Indexed text attachment
representation-theory-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Representation Theory in Higher Categories
View paper · Download original file
Lines 2521–2620 of 3021. Source text is displayed literally.
2521\section{The balanced tensor product}2522An \(A\)-to-\(B\) correspondence consists of \(E_B\) and a nondegenerate \(*\)-homomorphism \(A\to\mathcal L_B(E)\). A representation of \(A\) on a Hilbert space is an \(A\)-to-\(\mathbf C\) correspondence. Let \(F\) be a \(B\)-to-\(C\) correspondence, with left action \(\phi\). On the algebraic balanced product \(E\odot_B F\), use2523\[2524 \langle e\otimes f,e'\otimes f'\rangle_C2525 =\big\langle f,\phi(\langle e,e'\rangle_B)f'\big\rangle_C.2526\]2527For the first balanced relation, replacing \(e\) by \(eb\) changes the operator inside the inner product to \(\phi(b)^*\phi(\langle e,e'\rangle_B)\). This gives the same value as replacing \(f\) by \(\phi(b)f\). The second relation follows by conjugate symmetry.2528 2529To see positivity, let \(S:B^n\to E\) be \(S(b_1,\ldots,b_n)=\sum_i e_i b_i\). Its adjoint has \(i\)-th coordinate \(\langle e_i,-\rangle_B\), so the matrix \([\langle e_i,e_j\rangle_B]\) is positive because it represents \(S^*S\). Applying \(\phi\) entrywise gives a positive operator on \(F^n\). Its quadratic value on \((f_1,\ldots,f_n)\) is the inner product of \(\sum_i e_i\otimes f_i\) with itself. Quotient by the elements of squared norm zero and complete to obtain \(E\otimes_B F\). The \(A\)-action descends as a bounded action. For \(a\in A\), the Gram matrix of \((ae_i)\) is bounded above by \(\|a\|^2\) times the Gram matrix of \((e_i)\), by applying \(S^*(-)S\) to \(a^*a\leq\|a\|^2 1\) in \(\mathcal L_B(E)\).2530 2531If \(P\) is a \(C\)-to-\(D\) correspondence, the two bracketings give the same inner products on triples of pure tensors. The assignment \((e\otimes f)\otimes p\mapsto e\otimes(f\otimes p)\) therefore extends to a surjective unitary. The pentagon for four correspondences holds because both composites agree on pure tensors. The module \(A_A\) is an identity correspondence by multiplication and nondegeneracy. With unitary intertwiners as 2-morphisms, the algebras and correspondences form a bicategory.2532\[2533\begin{tikzcd}[column sep=large]2534 A \arrow[r,"E"] \arrow[rr,bend left=27,"E\otimes_B F"]2535 & B \arrow[r,"F"] & C2536\end{tikzcd}2537\]2538 2539\section{A compact free action gives compact operators}2540\label{sec:translation-morita}2541Let \(G\) be compact with Haar probability and act on itself by left translation. On \(\mathcal H=L^2(G)\), the covariant representation is multiplication by \(C(G)\) together with \(U_g\xi(x)=\xi(g^{-1}x)\). If \(F\) is a continuous function \((g,x)\mapsto F(g,x)\), the integrated form has kernel \(K_F\):2542\[2543 \int_G F(g,x)\xi(g^{-1}x)\,dg2544 =\int_G K_F(x,y)\xi(y)\,dy,\qquad2545 K_F(x,y)=F(xy^{-1},x).2546\]2547The change \(y=g^{-1}x\) preserves Haar measure because compact groups are unimodular and inversion preserves their Haar probability. The correspondence \(F\mapsto K_F\) is a linear bijection of the continuous function spaces, with inverse \(F(g,x)=K(x,g^{-1}x)\). Substituting the variables in the crossed-product convolution and applying Fubini gives2548\[2549 K_{F*Q}(x,z)=\int_G K_F(x,y)K_Q(y,z)\,dy,\qquad2550 K_{F^*}(x,y)=\overline{K_F(y,x)}.2551\]2552For example, multiplication before the change of variable gives the integrand \(F(s,x)Q(s^{-1}g,s^{-1}x)\) at \((g,x)\). At \(g=xz^{-1}\) this is precisely the kernel integrand after taking \(y=s^{-1}x\).2553 2554The full crossed-product norm on \(F\) is bounded above by \(\int_G\sup_x|F(g,x)|\,dg\), since this