Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

algebraic-and-differential-topology-in-machine-learning-and-ai.tex

Source for Algebraic and Differential Topology in Machine Learning and AI: Obstructions, Invariants, and Counts

View paper · Download original file

Lines 221–320 of 1055. Source text is displayed literally.

221The constant is special to round spheres.222This is the topological reason for latent spaces that are themselves spheres, tori or groups223\cite{DFdC18,FdH18}.224 225\subsection{Rotations}226 227Let $\rho\colon S^3\to\SO(3)$ send a unit quaternion $q$ to the rotation $v\mapsto qvq^{-1}$. It is onto, and228$\rho(q)=\rho(-q)$.229 230\begin{theorem}[Naming a rotation]\label{thm:rotation}231\Sli[\cite{ZBLYL19}; \cite{ADTHC}, Thm.~10.1] \emph{(a)} $\rho$ has no continuous right inverse: for every choice232of a quaternion $s(R)$ with $\rho(s(R))=R$ there is, on every non-contractible loop of rotations, a point where233$s$ jumps by $|q-(-q)|=2$. \emph{(b)} More generally a family of rotations $X\to\SO(3)$ has a continuous234quaternion target if and only if it induces the zero map $\pi_1(X)\to\pi_1(\SO(3))=\Z/2$. \emph{(c)} There is no235continuous representation of $\SO(3)$ in $\R^m$ for $m\le4$. \emph{(d)} Two columns of the rotation matrix, with236Gram--Schmidt orthogonalization as decoder, give a continuous representation in $\R^6$.237\end{theorem}238\begin{proof}239(a), (b): $\rho$ is the universal covering, and a map lifts through a covering exactly when it kills the240fundamental group; a full turn about an axis lifts to a path from $q$ to $-q$. (c) is proved in \cite{ZBLYL19}241from the fact that $\SO(3)$, which is real projective $3$-space, does not embed in $\R^4$. (d) The two columns242determine the third by the cross product.243\end{proof}244 245\begin{figure}[t]246\centering247\begin{tikzpicture}248\begin{scope}[shift={(0,0)}]249\draw[ink2] (0,2.3)--(0,0)--(3.25,0);250\draw[ink2] (0,0)--(0,-0.07) node[below,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $0$};251\draw[ink2] (1.625,0)--(1.625,-0.07) node[below,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $\pi$};252\draw[ink2] (3.25,0)--(3.25,-0.07) node[below,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $2\pi$};253\draw[ink2] (0,0.085)--(-0.07,0.085) node[left,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $-1$};254\draw[ink2] (0,1.15)--(-0.07,1.15) node[left,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $0$};255\draw[ink2] (0,2.215)--(-0.07,2.215) node[left,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $1$};256\node[below] at (1.625,-0.38) {\scriptsize angle of the turn};257\draw[ink2,very thin] (0,1.15)--(3.25,1.15);258\draw[thick,fwd] plot coordinates {(0,2.215) (0.016,2.215) (0.033,2.214) (0.049,2.214) (0.065,2.213) (0.081,2.212) (0.098,2.21) (0.114,2.208) (0.13,2.206) (0.146,2.204) (0.163,2.202) (0.179,2.199) (0.195,2.196) (0.211,2.193) (0.228,2.189) (0.244,2.185) (0.26,2.181) (0.276,2.177) (0.292,2.173) (0.309,2.168) (0.325,2.163) (0.341,2.157) (0.357,2.152) (0.374,2.146) (0.39,2.14) (0.406,2.134) (0.422,2.127) (0.439,2.12) (0.455,2.113) (0.471,2.106) (0.487,2.099) (0.504,2.091) (0.52,2.083) (0.536,2.075) (0.553,2.067) (0.569,2.058) (0.585,2.049) (0.601,2.04) (0.617,2.031) (0.634,2.021) (0.65,2.011) (0.666,2.002) (0.683,1.991) (0.699,1.981) (0.715,1.97) (0.731,1.96) (0.747,1.949) (0.764,1.938) (0.78,1.926) (0.796,1.915) (0.813,1.903) (0.829,1.891) (0.845,1.879) (0.861,1.867) (0.877,1.854) (0.894,1.842) (0.91,1.829) (0.926,1.816) (0.943,1.803) (0.959,1.789) (0.975,1.776) (0.991,1.762) (1.008,1.749) (1.024,1.735) (1.04,1.721) (1.056,1.706) (1.073,1.692) (1.089,1.678) (1.105,1.663) (1.121,1.648) (1.137,1.633) (1.154,1.618) (1.17,1.603) (1.186,1.588) (1.203,1.573) (1.219,1.557) (1.235,1.542) (1.251,1.526) (1.267,1.511) (1.284,1.495) (1.3,1.479) (1.316,1.463) (1.333,1.447) (1.349,1.431) (1.365,1.415) (1.381,1.399) (1.397,1.382) (1.414,1.366) (1.43,1.35) (1.446,1.333) (1.463,1.317) (1.479,1.3) (1.495,1.283) (1.511,1.267) (1.528,1.25) (1.544,1.234) (1.56,1.217) (1.576,1.2) (1.592,1.183) (1.609,1.167) (1.625,1.15)};259\draw[thick,fwd] plot