Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

partial-differential-equations-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Partial Differential Equations in Higher Categories

View paper · Download original file

Lines 3361–3460 of 3921. Source text is displayed literally.

3361%% ---- end ch/14-nonlinear.tex ----3362%% ---- begin ch/15-coda.tex ----3363\chapter{Assessment}\label{ch:coda}3364 3365\section{What the language did}3366 3367Eight things, roughly in the order of how much they changed our reading of the source.3368 3369\emph{Boundary conditions became objects.} A boundary condition is a character of a reflection group when the3370domain is a chamber (\Cref{thm:images}) and a Lagrangian plane of boundary values in general3371(\Cref{thm:lagrangian}). The first explains when the method of images works and extends it to diffusion, where3372the source says it fails; the second explains the source's ``symmetric'' conditions and puts Dirichlet, Neumann,3373Robin and periodic conditions in one three-dimensional family.3374 3375\emph{Two methods turned out to be one.} The sum over images and the sum over eigenfunctions are exchanged by3376Pontryagin duality (\Cref{thm:kernels}, \Cref{thm:fourier}), and the same exchange computes the heat trace3377(\Cref{prop:rect}). The source presents Fourier's method as the replacement for a method that does not3378generalize; they are dual.3379 3380\emph{The comparison of waves and diffusions was reduced to three lines.} Group or semigroup; symplectic form or3381positivity; and the six remaining rows of the source's table follow (\Cref{ch:diffusions}).3382 3383\emph{Stability of schemes was identified with structure.} For diffusion it is membership in the Markov category3384(\Cref{thm:explicit}); for waves it is respect for the causal structure (\Cref{thm:cfl}); for elliptic problems it is3385being a map of complexes (\Cref{thm:feec}).3386 3387\emph{Problems could be glued.} Dirichlet-to-Neumann maps, transfer matrices and boundary conditions compose as3388Lagrangian relations (\Cref{thm:gluing}, \Cref{thm:transfer}).3389 3390\emph{The type was located.} It is invisible to the algebra of formal solutions and lives in the real points of the3391characteristic variety (\Cref{rem:type}); it reappears as the singular support of the fundamental solution3392(\Cref{thm:fund}) and as the kind of functor that time is.3393 3394\emph{Solvable nonlinear equations were explained by morphisms.} Cole--Hopf and the scattering transform are maps3395of equations onto linear ones (\Cref{thm:colehopf}, \Cref{thm:ist}).3396 3397\emph{Isospectrality became an isomorphism of representations} that is not an isometry (\Cref{thm:sunada}).3398 3399\section{What it did not do}3400 3401It proved no theorem of analysis. Existence of solutions, in every chapter, rests on estimates that the language3402does not supply: the maximum principle, energy inequalities, compactness. The definition of well-posedness as an3403isomorphism in a category of topological vector spaces (\Cref{def:wellposed}) says where the difficulty is and3404does not reduce it. The machinery cited in \Cref{ch:equations}, the jet comonad and $\DD$-modules, was used only to3405say what a morphism of equations is. Microlocal analysis and hyperfunctions, where sheaf theory does real work3406for linear equations, are described and not used. The nonlinear chapter treats two integrable examples and one3407scalar conservation law; for systems of conservation laws, for the Euler and Navier--Stokes equations and for the3408full water wave problem the categorical viewpoint has, so far as we can see, nothing to offer beyond the remarks3409made. The observations tagged as such are short and may well be known in other forms.3410 3411\section{How much of this is higher}3412 3413\begin{center}\small3414\begin{tabular}{@{}>{\raggedright}p{0.2\textwidth}>{\raggedright}p{0.4\textwidth}>{\raggedright\arraybackslash}p{0.31\textwidth}@{}}3415\toprule3416Source & Structure used here & Level\\3417\midrule3418Ch.~1 & solution functor; symbol; quotient by characteristics & $1$-categorical\\3419Ch.~2--3 & group and Markov semigroup; reflection groups; causal functor & $1$-categorical\\3420Ch.~4--5 & Lagrangian planes; Pontryagin duality & $1$-categorical; relations compose\\3421Ch.~6--7 & sheaf of harmonic functions; Lagrangian relations & cohomology in degree $1$; a category of cospans\\3422Ch.~8 & commuting squares; cochain maps & $1$-categorical; chain level\\3423Ch.~9 & causal functor; descent; a holomorphic semigroup & $1$-categorical; microlocal sheaves cited\\3424Ch.~10 & representations of symmetry groups & $1$-categorical\\3425Ch.~11 & monotone functors; trace of a semigroup; permutation representations & $1$-categorical\\3426Ch.~12 & sheaf of distributions; hyperfunctions & local cohomology\\3427Ch.~13 & gauge groupoids; functorial field theory & stacks; derived solution spaces\\3428Ch.~14 & morphisms of equations; conservation laws & $1$-categorical; horizontal cohomology\\3429\bottomrule3430\end{tabular}3431\end{center}3432 3433\noindent The subject at the level of the source is ordinary category theory with a good deal of representation3434theory. Higher structure enters at four points, and only the last is unavoidable. Cohomology in degree one appears3435for the annulus, for comparison of discretizations, and for flat gauge fields. Networks and domains with boundary3436compose as cospans, which form a bicategory or double category when the gluing is tracked up to isomorphism.3437Hyperfunctions and the solution complexes of $\DD$-modules are derived objects; the cokernel in3438\Cref{ex:fredholm} is the first $\operatorname{Ext}$ group of the theory. And gauge fields form stacks, so that3439for the equations of \Cref{ch:fields} the solution functor does not take values in sets.3440 3441\section{Programme}3442 3443\Spg (1) Characterize the boundary-value problems solvable by images as those on quotients of space by reflection3444groupoids, including orbifold covers, and decide whether mixed and Robin conditions have a place there. (2)3445Formulate the equivalence theorem of \Cref{thm:lax} as a statement about lax natural transformations between3446functors on a category of grids, with stability as the condition for the colimit to exist. (3) Extend3447\Cref{thm:gluing} from networks to domains with geometry, as a functor from a category of cobordisms to Lagrangian3448relations, and relate it to the gluing formulas for determinants of Laplacians. (4) Find a universal property that3449selects entropy solutions among weak solutions of a balance law, as \Cref{thm:viscosity} selects them by a limit.3450 3451\section*{Notes}3452 3453The companion paper \cite{PDEML} applies the framework to machine learning: padding as a boundary condition, the3454score in diffusion models as the datum that makes the backward heat equation well-posed, the spectral gap as the3455rate of oversmoothing in graph networks, and the type of an equation as the rank of its solution operator. The3456volume belongs to a series with \cite{GIHC,ESCHC,DTHC,EGHC}.3457%% ---- end ch/15-coda.tex ----3458\appendix3459%% ---- begin ch/A-toolkit.tex ----3460\chapter{Toolkit}\label{app:toolkit}