bounds every covariant integrated form. Finite sums of \(e(x)\overline{f(y)}\) with \(e,f\in C(G)\) are uniformly dense in continuous kernels by Stone--Weierstrass. Each finite sum belongs to the matrix algebra of kernels on some finite-dimensional subspace of \(C(G)\), obtained by orthonormalizing the span of its \(e\)'s and \(f\)'s in \(L^2(G)\). All covariant integrated forms restrict to contractive \(*\)-representations of this matrix algebra. The integrated form on \(L^2(G)\) realizes its matrix norm. Thus the full norm and the kernel operator norm agree on finite sums and, by the displayed bound, on all continuous kernels. Finite-rank operators with continuous vectors are norm dense in \(\mathcal K(\mathcal H)\), since \(C(G)\) is dense in \(\mathcal H\). It follows that2555\begin{equation}2556 C(G)\rtimes G\simeq \mathcal K(L^2(G)).2557 \label{eq:translation-compact}2558\end{equation}2559This is the translation case of the crossed-product imprimitivity machinery developed in \cite{williams}.2560 2561\section{The inverse correspondence}2562A right Hilbert \(B\)-module is full if its inner products span a dense linear subspace of \(B\). An \(A\)-to-\(B\) correspondence that is full and whose left action identifies \(A\) with \(\mathcal K_B(E)\) is an imprimitivity bimodule. It implements strong Morita equivalence. For \eqref{eq:translation-compact}, let \(E=\mathcal H\) as a \(\mathcal K(\mathcal H)\)-to-\(\mathbf C\) correspondence. Its conjugate vector space \(\overline E\) has right action \(\bar e\cdot a=\overline{a^*e}\) and \(\mathcal K(\mathcal H)\)-valued inner product \(\langle\bar e,\bar f\rangle=\theta_{e,f}\). The left scalar action is ordinary multiplication on the conjugate space. The maps2563\[2564 \begin{aligned}2565 E\otimes_{\mathbf C}\overline E&\longrightarrow\mathcal K(\mathcal H),2566 & e\otimes\bar f&\longmapsto\theta_{e,f},\\2567 \overline E\otimes_{\mathcal K(\mathcal H)} E&\longrightarrow\mathbf C,2568 & \bar e\otimes f&\longmapsto\langle e,f\rangle2569 \end{aligned}2570\]2571preserve balances, inner products, and the left actions. For instance, in the first map the product of the adjoint of \(\theta_{e,f}\) with \(\theta_{e',f'}\) is \(\theta_{f\langle e,e'\rangle,f'}\), exactly the tensor inner product. Their images are dense by the rank-one formulas and the existence of a unit vector. The maps are therefore unitary. Composing twice with these correspondences recovers the starting module by the tensor associator. This yields the inverse equivalences on nondegenerate Hilbert-space representations and explains why a free transitive compact action and a point give the same stabilized invariants in Chapter~\ref{ch:equivariant-k}.2572 2573\section{Recovering a Hilbert-space representation}2574The Morita equivalence can also be seen inside an arbitrary nondegenerate representation of the kernel algebra. Let \(\rho:\mathcal K(\mathcal H)\to\mathcal L(\mathcal V)\) be such a representation and choose a unit vector \(e_0\in\mathcal H\). With \(p=\theta_{e_0,e_0}\) let \(M=\rho(p)\mathcal V\). Define2575\[2576 W:\mathcal H\odot M\longrightarrow\mathcal V,\qquad2577 W(e\otimes m)=\rho(\theta_{e,e_0})m .2578\]2579Using \(\theta_{e,e_0}^*\theta_{f,e_0}=\langle e,f\rangle p\) gives \(\langle W(e\otimes m),W(f\otimes n)\rangle=\langle e,f\rangle\langle m,n\rangle\). The range contains \(\rho(\theta_{e,f})v\) for every \(v\in\mathcal V\), since \(\theta_{e,f}=\theta_{e,e_0}\theta_{e_0,f}\) and \(\rho(\theta_{e_0,f})v\in M\). Nondegeneracy and density of rank-one operators therefore make \(W\) a unitary onto \(\mathcal V\). The rank-one identities also give \(W(ae\otimes m)=\rho(a)W(e\otimes m)\). Thus the