coordinates {(1.625,1.15) (1.641,1.167) (1.658,1.183) (1.674,1.2) (1.69,1.217) (1.706,1.234) (1.722,1.25) (1.739,1.267) (1.755,1.283) (1.771,1.3) (1.787,1.317) (1.804,1.333) (1.82,1.35) (1.836,1.366) (1.853,1.382) (1.869,1.399) (1.885,1.415) (1.901,1.431) (1.917,1.447) (1.934,1.463) (1.95,1.479) (1.966,1.495) (1.982,1.511) (1.999,1.526) (2.015,1.542) (2.031,1.557) (2.047,1.573) (2.064,1.588) (2.08,1.603) (2.096,1.618) (2.113,1.633) (2.129,1.648) (2.145,1.663) (2.161,1.678) (2.177,1.692) (2.194,1.706) (2.21,1.721) (2.226,1.735) (2.243,1.749) (2.259,1.762) (2.275,1.776) (2.291,1.789) (2.307,1.803) (2.324,1.816) (2.34,1.829) (2.356,1.842) (2.373,1.854) (2.389,1.867) (2.405,1.879) (2.421,1.891) (2.438,1.903) (2.454,1.915) (2.47,1.926) (2.486,1.938) (2.502,1.949) (2.519,1.96) (2.535,1.97) (2.551,1.981) (2.567,1.991) (2.584,2.002) (2.6,2.011) (2.616,2.021) (2.632,2.031) (2.649,2.04) (2.665,2.049) (2.681,2.058) (2.698,2.067) (2.714,2.075) (2.73,2.083) (2.746,2.091) (2.762,2.099) (2.779,2.106) (2.795,2.113) (2.811,2.12) (2.828,2.127) (2.844,2.134) (2.86,2.14) (2.876,2.146) (2.893,2.152) (2.909,2.157) (2.925,2.163) (2.941,2.168) (2.958,2.173) (2.974,2.177) (2.99,2.181) (3.006,2.185) (3.022,2.189) (3.039,2.193) (3.055,2.196) (3.071,2.199) (3.087,2.202) (3.104,2.204) (3.12,2.206) (3.136,2.208) (3.152,2.21) (3.169,2.212) (3.185,2.213) (3.201,2.214) (3.218,2.214) (3.234,2.215) (3.25,2.215)};260\draw[thick,bwd] plot coordinates {(0,1.15) (0.016,1.155) (0.033,1.16) (0.049,1.165) (0.065,1.17) (0.081,1.175) (0.098,1.18) (0.114,1.185) (0.13,1.19) (0.146,1.195) (0.163,1.2) (0.179,1.205) (0.195,1.21) (0.211,1.215) (0.228,1.22) (0.244,1.225) (0.26,1.23) (0.276,1.235) (0.292,1.24) (0.309,1.245) (0.325,1.25) (0.341,1.255) (0.357,1.259) (0.374,1.264) (0.39,1.269) (0.406,1.273) (0.422,1.278) (0.439,1.283) (0.455,1.287) (0.471,1.292) (0.487,1.296) (0.504,1.301) (0.52,1.305) (0.536,1.31) (0.553,1.314) (0.569,1.319) (0.585,1.323) (0.601,1.327) (0.617,1.331) (0.634,1.336) (0.65,1.34) (0.666,1.344) (0.683,1.348) (0.699,1.352) (0.715,1.356) (0.731,1.36) (0.747,1.363) (0.764,1.367) (0.78,1.371) (0.796,1.375) (0.813,1.378) (0.829,1.382) (0.845,1.385) (0.861,1.389) (0.877,1.392) (0.894,1.395) (0.91,1.399) (0.926,1.402) (0.943,1.405) (0.959,1.408) (0.975,1.411) (0.991,1.414) (1.008,1.417) (1.024,1.42) (1.04,1.422) (1.056,1.425) (1.073,1.428) (1.089,1.43) (1.105,1.433) (1.121,1.435) (1.137,1.438) (1.154,1.44) (1.17,1.442) (1.186,1.444) (1.203,1.446) (1.219,1.448) (1.235,1.45) (1.251,1.452) (1.267,1.454) (1.284,1.455) (1.3,1.457) (1.316,1.458) (1.333,1.46) (1.349,1.461) (1.365,1.463) (1.381,1.464) (1.397,1.465) (1.414,1.466) (1.43,1.467) (1.446,1.468) (1.463,1.469) (1.479,1.469) (1.495,1.47) (1.511,1.471) (1.528,1.471) (1.544,1.472) (1.56,1.472) (1.576,1.472) (1.592,1.473) (1.609,1.473) (1.625,1.473)};261\draw[thick,bwd] plot coordinates {(1.625,0.827) (1.641,0.827) (1.658,0.827) (1.674,0.828) (1.69,0.828) (1.706,0.828) (1.722,0.829) (1.739,0.829) (1.755,0.83) (1.771,0.831) (1.787,0.831) (1.804,0.832) (1.82,0.833) (1.836,0.834) (1.853,0.835) (1.869,0.836) (1.885,0.837) (1.901,0.839) (1.917,0.84) (1.934,0.842) (1.95,0.843) (1.966,0.845) (1.982,0.846) (1.999,0.848) (2.015,0.85) (2.031,0.852) (2.047,0.854) (2.064,0.856) (2.08,0.858) (2.096,0.86) (2.113,0.862) (2.129,0.865) (2.145,0.867) (2.161,0.87) (2.177,0.872) (2.194,0.875) (2.21,0.878) (2.226,0.88) (2.243,0.883) (2.259,0.886) (2.275,0.889) (2.291,0.892) (2.307,0.895) (2.324,0.898) (2.34,0.901) (2.356,0.905) (2.373,0.908) (2.389,0.911) (2.405,0.915) (2.421,0.918) (2.438,0.922) (2.454,0.925) (2.47,0.929) (2.486,0.933) (2.502,0.937) (2.519,0.94) (2.535,0.944) (2.551,0