Indexed text attachment
algebraic-and-differential-topology-in-machine-learning-and-ai.tex
Source for Algebraic and Differential Topology in Machine Learning and AI: Obstructions, Invariants, and Counts
View paper · Download original file
Lines 855–954 of 1055. Source text is displayed literally.
855\node[fwd,anchor=west,inner sep=2pt] at (6.6,2.67) {\scriptsize $d=1$};856\node[accent,anchor=west,inner sep=2pt] at (6.6,4.153) {\scriptsize $d=2$};857\end{scope}858\end{tikzpicture}859\caption{Fixed points of three maps $\theta\mapsto d\theta+\epsilon g(\theta)$ of the circle, with the same $g$. Plotted is the displacement $(d-1)\theta+\epsilon g(\theta)$; a fixed point is a crossing of a multiple of $2\pi$ (dotted). Downward crossings have index $1$ (filled) and upward ones index $-1$ (open). The curve for $d$ climbs by $d-1$ levels in one turn, so the indices add up to $1-d$: here $3$, $6$, $1$ points with sums $1$, $0$, $-1$ for $d=0,1,2$.}\label{fig:circlemap}860\end{figure}861 862\noindent For circle maps $\theta\mapsto d\theta+\epsilon g(\theta)$ with random $g$ and $\epsilon=2$, the fixed863points number $5,7,6,9,8$ for $d=-2,0,1,2,3$ and their indices add up to $3,1,0,-1,-2$ (\cref{fig:circlemap}864shows three maps of the same kind). \chk{N4} For three drift865fields on a torus there are four zeros each, a source, a sink and two saddles. \chk{N5} The consequences differ866by manifold. On a ring or a torus, noise in the weights breaks the continuum of fixed points into isolated ones,867stable and unstable in balance, or removes all of them and leaves a uniform drift, which $\chi=0$ permits. On a868sphere that second outcome is impossible: every perturbation of a spherical attractor keeps a fixed point,869because $\chi=2$.870 871\subsection{Degree and the passage through zero}872 873Let a network produce $u_w(\theta)\in\R^2$ for an input on a circle and output the direction $u_w/|u_w|$. As long874as $u_w$ does not vanish this is a map of the circle to itself with a degree.875 876\begin{theorem}\label{thm:zero}877\Scl[\cite{ADTHC}, Thm.~9.1] \emph{(a)} The degree is the signed number of preimages of any regular direction.878\emph{(b)} Along a path of weights the degree is constant unless $u_w(\theta)=0$ for some $\theta$ and some879weight on the path.880\end{theorem}881 882\begin{figure}[t]883\centering884\begin{tikzpicture}885\draw[ink2,very thin] (0,0)--(1.927,0);886\draw[ink2,very thin] (1.021,-1.254)--(1.021,1.254);887\draw[fwd,thick] plot coordinates {(1.743,-0.243) (1.736,-0.21) (1.73,-0.177) (1.722,-0.144) (1.715,-0.11) (1.706,-0.076) (1.697,-0.043) (1.687,-0.009) (1.677,0.024) (1.666,0.058) (1.654,0.091) (1.642,0.124) (1.63,0.157) (1.617,0.19) (1.603,0.222) (1.589,0.254) (1.574,0.285) (1.559,0.316) (1.543,0.347) (1.527,0.377) (1.511,0.406) (1.494,0.435) (1.477,0.464) (1.459,0.491) (1.441,0.518) (1.423,0.545) (1.404,0.571) (1.385,0.596) (1.365,0.62) (1.345,0.644) (1.325,0.667) (1.305,0.689) (1.284,0.711) (1.262,0.732) (1.241,0.752) (1.219,0.772) (1.