Indexed text attachment
representation-theory-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Representation Theory in Higher Categories
View paper · Download original file
Lines 2181–2280 of 3021. Source text is displayed literally.
2181quotient to a basis. Composing with the quotient and then the2182sign character gives a nontrivial abstract one-dimensional complex2183representation. It is trivial on the dense finite-support subgroup.2184A continuous map with this property into $\{1,-1\}$ would be2185trivial everywhere. This exhibits an action of $P^\delta$ that2186cannot arise from continuous descent.2187\par2188 2189\bookpart{VI}{Categorical reconstruction and characters}2190\chapter{Monoidal categories and fiber functors}2191\label{ch:affine-tannaka}2192 2193A representation supplies two kinds of data. It supplies a vector space on which an unknown symmetry acts, and it supplies maps between vector spaces that the symmetry must respect. Tensor products allow such maps to relate different representations. Chapter~\ref{ch:tannaka} used continuous unitary representations to reconstruct a compact group. We now work over an arbitrary field \(k\), retain the symmetric tensor product, and allow the reconstructed group to be evaluated on any commutative \(k\)-algebra. The coordinate algebra can then record infinitesimal symmetries, even when every \(k\)-valued point acts trivially.2194 2195\section{Matrix coefficients from a coend}2196 2197Let \(G=\operatorname{Spec}H\) be an affine group scheme over \(k\), so \(H\) is a commutative Hopf algebra. Write \(\operatorname{Rep}_k(G)\) for the category of finite-dimensional right \(H\)-comodules and \(\omega\) for the forgetful functor to finite-dimensional vector spaces. The tensor coaction multiplies the coefficients of the two factors. The unit object is \(k\) with coaction \(1\mapsto 1\otimes 1\), and the antipode supplies the dual coaction. Thus \(\omega\) is a faithful exact symmetric monoidal functor from a rigid abelian category. These properties are the starting data of neutral Tannaka theory \cite{deligne-milne-tannakian}.2198 2199A matrix coefficient associated to \(v\in V\) and \(\phi\in V^*\) is2200\[2201 c_{\phi,v}=(\phi\otimes\mathrm{id}_H)\rho_V(v)\in H.2202\]2203When \(f\colon V\to W\) is equivariant, \(c_{\psi,f(v)}=c_{\psi f,v}\). This relation suggests a vector space constructed entirely from \((\operatorname{Rep}_k(G),\omega)\). Take the direct sum of all \(\omega(V)\otimes\omega(V)^*\) over a small skeleton and quotient by the linear relations2204\[2205 [f(v),\psi]_W=[v,\psi f]_V.2206\]2207Denote the result by \(C_\omega\). This is the coend \(\int^V\omega(V)\otimes\omega(V)^*\). The quotient makes every compatible family of bilinear pairings out of the summands factor uniquely through \(C_\omega\).2208 2209\begin{theorem}[Affine reconstruction]2210The map \([v,\phi]_V\mapsto c_{\phi,v}\) identifies \(C_\omega\) with \(H\) as a commutative Hopf algebra. For every commutative \(k\)-algebra \(R\) there is a natural group isomorphism2211\[2212 G(R)\ \cong\ \operatorname{Aut}^{\otimes}_{R}(\omega_R),2213 \qquad \omega_R(V)=\omega(V)\otimes_k R .2214\]2215Here naturality on the right is with respect to equivariant maps in \(\operatorname{Rep}_k(G)\).2216\end{theorem}2217 2218\begin{proof}2219First consider \(H\) as a right comodule under \(\Delta\). Each \(z\in H\) belongs to a finite-dimensional subcomodule of \(H\). To see this, write \(\Delta(z)=\sum_i z_i\otimes a_i\) with the \(a_i\) linearly independent. Coassociativity gives2220\[2221 \sum_i\Delta(z_i)\otimes a_i=\sum_i z_i\otimes\Delta(a_i).2222\]2223Applying coordinate functionals on the last tensor factor shows that the span \(W\) of the \(z_i\) is a right subcomodule. Applying \(\mathrm{id}\otimes\epsilon\) to \(\Delta(z)\) gives \(z\in