Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

actions-of-toposes-on-toposes.tex

Source for Actions of Toposes on Toposes

View paper · Download original file

Lines 233–332 of 1373. Source text is displayed literally.

233bicategorical Yoneda argument.234\end{proof}235 236Testing only at $\mathrm{Set}$ can fail entirely.237Let $L$ be the locale of the complete Boolean algebra238of regular open subsets of $\mathbb R$. Its Boolean239algebra is atomless since any nonempty regular open240contains a nonempty smaller interval with closure241inside it. A locale point $h:\mathcal O(L)\to 2$242preserves arbitrary joins and finite meets. Set243$u=\bigvee\{v:h(v)=0\}$, so $h(u)=0$.244Every nonzero element below $\neg u$ has image $1$.245Two disjoint nonzero elements below $\neg u$ would246violate preservation of meets. Thus $\neg u$ would247be an atom. There is no such point.248 249The topos $\mathcal X=\operatorname{Sh}(L\amalg L)$250has no ordinary points. The identity and the swap of251its two summands give two different actions of the252two-element discrete group (realized geometrically253as in the next subsection). On ordinary points the254actions return the same empty description. With test255topos $\operatorname{Sh}(L)$, the inclusion of the256first summand is sent to itself or to the second257summand. Pullback of the subterminal selecting the258first summand distinguishes those two morphisms.259For the locale and sheaf correspondence see260\cite{johnstone-pointless,maclane-moerdijk}.261 262\subsection{Discrete parameters and composition}263 264For a set $I$ write $D_I=\mathrm{Set}^I$, the sheaf265topos of the discrete locale on $I$. Its underlying266category is a product of copies of $\mathrm{Set}$.267In $\mathbf{Top}$, however, it is their coproduct.268More generally a product of categories269$\prod_i\mathcal X_i$ is a coproduct of topoi in the270geometric direction: a left exact left adjoint into271it is a family of left exact left adjoints into the272individual factors. Given their right adjoints, the273right adjoint of the family is the product of their274values in the common source category.275 276\begin{proposition}[Discrete parameter topos]277\label{prop:discrete-param}278There is an equivalence in $\mathbf{Top}$279\[280 D_I\times\mathcal X\simeq\coprod_{i\in I}\mathcal X .281\]282For a discrete monoid $M$, the multiplication on $M$283induces one on $D_M$. Actions of $D_M$ on $\mathcal X$284are weak monoid actions by geometric endomorphisms.285For a group $G$ these are weak group actions by geometric286autoequivalences.287\end{proposition}288 289\begin{proof}290A morphism $\mathcal B\to D_I$ is classified by a291partition of its terminal object,292$1_{\mathcal B}=\coprod_{i\in I}U_i$, into disjoint293subterminal objects. To see this, apply inverse image to294the subterminal supported at each coordinate. In the295other direction the inverse image sends $(S_i)$ to296$\coprod_i S_i\cdot U_i$, where $S_i\cdot U_i$ denotes297the coproduct of $S_i$ copies of $U_i$. It has right298adjoint $A\mapsto(\operatorname{Hom}_{\mathcal B}(U_i,A))_i$.299The disjointness and pullback stability of coproducts300give left exactness. A natural transformation gives inequalities $U_i\leq V_i$301between the two partitions. Each $V_i$ is the coproduct of its302intersections with all the $U_j$, of which only $U_i$ remains.303Hence the partitions coincide, and on copowers the transformation304is fixed by its restriction to the $U_i$.305 306Disjoint stable coproducts give an equivalence307$\mathcal B\simeq\prod_i\mathcal B/U_i$.308A morphism $\mathcal B\to\mathcal X$ therefore309restricts to a family of morphisms310$\mathcal B/U_i\to\mathcal X$, and the restrictions311determine it. A map312$\mathcal B\to\coprod_i\mathcal X$ has exactly the same313data: pull back the subterminals selecting its summands314and take the induced maps on the pieces.315These descriptions are natural in $\mathcal B$ and316also identify transformations. This proves the product317formula.318 319In particular $D_{I\times J}\simeq D_I\times D_J$.320The action evaluation for $D_M$ is therefore specified321by its restrictions $a_m$ to the summands, and the cells322restrict to $a_{mn}\simeq a_m a_n$ and the identity at323the unit. Conversely these data assemble by the coproduct324property. For a group the component at $g^{-1}$ supplies325the inverse to the component at $g$.326\end{proof}327 328In particular $D_G$ and the classifying topos of $G$-sets329serve different purposes. The former parametrizes group330elements. The latter classifies torsors and retains their331automorphisms. For trivial action on $\mathrm{Set}$, a332geometric quotient is the classifying topos, as