Indexed text attachment
connections-curvature-higher-geometry.tex
Source for Connections, Curvature, and Higher Geometry: From covariant differentiation to differential cohomology
View paper · Download original file
Lines 401–500 of 4453. Source text is displayed literally.
401 402The acceleration of a curve in Euclidean space can be resolved into components tangent and normal to an immersed submanifold. The tangential component is governed by the induced metric. In dimension two the normal component also determines the intrinsic Gaussian curvature through a quadratic identity. We derive that identity from flatness of the ambient derivative and the splitting of the ambient tangent bundle. This gives the tensor form of the calculation underlying Tu's treatment \cite[\S\S\,5,8--9,12]{tu}.403 404\section{The curvature of a connection}405 406The curvature of \(\nabla\) is407\begin{equation}408 R(X,Y)Z=\nabla_X\nabla_Y Z-\nabla_Y\nabla_X Z409 -\nabla_{[X,Y]}Z .410 \label{eq:intrinsic-curvature}411\end{equation}412It is \(C^\infty(M)\)-linear in all three fields. In the first input, the term \(-Y(f)\nabla_XZ\) arising from \(fX\) cancels the contribution of the bracket \([fX,Y]=f[X,Y]-Y(f)X\). Skew symmetry then handles the second input. In the third input, the terms differentiating \(f\) once cancel between the two compositions of \(\nabla\), and the scalar second derivatives cancel against \([X,Y](f)\). Thus \(R\) is a two-form with values in endomorphisms of \(TM\).413 414For a metric connection, applying \(XY-YX-[X,Y]\) to the scalar \(g(Z,W)\) and expanding metric compatibility gives415\[416 g(R(X,Y)Z,W)=-g(Z,R(X,Y)W).417\]418The mixed terms from differentiating both fields cancel in pairs. For a torsion-free connection, the cyclic sum in \(X,Y,Z\) of \eqref{eq:intrinsic-curvature} is zero. To check this at a point, use coordinate fields, so that all brackets vanish. Pairing terms with the same outer derivative leaves419\(\nabla_X(\nabla_Y Z-\nabla_Z Y)\) and its cyclic permutations, each zero by symmetry of the Christoffel symbols. Tensoriality extends the statement to all fields.420 421For Levi-Civita curvature there is also pair exchange. Use the components422\[423 R_{ijk\ell}=g(R(\partial_i,\partial_j)\partial_k,\partial_\ell).424\]425At a point \(p\), start with a chart \(x\) centered there and introduce \(y\) by426\[427 x^a=y^a-\tfrac12\Gamma^a{}_{bc}(p)y^by^c .428\]429This defines new coordinates near \(p\) by the inverse function theorem. The second derivatives of \(x(y)\) cancel the old Christoffel symbols at \(p\). Torsion-freeness ensures they are symmetric in \(b,c\). In the new chart \(\Gamma(p)=0\), and metric compatibility also gives \(\partial_i g_{jk}(p)=0\). Evaluating \eqref{eq:levi-christoffel} and its first derivatives at \(p\) gives430\[431 \begin{split}432 2R_{ijk\ell}433 &=\partial_i\partial_k g_{\ell j}434 -\partial_i\partial_\ell g_{jk}\\435 &\quad-\partial_j\partial_k g_{\ell i}436 +\partial_j\partial_\ell g_{ik}.437 \end{split}438\]439Since mixed derivatives commute and \(g\) is symmetric, this expression equals \(2R_{k\ell ij}\). These identities characterize the symmetries of the metric curvature tensor \cite{lee-riemannian}.440 441For a two-plane \(\Pi\subseteq T_pM\), choose a spanning pair \(X,Y\). Its sectional curvature is442\[443 K(\Pi)=444 \frac{g(R(X,Y)Y,X)}445 {|X|_g^2|Y|_g^2-g(X,Y)^2}.446\]447In the numerator, skew symmetry in each pair gives a quadratic expression on \(X\wedge Y\). Both numerator and denominator therefore scale by the square of the determinant of a change of basis of \(\Pi\). This proves independence of the spanning pair. On a surface there is only one plane at each point, giving its Gaussian curvature.448 449\begin{example}[Bi-invariant metrics]450In the Lie group example of Chapter~\ref{ch:levi}, let \(X,Y,Z\) be left-invariant fields. The commutator of their covariant derivatives acts on \(Z\) by \(\tfrac14[[X,Y],Z]\), since the Jacobi identity rewrites the difference of the two nested brackets. The last term of \eqref{eq:intrinsic-curvature} acts by \(\tfrac12[[X,Y],Z]\). Thus451\[452 R(X,Y)Z=-\tfrac14[[X,Y],Z].453\]454Taking \(Z=Y\), pairing with \(X\), and using skew-adjointness of the bracket gives \(g(R(X,Y)Y,X)=\tfrac14|[X,Y]|^2\). Positive sectional curvature in a plane therefore occurs exactly when the two directions fail to commute. On a torus all brackets vanish, and this metric is flat.455\end{example}456 457\section{The Gauss and Codazzi identities}458 459Let \(M^n\) be immersed in \(\mathbb R^{n+1}\) with induced metric. Work locally with a smooth unit normal \(N\) and write \(D\) for the ambient Euclidean derivative. Differentiating \(\langle N,N\rangle=1\) shows that \(D_XN\) is tangent. Define the shape operator \(S(X)=-D_XN\) and the second fundamental form \(\mathrm{II}(X,Y)=g(SX,Y)\). Differentiating \(\langle Y,N\rangle=0\) yields460\[461 D_XY=\nabla_XY+\mathrm{II}(X,Y)N .462\]463Here \(\nabla\) is Levi-Civita by Chapter~\ref{ch:levi}. Taking the normal component of \(D_XY-D_YX=[X,Y]\) proves that \(\mathrm{II}\) is symmetric. This decomposition can also be recorded by the splitting464\[465 \begin{tikzcd}[column sep=3em]466 TM\oplus\mathbb RN \arrow[r,"\simeq"]467 \arrow[d,"\operatorname{pr}_{TM}"']&468 M\times\mathbb R^{n+1}\arrow[dl,"\operatorname{pr}_{TM}"]\\469 TM .470 \end{tikzcd}471\]472The derivative in the ambient bundle does not preserve either summand in general, and \(S\) and \(\mathrm{II}\) measure its off-diagonal terms.473 474\begin{theorem}[Gauss and Codazzi for a Euclidean hypersurface]475One has476\begin{align*}477 R(X,Y)Z478 &=\mathrm{II}(Y,Z)SX-\mathrm{II}(X,Z)SY,\\479 (\nabla_X\mathrm{II})(Y,Z)&=(\nabla_Y\mathrm{II})(X,Z).480\end{align*}481\end{theorem}482 483\begin{proof}484Insert the decomposition of \(D_YZ\) into \(D_XD_YZ\), subtract the counterpart with \(X,Y\) interchanged, and subtract \(D_{[X,Y]}Z\). Flatness of the Euclidean derivative makes the result zero. Its tangential component is \(R(X,Y)Z-\mathrm{II}(Y,Z)SX+\mathrm{II}(X,Z)SY\). Its normal component is the coefficient485\[486 \begin{split}487 X\mathrm{II}(Y,Z)-Y\mathrm{II}(X,Z)488 &+\mathrm{II}(X,\nabla_YZ)-\mathrm{II}(Y,\nabla_XZ)\\489 &-\mathrm{II}([X,Y],Z).490 \end{split}491\]492Use \([X,Y]=\nabla_XY-\nabla_YX\) and the product rule for the covariant derivative of a covariant tensor. The coefficient is the difference of the two derivatives in the second identity.493\end{proof}494 495When \(n=2\), choosing an orthonormal basis gives \(K=\det S\). Changing \(N\) to \(-N\) negates \(S\) while preserving its determinant in dimension two. Because the right-hand definition of \(K\) uses only the metric and its Levi-Civita connection, two isometric surfaces have equal Gaussian curvature at corresponding points. This is the intrinsic content of the Theorema Egregium.496 497\begin{example}[Graph, cylinder, and sphere]498For a graph \(z=f(x,y)\) in \(\mathbb R^3\), put \(w=(1+|\nabla f|^2)^{1/2}\) and use the upward normal \(N=(-f_x,-f_y,1)/w\). Its first fundamental form has determinant \(w^2\). The second fundamental form has matrix \((f_{ij}/w)\). Thus \(K=\det(f_{ij})/w^4\). Taking \(f=xy\) gives negative curvature at every point of its graph. On the cylinder of radius \(a\), the two eigenvalues of \(S\) with outward normal are \(-1/a\) in the circular direction and \(0\) along its axis. Hence \(K=0\). The local parametrization \((s,t)\mapsto(a\cos(s/a),a\sin(s/a),t)\) exhibits the same result by pulling the metric back to \(ds^2+dt^2\). On the sphere of radius \(a\) one has \(S=-a^{-1}\operatorname{id}\), so \(K=a^{-2}\).499\end{example}500