W\). Also \(z=(\epsilon|_W\otimes\mathrm{id})\Delta(z)\), so \(z\) is the coefficient of the pair \((z,\epsilon|_W)\). This proves surjectivity.2224 2225For injectivity, \(v\mapsto c_{\phi,v}\) defines a comodule map \(f_\phi\colon V\to H\) by coassociativity. Its composite with \(\epsilon\) is \(\phi\). Given a finite sum of generators of \(C_\omega\), take \(W\subset H\) to be the sum of the images of the corresponding maps \(f_\phi\). Each map now factors through the same finite-dimensional subcomodule \(W\). The defining relations rewrite the entire sum as \([\sum f_\phi(v),\epsilon|_W]_W\). The sum vanishes in \(C_\omega\) whenever its image vanishes in \(H\).2226 2227The Hopf operations are visible in the fiber functor. For a basis \(e_i\) of \(V\) with dual basis \(e_i^*\), the formulas are2228\begin{align*}2229 [v,\phi]_V[w,\psi]_W2230 &=[v\otimes w,\phi\otimes\psi]_{V\otimes W},\\2231 \Delta[v,\phi]_V2232 &=\sum_i[e_i,\phi]_V\otimes[v,e_i^*]_V,\qquad2233 \epsilon[v,\phi]_V=\phi(v),\\2234 S[v,\phi]_V&=[\phi,\operatorname{ev}_v]_{V^*}.2235\end{align*}2236The coproduct formula inserts the canonical element in \(V\otimes V^*\), so it is independent of the basis. The tensor unit gives the multiplicative unit. The corresponding coefficient identities in \(H\) follow from the tensor and dual coactions. The linear isomorphism therefore identifies all the indicated operations.2237 2238An \(R\)-linear natural transformation \(u\) of \(\omega_R\) determines a \(k\)-linear map on \(C_\omega\) by \([v,\phi]\mapsto (\phi\otimes\mathrm{id}_R)(u_V(v\otimes 1))\). Conversely, any such map gives the matrix entries of unique \(R\)-linear endomorphisms, with the coend relations exactly enforcing naturality. These endomorphisms satisfy the tensor and unit identities precisely when the map \(H\to R\) is a unital algebra homomorphism. In Sweedler notation the resulting transformation is2239\[2240 u_V(v\otimes 1)=\sum v_{(0)}\otimes a(v_{(1)}),2241 \qquad a\colon H\to R .2242\]2243The coproduct formula identifies composition of transformations with convolution. The inverse is supplied by \(aS\), so every monoidal natural transformation in question is invertible. The formulas commute with base change in \(R\).2244\end{proof}2245 2246\section{Three coordinate computations}2247 2248For \(G=\mathbb G_m\), write \(H=k[t,t^{-1}]\) with \(\Delta(t)=t\otimes t\). Writing a coaction as \(\rho(v)=\sum_n v_n\otimes t^n\), coassociativity implies \(\rho(v_n)=v_n\otimes t^n\), and the counit gives \(v=\sum_n v_n\). Thus the representation category consists of finite-dimensional \(\mathbb Z\)-graded vector spaces with tensor product adding degrees. A monoidal automorphism of \(\omega_R\) acts on the weight-\(n\) line by the \(n\)-th power of its value on the weight-one line. Naturality with respect to maps out of weight lines then determines it on all objects. Its parameter is any element of \(R^\times\).2249 2250For \(G=\mathbb G_a\) in characteristic zero, a representation is a polynomial matrix \(T(t)\) satisfying \(T(s+t)=T(s)T(t)\) and \(T(0)=I\). Comparing the coefficient of \(s\) gives \(T'(t)=NT(t)\), where \(N=T'(0)\). Over \(k\), this recurrence forces \(T(t)=\sum_{i\geq 0}t^iN^i/i!\). Since \(T(t)\) is a polynomial, \(N\) is nilpotent. Conversely every nilpotent \(N\) defines such a representation. A parameter \(a\in R\) acts by the finite expression \(\exp(aN)\). The tensor product sends \(N,M\) to \(N\otimes I+I\otimes M\), which accounts for the addition law on the reconstructed parameter.2251 2252In characteristic \(p>0\), let \(\mu_p\) have coordinate algebra \(k[t,t^{-1}]/(t^p-1)\). Its \(k\)-points consist only of \(1\). Over \(R=k[\varepsilon]/(\varepsilon^2)\) the element \(1+\varepsilon\) is a nontrivial \(p\)-th root of unity. Its action on the weight-one line