197,0.791) (1.174,0.809) (1.151,0.826) (1.128,0.843) (1.105,0.859) (1.081,0.875) (1.057,0.89) (1.033,0.904) (1.009,0.918) (0.984,0.931) (0.96,0.943) (0.935,0.955) (0.91,0.967) (0.886,0.977) (0.861,0.988) (0.837,0.997) (0.813,1.006) (0.789,1.015) (0.765,1.022) (0.742,1.03) (0.719,1.036) (0.696,1.042) (0.674,1.048) (0.653,1.052) (0.632,1.056) (0.611,1.06) (0.591,1.063) (0.572,1.065) (0.553,1.067) (0.535,1.068) (0.518,1.068) (0.501,1.068) (0.484,1.067) (0.469,1.065) (0.454,1.062) (0.439,1.059) (0.425,1.056) (0.412,1.051) (0.399,1.046) (0.386,1.04) (0.374,1.033) (0.362,1.026) (0.351,1.018) (0.341,1.009) (0.33,1) (0.32,0.99) (0.31,0.979) (0.301,0.967) (0.292,0.954) (0.283,0.941) (0.274,0.927) (0.266,0.913) (0.258,0.897) (0.25,0.881) (0.243,0.865) (0.235,0.847) (0.228,0.829) (0.222,0.811) (0.215,0.791) (0.209,0.772) (0.203,0.751) (0.197,0.73) (0.192,0.709) (0.187,0.687) (0.182,0.665) (0.177,0.642) (0.173,0.619) (0.17,0.595) (0.166,0.571) (0.163,0.547) (0.161,0.523) (0.159,0.498) (0.157,0.474) (0.156,0.449) (0.155,0.423) (0.155,0.398) (0.155,0.373) (0.156,0.347) (0.157,0.321) (0.159,0.296) (0.162,0.27) (0.164,0.244) (0.168,0.218) (0.172,0.192) (0.176,0.166) (0.182,0.14) (0.187,0.114) (0.193,0.088) (0.2,0.062) (0.208,0.037) (0.215,0.011) (0.224,-0.015) (0.233,-0.04) (0.243,-0.065) (0.253,-0.091) (0.264,-0.116) (0.275,-0.141) (0.287,-0.166) (0.3,-0.19) (0.313,-0.215) (0.327,-0.239) (0.342,-0.263) (0.357,-0.287) (0.373,-0.311) (0.39,-0.335) (0.407,-0.359) (0.425,-0.382) (0.444,-0.405) (0.463,-0.429) (0.483,-0.452) (0.504,-0.474) (0.526,-0.497) (0.548,-0.52) (0.571,-0.542) (0.595,-0.564) (0.619,-0.586) (0.644,-0.608) (0.67,-0.629) (0.696,-0.651) (0.722,-0.672) (0.75,-0.693) (0.777,-0.713) (0.805,-0.733) (0.834,-0.753) (0.862,-0.773) (0.891,-0.792) (0.92,-0.81) (0.949,-0.828) (0.978,-0.846) (1.007,-0.864) (1.036,-0.88) (1.065,-0.896) (1.093,-0.912) (1.121,-0.927) (1.149,-0.942) (1.176,-0.956) (1.202,-0.969) (1.228,-0.982) (1.254,-0.994) (1.278,-1.005) (1.302,-1.016) (1.325,-1.026) (1.348,-1.036) (1.369,-1.044) (1.39,-1.053) (1.41,-1.06) (1.429,-1.067) (1.447,-1.073) (1.465,-1.079) (1.482,-1.084) (1.498,-1.088) (1.513,-1.091) (1.527,-1.094) (1.541,-1.097) (1.554,-1.098) (1.567,-1.099) (1.579,-1.099) (1.59,-1.099) (1.601,-1.098) (1.611,-1.097) (1.621,-1.094) (1.63,-1.091) (1.639,-1.088) (1.647,-1.083) (1.655,-1.078) (1.663,-1.072) (1.67,-1.066) (1.677,-1.059) (1.683,-1.051) (1.69,-1.042) (1.696,-1.032) (1.702,-1.022) (1.707,-1.011) (1.712,-0.999) (1.718,-0.986) (1.722,-0.973) (1.727,-0.958) (1.732,-0.943) (1.736,-0.927) (1.74,-0.91) (1.744,-0.892) (1.748,-0.873) (1.751,-0.854) (1.755,-0.833) (1.758,-0.812) (1.76,-0.79) (1.763,-0.767) (1.765,-0.743) (1.767,-0.719) (1.769,-0.694) (1.77,-0.668) (1.771,-0.641) (1.772,-0.613) (1.772,-0.585) (1.772,-0.557) (1.771,-0.528) (1.77,-0.498) (1.769,-0.467) (1.767,-0.437) (1.764,-0.405) (1.761,-0.374) (1.757,-0.342) (1.753,-0.309) (1.748,-0.276) (1.743,-0.243)};888\draw[fwd,thick,-{Stealth[length=4pt]}] (1.325,0.667)--(1.284,0.711);889\fill[accent] (1.021,0) circle (1.8pt);890\node at (0.964,-1.504) {\scriptsize $b=0$};891\node at (0.964,-1.824) {\scriptsize degree $1$};892\draw[ink2,very thin] (2.277,0)--(4.204,0);893\draw[ink2,very thin] (2.496,-1.254)--(2.496,1.254);894\draw[fwd,thick] plot coordinates {(4.02,-0.243) (4.014,-0.21) (4.007,-0.177) (4,-0.144) (3.992,-0.11) (3.983,-0.076) (3.974,-0.043) (3.964,-0.009) (3.954,0.024) (3.943,0.058) (3.932,0.091) (3.92,0.124) (3.907,0.157) (3.894,0.19) (3.88,0.222) (3.866,0.254) (3.851,0.285) (3.836,0.316) (3.821,0.347) (3.805,0.377) (3.788,0.406) (3.771,0.435) (3.754,0.464) (3.736,0.491) (3.718,0.518) (3.7,0.545) (3.681,0.571) (3.662,0.596) (3.642,0.62) (3.623,0.644) (3.602,0.667) (3.582,0.689) (3.561,0.711) (3.54,0.732) (3.518,0.752) (3.496,0.772) (3.474,0.791) (3.451,0.809) (3.429,0.826) (3.405,0.843) (3.382,0.859) (3.358,0.875) (3.334,0.89) (3.31,0.904) (3.286,0.918) (3.261,0.931) (3.237,0.943) (3.212,0.955) (3.188,0.967) (3.163,0.977) (3.139,0.988) (3.114,0.997) (3.09,1.006) (3.066,1.015) (3.042,1.022) (3.019,1.03) (2.996,1.036) (2.973,1.042) (2.951,1.048) (2.93,1.052) (2.909,1.056) (2.888,1.06) (2.868,1.063) (2.849,1.065) (2.83,1.067) (2.812,1.068) (2.795,1.068) (2.778,1.068) (2.762,1.067) (2.746,1.065) (2.731,1.062) (2.716,1.059) (2.702,1.056) (2.689,1.051) (2.676,1.046) (2.663,1.04) (2.651,1.033) (2.64,1.026) (2.629,1.018) (2.618,1.009) (2.607,1) (2.597,0.99) (2.588,0.979) (2.578,0.967) (2.569,0.954) (2.56,0.941) (2.552,0.927) (2.543,0.913) (2.535,0.897) (2.527,0.881) (2.52,0.865) (2.513,0.847) (2.506,0.829) (2.499,0.811) (2.492,0.791) (2.486,0.772) (2.48,0.751) (2.474,0.73) (2.469,0.709) (2.464,0.687) (2.459,0.665) (2.455,0.642) (2.451,0.619) (2.447,0.595) (2.443,0.571) (2.441,0.547) (2.438,0.523) (2.436,0.498) (2.434,0.474) (2.433,0.449) (2.432,0.423) (2.432,0.398) (2.433,0.373) (2.433,0.347) (2.435,0.321) (2.436,0.296) (2.439,0.27) (2.442,0.244) (2.445,0.218) (2.449,0.192) (2.454,0.166) (2.459,0.14) (2.464,0.114) (2.471,0.088) (2.477,0.062) (2.485,0.037) (2.493,0.011) (2.501,-0.015) (2.51,-0.04) (2.52,-0.065) (2.53,-0.091) (2.541,-0.116) (2.552,-0.141) (2.564,-0.166) (2.577,-0.19) (2.59,-0.215) (2.604,-0.239) (2.619,-0.263) (2.634,-0.287) (2.65,-0.311) (2.667,-0.335) (2.684,-0.359) (2.702,-0.382) (2.721,-0.405) (2.74,-0.429) (2.761,-0.452) (2.781,-0.474) (2.803,-0.497) (2.825,-0.52) (2.848,-0.542) (2.872,-0.564) (2.896,-0.586) (2.921,-0.608) (2.947,-0.629) (2.973,-0.651) (3,-0.672) (3.027,-0.693) (3.054,-0.713) (3.082,-0.733) (3.111,-0.753) (3.139,-0.773) (3.168,-0.792) (3.197,-0.81) (3.226,-0.828) (3.255,-0.846) (3.284,-0.864) (3.313,-0.88) (3.342,-0.896) (3.37,-0.912) (3.398,-0.927) (3.426,-0.942) (3.453,-0.956) (3.48,-0.969) (3.505,-0.982) (3.531,-0.994) (3.555,-1.005) (3.579,-1.016) (3.602,-1.026) (3.625,-1.036) (3.646,-1.044) (3.667,-1.053) (3.687,-1.06) (3.706,-1.067) (3.725,-1.073) (3.742,-1.079) (3.759,-1.084) (3.775,-1.088) (3.79,-1.091) (3.805,-1.094) (3.818,-1.097) (3.832,-1.098) (3.844,-1.099) (3.856,-1.099) (3.867,-1.099