Indexed text attachment
partial-differential-equations-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Partial Differential Equations in Higher Categories
View paper · Download original file
Lines 361–460 of 3921. Source text is displayed literally.
361solutions restrict to open subsets and glue, $\Sol(\EE)$ is a sheaf on $M$.362 363\section{Linear equations and their modules}364 365Let $\DD$ be the ring of linear differential operators on $M$ with smooth coefficients. A linear equation $Pu=0$366is recorded by the left $\DD$-module $\DD/\DD P$, and for any left $\DD$-module $\FF$ of functions367\[ \Sol(P;\FF)=\Hom_\DD(\DD/\DD P,\FF)=\{u\in\FF:Pu=0\}. \]368This is functorial in both variables. In $\FF$ it is covariant: smooth functions sit inside distributions, and369classical solutions inside weak ones (\Cref{ch:distributions}). In the equation it is contravariant: if $QR=SP$ then370$u\mapsto Ru$ maps $\Sol(P)$ to $\Sol(Q)$.371 372\begin{proposition}[Factorization]\label{prop:factor}373\Srf For operators $P,Q$ there is an exact sequence374\[ 0\longrightarrow\Sol(Q)\longrightarrow\Sol(PQ)\xrightarrow{\ Q\ }\Sol(P). \]375If $P$ and $Q$ commute, then $\Sol(P)+\Sol(Q)\subseteq\Sol(PQ)$, with equality as soon as $Q$ maps $\Sol(P)$ onto376itself: for $u\in\Sol(PQ)$ choose $w\in\Sol(P)$ with $Qw=Qu$, and then $u-w\in\Sol(Q)$.377\end{proposition}378 379\noindent The wave operator is the case $P=\pd_t-c\pd_x$, $Q=\pd_t+c\pd_x$, checked on polynomials \chk{E5}; d'Alembert's380solution in \Cref{ch:waves} is the equality $\Sol(PQ)=\Sol(P)+\Sol(Q)$.381 382In a diagram: for commuting $P$ and $Q$ the square of inclusions383\[\begin{tikzcd}[column sep=large]384\Sol(P)\cap\Sol(Q)\arrow[r,hook]\arrow[d,hook] & \Sol(P)\arrow[d,hook]\\385\Sol(Q)\arrow[r,hook] & \Sol(PQ)386\end{tikzcd}\]387is a pullback of vector spaces, and it is also a pushout exactly when $\Sol(P)+\Sol(Q)=\Sol(PQ)$. For the wave388operator the corner is the constants, and d'Alembert's theorem says that the square is bicartesian: a solution is389a right-moving and a left-moving wave, glued along what they have in common.390 391For constant coefficients $\DD=\R[\pd_1,\dots,\pd_n]$ is a polynomial ring, $P=p(\pd)$, and the module is392$\R[\xi]/(p)$: the equation \emph{is} the hypersurface $V(p)=\{p(\xi)=0\}\subseteq\C^n$. Each point $\xi\in V(p)$ gives the393exponential solution $e^{\xi\cdot x}$.394 395\begin{theorem}[Fundamental principle]\label{thm:ehrenpreis}396\Sli[\cite{Ehr70,Pal70}] On a convex domain every smooth solution of a constant-coefficient equation $p(\pd)u=0$ is an397integral, over $V(p)$, of exponential solutions with polynomial coefficients.398\end{theorem}399 400\noindent Separation of variables is thus not a trick that happens to work: for constant coefficients it is the401general solution. The source's Fourier method (\Cref{ch:fourier}) is the special case in which boundary conditions402select a discrete set of points of $V(p)$.403 404\section{The symbol and the type}405 406Write a second-order operator as $P=\sum_{i,j}a_{ij}(x)\pd_i\pd_j+{}$lower order, with $a_{ij}$ symmetric. Its407\term{principal