multiplicity space \(M\) classifies \(\rho\) up to unitary equivalence. Choosing another unit vector changes the corner space by the unitary supplied by the corresponding rank-one operator. For the original action \(G\curvearrowright G\), the integrated operator includes both translation and multiplication. This result classifies that pair up to multiplicity, whereas a representation of translation alone has the many independent Peter--Weyl types.2580\par2581\chapter{Equivariant \texorpdfstring{\(K\)}{K}-theory and crossed products}2582\label{ch:equivariant-k}2583A crossed product retains the compatibility between functions on a space and motion by a group. Its \(K\)-theory expresses part of that compatibility in terms of stable classes. A projection \(p\) in a matrix algebra over \(C(X)\) determines a vector bundle by taking the range \(p(x)\) at every \(x\). The analogous definition for a general \(C^*\)-algebra uses the module \(pA^n\). For unital \(A\), \(K_0(A)\) is the Grothendieck group of stable equivalence classes of projections with addition by block sum. The group \(K_1(A)\) uses path components of unitaries after adjoining identity blocks. For a nonunital \(A\) one uses its unitization and takes the kernel of the map to the scalar summand. These constructions are stable under passage to compact operators on a full Hilbert module, by Morita invariance \cite{blackadar}.2584 2585\section{The compact comparison}2586Suppose \(G\) is a second-countable compact group and \(A\) a separable \(G\)-\(C^*\)-algebra with a continuous action. In the compact Green--Julg theorem the trivial algebra \(\mathbf C\) occurs in the first Kasparov variable. The natural isomorphisms are2587\[2588 KK^G_i(\mathbf C,A)\simeq K_i(A\rtimes G),\qquad i=0,1.2589\]2590One description descends a class to a correspondence from \(C^*(G)\) to \(A\rtimes G\) and takes its Kasparov product with the class of the projection for the trivial representation. In \(C^*(G)\) this is the continuous function \(g\mapsto 1\): convolution with itself remains \(1\) because Haar has mass one. The same compact theorem applies to the reduced product since compact groups are amenable. For \(A=C(X)\) with \(X\) compact metrizable and \(G\) compact Lie, \(KK^G_0(\mathbf C,C(X))\) identifies with the Grothendieck group \(K^0_G(X)\) of equivariant complex vector bundles, by the equivariant projection description. Odd topological \(K\)-theory is defined by suspension. The crossed product identification is an isomorphism of groups. Tensor multiplication of bundles is extra structure on the geometric side \cite[Sec.~11.7]{blackadar}\cite{segal}.2591 2592The hypotheses in this statement do work. For example, a general locally compact group has no Haar probability and the constant function need not furnish a projection in its group algebra. To see how the compact theorem behaves, it helps to compare the two transitive extremes, a point with stabilizer \(G\) and \(G\) itself with trivial stabilizer.2593 2594\section{Point, free orbit, and homogeneous orbit}2595At a point \(K^0_G(*)=R(G)\), the Grothendieck group of finite-dimensional continuous complex representations, with multiplication from tensor product. The full group \(C^*\)-algebra satisfies2596\[2597 C^*(G)\simeq\bigoplus_{\pi\in\widehat G}^{c_0}\operatorname{End}(V_\pi).2598\]2599Indeed, the integrated map uses \(\pi(F)=\int_G F(g)\pi(g)\,dg\). The full norm is the supremum of these matrix norms because every unitary representation decomposes into irreducibles. Peter--Weyl orthogonality supplies a continuous function for any single matrix block, with all other blocks zero. Finite sums of matrix coefficients are uniformly