Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

actions-of-toposes-on-toposes.tex

Source for Actions of Toposes on Toposes

View paper · Download original file

Lines 173–272 of 1373. Source text is displayed literally.

173product before taking inverse image. The cartesian product174of the underlying categories of sheaves typically gives a175different topos in $\mathbf{Top}$.176 177For an exponentiable $\mathcal X$ in the bicategorical178sense, an action can be curried to a morphism179$\mathcal T\to[\mathcal X,\mathcal X]$. The endomorphism180topos then has a multiplication induced by composition,181and the action cells say that this map preserves it182coherently. The evaluation definition works without this183exponential hypothesis. Exponentiability of Grothendieck184topoi is a separate property studied by Johnstone and185Joyal \cite{johnstone-joyal-exponential}.186 187\subsection{Generalized points determine the action}188 189Write $\operatorname{Geom}(\mathcal B,\mathcal X)$ for190the category of geometric morphisms and transformations.191An action evaluates on each test topos $\mathcal B$ by192the functor193\[194 \begin{aligned}195 \operatorname{Geom}(\mathcal B,\mathcal T)\times196 \operatorname{Geom}(\mathcal B,\mathcal X)197 &\longrightarrow \operatorname{Geom}(\mathcal B,\mathcal X),\\198 (t,x)&\longmapsto a\langle t,x\rangle .199 \end{aligned}200\]201The action cells induce the corresponding cells on all202these functors. In particular, $t:\mathcal B\to\mathcal T$203acts on $\mathcal B\times\mathcal X$ over $\mathcal B$204by the pair205$\langle\pi_{\mathcal B},a\langle t\pi_{\mathcal B},\pi_{\mathcal X}\rangle\rangle$.206If $\mathcal T$ has an inverse morphism with the usual207group identities up to coherent invertible cells, this208endomorphism over $\mathcal B$ is an equivalence.209The inverse is induced by the inverse generalized point,210using the unit and multiplication cells.211 212\begin{proposition}[Test-topos description]213The evaluation $a$ and its coherence cells are equivalent214to the operation on geometric morphisms from every test215topos, with its coherence cells and pseudonaturality under216precomposition.217\end{proposition}218 219\begin{proof}220A product gives a pseudonatural equivalence between the221pair of input hom-categories and222$\operatorname{Geom}(\mathcal B,\mathcal T\times\mathcal X)$.223At $\mathcal B=\mathcal T\times\mathcal X$, apply the224operation to its two projections. The resulting225geometric morphism is $a$. For a pair $(t,x)$ with test226topos $\mathcal B$, pseudonaturality under227$\langle t,x\rangle$ identifies its evaluation with228$a\langle t,x\rangle$. Evaluating transformations at229the same projections recovers the transformation230between action morphisms. Applying this argument with231the products of two and three parameter factors recovers232the coherence cells and their equations. This is the233bicategorical Yoneda argument.234\end{proof}235 236Testing only at $\mathrm{Set}$ can fail entirely.237Let $L$ be the locale of the complete Boolean algebra238of regular open subsets of $\mathbb R$. Its Boolean239algebra is atomless since any nonempty regular open240contains a nonempty smaller interval with closure241inside it. A locale point $h:\mathcal O(L)\to 2$242preserves arbitrary joins and finite meets. Set243$u=\bigvee\{v:h(v)=0\}$, so $h(u)=0$.244Every nonzero element below $\neg u$ has image $1$.245Two disjoint nonzero elements below $\neg u$ would246violate preservation of meets. Thus $\neg u$ would247be an atom. There is no such point.248 249The topos $\mathcal X=\operatorname{Sh}(L\amalg L)$250has no ordinary points. The identity and the swap of251its two summands give two different actions of the252two-element discrete group (realized geometrically253as in the next subsection). On ordinary points the254actions return the same empty description. With test255topos $\operatorname{Sh}(L)$, the inclusion of the256first summand is sent to itself or to the second257summand. Pullback of the subterminal selecting the258first summand distinguishes those two morphisms.259For the locale and sheaf correspondence see260\cite{johnstone-pointless,maclane-moerdijk}.261 262\subsection{Discrete parameters and composition}263 264For a set $I$ write $D_I=\mathrm{Set}^I$, the sheaf265topos of the discrete locale on $I$. Its underlying266category is a product of copies of $\mathrm{Set}$.267In $\mathbf{Top}$, however, it is their coproduct.268More generally a product of categories269$\prod_i\mathcal X_i$ is a coproduct of topoi in the270geometric direction: a left exact left adjoint into271it is a family of left exact left adjoints into the272individual factors. Given their right adjoints, the