) (3.878,-1.098) (3.888,-1.097) (3.898,-1.094) (3.907,-1.091) (3.916,-1.088) (3.924,-1.083) (3.932,-1.078) (3.94,-1.072) (3.947,-1.066) (3.954,-1.059) (3.961,-1.051) (3.967,-1.042) (3.973,-1.032) (3.979,-1.022) (3.984,-1.011) (3.99,-0.999) (3.995,-0.986) (4,-0.973) (4.004,-0.958) (4.009,-0.943) (4.013,-0.927) (4.017,-0.91) (4.021,-0.892) (4.025,-0.873) (4.029,-0.854) (4.032,-0.833) (4.035,-0.812) (4.038,-0.79) (4.04,-0.767) (4.043,-0.743) (4.045,-0.719) (4.046,-0.694) (4.048,-0.668) (4.049,-0.641) (4.049,-0.613) (4.049,-0.585) (4.049,-0.557) (4.049,-0.528) (4.048,-0.498) (4.046,-0.467) (4.044,-0.437) (4.041,-0.405) (4.038,-0.374) (4.034,-0.342) (4.03,-0.309) (4.025,-0.276) (4.02,-0.243)};895\draw[fwd,thick,-{Stealth[length=4pt]}] (3.602,0.667)--(3.561,0.711);896\fill[accent] (2.496,0) circle (1.8pt);897\node at (3.241,-1.504) {\scriptsize $b=1.2930$};898\node at (3.241,-1.824) {\scriptsize undefined};899\draw[ink2,very thin] (4.554,0)--(6.98,0);900\draw[ink2,very thin] (4.709,-1.254)--(4.709,1.254);901\draw[fwd,thick] plot coordinates {(6.795,-0.243) (6.789,-0.21) (6.783,-0.177) (6.775,-0.144) (6.767,-0.11) (6.759,-0.076) (6.75,-0.043) (6.74,-0.009) (6.73,0.024) (6.719,0.058) (6.707,0.091) (6.695,0.124) (6.683,0.157) (6.669,0.19) (6.656,0.222) (6.642,0.254) (6.627,0.285) (6.612,0.316) (6.596,0.347) (6.58,0.377) (6.564,0.406) (6.547,0.435) (6.53,0.464) (6.512,0.491) (6.494,0.518) (6.475,0.545) (6.457,0.571) (6.437,0.596) (6.418,0.62) (6.398,0.644) (6.378,0.667) (6.357,0.689) (6.336,0.711) (6.315,0.732) (6.294,0.752) (6.272,0.772) (6.25,0.791) (6.227,0.809) (6.204,0.826) (6.181,0.843) (6.158,0.859) (6.134,0.875) (6.11,0.89) (6.086,0.904) (6.062,0.918) (6.037,0.931) (6.012,0.943) (5.988,0.955) (5.963,0.967) (5.939,0.977) (5.914,0.988) (5.89,0.997) (5.865,1.006) (5.841,1.015) (5.818,1.022) (5.794,1.03) (5.771,1.036) (5.749,1.042) (5.727,1.048) (5.705,1.052) (5.684,1.056) (5.664,1.06) (5.644,1.063) (5.625,1.065) (5.606,1.067) (5.588,1.068) (5.57,1.068) (5.553,1.068) (5.537,1.067) (5.521,1.065) (5.506,1.062) (5.492,1.059) (5.478,1.056) (5.464,1.051) (5.451,1.046) (5.439,1.04) (5.427,1.033) (5.415,1.026) (5.404,1.018) (5.393,1.009) (5.383,1) (5.373,0.99) (5.363,0.979) (5.354,0.967) (5.345,0.954) (5.336,0.941) (5.327,0.927) (5.319,0.913) (5.311,0.897) (5.303,0.881) (5.295,0.865) (5.288,0.847) (5.281,0.829) (5.274,0.811) (5.268,0.791) (5.262,0.772) (5.256,0.751) (5.25,0.73) (5.244,0.709) (5.239,0.687) (5.235,0.665) (5.23,0.642) (5.226,0.619) (5.222,0.595) (5.219,0.571) (5.216,0.547) (5.214,0.523) (5.211,0.498) (5.21,0.474) (5.209,0.449) (5.208,0.423) (5.208,0.398) (5.208,0.373) (5.209,0.347) (5.21,0.321) (5.212,0.296) (5.214,0.27) (5.217,0.244) (5.221,0.218) (5.225,0.192) (5.229,0.166) (5.234,0.14) (5.24,0.114) (5.246,0.088) (5.253,0.062) (5.26,0.037) (5.268,0.011) (5.277,-0.015) (5.286,-0.04) (5.295,-0.065) (5.306,-0.091) (5.316,-0.116) (5.328,-0.141) (5.34,-0.166) (5.353,-0.19) (5.366,-0.215) (5.38,-0.239) (5.395,-0.263) (5.41,-0.287) (5.426,-0.311) (5.442,-0.335) (5.46,-0.359) (5.478,-0.382) (5.497,-0.405) (5.516,-0.429) (5.536,-0.452) (5.557,-0.474) (5.579,-0.497) (5.601,-0.52) (5.624,-0.542) (5.648,-0.564) (5.672,-0.586) (5.697,-0.608) (5.722,-0.629) (5.749,-0.651) (5.775,-0.672) (5.802,-0.693) (5.83,-0.713) (5.858,-0.733) (5.886,-0.753) (5.915,-0.773) (5.944,-0.792) (5.973,-0.81) (6.002,-0.828) (6.031,-0.846) (6.06,-0.864) (6.089,-0.88) (6.118,-0.896) (6.146,-0.912) (6.174,-0.927) (6.201,-0.942) (6.229,-0.956) (6.255,-0.969) (6.281,-0.982) (6.306,-0.994) (6.331,-1.005) (6.355,-1.016) (6.378,-1.026) (6.4,-1.036) (6.422,-1.044) (6.443,-1.053) (6.463,-1.06) (6.482,-1.067) (6.5,-1.073) (6.518,-1.079) (6.534,-1.084) (6.55,-1.088) (6.566,-1.091) (6.58,-1.094) (6.594,-1.097) (6.607,-1.098) (6.62,-1.099) (6.632,-1.099) (6.643,-1.099) (6.654,-1.098) (6.664,-1.097) (6.673,-1.094) (6.683,-1.091) (6.691,-1.088) (6.7,-1.083) (6.708,-1.078) (6.715,-1.072) (6.723,-1.066) (6.73,-1.059) (6.736,-1.051) (6.742,-1.042) (6.749,-1.032) (6.754,-1.022) (6.76,-1.011) (6.765,-0.999) (6.77,-0.986) (6.775,-0.973) (6.78,-0.958) (6.784,-0.943) (6.789,-0.927) (6.793,-0.91) (6.797,-0.892) (6.801,-0.873) (6.804,-0.854) (6.807,-0.833) (6.81,-0.812) (6.813,-0.79) (6.816,-0.767) (6.818,-0.743) (6.82,-0.719) (6.822,-0.694) (6.823,-0.668) (6.824,-0.641) (6.825,-0.613) (6.825,-0.585) (6.825,-0.557) (6.824,-0.528) (6.823,-0.498) (6.821,-0.467) (6.819,-0.437) (6.817,-0.405) (6.814,-0.374) (6.81,-0.342) (6.806,-0.309) (6.801,-0.276) (6.795,-0.243)};902\draw[fwd,thick,-{Stealth[length=4pt]}] (6.378,0.667)--(6.336,0.711);903\fill[accent] (4.709,0) circle (1.8pt);904\node at (5.767,-1.504) {\scriptsize $b=2.2$};905\node at (5.767,-1.824) {\scriptsize degree $0$};906\end{tikzpicture}907\caption{The output curve of a network with four hidden units, for three values of a bias $b$ added to the first output; the dot is the origin. The normalized output has degree $1$ while the curve encloses the origin and degree $0$ after it has left; in between, at $b=1.2930$, the curve passes through the origin and the normalized output is not defined.}\label{fig:degree}908\end{figure}909 910\noindent For a network with four hidden units (\cref{fig:degree}) the degree is $1$, and the signed number of preimages of three911directions is $1$ each. Adding a bias $b$ to the first output, the degree drops to $0$ at $b=1.2930$, where the912smallest output norm over the circle is $10^{-4}$. \chk{N6} Training that must change the degree of the output,913to fit a target of another class, has to pass through weights at which the normalized output is undefined and914its gradient unbounded; and if the initial class is the right one, a barrier of the same kind protects it. By915Hopf's theorem the degree is the only such invariant for maps to a sphere of the same dimension.916 917\subsection{Zeros of odd networks}918 919\begin{proposition}[Odd networks]\label{prop:odd}920\Scl[Borsuk--Ulam \cite{Mat03}] A network $\R^{n+1}\to\R^n$ without biases and with odd activations is an odd map,921and