Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

partial-differential-equations-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Partial Differential Equations in Higher Categories

View paper · Download original file

Lines 561–660 of 3921. Source text is displayed literally.

561%% ---- end ch/01-equations.tex ----562%% ---- begin ch/02-archetypes.tex ----563\chapter{Three Archetypes and Well-Posedness}\label{ch:archetypes}564 565Three equations carry the source: the wave equation, the diffusion equation and Laplace's equation. This566chapter says where they come from, in a form that shows which of their properties are forced, and then567states what it means for a problem to be correctly set.568 569\section{Conservation and constitution}570 571Each derivation in the source \src{\S1.3} has two steps. The first is a balance: what is in a region changes only572by what crosses its boundary,573\begin{equation}\label{eq:balance}574\pd_t\rho+\Div j=0 .575\end{equation}576The second is a material law expressing the flux $j$ through the unknown.577\begin{center}\small578\begin{tabular}{@{}llll@{}}579\toprule580phenomenon & conserved & material law & equation\\581\midrule582transport & mass & $j=c\rho$ & $u_t+cu_x=0$\\583diffusion & mass, heat & $j=-k\nabla u$ (Fick, Fourier) & $u_t=k\Lap u$\\584vibration & momentum & stress $=T\nabla u$ (Hooke) & $\rho u_{tt}=T\Lap u$\\585equilibrium & --- & either of the last two, steady & $\Lap u=0$\\586\bottomrule587\end{tabular}588\end{center}589 590\begin{proposition}[Topological and metric parts]\label{prop:tonti}591\Srf[\cite{Ton75,Bos98}] The balance \eqref{eq:balance} is the statement that a differential form is closed: it592uses only the exterior derivative, which commutes with pullback along every smooth map. The material law is a593Hodge star: it uses a metric, and commutes only with isometries. The Laplacian is the composite594$\Lap=-\dd^*\dd$, with $\dd^*=\pm\star\,\dd\,\star$.595\end{proposition}596 597\noindent On a graph the same factorization is exact arithmetic: with $D$ the incidence matrix, the Laplacian is598$D^{\T}WD$ for a diagonal matrix $W$ of conductances, and the columns of $D^{\T}D$ sum to zero, which is conservation599of mass. \chk{W3} Two things follow at once. The symmetries of the three archetypes are the isometries, because the600only non-natural ingredient is the metric (\Cref{ch:harmonic,ch:symmetry}). And a discretization should discretize601$\dd$ exactly and $\star$ approximately (\Cref{ch:numerics}).602 603With signs suppressed, the proposition is the square604\[\begin{tikzcd}[column sep=huge,row sep=large]605\text{potential }u\arrow[r,"\dd"]\arrow[d,dashed,"\Lap"'] & \text{gradient }\dd u\arrow[d,"\star\ \text{(material)}"]\\606\text{source }f & \text{flux }q\arrow[l,"\dd"]607\end{tikzcd}\]608in which the horizontal arrows are natural for all smooth maps and the right-hand one only for isometries. Every609linear equation of the volume is a way round a square of this shape, sometimes with time as one of the variables.610 611\section{Data as a restriction map}612 613An equation has many solutions; a problem adds conditions \src{\S1.4}. Initial conditions prescribe $u$, and for614second order in time also $u_t$, on $\{t=0\}$. Boundary conditions prescribe $u$ (Dirichlet), the normal derivative615(Neumann) or a combination $\pd_nu+au$ (Robin) on the boundary of the spatial domain. In every case there is a616linear map617\[ r\colon\Sol(P;X)\longrightarrow Y \]618from solutions in a chosen function space $X$ to data in a chosen space $Y$.619 620\begin{definition}[Hadamard]\label{def:wellposed}621The problem $(P,r,X,Y)$ is \term{well-posed} if $r$ is an isomorphism of topological vector spaces: surjective622(existence), injective (uniqueness), with continuous inverse (stability).623\end{definition}624 625\noindent The definition is the source's \src{\S1.5} with one addition that the categorical phrasing makes626unavoidable: stability is a property of a morphism in a category of topological vector spaces, and it depends on627the category. A problem may be well-posed for one pair $(X,Y)$ and ill-posed for another.628 629\begin{example}[Kernel and cokernel]\label{ex:fredholm}630For the Neumann problem $-\Lap u=f$, $\pd_nu=0$, the map from $u$ to $f$ is not an isomorphism: constants are in631the kernel and a solution exists only if $\int f=0$. It is Fredholm of index zero, with an exact sequence632$0\to\R\to X\to Y\to\R\to0$. On a path with six vertices the rank is $5$ and the system is solvable exactly for633sources of mean zero. \chk{W5} The source's underdetermined and overdetermined problems are those with non-zero634kernel and cokernel; its first example, $u''+u=0$ with $u(0)=u(L)=0$, has a kernel exactly when $\sin L=0$. \chk{W6}635\end{example}636 637\begin{example}[Hadamard]\label{ex:hadamard}638The functions $u_n(x,y)=n^{-1}e^{-\sqrt n}\sin nx\sinh ny$ are harmonic, vanish on $y=0$, and have normal639derivative $e^{-\sqrt n}\sin nx$ there, which tends to zero with all its derivatives. At $y=1$ their size is640$e^{-\sqrt n}\sinh n/n$.641\begin{center}\small642\begin{tabular}{@{}lccc@{}}643\toprule644$n$ & $25$ & $100$ & $400$\\645\midrule646size of the data & $6.7\times10^{-3}$ & $4.5\times10^{-5}$ & $2.1\times10^{-9}$\\647size of the solution at $y=1$ & $9.7\times10^{6}$ & $6.1\times10^{36}$ & $1.3\times10^{162}$\\648\bottomrule649\end{tabular}650\end{center}651The Cauchy problem for Laplace's equation has at most one solution, and its inverse is not continuous in any652topology of finitely many derivatives. \chk{W1}653\end{example}654 655\begin{example}[Time's arrow]\label{ex:backward}656For $u_t=u_{xx}$ on $(0,\pi)$ the mode $\sin nx$ evolves by the factor $e^{-n^2t}$. Forwards this is a contraction.657Backwards over a time $0.1$ the modes $n=1,10,30$ are amplified by $1.1$, $2.2\times10^4$ and $1.2\times10^{39}$.658\chk{W2} The backward problem is solvable on a dense set of data and its solution map is unbounded: the heat659flow is a semigroup that is not a group (\Cref{ch:diffusions}).660\end{example}