detects it. The coend and the \(R\)-valued automorphisms retain precisely the testing information that is invisible on \(k\)-points alone.2253 2254The standard representation of \(\operatorname{SL}_n\), for \(n\geq 2\), gives a different way to recognize the coordinates from morphisms. Write \(U=k^n\) and choose a basis \(e_1,\ldots,e_n\). The volume functional \(U^{\otimes n}\to k\) sends2255\(u_1\otimes\cdots\otimes u_n\) to the determinant of the matrix with columns \(u_i\). It is an equivariant map. Naturality and the tensor identity therefore make the matrix \(u_U\) of a fiber automorphism preserve the volume functional over \(R\). Evaluation on \(e_1\otimes\cdots\otimes e_n\) gives \(\det(u_U)=1\).2256 2257The coefficients \(c_{e_i^*,e_j}\) of \(U\) generate the coordinate algebra \(k[x_{ij}]/(\det(x_{ij})-1)\), since they are the coordinate functions \(x_{ij}\). A tensor automorphism is determined by its entries on \(U\) by affine reconstruction. Every determinant-one matrix in \(M_n(R)\) then supplies an evaluation homomorphism and hence an automorphism of the fiber functor on all representations. The factorization through the determinant relation holds over every \(R\), including rings with nilpotents. This gives both the reason for the constraint on \(u_U\) and the sufficiency of that constraint.2258 2259\section{The target of the fiber functor}2260 2261Over \(\mathbb C\), finite-dimensional continuous unitary representations of the circle also split into integral weights. The forgetful functor to Hilbert spaces retains norms. A unitary tensor natural automorphism acts on the weight-one line by a scalar of norm \(1\), giving \(S^1\). The underlying functor to complex vector spaces permits an arbitrary nonzero scalar and gives \(\mathbb C^\times\), the complex points of \(\mathbb G_m\). The difference comes from the structure preserved by an automorphism of the chosen fiber functor.2262 2263A derived fiber functor takes values in a symmetric monoidal category of modules over a base ring spectrum. Its automorphisms and their homotopies form a space with composition. The ordinary calculation above uses the endomorphisms of finite vector spaces and a set of natural transformations. The corresponding derived questions require control of the entire mapping spaces and of the geometric conditions on the objects that a fiber functor preserves.2264\par2265\chapter{Derived Tannaka duality and affine group stacks}2266\label{ch:derived-tannaka}2267\chaptermark{Derived Tannaka duality}2268 2269Two fiber functors can be equivalent in several ways, and equivalences can themselves be homotopic along several paths. This data becomes relevant when the coefficients of a representation have higher homotopy groups. In this chapter \(A\) and \(B\) are connective \(E_\infty\)-rings. Connectivity means \(\pi_i A=0\) for \(i<0\), and the same convention applies to modules. The notation \(\operatorname{Mod}_A\) denotes the stable \(\infty\)-category of all \(A\)-module spectra, with tensor product over \(A\). For a discrete ring \(a\), taking \(A=Ha\) recovers the derived category of \(a\)-modules with its mapping spaces.2270 2271\section{The affine module category}2272 2273The tensor unit in \(\operatorname{Mod}_A\) is \(A\). Its endomorphism spectrum is \(A\) itself. The multiplication and all commutativity coherences in this identification come from the symmetric monoidal structure on endomorphisms of the unit. Consequently, a colimit-preserving symmetric monoidal functor from \(\operatorname{Mod}_A\) to \(\operatorname{Mod}_B\) induces a map of \(E_\infty\)-rings \(A\to B\).2274 2275\begin{theorem}[Affine pullback]2276Extension of scalars induces an equivalence of spaces2277\[2278 \operatorname{Map}_{\mathrm{CAlg}}(A,B)2279 \ \simeq\2280 \bigl(\operatorname{Fun}^{L,\otimes}