dense in continuous functions, hence dense in \(L^1(G)\). The estimate \(\|\pi(F)\|\leq\|F\|_1\) then gives precisely the \(c_0\)-completion. For finite sums of full matrix algebras the \(K_0\)-coordinate is matrix rank and the unitary groups are path connected. Passing to the limit over finite sets of blocks yields2600\[2601 K_0(C^*(G))=\bigoplus_{\pi\in\widehat G}\mathbf Z,2602 \qquad K_1(C^*(G))=0.2603\]2604The limit can also be seen from the norm topology. A projection in matrices over the \(c_0\)-sum has finitely many nonzero components since a nonzero projection has norm one. A unitary with scalar part \(1\) has tail uniformly near \(1\). On that tail one contracts it by the logarithm, while separately contracting each of the finitely many remaining finite-dimensional unitaries.2605 2606For the free orbit \(G\), an equivariant bundle \(E\) has canonical trivialization over the group given by \((g,v)\mapsto g v\) for \(v\in E_1\). Its inverse sends \(w\in E_g\) to \((g,g^{-1}w)\). The vector space \(E_1\) therefore determines its class and \(K^0_G(G)=\mathbf Z\). On the algebraic side, Chapter~\ref{ch:morita} identifies \(C(G)\rtimes G\) with the compacts, so this agrees with the compact-operator rank calculation.2607 2608For a closed subgroup \(H\) of a compact Lie group \(G\), evaluate a \(G\)-equivariant vector bundle on \(G/H\) at \(1H\). The fiber is an \(H\)-representation and an inverse constructs \(G\times_H V\) from \(V\). The defining relation is \((gh,v)\sim(g,hv)\); the repair of local coordinates on two sections of \(G\to G/H\) is consequently the action of the transition function on \(V\). For an input bundle \(E\), the formula \([g,v]\mapsto gv\) gives an equivariant linear bijection on fibers and a bundle isomorphism by local triviality. Since both operations preserve direct sum and tensor product, this proves \(K^0_G(G/H)\simeq R(H)\) as rings. On the algebra side, Green's imprimitivity theorem gives a Morita equivalence from \(C(G/H)\rtimes G\) to \(C^*(H)\). Thus either path computes the even group and \(K_1(C(G/H)\rtimes G)=0\) \cite[Thm.~4.22]{williams}.2609\[2610\begin{tikzcd}[column sep=2.4em, row sep=1.3em]2611 & R(H) \arrow[dr,"\mathrm{dual\ block\ ranks}"] &\\2612 K^0_G(G/H) \arrow[ur,"\mathrm{fiber}"] \arrow[dr,"\mathrm{Green\text{--}Julg}"]2613 && K_0(C^*(H))\\2614 & K_0(C(G/H)\rtimes G) \arrow[ur,"\mathrm{Morita}"] &2615\end{tikzcd}2616\]2617The block convention in this diagram can be checked using projections. Present an equivariant bundle \(E\) as the range of \(p(x)\) in a trivial bundle with finite-dimensional unitary fiber representation \(\rho\). The covariance equation is \(p(gx)=\rho(g)p(x)\rho(g)^*\). In matrices over the crossed product, the descended class comes from the kernel \(F(g,x)=p(x)\rho(g)\): it is the product of the bundle projection with the averaging projection for the diagonal action. Covariance and normalization of Haar give \(F*F=F=F^*\).2618 2619Under the homogeneous imprimitivity equivalence, the block indexed by an irreducible \(H\)-representation \(\eta\) acts on sections of \(E_\eta=G\times_H V_\eta\); it uses multiplication and the induced \(G\)-action \(U_g^\eta\). There \(F\) acts as \(p\) times the averaging operator for \(\rho(g)\otimes U_g^\eta\). These orthogonal projections commute by covariance. The range is the space of invariant sections of \(E\otimes E_\eta\), and averaging continuous sections has image in the finite-dimensional space determined by an \(H\)-invariant value at \(o\), since transitivity forces \(s(go)=g s(o)\). Continuous sections are dense, and the finite-dimensional image is closed. Thus the range in the Hilbert space has dimension2620\[