Indexed text attachment
representation-theory-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Representation Theory in Higher Categories
View paper · Download original file
Lines 2481–2580 of 3021. Source text is displayed literally.
2481The graded lines remain dualizable after twisting. For \(X=k_g\), choose \(X^*=k_{g^{-1}}\), coevaluation \(k_e\to X\otimes X^*\) with scalar \(1\), and evaluation \(X^*\otimes X\to k_e\) with scalar \(v\). The two triangle composites have scalars2482\[2483 v\,\omega(g,g^{-1},g),\qquad2484 v\,\omega(g^{-1},g,g^{-1})^{-1}.2485\]2486The pentagon for \((g,g^{-1},g,g^{-1})\), together with normalization, makes these factors equal. Taking \(v=\omega(g,g^{-1},g)^{-1}\) gives both triangle identities. Applying the same construction to \(k_{g^{-1}}\) provides duality in the other direction. Finite direct sums have duals obtained by taking the corresponding direct sums of dual lines, with evaluation and coevaluation pairing the summands. For finite \(G\), this gives a semisimple rigid category with finitely many simple objects, each tensor-invertible.2487 2488\section{The multiplier in a categorical character}2489 2490A normalized 2-cocycle \(\alpha\) gives a weak \(G\)-action on finite-dimensional vector spaces, regarded as a linear category. Take each \(F_g\) to be the identity functor and let \(\mu_{g,h}=\alpha(g,h)\mathrm{id}\). Associativity of a weak action is the 2-cocycle equation in this case. In Chapter~\ref{ch:categorical-characters}, the trace space \(T_g\) was defined by \(\operatorname{Nat}(\mathrm{Id},F_g)\). Here it is a single copy of \(k\). For \(gh=hg\), the conjugation transport first applies \(\mu_{h,g}\) and then \(\mu_{g,h}^{-1}\). Thus the scalar on \(T_g\) is2491\[2492 \chi(g,h)=\frac{\alpha(h,g)}{\alpha(g,h)}.2493\]2494A coboundary is symmetric on commuting pairs, so this expression depends only on the multiplier class. For the pair from the two generators in the matrix example, the value is \(-1\).2495 2496The same ratio appears when conjugating \(\rho_g\) by \(\rho_h\) in a projective representation with multiplier \(\alpha\), since the two orders of the product have the same group index. If the ratio differs from \(1\), ordinary matrix trace gives \(\operatorname{tr}\rho_g=0\). In the categorical action the ratio itself survives as an operation on a one-dimensional trace space. The scalar twists are detected by the categorical character even for actions whose individual functors are all identities.2497 2498For fixed \(g\), the ratio is a one-dimensional character of \(C_G(g)\). One can prove this either by the composition law for conjugation transport or directly in the central extension. The commutator of a lift of \(h\in C_G(g)\) with a lift of \(g\) lies in the central subgroup and equals the ratio. When two commutators lie in the center, the commutator for the product of their first entries is the product of the two commutators. This gives multiplicativity in \(h\) and explains how the degree-two cocycle produces an ordinary character on each centralizer.2499\par2500 2501\bookpart{VII}{Operator categories and equivariance}2502\chapter{Hilbert modules, correspondences, and Morita equivalence}2503\label{ch:morita}2504A covariant representation combines an algebra action with a group action on a Hilbert space. A correspondence replaces the scalar field of that Hilbert space by a second algebra. The replacement makes it possible to compose two generalized actions by tensoring over their common algebra. In particular, an algebra of kernels may carry the same module theory as the scalars even when its elements, multiplication, and ideals arise from a nontrivial geometric action.2505 2506\section{Hilbert modules and their adjoints}2507A right Hilbert \(B\)-module \(E\), for a \(C^*\)-algebra \(B\), has a \(B\)-valued inner product. We use the convention linear in the second variable for module inner products. The identities2508\[2509 \langle e,fb\rangle_B=\langle e,f\rangle_B b,2510 \qquad2511 \langle e,f\rangle_B^*=\langle f,e\rangle_B2512\]2513relate multiplication to the involution. Positive definiteness and completeness are taken with respect to \(\|e\|=\|\langle e,e\rangle_B\|^{1/2}\). In \(B\) itself the inner product is \(b^*c\). In a Hilbert space with scalar right action it is its