.948) (2.567,0.952) (2.584,0.956) (2.6,0.96) (2.616,0.964) (2.632,0.969) (2.649,0.973) (2.665,0.977) (2.681,0.981) (2.698,0.986) (2.714,0.99) (2.73,0.995) (2.746,0.999) (2.762,1.004) (2.779,1.008) (2.795,1.013) (2.811,1.017) (2.828,1.022) (2.844,1.027) (2.86,1.031) (2.876,1.036) (2.893,1.041) (2.909,1.045) (2.925,1.05) (2.941,1.055) (2.958,1.06) (2.974,1.065) (2.99,1.07) (3.006,1.075) (3.022,1.08) (3.039,1.085) (3.055,1.09) (3.071,1.095) (3.087,1.1) (3.104,1.105) (3.12,1.11) (3.136,1.115) (3.152,1.12) (3.169,1.125) (3.185,1.13) (3.201,1.135) (3.218,1.14) (3.234,1.145) (3.25,1.15)};262\draw[thick,bwd,densely dashed] plot coordinates {(0,1.15) (0.016,1.142) (0.033,1.133) (0.049,1.125) (0.065,1.116) (0.081,1.108) (0.098,1.099) (0.114,1.091) (0.13,1.083) (0.146,1.074) (0.163,1.066) (0.179,1.058) (0.195,1.049) (0.211,1.041) (0.228,1.033) (0.244,1.024) (0.26,1.016) (0.276,1.008) (0.292,1) (0.309,0.992) (0.325,0.984) (0.341,0.976) (0.357,0.968) (0.374,0.96) (0.39,0.952) (0.406,0.944) (0.422,0.936) (0.439,0.929) (0.455,0.921) (0.471,0.913) (0.487,0.906) (0.504,0.898) (0.52,0.891) (0.536,0.884) (0.553,0.876) (0.569,0.869) (0.585,0.862) (0.601,0.855) (0.617,0.848) (0.634,0.841) (0.65,0.834) (0.666,0.827) (0.683,0.82) (0.699,0.814) (0.715,0.807) (0.731,0.801) (0.747,0.794) (0.764,0.788) (0.78,0.782) (0.796,0.776) (0.813,0.77) (0.829,0.764) (0.845,0.758) (0.861,0.752) (0.877,0.747) (0.894,0.741) (0.91,0.736) (0.926,0.73) (0.943,0.725) (0.959,0.72) (0.975,0.715) (0.991,0.71) (1.008,0.705) (1.024,0.7) (1.04,0.696) (1.056,0.691) (1.073,0.687) (1.089,0.683) (1.105,0.679) (1.121,0.675) (1.137,0.671) (1.154,0.667) (1.17,0.663) (1.186,0.66) (1.203,0.656) (1.219,0.653) (1.235,0.65) (1.251,0.647) (1.267,0.644) (1.284,0.641) (1.3,0.639) (1.316,0.636) (1.333,0.634) (1.349,0.631) (1.365,0.629) (1.381,0.627) (1.397,0.625) (1.414,0.623) (1.43,0.622) (1.446,0.62) (1.463,0.619) (1.479,0.618) (1.495,0.616) (1.511,0.615) (1.528,0.615) (1.544,0.614) (1.56,0.613) (1.576,0.613) (1.592,0.612) (1.609,0.612) (1.625,0.612)};263\draw[thick,bwd,densely dashed] plot coordinates {(1.625,1.688) (1.641,1.688) (1.658,1.688) (1.674,1.687) (1.69,1.687) (1.706,1.686) (1.722,1.685) (1.739,1.685) (1.755,1.684) (1.771,1.682) (1.787,1.681) (1.804,1.68) (1.82,1.678) (1.836,1.677) (1.853,1.675) (1.869,1.673) (1.885,1.671) (1.901,1.669) (1.917,1.666) (1.934,1.664) (1.95,1.661) (1.966,1.659) (1.982,1.656) (1.999,1.653) (2.015,1.65) (2.031,1.647) (2.047,1.644) (2.064,1.64) (2.08,1.637) (2.096,1.633) (2.113,1.629) (2.129,1.625) (2.145,1.621) (2.161,1.617) (2.177,1.613) (2.194,1.609) (2.21,1.604) (2.226,1.6) (2.243,1.595) (2.259,1.59) (2.275,1.585) (2.291,1.58) (2.307,1.575) (2.324,1.57) (2.34,1.564) (2.356,1.559) (2.373,1.553) (2.389,1.548) (2.405,1.542) (2.421,1.536) (2.438,1.53) (2.454,1.524) (2.47,1.518) (2.486,1.512) (2.502,1.506) (2.519,1.499) (2.535,1.493) (2.551,1.486) (2.567,1.48) (2.584,1.473) (2.6,1.466) (2.616,1.459) (2.632,1.452) (2.649,1.445) (2.665,1.438) (2.681,1.431) (2.698,1.424) (2.714,1.416) (2.73,1.409) (2.746,1.402) (2.762,1.394) (2.779,1.387) (2.795,1.379) (2.811,1.371) (2.828,1.364) (2.844,1.356) (2.86,1.348) (2.876,1.34) (2.893,1.332) (2.909,1.324) (2.925,1.316) (2.941,1.308) (2.958,1.3) (2.974,1.292) (2.99,1.284) (3.006,1.276) (3.022,1.267) (3.039,1.259) (3.055,1.251) (3.071,1.242) (3.087,1.234) (3.104,1.226) (3.12,1.217) (3.136,1.209) (3.152,1.201) (3.169,1.192) (3.185,1.184) (3.201,1.175) (3.218,1.167) (3.234,1.158) (3.25,1.15)};264\draw[thick,bwd,dash dot] plot coordinates {(0,1.15) (0.016,1.164) (0.033,1.177) (0.049,1.191) (0.065,1.204) (0.081,1.218) (0.098,1.231) (0.114,1.244) (0.13,1.258) (0.146,1.271) (0.163,1.285) (0.179,1.298) (0.195,1.311) (0.211,1.324) (0.228,1.338) (0.244,1.351) (0.26,1.364) (0.276,1.377) (0.292,1.39) (0.309,1.403) (0.325,1.416) (0.341,1.429) (0.357,1.441) (0.374,1.454) (0.39,1.467) (0.406,1.479) (0.422,1.492) (0.439,1.504) (0.455,1.516) (0.471,1.529) (0.487,1.541) (0.504,1.553) (0.52,1.565) (0.536,1.576) (0.553,1.588) (0.569,1.6) (0.585,1.611) (0.601,1.622) (0.617,1.634) (0.634,1.645) (0.65,1.656) (0.666,1.667) (0.683,1.677) (0.699,1.688) (0.715,1.699) (0.731,1.709) (0.747,1.719) (0.764,1.729) (0.78,1.739) (0.796,1.749) (0.813,1.758) (0.829,1.768) (0.845,1.777) (0.861,1.786) (0.877,1.795) (0.894,1.804) (0.91,1.813) (0.926,1.822) (0.943,1.83) (0.959,1.838) (0.975,1.846) (0.991,1.854) (1.008,1.862) (1.024,1.869) (1.04,1.877) (1.056,1.884) (1.073,1.891) (1.089,1.897) (1.105,1.904) (1.121,1.91) (1.137,1.917) (1.154,1.923) (1.17,1.929) (1.186,1.934) (1.203,1.94) (1.219,1.945) (1.235,1.95) (1.251,1.955) (1.267,1.96) (1.284,1.964) (1.3,1.968) (1.316,1.972) (1.333,1.976) (1.349,1.98) (1.365,1.983) (1.381,1.987) (1.397,1.99) (1.414,1.993) (1.43,1.995) (1.446,1.998) (1.463,2) (1.479,2.002) (1.495,2.004) (1.511,2.005) (1.528,2.007) (1.544,2.008) (1.56,2.009) (1.576,2.01) (1.592,2.01) (1.609,2.01) (1.625,2.011)};265\draw[thick,bwd,dash dot] plot coordinates {(1.625,0.289) (1.641,0.29) (1.658,0.29) (1.674,0.29) (1.69,0.291) (1.706,0.292) (1.722,0.293) (1.739,0.295) (1.755,0.296) (1.771,0.298) (1.787,0.3) (1.804,0.302) (1.82,0.305) (1.836,0.307) (1.853,0.31) (1.869,0.313) (1.885,0.317) (1.901,0.32) (1.917,0.324) (1.934,0.328) (1.95,0.332) (1.966,0.336) (1.982,0.34) (1.999,0.345) (2.015,0.35) (2.031,0.355) (2.047,0.36) (2.064,0.366) (2.08,0.371) (2.096,0.377) (2.113,0.383) (2.129,0.39) (2.145,0.396) (2.161,0.403) (2.177,0.409) (2.194,0.416) (2.21,0.423) (2.226,0.431) (2.243,0.438) (2.259,0.446) (2.275,0.454) (2.291,0.462) (2.307,0.47) (2.324,0.478) (2.34,0.487) (2.356,0.496) (2.373,0.505) (2.389,0.514) (2.405,0.523) (2.421,0.532) (2.438,0.542) (2.454,0.551) (2.47,0.561) (2.486,0.571) (2.502,0.581) (2.519,0.591) (2.535,0.601) (2.551,0.612) (2.567,0.623) (2.584,0.633) (2.6,0.644) (2.616,0.655) (2.632,0.666) (2.649,0.678) (2.665,0.689) (2.681,0.7) (2.698,0.712) (2.714,0.724) (2.73,0.735) (2.746,0.747) (2.762,0.759) (2.779,0.771) (2.795,0.784) (2.811,0.796) (2.828,0.808) (2.844,0.821) (2.86,0.833) (2.876,0.846) (2.893,0.859) (2.909,0.871) (2.925,0.884) (2.941,0.897) (2.958,0.91) (2.974,0.923) (2.99,0.936) (3.006,0.949) (3.022,0.962) (3.039,0.976) (3.055,0.989) (3.071,1.002) (3.087,1.015) (3.104,1.029) (3.12,1.042) (3.136,1.056) (3.152,1.069) (3.169,1.082) (3.185,1.096) (3.201,1.109) (3.218,1.123) (3.234,1.136) (3.25,1.15)};266\draw[accent,densely dotted] (1.625,0)--(1.625,2.3);267\node[above,inner sep=1pt] at (1.625,2.35) {\scriptsize quaternion, $w\ge0$};268\end{scope}269\begin{scope}[shift={(4,0)}]270\draw[ink2] (0,2.3)--(0,0)--(3.25,0);271\draw[ink2] (0,0)--(0,-0.07) node[below,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $0$};272\draw[ink2] (1.625,0)--(1.625,-0.07) node[below,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $\pi$};273\draw[ink2] (3.25,0)--(3.25,-0.07) node[below,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize $2\pi$};274\draw[ink2] (0,0.085)--(-0.07,0.085) node[left,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize };275\draw[ink2] (0,1.15)--(-0.07,1.15) node[left,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize };276\draw[ink2] (0,2.215)--(-0.07,2.215) node[left,inner sep=1.5pt]{\scriptsize };277\node[below] at (1.625,-0.38) {\scriptsize angle of the turn};278\draw[ink2,very thin] (0,1.15)--(3.25,1.15);279\draw[thick,fwd] plot coordinates {(0,2.215) (0.02,2.214) (0.041,2.212) (0.061,2.208) (0.081,2.203) (0.102,2.196) (0.122,2.188) (0.142,2.179) (0.163,2.167) (0.183,2.155) (0.203,2.141) (0.223,2.126) (0.244,2.109) (0.264,2.092) (0.284,2.072) (0.305,2.052) (0.325,2.03) (0.345,2.007) (0.366,1.983) (0.386,1.958) (0.406,1.932) (0.427,1.904) (0.447,1.876) (0.467,1.846) (0.487,1.816) (0.508,1.785) (0.528,1.753) (0.548,1.72) (0.569,1.687) (0.589,1.653) (0.609,1.618) (0.63,1.582) (0.65,1.547) (0.67,1.51) (0.691,1.474) (0.711,1.436) (0.731,1.399) (0.752,1.361) (0.772,1.324) (0.792,1.286) (0.813,1.248) (0.833,1.21) (0.853,1.172) (0.873,1.134) (0.894,1.097) (0.914,1.059) (0.934,1.022) (0.955,0.985) (0.975,0.949) (0.995,0.913) (1.016,0.878) (1.036,0.843) (1.056,0.809) (1.077,0.775) (1.097,0.743) (1.117,0.711) (1.137,0.679) (1.158,0.649) (1.178,0.62) (1.198,0.591) (1.219,0.564) (1.239,0.538) (1.259,0.512) (1.28,0.488) (1.3,0.465) (1.32,0.444) (1.341,0.423) (1.361,0.404) (1.381,0.386) (1.402,0.37) (1.422,0.354) (1.442,0.341) (1.463,0.328) (1.483,0.317) (1.503,0.307) (1.523,0.299) (1.544,0.293) (1.564,0.287) (1.584,0.284) (1.605,0.282) (1.625,0.281) (1.645,0.282) (1.666,0.284) (1.686,0.287) (1.706,0.293) (1.727,0.299) (1.747,0.307) (1.767,0.317) (1.787,0.328) (1.808,0.341) (1.828,0.354) (1.848,0.37) (1.869,0.386) (1.889,0.404) (1.909,0.423) (1.93,0.444) (1.95,0.465) (1.97,0.488) (1.991,0.512) (2.011,0.538) (2.031,0.564) (2.052,0.591) (2.072,0.62) (2.092,0.649) (2.113,0.679) (2.133,0.711) (2.153,0.743) (2.173,0.775) (2.194,0.809) (2.214,0.843) (2.234,0.878) (2.255,0.913) (2.275,0.949) (2.295,0.985) (2.316,1.022) (2.336,1.059) (2.356,1.097) (2.377,1.134) (2.397,1.172) (2.417,1.21) (2.438,1.248) (2.458,1.286) (2.478,1.324) (2.498,1.361) (2.519,1.399) (2.539,1.436) (2.559,1.474) (2.58,1.51) (2.6,1.547) (2.62,1.582) (2.641,1.618) (2.661,1.653) (2.681,1.687) (2.702,1.72) (2.722,1.753) (2.742,1.785) (2.762,1.816) (2.783,1.846) (2.803,1.876) (2.823,1.904) (2.844,1.932) (2.864,1.958) (2.884,1.983) (2.905,2.007) (2.925,2.03) (2.945,2.052) (2.966,2.072) (2.986,2.092) (3.006,2.109) (3.027,2.126) (3.047,2.141) (3.067,2.155) (3.087,2.167) (3.108,2.179) (3.128,2.188) (3.148,2.196) (3.169,2.203) (3.189,2.208) (3.209,2.212) (3.23,2.214) (3.25,2.215)};280\draw[thick,fwd,densely dashed] plot coordinates {(0,1.15) (0.02,1.184) (0.041,1.217) (0.061,1.25) (0.081,1.283) (0.102,1.315) (0.122,1.346) (0.142,1.377) (0.163,1.408) (0.183,1.438) (0.203,1.467) (0.223,1.495) (0.244,1.523) (0.264,1.55) (0.284,1.576) (0.305,1.601) (0.325,1.625) (0.345,1.648) (0.366,1.67) (0.386,1.691) (0.406,1.711) (0.427,1.73) (0.447,1.747) (0.467,1.764) (0.487,1.779) (0.508,1.793) (0.528,1.806) (0.548,1.817) (0.569,1.828) (0.589,1.837) (0.609,1.844) (0.63,1.851) (0.65,1.856) (0.67,1.859) (0.691,1.862) (0.711,1.863) (0.731,1.862) (0.752,1.861) (0.772,1.858) (0.792,1.853) (0.813,1.848) (0.833,1.84) (0.853,1.832) (0.873,1.822) (0.894,1.811) (0.914,1.799) (0.934,1.786) (0.955,1.771) (0.975,1.755) (0.995,1.738) (1.016,1.72) (1.036,1.7) (1.056,1.68) (1.077,1.658) (1.097,1.636) (1.117,1.612) (1.137,1.587) (1.158,1.562) (1.178,1.535) (1.198,1.508) (1.219,1.48) (1.239,1.451) (1.259,1.422) (1.28,1.392) (1.3,1.361) (1.32,1.33) (1.341,1.298) (1.361,1.265) (1.381,1.232) (1.402,1.199) (1.422,1.166) (1.442,1.132) (1.463,1.098) (1.483,1.064) (1.503,1.029) (1.523,0.995) (1.544,0.961) (1.564,0.926) (1.584,0.892) (1.605,0.858) (1.625,0.824) (1.645,0.79) (1.666,0.757) (1.686,0.724) (1.706,0.691) (1.727,0.659) (1.747,0.628) (1.767,0.597) (1.787,0.566) (1.808,0.536) (1.828,0.507) (1.848,0.479) (1.869,0.451) (1.889,0.424) (1.909,0.398) (1.93,0.373) (1.95,0.349) (1.97,0.326) (1.991,0.304) (2.011,0.283) (2.031,0.263) (2.052,0.245) (2.072,0.227) (2.092,0.21) (2.113,0.195) (2.133,0.181) (2.153,0.168) (2.173,0.157) (2.194,0.146) (2.214,0.137) (2.234,0.13) (2.255,0.123) (2.275,0.118) (2.295,0.115) (2.316,0.112) (2.336,0.111) (2.356,0.112) (2.377,0.113) (2.397,0.116) (2.417,0.121) (2.438,0.127) (2.458,0.134) (2.478,0.142) (2.498,0.152) (2.519,0.163) (2.539,0.175) (2.559,0.188) (2.58,0.203) (2.6,0.219) (2.62,0.236) (2.641,0.254) (2.661,0.274) (2.681,0.294) (2.702,0.316) (2.722,0.338) (2.742,0.362) (2.762,0.387) (2.783,0.412) (2.803,0.439) (2.823,0.466) (2.844,0.494) (2.864,0.523) (2.884,0.552) (2.905,0.582) (2.925,0.613) (2.945,0.644) (2.966,0.676) (2.986,0.709) (3.006,0.742) (3.027,0.775) (3.047,0.808) (3.067,0.842) (3.087,0.876) (3.108,0.91) (3.128,0.945) (3.148,0.979) (3.169,1.013) (3.189,1.048) (3.209,1.082) (3.23,1.116) (3.25,1.15)};281\draw[thick,fwd,dash