Indexed text attachment
representation-theory-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Representation Theory in Higher Categories
View paper · Download original file
Lines 781–880 of 3021. Source text is displayed literally.
781The first repeated multiplicity arises in $V_1^{\otimes3}\cong V_3\oplus V_1^{\oplus2}$. For an explicit pair of maps to $V_1$, take $(u,v,w)\mapsto\varepsilon(u,v)w$ and $(u,v,w)\mapsto\varepsilon(v,w)u$. The maps are independent, as shown by first setting $u=v=e_1,w=e_2$ and then setting $u=e_2,v=w=e_1$. They thus give a basis of the two-dimensional intertwiner space. The third contraction $(u,v,w)\mapsto\varepsilon(w,u)v$ is the negative sum of the other two.782\[783\varepsilon(u,v)w+\varepsilon(v,w)u+\varepsilon(w,u)v=0.784\]785The left side is alternating in the three vectors and therefore factors through $\bigwedge^3\mathbb C^2=0$. This relation is a concrete change of linear coordinates between possible choices of intermediate pair in a triple tensor product. In the space of equivariant maps, the contraction identity displays the dependence that the tensor rule counts.786 787\section{The central quotient and spherical representations}788 789The conjugation action on the real three-dimensional space $\mathfrak{su}_2$ preserves the positive inner product $(X,Y)\mapsto-\operatorname{tr}(XY)$. The determinant is one because $SU(2)$ is connected. The derivative has kernel the center of $\mathfrak{su}_2$, which is zero, and source and target Lie algebras both have dimension three. The image in $SO(3)$ is therefore open and equals $SO(3)$ by connectedness. The kernel consists of matrices commuting with all of $\mathfrak{su}_2$. Such a matrix is scalar because it also commutes with the complex span $\mathfrak{sl}_2(\mathbb C)$, and its determinant one condition makes it either $I$ or $-I$. This realizes $SO(3)\cong SU(2)/\{\pm I\}$.790 791The central element $-I$ acts on $V_n$ by $(-1)^n$. Pullback along the quotient identifies $SO(3)$-representations with direct sums of the $V_{2k}$. Their tensor rule follows by taking even indices in Clebsch--Gordan. In particular the complexified three-dimensional vector representation $V_2$ has tensor square $V_4\oplus V_2\oplus V_0$. Its three summands are respectively traceless symmetric tensors, alternating tensors, and the metric line. The even subring of $\mathbb Z[x]$ is $\mathbb Z[x^2]=\mathbb Z[y]$, where $y=[V_2]=x^2-1$.792 793The form $\varepsilon^{\otimes n}$ restricts to a nonzero invariant bilinear form on $V_n$, as shown by evaluation on $e_1^n,e_2^n$. Interchanging its arguments multiplies it by $(-1)^n$. The Frobenius--Schur indicator of $V_n$ is therefore $(-1)^n$ by Chapter~\ref{ch:characters}. The same parity appears in reciprocity for $T\subset SU(2)$. The space $V_n^T$ is one-dimensional for even $n$ and zero for odd $n$ by the torus weight formula. The orbit of a unit diagonal vector in $\mathfrak{su}_2$ is the two-sphere with stabilizer $T$. Consequently $L^2(S^2)$ has exactly one copy of each $V_{2k}$ in its Hilbert direct sum decomposition. The torus fixed line chooses the type appearing in spherical functions, while the central quotient certifies which types can act as rotations.794 795 796More generally let $L_m$ be the torus line on which $t(z)$ acts by $z^m$. By reciprocity, the multiplicity of $V_n$ in $\operatorname{Ind}_T^{SU(2)} L_m$ is the multiplicity of weight $m$ in $V_n$. The weight list yields797\[798\dim\operatorname{Hom}_{SU(2)}(V_n,\operatorname{Ind}_T^{SU(2)}L_m)799=\begin{cases}8001 & n\geq |m|\text{ and }n\equiv m\pmod{2},\\8010 & \text{otherwise}.802\end{cases}803\]804This identifies all the irreducible summands of the induced Hilbert space. In particular the center acts on the whole induced space by the common scalar $(-1)^m$. Taking $m=0$ recovers the scalar spherical functions above.805\par806\chapter{Compact Tannaka reconstruction}807\label{ch:tannaka}808 809The tensor category of finite-dimensional representations records the group element $g$ as a coherent family of linear maps $\rho_V(g)$. The coherence includes tensor products, the unit, and every intertwiner. Tannaka reconstruction asks whether these conditions