Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

algebraic-and-differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Algebraic and Differential Topology in Higher Categories

View paper · Download original file

Lines 9341–9440 of 10051. Source text is displayed literally.

9341\node at (0,-1.5) {\small cap with two discs};9342\end{scope}9343\end{tikzpicture}9344\figcap{Surgery, which the source calls reconstruction. A curve $a$ on the surface with $q(a)=0$ carries the frame9345that extends over a disc. Cut along $a$ and glue in two parallel copies of that disc, with the extended frame:9346the result is a framed surface of genus one less, framed cobordant to the original. If $q(a)=1$ the frame does9347not extend and the handle cannot be cut.}\label{fig:surgery}9348\end{center}9349 9350\begin{proposition}\label{prop:surgery}9351\Scl[\src{II,\,\S11, \S15}] Surgery on a class $a$ with $q(a)=0$ replaces $H_1$ by $a^\perp/\langle a\rangle$ with the9352induced form, and does not change the Arf invariant. A form with $\Arf=0$ can be reduced to genus zero. A form9353with $\Arf=1$ can be reduced to a torus on which $q$ is $1$ on all three non-zero classes, and no further.9354\end{proposition}9355 9356\noindent This was verified for all $84$ forms of genus at most three, by carrying out the reduction. \chk{A5}9357 9358\begin{theorem}\label{thm:second}9359\Scl[\src{II,\,\S15, Thm.~24}] For $n\ge2$, $\pi_{n+2}(S^n)\cong\Z/2$. The class of a framed surface is the Arf9360invariant of its quadratic form, and the non-zero class is represented by the torus $S^1\times S^1$ with the9361product of two copies of the non-bounding frame of the circle: $\eta^2\ne0$.9362\end{theorem}9363\begin{proof}[Structure of the proof]9364By \Cref{prop:surgery} a framed surface is framed cobordant to a sphere or to the odd torus. A framed sphere9365is framed cobordant to zero, since $\pi_2(\SO(n))=0$ and so all frames on it are equivalent. The Arf invariant is9366a cobordism invariant, by the analysis of the critical levels of a framed $3$-manifold \src{II,\,\S15,9367Thms.~22--24}, so the odd torus is not zero.9368\end{proof}9369 9370\section{History, and what the form means}9371 9372The first announcement of this result, in 1938, gave the answer zero; the correct value was published in 19509373\src{II, refs.~1, 2}. The slip was to treat $q$ as if it were linear. If it were, it would vanish on a9374half-dimensional subspace, every handle could be cut, and the group would be trivial. The cross term $x\cdot y$9375in \Cref{thm:quadratic} is what prevents this, and it has a structural meaning.9376 9377\begin{remark}[Why quadratic]\label{rem:kinvariant}9378\Scl A class $x\in H_1(M;\Z/2)$ on a framed surface determines a framed circle, hence an element $q(x)$ of9379$\pis_1$. So $q$ is the map on first framed bordism induced by collapsing $M$ to a point, restricted to classes9380coming from homology, and it would be linear if the framed bordism of $M$ split as the homology of $M$ with9381coefficients in $\pis_0$ and $\pis_1$ separately. It does not split: the sphere spectrum is not a product of9382Eilenberg--MacLane spectra, and the first obstruction, its first $k$-invariant, is the Steenrod square $Sq^2$.9383The Arf invariant of a framed surface is that $k$-invariant, seen through a manifold.9384\end{remark}9385 9386\begin{remark}[Spin structures]\label{rem:spin}9387\Sli[\cite{Joh80,Ati71}] A stable framing of a surface induces a spin structure, and $q$ depends only on it: the9388quadratic refinements of the intersection form correspond exactly to the $2^{2g}$ spin structures on the9389surface. The Arf invariant is the parity of the dimension of the space of holomorphic sections of the9390corresponding square root of the canonical bundle, and is the isomorphism from the spin bordism group of9391surfaces to $\Z/2$. The counts of \Cref{thm:arf}\emph{(b)} are the numbers of even and odd theta9392characteristics.9393\end{remark}9394 9395\begin{remark}[The Kervaire invariant]\label{rem:kervaire}9396\Sli[\cite{Ker60,Bro69,HHR16,LWX24}] The same construction on framed manifolds of dimension $4m+2$, with the middle9397homology in place of $H_1$, gives the Kervaire invariant. Browder showed that it can be non-zero only in9398dimensions $2^{j+1}-2$. Framed manifolds with invariant one exist in dimensions $2,6,14,30,62$; Hill, Hopkins and9399Ravenel showed there are none in dimensions $254$ and above. The preprint of Lin, Wang and Xu establishes9400existence in dimension $126$, the final case left by those results. The dimension-two case is \Cref{thm:second}.9401\end{remark}9402 9403\section*{Notes}9404The source obtains the quadratic property of $q$ and its invariance by direct geometric arguments on surfaces9405in general position and on the level sets of a three-dimensional cobordism. Arf's classification dates from94061941. For the relation with spin structures see Johnson \cite{Joh80}. The history of the correction is as usually9407told; the two notes are the first two references of the source's second monograph.9408 9409\section*{Exercises}9410\begin{exercise}\label{exer:arf1}9411List the four quadratic refinements in genus one with their values on $a$, $b$, $a+b$, and verify9412\Cref{thm:arf}\emph{(b)} and \emph{(c)}.9413\end{exercise}9414\begin{exercise}\label{exer:arfcount}9415Prove the counts in \Cref{thm:arf}\emph{(b)} by induction on the genus from \emph{(d)}.9416\end{exercise}9417\begin{exercise}\label{exer:lin}9418Show that if $q$ were linear and the intersection form non-degenerate, there would be a class $a\neq0$ with9419$q(a)=0$ whenever $g\ge1$, and that surgery could be continued to genus zero. Where does the argument fail for9420the odd torus?9421\end{exercise}9422\begin{exercise}\label{exer:prodarf}9423Let $q_1,q_2$ be the odd forms on two tori. Compute the Arf invariant of the form on the genus-two surface that is9424their orthogonal sum, and interpret the result in $\pis_2$.9425\end{exercise}9426%% ---- end ch/11-arf.tex ----9427%% ---- begin ch/12-stems.tex ----9428\chapter{Stable Stems as the Homotopy of the Unit}\label{ch:stems}9429 9430The two monographs of the source were written decades apart and share no notation. This chapter states the9431sense in which they are one theory with two coefficient rings, and places Pontryagin's results in the table of9432stable stems that later methods filled in.9433 9434\section{Two rings}9435 9436A \term{spectrum} is the stable analogue of a space, an object on which suspension has been made invertible;9437spectra form a symmetric monoidal $\infty$-category $\Sp$ whose unit is the sphere spectrum $\sS$ of9438\Cref{thm:sphere}. Every abelian group $A$ gives an Eilenberg--MacLane spectrum $HA$, and $\HZ$ is a commutative9439ring spectrum whose modules are the objects of $\DD(\Z)$.9440