Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

actions-of-toposes-on-toposes.tex

Source for Actions of Toposes on Toposes

View paper · Download original file

Lines 781–880 of 1373. Source text is displayed literally.

781 782For example, ordinary real addition and real addition with783the discrete topology give different group topoi. Both784have $(\mathbb R,+)$ as their group of geometric points.785Their subterminal frames distinguish them. For the discrete786topology the frame is a Boolean power set. For the usual787topology, a proper nonempty open interval has no open788complement in the connected real line. The two topoi789therefore cannot be equivalent. Both act on the sheaf topos790of the usual real line by translations. The two actions791agree on individual ordinary points, while their parameter792topoi encode different families of translations.793 794A simple monoid that is not a group is the Sierpi\'nski locale795$\Sigma$, whose frame is free on one generator. A geometric map796$\mathcal U\to\operatorname{Sh}(\Sigma)$ classifies a subobject of797$1$ in $\mathcal U$ \cite{vickers-double}. The product798$\operatorname{Sh}(\Sigma)^2$ classifies two such subobjects.799The universal operation $(U,V)\mapsto U\cap V$, together with800the unit $1\hookrightarrow 1$, defines a monoidal structure on801$\operatorname{Sh}(\Sigma)$. The operation commutes with inverse802image functors because they preserve finite limits. On the product803topos $\operatorname{Sh}(\Sigma)^r$ it defines an action by804\[805   (U,V_1,\ldots,V_r)806      \longmapsto (U\cap V_1,\ldots,U\cap V_r).807\]808Applying first $U$ and then $W$ gives the same family as applying809$U\cap W$. The point classifying $0\hookrightarrow1$ sends every810tuple to the one consisting of zero subobjects. For $r\geq1$ it811cannot act by an equivalence since this map identifies distinct812tuples already over $\mathbf{Set}$. This example has a813noninvertible action in geometric morphisms, expressed814entirely by geometric logical operations.815 816\subsection{When a torsor classifier is monoidal}817 818The classifying property of $\mathbf B G$ identifies geometric maps819$\mathcal U\to \mathbf B G$ with right $G$-torsors in $\mathcal U$;820$G$ is interpreted as the constant group821\cite[Ch.~VIII, Thm.~2.7]{maclane-moerdijk}. For an ordinary group822$H$, a right $G$-torsor in $\mathbf B H$ is a right $G$-torsor of sets823equipped with a commuting left $H$-action. Choose an element $p$824of the torsor and write $h\cdot p=p\phi(h)$. Commutation of the825actions gives $\phi(hh')=\phi(h)\phi(h')$. Replacing $p$ by826$pg$ conjugates $\phi$ by $g^{-1}$. Conversely, any827homomorphism $\phi:H\to G$ gives a torsor by taking the828regular right $G$-set with left $H$-action by $\phi$.829Thus maps $\mathbf B H\to \mathbf B G$ are classified up to isomorphism830by homomorphisms $H\to G$ up to conjugation. A map induced831by $\phi$ has inverse image given by restriction of action832along $\phi$. Composition of the geometric maps therefore833agrees with composition of the inducing homomorphisms.834 835There is a product equivalence $\mathbf B G\times \mathbf B H\simeq \mathbf B(G\times H)$.836Indeed, the product of a right $G$-torsor and a right837$H$-torsor is a right $(G\times H)$-torsor. Conversely,838a $(G\times H)$-torsor $P$ recovers the two torsors by839quotienting by the $H$- and $G$-actions respectively.840The reconstructed product identifies with $P$ after a covering841over which the torsor is trivial, hence globally by descent.842The two constructions are natural in the test topos,843so represent the same product.844 845\begin{proposition}846\label{prop:torsor-classifier-monoidal}847The topos $\mathbf B G$ admits a monoidal structure for the Cartesian848product of Grothendieck topoi if and only if $G$ is abelian.849For abelian $G$ the standard multiplication makes $\mathbf B G$850a group object, with all laws interpreted up to the851canonical equivalences of products.852\end{proposition}853 854\begin{proof}855A multiplication is classified by a homomorphism856$\mu:G\times G\to G$. The unit map $\mathbf{Set}\to \mathbf B G$ is857unique up to isomorphism, since right $G$-torsors in sets858are isomorphic to $G$. The two unit comparisons imply859that each restriction of $\mu$ to a factor is conjugate860to the identity. Both restrictions are therefore surjective.861Their images commute elementwise, since the factors of862$G\times G$ do. Thus any two elements of $G$ commute.863 864When $G$ is abelian, $(g,h)\mapsto gh$ is a homomorphism.865Its associativity and unit equalities induce the required866coherences by restriction of actions. The inverse867homomorphism $g\mapsto g^{-1}$ similarly supplies inversion.868\end{proof}869 870There are actions of such group topoi that are visible on871automorphisms of points. Let $A$ be abelian and let872$\lambda:A\to Z(H)$ be a homomorphism into the center of873an arbitrary group $H$. The map874\[875 A\times H\longrightarrow H,\qquad876 (a,h)\longmapsto\lambda(a)h877\]878is a homomorphism. It gives a left action $\mathbf B A\times \mathbf B H\to \mathbf B H$879because the unit and associativity equalities hold on these880homomorphisms. Conversely, an action morphism with invertible