dot] plot coordinates {(0,1.15) (0.02,1.171) (0.041,1.193) (0.061,1.215) (0.081,1.237) (0.102,1.26) (0.122,1.283) (0.142,1.306) (0.163,1.329) (0.183,1.352) (0.203,1.376) (0.223,1.399) (0.244,1.423) (0.264,1.446) (0.284,1.469) (0.305,1.493) (0.325,1.516) (0.345,1.539) (0.366,1.562) (0.386,1.584) (0.406,1.607) (0.427,1.629) (0.447,1.65) (0.467,1.672) (0.487,1.693) (0.508,1.713) (0.528,1.733) (0.548,1.753) (0.569,1.772) (0.589,1.79) (0.609,1.808) (0.63,1.825) (0.65,1.842) (0.67,1.858) (0.691,1.873) (0.711,1.887) (0.731,1.901) (0.752,1.914) (0.772,1.926) (0.792,1.938) (0.813,1.949) (0.833,1.958) (0.853,1.967) (0.873,1.976) (0.894,1.983) (0.914,1.989) (0.934,1.995) (0.955,1.999) (0.975,2.003) (0.995,2.006) (1.016,2.007) (1.036,2.008) (1.056,2.008) (1.077,2.007) (1.097,2.006) (1.117,2.003) (1.137,1.999) (1.158,1.995) (1.178,1.989) (1.198,1.983) (1.219,1.975) (1.239,1.967) (1.259,1.958) (1.28,1.949) (1.3,1.938) (1.32,1.926) (1.341,1.914) (1.361,1.901) (1.381,1.887) (1.402,1.873) (1.422,1.858) (1.442,1.842) (1.463,1.825) (1.483,1.808) (1.503,1.79) (1.523,1.771) (1.544,1.752) (1.564,1.733) (1.584,1.713) (1.605,1.692) (1.625,1.672) (1.645,1.65) (1.666,1.629) (1.686,1.607) (1.706,1.584) (1.727,1.562) (1.747,1.539) (1.767,1.516) (1.787,1.493) (1.808,1.469) (1.828,1.446) (1.848,1.422) (1.869,1.399) (1.889,1.376) (1.909,1.352) (1.93,1.329) (1.95,1.306) (1.97,1.283) (1.991,1.26) (2.011,1.237) (2.031,1.215) (2.052,1.193) (2.072,1.171) (2.092,1.15) (2.113,1.129) (2.133,1.108) (2.153,1.088) (2.173,1.069) (2.194,1.05) (2.214,1.032) (2.234,1.014) (2.255,0.996) (2.275,0.98) (2.295,0.964) (2.316,0.949) (2.336,0.934) (2.356,0.92) (2.377,0.907) (2.397,0.895) (2.417,0.884) (2.438,0.873) (2.458,0.863) (2.478,0.854) (2.498,0.846) (2.519,0.839) (2.539,0.832) (2.559,0.827) (2.58,0.822) (2.6,0.819) (2.62,0.816) (2.641,0.814) (2.661,0.813) (2.681,0.813) (2.702,0.814) (2.722,0.816) (2.742,0.819) (2.762,0.822) (2.783,0.827) (2.803,0.832) (2.823,0.839) (2.844,0.846) (2.864,0.854) (2.884,0.863) (2.905,0.873) (2.925,0.884) (2.945,0.895) (2.966,0.907) (2.986,0.92) (3.006,0.934) (3.027,0.949) (3.047,0.964) (3.067,0.98) (3.087,0.997) (3.108,1.014) (3.128,1.032) (3.148,1.05) (3.169,1.069) (3.189,1.089) (3.209,1.109) (3.23,1.129) (3.25,1.15)};282\draw[thick,bwd] plot coordinates {(0,1.15) (0.02,1.116) (0.041,1.082) (0.061,1.048) (0.081,1.013) (0.102,0.979) (0.122,0.945) (0.142,0.91) (0.163,0.876) (0.183,0.842) (0.203,0.808) (0.223,0.775) (0.244,0.742) (0.264,0.709) (0.284,0.676) (0.305,0.644) (0.325,0.613) (0.345,0.582) (0.366,0.552) (0.386,0.523) (0.406,0.494) (0.427,0.466) (0.447,0.439) (0.467,0.412) (0.487,0.387) (0.508,0.362) (0.528,0.338) (0.548,0.316) (0.569,0.294) (0.589,0.274) (0.609,0.254) (0.63,0.236) (0.65,0.219) (0.67,0.203) (0.691,0.188) (0.711,0.175) (0.731,0.163) (0.752,0.152) (0.772,0.142) (0.792,0.134) (0.813,0.127) (0.833,0.121) (0.853,0.116) (0.873,0.113) (0.894,0.112) (0.914,0.111) (0.934,0.112) (0.955,0.115) (0.975,0.118) (0.995,0.123) (1.016,0.13) (1.036,0.137) (1.056,0.146) (1.077,0.157) (1.097,0.168) (1.117,0.181) (1.137,0.195) (1.158,0.21) (1.178,0.227) (1.198,0.245) (1.219,0.263) (1.239,0.283) (1.259,0.304) (1.28,0.326) (1.3,0.349) (1.32,0.373) (1.341,0.398) (1.361,0.424) (1.381,0.451) (1.402,0.479) (1.422,0.507) (1.442,0.536) (1.463,0.566) (1.483,0.597) (1.503,0.628) (1.523,0.659) (1.544,0.691) (1.564,0.724) (1.584,0.757) (1.605,0.79) (1.625,0.824) (1.645,0.858) (1.666,0.892) (1.686,0.926) (1.706,0.961) (1.727,0.995) (1.747,1.029) (1.767,1.064) (1.787,1.098) (1.808,1.132) (1.828,1.166) (1.848,1.199) (1.869,1.232) (1.889,1.265) (1.909,1.298) (1.93,1.33) (1.95,1.361) (1.97,1.392) (1.991,1.422) (2.011,1.451) (2.031,1.48) (2.052,1.508) (2.072,1.535) (2.092,1.562) (2.113,1.587) (2.133,1.