ordinary Hilbert inner product. The bundle example is the space of continuous sections of a Hermitian vector bundle over a compact base \(X\), with pointwise \(C(X)\)-action and pointwise inner product.2514 2515An adjointable endomorphism \(T\) has a bounded \(B\)-linear adjoint \(T^*\) with \(\langle Te,f\rangle=\langle e,T^*f\rangle\). These operators form \(\mathcal L_B(E)\). For \(e,f\in E\) put2516\[2517 \theta_{e,f}(u)=e\langle f,u\rangle_B.2518\]2519Its adjoint is \(\theta_{f,e}\), and \(\theta_{e,f}\theta_{u,v}=\theta_{e\langle f,u\rangle_B,v}\). Their closed linear span is the \(C^*\)-algebra \(\mathcal K_B(E)\). For the module \(B\) the operators \(\theta_{b,c}\) are left multiplications by \(bc^*\), whose linear span is dense in \(B\). Thus \(\mathcal K_B(B)\) is \(B\), including for nonunital \(B\). On a Hilbert space this construction gives the ordinary compact operators. For other coefficient algebras the term compact refers to the module construction. See \cite[Chs.~1, 4, and 7]{lance} for the general theory.2520 2521\section{The balanced tensor product}2522An \(A\)-to-\(B\) correspondence consists of \(E_B\) and a nondegenerate \(*\)-homomorphism \(A\to\mathcal L_B(E)\). A representation of \(A\) on a Hilbert space is an \(A\)-to-\(\mathbf C\) correspondence. Let \(F\) be a \(B\)-to-\(C\) correspondence, with left action \(\phi\). On the algebraic balanced product \(E\odot_B F\), use2523\[2524 \langle e\otimes f,e'\otimes f'\rangle_C2525 =\big\langle f,\phi(\langle e,e'\rangle_B)f'\big\rangle_C.2526\]2527For the first balanced relation, replacing \(e\) by \(eb\) changes the operator inside the inner product to \(\phi(b)^*\phi(\langle e,e'\rangle_B)\). This gives the same value as replacing \(f\) by \(\phi(b)f\). The second relation follows by conjugate symmetry.2528 2529To see positivity, let \(S:B^n\to E\) be \(S(b_1,\ldots,b_n)=\sum_i e_i b_i\). Its adjoint has \(i\)-th coordinate \(\langle e_i,-\rangle_B\), so the matrix \([\langle e_i,e_j\rangle_B]\) is positive because it represents \(S^*S\). Applying \(\phi\) entrywise gives a positive operator on \(F^n\). Its quadratic value on \((f_1,\ldots,f_n)\) is the inner product of \(\sum_i e_i\otimes f_i\) with itself. Quotient by the elements of squared norm zero and complete to obtain \(E\otimes_B F\). The \(A\)-action descends as a bounded action. For \(a\in A\), the Gram matrix of \((ae_i)\) is bounded above by \(\|a\|^2\) times the Gram matrix of \((e_i)\), by applying \(S^*(-)S\) to \(a^*a\leq\|a\|^2 1\) in \(\mathcal L_B(E)\).2530 2531If \(P\) is a \(C\)-to-\(D\) correspondence, the two bracketings give the same inner products on triples of pure tensors. The assignment \((e\otimes f)\otimes p\mapsto e\otimes(f\otimes p)\) therefore extends to a surjective unitary. The pentagon for four correspondences holds because both composites agree on pure tensors. The module \(A_A\) is an identity correspondence by multiplication and nondegeneracy. With unitary intertwiners as 2-morphisms, the algebras and correspondences form a bicategory.2532\[2533\begin{tikzcd}[column sep=large]2534 A \arrow[r,"E"] \arrow[rr,bend left=27,"E\otimes_B F"]2535 & B \arrow[r,"F"] & C2536\end{tikzcd}2537\]2538 2539\section{A compact free action gives compact operators}2540\label{sec:translation-morita}2541Let \(G\) be compact with Haar probability and act on itself by left translation. On \(\mathcal H=L^2(G)\), the covariant representation is multiplication by \(C(G)\) together with \(U_g\xi(x)=\xi(g^{-1}x)\). If \(F\) is a continuous function \((g,x)\mapsto F(g,x)\), the integrated form has kernel \(K_F\):2542\[2543 \int_G F(g,x)\xi(g^{-1}x)\,dg2544 =\int_G K_F(x,y)\xi(y)\,dy,\qquad2545 K_F(x,y)=F(xy^{-1},x).2546\]2547The change \(y=g^{-1}x\) preserves Haar measure because compact groups are unimodular and inversion preserves their Haar probability. The correspondence \(F\mapsto K_F\) is a linear bijection of the continuous function spaces, with inverse \(F(g,x)=K(x,g^{-1}x)\). Substituting the variables in the crossed-product convolution and applying Fubini gives2548\[2549 K_{F*Q}(x,z)=\int_G K_F(x,y)K_Q(y,z)\,dy,\qquad2550 K_{F^*}(x,y)=\overline{K_F(y,x)}.2551\]2552For example, multiplication before the change of variable gives the integrand \(F(s,x)Q(s^{-1}g,s^{-1}x)\) at \((g,x)\). At \(g=xz^{-1}\) this