Indexed text attachment
actions-of-toposes-on-toposes.tex
Source for Actions of Toposes on Toposes
View paper · Download original file
Lines 713–812 of 1373. Source text is displayed literally.
713epimorphism preserves its classifying topos by this714descent argument. This is a basic Morita invariance715mechanism. For continuous and localic groupoids, object716and arrow spaces have topology and the actions used in717the classifying topos are on equivariant sheaves.718The geometric hypotheses and the descent results for719those settings are developed in720\cite{moerdijk-groupoid,moerdijk-classifying,joyal-tierney}.721 722\begin{example}[A sheaf of groups with trivial global group]723Over \(S^1=\mathbb R/\mathbb Z\), let \(G\) be the locally724constant sheaf with fiber \(\mathbb Z/3\) and monodromy725\(a\mapsto-a\). It is represented as an \'{e}tale group726bundle by identifying \((t,a)\) with \((t+1,-a)\) in727\(\mathbb R\times\mathbb Z/3\). A global section is fixed728by inversion, so the group of global sections is729trivial. Pullback of \(B_{\operatorname{Sh}(S^1)}G\)730over any point gives the topos of \(\mathbb Z/3\)-sets731by base change. This topos has a nontrivial regular732action that is noninitial in the action topos and has no733equivariant global element. In \(\operatorname{Set}\) every noninitial734object has a global element. The global section group735has classifying topos \(\operatorname{Set}\). The relative736classifying topos thus retains the local group and its737transport.738\end{example}739\par740\section{Concrete monoidal topoi and actions}741\label{sec:module-examples}742 743An ordinary group $G$ produces two different topoi. The744topos $\operatorname{Sh}(G_{\mathrm{disc}})$ is the sheaf topos745of the discrete locale with set of points $G$. Multiplication746of the discrete locale gives a monoidal multiplication of this747topos, with inverse induced by $g\mapsto g^{-1}$. By contrast,748write $\mathbf B G$ for the topos of left $G$-sets. It classifies right749$G$-torsors, and the ordinary group law on $G$ does not in750general induce a multiplication of $\mathbf B G$. The distinction751already appears over $\mathbf{Set}$: the discrete locale has752one geometric point for every element of $G$, whereas $\mathbf B G$753has one point up to isomorphism, with automorphism group $G$.754 755\subsection{From locales to monoidal topoi}756 757The construction $\operatorname{Sh}$ preserves products of758locales as products of topoi. One explanation uses the759localic reflection: for a Grothendieck topos $\mathcal U$,760maps $\mathcal U\to\operatorname{Sh}(L)$ classify frame maps761\[762 \mathcal O(L)\longrightarrow763 \operatorname{Sub}_{\mathcal U}(1).764\]765Here a frame map preserves arbitrary joins and finite meets.766The frame of opens of a locale product is the coproduct of767the two frames. Hence giving the classifying data for a map768into the sheaves on a product is equivalent to giving them769for each factor. The same statement holds for the comparisons770of maps: they are determined by the order on the images of771opens, which can be checked on the two factor frames772\cite[Ch.~IX, \S5, Prop.~3]{maclane-moerdijk}. Thus if a group locale $K$773acts on a locale $L$, the multiplication and action induce774\[775 \operatorname{Sh}(K)\times\operatorname{Sh}(L)776 \longrightarrow\operatorname{Sh}(L)777\]778with the required associativity and unit. The construction is779pointfree and applies to localic group actions used in780topos descent \cite[Chs.~V--VIII]{joyal-tierney}.781 782For example, ordinary real addition and real addition with783the discrete topology give different group topoi. Both784have $(\mathbb R,+)$ as their group of geometric points.785Their subterminal frames distinguish them. For the discrete786topology the frame is a Boolean power set. For the usual787topology, a proper nonempty open interval has no open788complement in the connected real line. The two topoi789therefore cannot be equivalent. Both act on the sheaf topos790of the usual real line by translations. The two actions791agree on individual ordinary points, while their parameter792topoi encode different families of translations.793 794A simple monoid that is not a group is the Sierpi\'nski locale795$\Sigma$, whose frame is free on one generator. A geometric map796$\mathcal U\to\operatorname{Sh}(\Sigma)$ classifies a subobject of797$1$ in $\mathcal U$ \cite{vickers-double}. The product798$\operatorname{Sh}(\Sigma)^2$ classifies two such subobjects.799The universal operation $(U,V)\mapsto U\cap V$, together with800the unit $1\hookrightarrow 1$, defines a monoidal structure on801$\operatorname{Sh}(\Sigma)$. The operation commutes with inverse802image functors because they preserve finite limits. On the product803topos $\operatorname{Sh}(\Sigma)^r$ it defines an action by804\[805 (U,V_1,\ldots,V_r)806 \longmapsto (U\cap V_1,\ldots,U\cap V_r).807\]808Applying first $U$ and then $W$ gives the same family as applying809$U\cap W$. The point classifying $0\hookrightarrow1$ sends every810tuple to the one consisting of zero subobjects. For $r\geq1$ it811cannot act by an equivalence since this map identifies distinct812tuples already over $\mathbf{Set}$. This example has a