symbol} is the quadratic form $\sigma_P(x,\xi)=\sum a_{ij}(x)\xi_i\xi_j$.408 409\begin{theorem}[Type]\label{thm:type}410\Scl[source, Theorem 1 of \S1.6] Under a change of coordinates $y=\varphi(x)$ the symbol transforms by congruence411with the Jacobian, so $\sigma_P$ is a function on the cotangent bundle and its inertia $(p,q,z)$ at each point is412invariant. The operator is \term{elliptic} at $x$ if $\sigma_P$ is definite, \term{hyperbolic} if it is413non-degenerate with one sign differing from the rest, \term{parabolic} if it is semidefinite with a one-dimensional414kernel. In two variables these are the cases $a_{12}^2<a_{11}a_{22}$, $>$ and $=$.415\end{theorem}416 417\noindent Invariance was tested on three hundred random symbols and changes of variables, and the classification of418the source's variable-coefficient example by the sign of $1-xy$ was reproduced. \chk{E1, E2}419 420\begin{center}421\begin{tikzpicture}422\begin{scope}[shift={(0,0)}]423\draw[ink2] (0,0) rectangle (4.2,4.2);424\draw[ink2] (0.7,0)--(0.7,-0.07) node[below,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $-2$};425\draw[ink2] (2.1,0)--(2.1,-0.07) node[below,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $0$};426\draw[ink2] (3.5,0)--(3.5,-0.07) node[below,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $2$};427\draw[ink2] (0,0.7)--(-0.07,0.7) node[left,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $-2$};428\draw[ink2] (0,2.1)--(-0.07,2.1) node[left,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $0$};429\draw[ink2] (0,3.5)--(-0.07,3.5) node[left,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $2$};430\fill[bwd!14] (2.333,4.2) -- (2.38,3.85) -- (2.427,3.6) -- (2.473,3.413) -- (2.52,3.267) -- (2.567,3.15) -- (2.613,3.055) -- (2.66,2.975) -- (2.707,2.908) -- (2.753,2.85) -- (2.8,2.8) -- (2.847,2.756) -- (2.893,2.718) -- (2.94,2.683) -- (2.987,2.653) -- (3.033,2.625) -- (3.08,2.6) -- (3.127,2.577) -- (3.173,2.557) -- (3.22,2.538) -- (3.267,2.52) -- (3.313,2.504) -- (3.36,2.489) -- (3.407,2.475) -- (3.453,2.462) -- (3.5,2.45) -- (3.547,2.439) -- (3.593,2.428) -- (3.64,2.418) -- (3.687,2.409) -- (3.733,2.4) -- (3.78,2.392) -- (3.827,2.384) -- (3.873,2.376) -- (3.92,2.369) -- (3.967,2.363) -- (4.013,2.356) -- (4.06,2.35) -- (4.107,2.344) -- (4.153,2.339) -- (4.2,2.333) -- (4.2,4.2) -- cycle;431\fill[bwd!14] (1.867,0) -- (1.82,0.35) -- (1.773,0.6) -- (1.727,0.788) -- (1.68,0.933) -- (1.633,1.05) -- (1.587,1.145) -- (1.54,1.225) -- (1.493,1.292) -- (1.447,1.35) -- (1.4,1.4) -- (1.353,1.444) -- (1.307,1.482) -- (1.26,1.517) -- (1.213,1.547) -- (1.167,1.575) -- (1.12,1.6) -- (1.073,1.623) -- (1.027,1.643) -- (0.98,1.662) -- (0.933,1.68) -- (0.887,1.696) -- (0.84,1.711) -- (0.793,1.725) -- (0.747,1.738) -- (0.7,1.75) -- (0.653,1.761) -- (0.607,1.772) -- (0.56,1.782) -- (0.513,1.791) -- (0.467,1.8) -- (0.42,1.808) -- (0.373,1.816) -- (0.327,1.824) -- (0.28,1.831) -- (0.233,1.838) -- (0.187,1.844) -- (0.14,1.85) -- (0.093,1.856) -- (0.047,1.861) -- (0,1.867) -- (0,0) -- cycle;432\draw[thick,bwd] (2.333,4.2) -- (2.38,3.85) -- (2.427,3.6) -- (2.473,3.413) -- (2.52,3