is precisely the kernel integrand after taking \(y=s^{-1}x\).2553 2554The full crossed-product norm on \(F\) is bounded above by \(\int_G\sup_x|F(g,x)|\,dg\), since this bounds every covariant integrated form. Finite sums of \(e(x)\overline{f(y)}\) with \(e,f\in C(G)\) are uniformly dense in continuous kernels by Stone--Weierstrass. Each finite sum belongs to the matrix algebra of kernels on some finite-dimensional subspace of \(C(G)\), obtained by orthonormalizing the span of its \(e\)'s and \(f\)'s in \(L^2(G)\). All covariant integrated forms restrict to contractive \(*\)-representations of this matrix algebra. The integrated form on \(L^2(G)\) realizes its matrix norm. Thus the full norm and the kernel operator norm agree on finite sums and, by the displayed bound, on all continuous kernels. Finite-rank operators with continuous vectors are norm dense in \(\mathcal K(\mathcal H)\), since \(C(G)\) is dense in \(\mathcal H\). It follows that2555\begin{equation}2556 C(G)\rtimes G\simeq \mathcal K(L^2(G)).2557 \label{eq:translation-compact}2558\end{equation}2559This is the translation case of the crossed-product imprimitivity machinery developed in \cite{williams}.2560 2561\section{The inverse correspondence}2562A right Hilbert \(B\)-module is full if its inner products span a dense linear subspace of \(B\). An \(A\)-to-\(B\) correspondence that is full and whose left action identifies \(A\) with \(\mathcal K_B(E)\) is an imprimitivity bimodule. It implements strong Morita equivalence. For \eqref{eq:translation-compact}, let \(E=\mathcal H\) as a \(\mathcal K(\mathcal H)\)-to-\(\mathbf C\) correspondence. Its conjugate vector space \(\overline E\) has right action \(\bar e\cdot a=\overline{a^*e}\) and \(\mathcal K(\mathcal H)\)-valued inner product \(\langle\bar e,\bar f\rangle=\theta_{e,f}\). The left scalar action is ordinary multiplication on the conjugate space. The maps2563\[2564 \begin{aligned}2565 E\otimes_{\mathbf C}\overline E&\longrightarrow\mathcal K(\mathcal H),2566 & e\otimes\bar f&\longmapsto\theta_{e,f},\\2567 \overline E\otimes_{\mathcal K(\mathcal H)} E&\longrightarrow\mathbf C,2568 & \bar e\otimes f&\longmapsto\langle e,f\rangle2569 \end{aligned}2570\]2571preserve balances, inner products, and the left actions. For instance, in the first map the product of the adjoint of \(\theta_{e,f}\) with \(\theta_{e',f'}\) is \(\theta_{f\langle e,e'\rangle,f'}\), exactly the tensor inner product. Their images are dense by the rank-one formulas and the existence of a unit vector. The maps are therefore unitary. Composing twice with these correspondences recovers the starting module by the tensor associator. This yields the inverse equivalences on nondegenerate Hilbert-space representations and explains why a free transitive compact action and a point give the same stabilized invariants in Chapter~\ref{ch:equivariant-k}.2572 2573\section{Recovering a Hilbert-space representation}2574The Morita equivalence can also be seen inside an arbitrary nondegenerate representation of the kernel algebra. Let \(\rho:\mathcal K(\mathcal H)\to\mathcal L(\mathcal V)\) be such a representation and choose a unit vector \(e_0\in\mathcal H\). With \(p=\theta_{e_0,e_0}\) let \(M=\rho(p)\mathcal V\). Define2575\[2576 W:\mathcal H\odot M\longrightarrow\mathcal V,\qquad2577 W(e\otimes m)=\rho(\theta_{e,e_0})m .2578\]2579Using \(\theta_{e,e_0}^*\theta_{f,e_0}=\langle e,f\rangle p\) gives \(\langle W(e\otimes m),W(f\otimes n)\rangle=\langle e,f\rangle\langle m,n\rangle\). The range contains \(\rho(\theta_{e,f})v\) for every \(v\in\mathcal V\), since \(\theta_{e,f}=\theta_{e,e_0}\theta_{e_0,f}\) and \(\rho(\theta_{e_0,f})v\in M\). Nondegeneracy and density of rank-one operators therefore make \(W\) a unitary onto \(\mathcal V\). The rank-one identities also give \(W(ae\otimes m)=\rho(a)W(e\otimes m)\). Thus the multiplicity space \(M\) classifies \(\rho\) up to unitary equivalence. Choosing another unit vector changes the corner space by the unitary supplied by the corresponding rank-one operator. For the original action \(G\curvearrowright G\), the integrated operator includes both translation and multiplication. This result classifies that pair up to multiplicity, whereas a representation of translation alone has the many independent Peter--Weyl types.2580\par