characterize the families arising from individual elements. For compact groups the answer uses unitarity and the ability of invariant tensors to separate a compact subgroup from other unitary transformations. See \cite[\S 9]{robert} and \cite{br-tom-dieck} for compact duality.810 811\section{The group of coherent transformations}812 813Let $\operatorname{Rep}_{\mathrm{fd}}(G)$ contain finite-dimensional continuous unitary representations of a compact Hausdorff group $G$ and all linear intertwiners. It is symmetric monoidal by tensor product with the usual flip and rigid by the contragredient dual. The forgetful functor814\[815F:\operatorname{Rep}_{\mathrm{fd}}(G)\longrightarrow816\operatorname{Hilb}_{\mathrm{fd}}817\]818preserves these structures and the adjoint of every morphism. Its target has finite-dimensional complex Hilbert spaces and all linear maps.819 820A unitary tensor automorphism of $F$ is a family of unitary operators $a_V:F(V)\to F(V)$ satisfying $a_{\mathbf1}=1$, $a_{V\otimes W}=a_V\otimes a_W$, and $F(f)a_V=a_WF(f)$ for every intertwiner $f:V\to W$. The equalities use the structural identifications of $F$. Naturality for the dual evaluation $V^*\otimes V\to\mathbf1$ implies $a_{V^*}=(a_V^{-1})^\vee$, where the superscript $\vee$ is the algebraic linear dual. The compatibility condition is the commutativity of821\[822\begin{tikzcd}[column sep=large]823F(V)^*\otimes F(V) \arrow[r,"a_{V^*}\otimes a_V" above]824 \arrow[dr,"\operatorname{ev}" below] &825F(V)^*\otimes F(V) \arrow[d,"\operatorname{ev}"] \\826 & \mathbb C .827\end{tikzcd}828\]829Indeed evaluating at $\lambda\otimes v$ yields $(a_{V^*}\lambda)(a_Vv)=\lambda(v)$. Tensor coherence and the unit also imply that every invariant tensor $w$ in a mixed tensor power of $V$ is fixed by its corresponding operator. The vector $w$ is the value at $1$ of an intertwiner from the trivial representation.830 831\section{Invariant tensors determine a compact subgroup}832 833\begin{lemma}834\label{lem:invariant-tensors-determine-subgroup}835Let $K$ be a compact subgroup of $U(E)$ for a finite-dimensional Hilbert space $E$. For each $p,q\geq 0$ let $R_{p,q}$ be the representation of $U(E)$ on $E^{\otimes p}\otimes(E^*)^{\otimes q}$. Then $K$ is the set of all $u\in U(E)$ such that $R_{p,q}(u)w=w$ for all $w\in R_{p,q}^K$ and all $p,q$.836\end{lemma}837 838\begin{proof}839Each $u\in K$ fixes those vectors by definition. Suppose $u\notin K$. Since the compact Hausdorff right-coset space $U(E)/K$ separates $uK$ and $K$ by a continuous function, there is a continuous right-$K$-invariant scalar function $b$ on $U(E)$ with $b(u)=1$ and $b(1)=0$.840 841Polynomials in the matrix entries of $x\in U(E)$ and their complex conjugates form a unital self-adjoint subalgebra separating points. By Stone--Weierstrass it contains an element $c$ with $\|c-b\|_\infty<1/3$. Products of coefficients are coefficients of tensor products, and conjugate entries are entries of the contragredient representation in the dual basis. Hence $c$ is a finite sum of coefficients $x\mapsto\ell(R_{p,q}(x)v)$. Right averaging over $K$ preserves the uniform bound because $b$ is right invariant. It changes each such coefficient to842\[843x\longmapsto\ell(R_{p,q}(x)w),\qquad844w=\int_K R_{p,q}(k)v\,dk\in R_{p,q}^K.845\]846The averaged function still takes different values at $u$ and at $1$. For at least one of its summands $R_{p,q}(u)w$ differs from $w$. This proves the asserted description of $K$.847\end{proof}848 849In the defining representation of $SU(2)$ the invariant alternating tensor spans the determinant line. Its stabilizer inside $U(2)$ is $SU(2)$, so a single invariant in the lemma suffices there. In general the lemma permits arbitrarily large tensor powers and applies to every compact matrix quotient of $G$.850 851\section{Reconstruction and functoriality}852 853\begin{theorem}[Compact Tannaka reconstruction]854There is a natural isomorphism of topological groups855\[856G\longrightarrow\operatorname{Aut}^{\otimes}_{\mathrm{unitary}}(F),857\qquad858g\longmapsto(\rho_V(g))_{V}.859\]860The automorphism group has the topology of pointwise convergence in the unitary groups of a set of representatives of the finite-dimensional