Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories

View paper · Download original file

Lines 5459–5558 of 6119. Source text is displayed literally.

5459\par5460\chapter{Factorization through an intermediate manifold}5461\label{ch:factorizations}5462 5463A smooth map \(f:X\to Y\) may be specified by two maps through an5464intermediate manifold \(L\). The factorization retains how the map5465is constructed. Rank bounds give local restrictions, and homotopy5466invariants can rule out a factorization even when every local5467rank test passes. We will also distinguish a pointwise choice of5468factorization from a continuous family of choices.5469 5470\section{Differential constraints}5471 5472Suppose \(f=d\circ e\) with \(e:X\to L\) and \(d:L\to Y\).5473The chain rule says that \(D_xf\) factors as5474\[5475T_xX\xrightarrow{D_xe}T_{e(x)}L\xrightarrow{D_{e(x)}d}T_{f(x)}Y.5476\]5477Consequently \(\operatorname{rank}D_xf\le\dim L\). The constant-rank5478normal form gives a local converse at points of an open region where5479the rank is some fixed \(r\): in suitable coordinates the map is5480the projection to \(r\) coordinates followed by the inclusion of5481those coordinates in the target chart. This describes a local5482factorization through an open subset of \(\mathbb R^r\). The5483coordinate projections on two such neighborhoods need not provide5484one global intermediary.5485 5486\begin{proposition}[An exact reconstruction embeds the source]5487\label{prop:split-embedding}5488If \(X\) is compact and \(d\circ e=\mathrm{id}_X\) with smooth5489\(e:X\to L\) and \(d:L\to X\), then \(e\) is a smooth embedding.5490If \(X\) and \(L\) have the same dimension, both have no boundary,5491and \(L\) is connected, then \(e\) is a diffeomorphism for5492nonempty \(X\).5493\end{proposition}5494 5495\begin{proof}5496The left-inverse identity makes \(e\) injective, and differentiating5497it makes \(De\) injective at every point. Compactness of \(X\) and5498the Hausdorff property of \(L\) give a homeomorphism onto the5499image. Together with immersion, this is the embedding condition.5500In equal dimensions the inverse function theorem makes \(e(X)\)5501open. It is also compact, hence closed, and connectedness of \(L\)5502implies \(e(X)=L\). The local smooth inverses then give the global5503inverse.5504\end{proof}5505 5506The derivative already imposes a representation constraint when5507a group acts on the spaces and both maps are equivariant. At a5508fixed input \(x\), the identity factors through \(T_{e(x)}L\) by5509two intertwiners. Thus \(T_xX\) must occur as a split subrepresentation5510for the stabilizer of \(x\). This may exclude an intermediate5511manifold of sufficient ordinary dimension.5512 5513Conversely, every smooth embedding of compact \(X\) in \(L\)5514admits an exact reconstruction defined on a neighborhood of the5515encoded image. By the tubular-neighborhood theorem, a small5516neighborhood \(U\) of \(e(X)\) is identified with a neighborhood5517of the zero section in its normal bundle. Projection from the5518bundle to \(e(X)\), followed by \(e^{-1}\), gives a smooth5519decoder \(U\to X\). The existence of a decoder on all of \(L\)5520asks for an extension of a left inverse. A local normal form5521alone only supplies the neighborhood decoder, even when the5522embedded image is closed. For example, the usual inclusion of5523\(S^n\) in \(\mathbb R^{n+1}\) has the radial decoder on an5524annulus, yet a global sphere-valued decoder would induce an5525impossible retraction on top cohomology.5526 5527\section{Obstructions preserved by homotopy}5528 5529Suppose now that \(d\circ e\) is homotopic to \(\mathrm{id}_X\).5530For any commutative coefficient ring \(R\), functoriality in singular cohomology5531gives unital graded ring maps5532\[5533H^*(X;R)\xrightarrow{d^*}H^*(L;R)5534 \xrightarrow{e^*}H^*(X;R),\qquad e^*d^*=\mathrm{id}.5535\]5536A nonzero cup product in \(H^*(X;R)\) must remain nonzero after5537applying \(d^*\). Rank tests on the groups \(H^k\) alone can miss5538this restriction. Similarly, on homotopy groups a path supplied5539by the homotopy allows the base point of \(d\circ e\) to be compared5540with the starting point in \(X\). With that comparison in place,5541the map on each homotopy group induced by \(e\) has a left5542inverse induced by \(d\). See \cite{hatcher-at} for the cohomology and5543base-point conventions.5544 5545For a closed connected oriented \(n\)-manifold \(X\), with \(n>0\),5546a degree-one reconstruction of \(X\) induces a nonzero map on5547\(H^n(X;\mathbb Z)\). It cannot factor through a manifold of5548dimension less than \(n\), since that manifold has no cohomology5549in degree \(n\). Here one can use a triangulation of the5550intermediate smooth manifold and its dimension bound. This is a5551homotopy obstruction, so it also applies when the reconstruction5552has critical points. A factorization through a contractible5553\(L\) makes the composite nullhomotopic by applying \(d\) to a5554contraction after \(e\). Positive dimension allows degree to5555distinguish this case from the identity.5556 5557\begin{example}[The cup product on a torus]5558Let \(X=T^2\) and take \(L\) to be the connected sum of two copies of