612) (2.153,1.636) (2.173,1.658) (2.194,1.68) (2.214,1.7) (2.234,1.72) (2.255,1.738) (2.275,1.755) (2.295,1.771) (2.316,1.786) (2.336,1.799) (2.356,1.811) (2.377,1.822) (2.397,1.832) (2.417,1.84) (2.438,1.848) (2.458,1.853) (2.478,1.858) (2.498,1.861) (2.519,1.862) (2.539,1.863) (2.559,1.862) (2.58,1.859) (2.6,1.856) (2.62,1.851) (2.641,1.844) (2.661,1.837) (2.681,1.828) (2.702,1.817) (2.722,1.806) (2.742,1.793) (2.762,1.779) (2.783,1.764) (2.803,1.747) (2.823,1.73) (2.844,1.711) (2.864,1.691) (2.884,1.67) (2.905,1.648) (2.925,1.625) (2.945,1.601) (2.966,1.576) (2.986,1.55) (3.006,1.523) (3.027,1.495) (3.047,1.467) (3.067,1.438) (3.087,1.408) (3.108,1.377) (3.128,1.346) (3.148,1.315) (3.169,1.283) (3.189,1.25) (3.209,1.217) (3.23,1.184) (3.25,1.15)};283\draw[thick,bwd,densely dashed] plot coordinates {(0,2.215) (0.02,2.214) (0.041,2.212) (0.061,2.209) (0.081,2.205) (0.102,2.2) (0.122,2.193) (0.142,2.185) (0.163,2.176) (0.183,2.166) (0.203,2.154) (0.223,2.142) (0.244,2.128) (0.264,2.114) (0.284,2.098) (0.305,2.081) (0.325,2.063) (0.345,2.045) (0.366,2.025) (0.386,2.004) (0.406,1.982) (0.427,1.96) (0.447,1.937) (0.467,1.913) (0.487,1.888) (0.508,1.862) (0.528,1.836) (0.548,1.809) (0.569,1.782) (0.589,1.754) (0.609,1.725) (0.63,1.696) (0.65,1.667) (0.67,1.637) (0.691,1.607) (0.711,1.576) (0.731,1.546) (0.752,1.515) (0.772,1.484) (0.792,1.453) (0.813,1.422) (0.833,1.39) (0.853,1.359) (0.873,1.328) (0.894,1.298) (0.914,1.267) (0.934,1.236) (0.955,1.206) (0.975,1.177) (0.995,1.147) (1.016,1.118) (1.036,1.09) (1.056,1.062) (1.077,1.034) (1.097,1.007) (1.117,0.981) (1.137,0.955) (1.158,0.931) (1.178,0.907) (1.198,0.883) (1.219,0.861) (1.239,0.839) (1.259,0.818) (1.28,0.799) (1.3,0.78) (1.32,0.762) (1.341,0.745) (1.361,0.73) (1.381,0.715) (1.402,0.701) (1.422,0.689) (1.442,0.677) (1.463,0.667) (1.483,0.658) (1.503,0.65) (1.523,0.644) (1.544,0.638) (1.564,0.634) (1.584,0.631) (1.605,0.629) (1.625,0.628) (1.645,0.629) (1.666,0.631) (1.686,0.634) (1.706,0.638) (1.727,0.644) (1.747,0.65) (1.767,0.658) (1.787,0.667) (1.808,0.677) (1.828,0.689) (1.848,0.701) (1.869,0.715) (1.889,0.73) (1.909,0.745) (1.93,0.762) (1.95,0.78) (1.97,0.799) (1.991,0.818) (2.011,0.839) (2.031,0.861) (2.052,0.883) (2.072,0.907) (2.092,0.931) (2.113,0.955) (2.133,0.981) (2.153,1.007) (2.173,1.034) (2.194,1.062) (2.214,1.09) (2.234,1.118) (2.255,1.147) (2.275,1.177) (2.295,1.206) (2.316,1.236) (2.336,1.267) (2.356,1.298) (2.377,1.328) (2.397,1.359) (2.417,1.39) (2.438,1.422) (2.458,1.453) (2.478,1.484) (2.498,1.515) (2.519,1.546) (2.539,1.576) (2.559,1.607) (2.58,1.637) (2.6,1.667) (2.62,1.696) (2.641,1.725) (2.661,1.754) (2.681,1.782) (2.702,1.809) (2.722,1.836) (2.742,1.862) (2.762,1.888) (2.783,1.913) (2.803,1.937) (2.823,1.96) (2.844,1.982) (2.864,2.004) (2.884,2.025) (2.905,2.045) (2.925,2.063) (2.945,2.081) (2.966,2.098) (2.986,2.114) (3.006,2.128) (3.027,2.142) (3.047,2.154) (3.067,2.166) (3.087,2.176) (3.108,2.185) (3.128,2.193) (3.148,2.2) (3.169,2.205) (3.189,2.209) (3.209,2.212) (3.23,2.214) (3.25,2.215)};284\draw[thick,bwd,dash dot] plot coordinates {(0,1.15) (0.02,1.162) (0.041,1.174) (0.061,1.185) (0.081,1.195) (0.102,1.205) (0.122,1.213) (0.142,1.221) (0.163,1.228) (0.183,1.235) (0.203,1.24) (0.223,1.245) (0.244,1.249) (0.264,1.252) (0.284,1.255) (0.305,1.256) (0.325,1.257) (0.345,1.256) (0.366,1.255) (0.386,1.254) (0.406,1.251) (0.427,1.247) (0.447,1.243) (0.467,1.238) (0.487,1.232) (0.508,1.225) (0.528,1.218) (0.548,1.209) (0.569,1.2) (0.589,1.19) (0.609,1.18) (0.63,1.169) (0.65,1.157) (0.67,1.144) (0.691,1.131) (0.711,1.117) (0.731,1.102) (0.752,1.087) (0.772,1.071) (0.792,1.055) (0.813,1.038) (0.833,1.021) (0.853,1.003) (0.873,0.985) (0.894,0.966) (0.914,0.947) (0.934,0.928) (0.955,0.908) (0.975,0.888) (0.995,0.868) (1.016,0.847) (1.036,0.826) (1.056,0.806) (1.077,0.785) (1.097,0.763) (1.117,0.742) (1.137,0.721) (1.158,0.7) (1.178,0.678) (1.198