it vanishes somewhere on every sphere centred at the origin. For $n=1$, if its restriction to the circle is922continuously differentiable and all its zeros are simple, their number is congruent to $2$ modulo $4$.923\end{proposition}924\begin{proof}925Borsuk--Ulam gives an antipodal pair with equal values. Oddness makes that common value zero.926For $n=1$, start the half-turn at a point with nonzero output. The endpoint signs are opposite, and each927simple zero changes the sign, so the half-turn contains an odd number of zeros. The other half-turn contains928their antipodes, giving twice an odd number in all.929\end{proof}930 931\noindent A sign scan on the unit circle found $2$ crossings for $193$ of $200$ random networks with six932hyperbolic tangent units and $6$ for the other $7$. An output bias of $10$ makes the last network strictly933positive, since it exceeds the sum of absolute output weights. \chk{N7} Oddness also applies to934\cref{thm:bottleneck}, whose collisions are the zeros of the odd map $e(x)-e(-x)$. An architecture made odd for935the sake of a symmetry therefore pays for it: its scalar outputs cannot be of one sign on any sphere, and the936decision boundary of a bias-free odd classifier meets every sphere round the origin.937 938\section{Summary of results}\label{sec:summary}939 940\begin{table*}[t]941\centering\small942\begin{tabular}{@{}>{\raggedright}p{0.14\textwidth}>{\raggedright}p{0.33\textwidth}>{\raggedright}p{0.36\textwidth}l@{}}943\toprule944Topic & Qualitative statement & Quantitative statement & Checks\\945\midrule946Bottleneck & no continuous injective code of $S^n$ in $\R^n$ & worst-case error $\ge1$, attained; fibre radius $1.0000$ in $100$ trials & O1--O3\\947Rotations & no continuous quaternion or Euler-angle target on a non-contractible loop; a six-dimensional one exists & jumps $2.0000$ and $3.1416$ against steps $0.004$; decoder Lipschitz constant $\le1.40$ & O4, O5\\948Meshes & no global frame field unless $\chi=0$; on spheres only for $n=1,3,7$ & index sums $2,2,0,1,0$ on five surfaces; frame on $S^3$ to $10^{-15}$ & O6, O11\\949Pieces & degree needs pieces & $N\ge2|d|+1$; windings $-2,3,3$ for $d=3$, $N=5,7,12$ & O7, O8\\950Depth & composition multiplies degree & degree $2^L$ with $4\cdot2^L$ pieces at depth $L\le6$; one layer needs more than $2^L-2$ units & O9\\951Width & $n$ units per layer cannot enclose a region; $n+1$ can & $30$ networks: both regions connected and unbounded; island value $1$ inside, $\le-2.46$ outside & O10\\952Hodge diffusion & converges to real homology; blind to torsion & kernels equal Betti numbers on six complexes; gap $1.5858$, $99$ layers & V1--V3\\953Rips complexes & higher spheres at large scales are artefacts & $n=12$ has $S^1$ for $1\le k\le3$, a wedge of three $S^2$ at $k=4$, and $S^5$ at $k=5$. Circle seen for $1.52<r<\sqrt3$ & V4--V6\\954Persistence & diagrams are stable, counts are not & distance $\le$ perturbation in $60$ trials, ratio up to $1.000$; count changed in $35$ & V7\\