representations.861\end{theorem}862 863\begin{proof}864An element of $G$ defines a coherent unitary family by the tensor product and intertwiner identities. The map is continuous. Its kernel is trivial because finite-dimensional matrix coefficients separate points by Peter--Weyl. Conversely let $a$ be a coherent family and fix $V$. Take $K=\rho_V(G)\subset U(F(V))$. The mixed tensors fixed by $K$ are the vectors invariant under $G$. Naturality and dual compatibility imply that $a_V$ satisfies every stabilizer condition in Lemma~\ref{lem:invariant-tensors-determine-subgroup}. Thus $a_V\in\rho_V(G)$.865 866To obtain a common element of $G$, consider $S_V=\{g\in G:\rho_V(g)=a_V\}$. This is closed and nonempty. Given finitely many $V_1,\ldots,V_n$, use $V=\bigoplus_iV_i$. Naturality for its inclusions shows that $a_V$ restricts to the specified $a_{V_i}$ on every summand. It follows that $S_V\subset\bigcap_i S_{V_i}$. Compactness gives an element in all $S_V$ and point separation makes it unique. The topological assertion follows because the continuous bijection is from a compact space to a Hausdorff space.867\end{proof}868 869For a continuous homomorphism $\varphi:G\to H$, restriction along $\varphi$ is a symmetric monoidal functor $\varphi^*: \operatorname{Rep}_{\mathrm{fd}}(H)\to\operatorname{Rep}_{\mathrm{fd}}(G)$, compatible with the two forgetful functors. A family for $G$ restricts to one for $H$ by taking its values on the representations $\varphi^*W$. The reconstructed map sends $g$ to $\varphi(g)$ because $(\varphi^*\rho_W)(g)=\rho_W(\varphi(g))$. In particular reconstruction is compatible with the direction reversal from restricting representations.870 871\section{The role of the structure on the category}872 873For $U(1)$ the irreducible representations are the weight lines $L_n$, $n\in\mathbb Z$. Naturality on direct sums and their inclusions determines a family from its scalars $a_n$ on the weight lines. Tensor compatibility becomes $a_{m+n}=a_ma_n$ and $a_0=1$. Allowing all complex-linear invertible components gives $a_n=z^n$ with $z\in\mathbb C^\times$. Requiring unitary components gives $|z|=1$. With naturality and unitarity alone, the scalars on different weight lines can be assigned independently. This example isolates the roles of tensor compatibility and the Hilbert structure.874 875The proof reconstructs the group from a category equipped with its concrete symmetric tensor functor. It uses the actual morphisms out of the unit, the operation of tensoring transformations, duality, and the Hilbert structure. The ordinary representation category with only its underlying linear category structure records the simple objects and their multiplicity spaces. The fusion ring adds the dimensions of tensor multiplicity spaces. The fixed tensors used in the subgroup lemma are vectors in concrete Hilbert spaces, so the dimensions by themselves do not encode the stabilizer conditions.876 877For example, the dihedral group of order eight and the quaternion group of order eight both have abelianization of order four isomorphic to $C_2\times C_2$. Each consequently has four linear characters. The remaining squared dimension is four, giving a unique two-dimensional irreducible $S$ in each case. Twisting $S$ by a character yields $S$, and $S$ is self-dual by uniqueness. Therefore $S\otimes S$ contains each linear character once by tensor--Hom duality, exhausting its dimension. The two representation rings are isomorphic as rings with distinguished irreducible bases, while the groups have different numbers of elements of order two. The symmetric structure supplies an additional distinction in the signs of the indicators. For the dihedral group, the real planar action complexifies to $S$ with invariant symmetric form. For the quaternion group, the two-dimensional realization in $SU(2)$ has the invariant alternating form.878 879There is also an abstract recognition theorem for appropriate symmetric rigid $C^*$-tensor categories, which addresses existence of a compact group and a fiber functor from intrinsic category axioms \cite{doplicher-roberts}. Here the functor is already supplied and the theorem computes its unitary automorphism group.880\par