,0.657) (1.219,0.636) (1.239,0.615) (1.259,0.594) (1.28,0.574) (1.3,0.553) (1.32,0.533) (1.341,0.513) (1.361,0.494) (1.381,0.475) (1.402,0.456) (1.422,0.437) (1.442,0.419) (1.463,0.402) (1.483,0.385) (1.503,0.368) (1.523,0.352) (1.544,0.337) (1.564,0.322) (1.584,0.307) (1.605,0.294) (1.625,0.281) (1.645,0.268) (1.666,0.257) (1.686,0.246) (1.706,0.236) (1.727,0.226) (1.747,0.217) (1.767,0.209) (1.787,0.202) (1.808,0.196) (1.828,0.19) (1.848,0.186) (1.869,0.182) (1.889,0.179) (1.909,0.176) (1.93,0.175) (1.95,0.174) (1.97,0.174) (1.991,0.175) (2.011,0.177) (2.031,0.18) (2.052,0.183) (2.072,0.188) (2.092,0.193) (2.113,0.199) (2.133,0.206) (2.153,0.213) (2.173,0.221) (2.194,0.231) (2.214,0.24) (2.234,0.251) (2.255,0.262) (2.275,0.274) (2.295,0.287) (2.316,0.3) (2.336,0.314) (2.356,0.329) (2.377,0.344) (2.397,0.36) (2.417,0.376) (2.438,0.393) (2.458,0.41) (2.478,0.428) (2.498,0.446) (2.519,0.465) (2.539,0.484) (2.559,0.503) (2.58,0.523) (2.6,0.543) (2.62,0.563) (2.641,0.584) (2.661,0.604) (2.681,0.625) (2.702,0.646) (2.722,0.667) (2.742,0.689) (2.762,0.71) (2.783,0.731) (2.803,0.752) (2.823,0.773) (2.844,0.795) (2.864,0.815) (2.884,0.836) (2.905,0.857) (2.925,0.877) (2.945,0.897) (2.966,0.917) (2.986,0.937) (3.006,0.956) (3.027,0.975) (3.047,0.993) (3.067,1.011) (3.087,1.029) (3.108,1.046) (3.128,1.063) (3.148,1.079) (3.169,1.094) (3.189,1.109) (3.209,1.123) (3.23,1.137) (3.25,1.15)};285\node[above,inner sep=1pt] at (1.625,2.35) {\scriptsize six-dimensional code};286\end{scope}287\end{tikzpicture}288\caption{Two codes for the rotations about a fixed axis, through one full turn. Left: the four components of the unit quaternion with non-negative real part. At the half-turn the real part vanishes and the three others change sign, a jump of length $2.0000$. Right: the six components of the first two columns of the rotation matrix, which return to their initial values without a jump.}\label{fig:rotation}289\end{figure}290 291\noindent Along a full turn in $2000$ steps (\cref{fig:rotation}) the rotation matrix moves by at most $0.0044$ per step and the292six-dimensional code by $0.0040$, while the quaternion with non-negative real part jumps by $2.0000$ and the293Euler angles of a turn about the second axis by $3.1416$. \chk{O4} For $200$ random rotations the Gram--Schmidt294decoder recovers the matrix to $10^{-12}$, and it moves by at most $1.40$ times a perturbation of the code.295\chk{O5} Statement (b) is the usable form: a data set of poses that contains a loop equivalent to a full turn has296no continuous quaternion labelling, whatever the convention; a data set confined to a ball of rotations has one.297A loss that identifies $q$ with $-q$ repairs the target but not the output layer, which still has to choose.298 299\subsection{Combing a mesh}300 301A convolution on a surface compares feature vectors at neighbouring points, which requires a frame at each point302in which to express them. A frame field is a framing in the sense of \cite[Ch.~8]{ADTHC}.303 304\begin{theorem}[Hairy ball, on meshes]\label{thm:hairy}305\Scl[Poincar\'e--Hopf; \cite{Ban67}] The zeros of a tangent vector field on a closed surface, counted with index,306number $\chi$. On a triangulated surface with a generic function $h$ on the vertices, define the index of a307vertex as $1-\frac12\#\{\text{sign changes of }h(w)-h(v)\text{ round the link}\}$; the indices add up to $\chi$.308\end{theorem}309 310\begin{figure}[t]311\centering312\begin{tikzpicture}313\draw[ink2] (1,0.78)--(0.325,0.39)--(0.325,-0.39)--(1,-0.78)--(1.675,-0.39)--(1.675,0.39)--cycle;314\draw[ink2,very thin] (1,0)--(1,0.78);315\draw[ink2,very thin] (1,0)--(0.325,0.39);316\draw[ink2,very thin] (1,0)--(0.325,-0.39);317\draw[ink2,very thin] (1,0)--(1,-0.78);318\draw[ink2,very thin] (1,0)--(1.675,-0.39);319\draw[ink2,very thin] (1,0)--(1.675,0.39);320\draw[bwd,fill=white] (1,0.78) circle (2.1pt);