.267) -- (2.567,3.15) -- (2.613,3.055) -- (2.66,2.975) -- (2.707,2.908) -- (2.753,2.85) -- (2.8,2.8) -- (2.847,2.756) -- (2.893,2.718) -- (2.94,2.683) -- (2.987,2.653) -- (3.033,2.625) -- (3.08,2.6) -- (3.127,2.577) -- (3.173,2.557) -- (3.22,2.538) -- (3.267,2.52) -- (3.313,2.504) -- (3.36,2.489) -- (3.407,2.475) -- (3.453,2.462) -- (3.5,2.45) -- (3.547,2.439) -- (3.593,2.428) -- (3.64,2.418) -- (3.687,2.409) -- (3.733,2.4) -- (3.78,2.392) -- (3.827,2.384) -- (3.873,2.376) -- (3.92,2.369) -- (3.967,2.363) -- (4.013,2.356) -- (4.06,2.35) -- (4.107,2.344) -- (4.153,2.339) -- (4.2,2.333);433\draw[thick,bwd] (1.867,0) -- (1.82,0.35) -- (1.773,0.6) -- (1.727,0.788) -- (1.68,0.933) -- (1.633,1.05) -- (1.587,1.145) -- (1.54,1.225) -- (1.493,1.292) -- (1.447,1.35) -- (1.4,1.4) -- (1.353,1.444) -- (1.307,1.482) -- (1.26,1.517) -- (1.213,1.547) -- (1.167,1.575) -- (1.12,1.6) -- (1.073,1.623) -- (1.027,1.643) -- (0.98,1.662) -- (0.933,1.68) -- (0.887,1.696) -- (0.84,1.711) -- (0.793,1.725) -- (0.747,1.738) -- (0.7,1.75) -- (0.653,1.761) -- (0.607,1.772) -- (0.56,1.782) -- (0.513,1.791) -- (0.467,1.8) -- (0.42,1.808) -- (0.373,1.816) -- (0.327,1.824) -- (0.28,1.831) -- (0.233,1.838) -- (0.187,1.844) -- (0.14,1.85) -- (0.093,1.856) -- (0.047,1.861) -- (0,1.867);434\draw[ink2,very thin] (0,2.1)--(4.2,2.1);435\draw[ink2,very thin] (2.1,0)--(2.1,4.2);436\node[] at (3.57,3.71) {\scriptsize elliptic};437\node[] at (0.63,0.49) {\scriptsize elliptic};438\node[] at (1.19,3.08) {\scriptsize hyperbolic};439\node[] at (3.045,1.05) {\scriptsize hyperbolic};440\node[bwd] at (3.885,2.534) {\scriptsize $xy=1$};441\end{scope}442\end{tikzpicture}443\figcap{The type of $yu_{xx}-2u_{xy}+xu_{yy}$ in the plane: hyperbolic where $xy<1$, elliptic where $xy>1$, parabolic on the two branches of $xy=1$. The type is a function on the domain and may change across it.}444\end{center}445 446The \term{characteristic variety} $\Char(P)=\{(x,\xi):\xi\ne0,\ \sigma_P(x,\xi)=0\}$ is the real part of the447hypersurface above, taken to leading order. It is empty exactly for elliptic operators; for the wave operator it448is the light cone and for the heat operator a line. \chk{E5}449 450\begin{remark}[Algebra does not see the type]\label{rem:type}451\Sob The homogeneous polynomial solutions of degree $k$ of a non-zero homogeneous second-order operator in $n$452variables with constant coefficients form a space of dimension $\binom{n+k-1}{k}-\binom{n+k-3}{k-2}$, whatever the453type: the operator maps polynomials of degree $k$ onto those of degree $k-2$. \chk{E4} The count is $2$ in the plane454and $2k+1$ in space, for Laplace, wave and degenerate operators alike. Elliptic, hyperbolic and parabolic455equations have the same formal solutions; they differ in which formal solutions converge and in how solutions456depend on data. The type is a statement about the \emph{real} points of the characteristic variety, and its457consequences are analytic. This is why the three archetypes need three chapters, and why the categorical language458must include topology on spaces of functions to say anything about them.459\end{remark}460