single critical point: the disc as a cobordism $\emptyset\to S^1$ (index $0$) and2843$S^1\to\emptyset$ (index $2$), and the pair of pants as a cobordism from two circles to one and from one to2844two (index $1$).2845 2846\begin{theorem}\label{thm:2cob}\Scl[folklore; Abrams \cite{Abr96}; Kock \cite{Koc04}]2847$2\cat{Cob}$ is generated as a symmetric monoidal category by2848\[\eta\colon\emptyset\to S^1,\qquad\epsilon\colon S^1\to\emptyset,\qquad2849\mu\colon S^1\sqcup S^1\to S^1,\qquad\delta\colon S^1\to S^1\sqcup S^1,\]2850subject to the relations: $(\mu,\eta)$ is a commutative monoid, $(\delta,\epsilon)$ is a cocommutative2851comonoid, and2852$(\mu\sqcup\id)(\id\sqcup\delta)=\delta\mu=(\id\sqcup\mu)(\delta\sqcup\id)$.2853\end{theorem}2854 2855\begin{proof}[Where the classification enters]2856Generation is Morse theory. Using the relations, every connected composite of generators from $m$ circles to2857$n$ circles can be brought to the normal form $\delta^{n-1}(\mu\delta)^g\mu^{m-1}$, with $g$ the number of2858times a $\delta$ is followed by a $\mu$ that rejoins its two outputs. Two cobordisms with the same normal form2859are equal in the presented category. Conversely, two connected oriented cobordisms with the same $m$, $n$2860and $g$ are diffeomorphic by \cref{thm:classification}, since $g$ is the genus and $m+n$ the number of2861boundary components. So the functor from the presented category to $2\cat{Cob}$ is faithful as well as full.2862\end{proof}2863 2864The classification theorem is thus exactly the completeness of the relations. The same structure is visible2865one level up: by \cref{thm:cerf}, two Morse functions on the same cobordism are joined by a path with2866isolated births, deaths and crossings, and each such event is one of the relations of the theorem.2867 2868\section{Two-dimensional field theories}2869 2870A commutative \term{Frobenius algebra} over a field $k$ is a finite-dimensional commutative algebra $A$2871with a linear form $\varepsilon\colon A\to k$ such that $(a,b)\mapsto\varepsilon(ab)$ is non-degenerate.2872 2873\begin{theorem}\label{thm:frob}\Scl[Dijkgraaf; Abrams \cite{Abr96}; \cite{Koc04}]2874The category of symmetric monoidal functors $2\cat{Cob}\to\cat{Vect}_k$ is equivalent to the category of2875commutative Frobenius algebras over $k$ and their isomorphisms, by $Z\mapsto Z(S^1)$. The comultiplication2876is dual to the multiplication under the pairing, and for the closed surface of genus $g$,2877\[Z(\Sigma_g)=\varepsilon(w^g),\qquad w=\mu\delta(1)=\sum_ie_ie_i^\#,\]2878where $(e_i)$ is a basis and $(e_i^\#)$ the dual basis for the pairing.2879\end{theorem}2880 2881\begin{example}\label{ex:frob}2882(a) $A=k[x]/(x^2)$ with $\varepsilon(1)=0$, $\varepsilon(x)=1$: the cohomology of the sphere. The dual basis2883of $(1,x)$ is $(x,1)$, so $w=2x$ and $Z(S^2)=0$, $Z(T^2)=2$, $Z(\Sigma_g)=0$ for $g\ge2$. The handle element is2884the Euler class.2885 2886(b) $A=\C[G]$ for a finite abelian group $G$ of order $n$, with $\varepsilon(g)=\delta_{g,e}/n$. The dual2887basis of $(g)$ is $(n\,g^{-1})$, so $w=n^2e$ and $Z(\Sigma_g)=\varepsilon(n^{2g}e)=n^{2g-1}$. This is2888$\#\Hom(\pi_1\Sigma_g,G)/\#G$, the number of principal $G$-bundles on $\Sigma_g$ counted with weight one over2889the order of the automorphism group.2890 2891In every case $Z(T^2)=\dim A$: the torus is the trace of the identity of $Z(S^1)$, as in \cref{thm:CH} for2892$d=1$. The script checks the Frobenius relation and these values from the structure constants.2893\end{example}2894 2895\section{Extended theories}2896 2897A field theory in the sense above assigns nothing to a point, and circles cannot be cut. Allowing2898$1$-manifolds with boundary and surfaces with corners gives a symmetric monoidal bicategory $\Bord_2$.2899 2900\begin{theorem}\label{thm:SP}\Sli[Schommer-Pries \cite{SP09}]2901The oriented bordism bicategory $\Bord^{\mathrm{or}}_2$ has a finite presentation by generators and relations,2902obtained from the classification of the generic singularities of maps from surfaces to the plane and of2903one-parameter families of them. Consequently, extended oriented two-dimensional field theories with values2904in the bicategory of algebras, bimodules and bimodule maps are classified by separable symmetric Frobenius2905algebras.2906\end{theorem}2907 2908The proof is the method of \cref{thm:2cob} with $\R$ replaced by $\R^2$: a generic map to the plane has folds2909and cusps where a Morse function has critical points, and the jet transversality theorem in one and two2910parameters supplies the relations. For framed theories the theorem confirms \cref{thm:CH} in dimension two:2911the fully dualizable algebras are the separable ones.2912 2913\section{Moduli}2914 2915By \cref{thm:ehresmann} the stack of bundles of closed connected surfaces has shape2916\[\mathcal M_2\ \simeq\ \coprod_{g\ge0}B\Diff(\Sigma_g)\ \sqcup\ \coprod_{h\ge1}B\Diff(N_h),\]2917and \cref{thm:classification} is the computation of $\pi_0\mathcal M_2$. The next question is the homotopy2918type of each component.2919 2920\begin{theorem}\label{thm:EE}\Scl[Smale; Earle--Eells \cite{EE69}; Gramain]