Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

galois-theory-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Galois Theory in Higher Categories

View paper · Download original file

Lines 611–710 of 4071. Source text is displayed literally.

611 612By effectivity \(V_0\to Y\) is an effective epimorphism and \(V_1\simeq V_0\times_Y V_0\). There is a canonical comparison \(V_0\to Y\times_B U\) over \(Y\). After pullback along \(V_0\to Y\), this comparison becomes613\[614       V_0\times_Y V_0\longrightarrow V_0\times_B U.615\]616The source is \(V_1\), and the target is \(V_0\times_U U_1\) where \(U_1\to U\) uses the initial vertex. The comparison is therefore the cartesian vertex equivalence of the datum. To descend that equivalence, pull it and both its domain and codomain to the entire \v{C}ech nerve of \(V_0\to Y\). The comparison is an equivalence in every such degree. Each original object is recovered by realizing its pullback diagram, by universality of colimits. Hence \(V_0\simeq Y\times_B U\). The vertex comparison in each degree identifies \(V_n\simeq Y\times_B U_n\), compatibly with all simplex operators. This gives the natural equivalences of the two composites.617\end{proof}618 619This gives the underlying mechanism of the action equivalence of Theorem~\ref{thm:actions-delooping}. When \(U=1\) and \(B=BG\), the \v{C}ech nerve is the bar groupoid of \(G\). At the other extreme, there may be no distinguished global point of \(U\) or \(B\). The internal groupoid then describes transitions between varying objects of objects. Replacing it by the loops at a chosen object would require extra hypotheses that are absent for most covers in a topos.620 621\begin{corollary}[What a general map sees]622\label{cor:descent-image}623For any \(q:U\to B\), let \(i:I\hookrightarrow B\) denote its image and \(p:U\to I\) the associated effective epimorphism. There is a canonical equivalence \(\operatorname{Desc}(q)\simeq\mathcal X_{/I}\), under which comparison from \(\mathcal X_{/B}\) is restriction along \(i\). Comparison is an equivalence if and only if \(q\) is an effective epimorphism.624\end{corollary}625 626\begin{proof}627The \\v{C}ech diagrams for \(p\) and \(q\) coincide because \(i\) is a monomorphism. More explicitly \(I\times_B I\simeq I\), so the comparison \(U\times_I U\to U\times_B U\) is an equivalence, and the same holds for every iterated pullback. Theorem~\ref{thm:effective-descent} applied to \(p\) gives the conclusion about restriction. If \(i^*\) is an equivalence, it reflects equivalences and carries \((I\to B)\to(B\to B)\) to an equivalence. Thus \(i\) is an equivalence.628\end{proof}629 630\section{Mapping spaces and properties local on the base}631\index{descent!mapping spaces}\index{truncated map}632 633Descent reconstructs morphisms as well as objects. For \(E,F\to B\) and \(q\) effective, it identifies634\begin{equation}635\label{eq:descent-mapping}636 \operatorname{Map}_{\mathcal X_{/B}}(E,F)637 \simeq638 \lim_{[n]\in\Delta}639 \operatorname{Map}_{\mathcal X_{/U_n}}640       (E\times_B U_n,F\times_B U_n).641\end{equation}642To check this directly, realize the augmented diagram \(E\times_B U_\bullet\to E\) in the slice over \(B\). Mapping into \(F\) turns its colimit into a limit of mapping spaces. The adjunction between composition and pullback along \(U_n\to B\) identifies each term of that limit with the corresponding term on the right of \eqref{eq:descent-mapping}. An element of the right-hand side specifies a local map together with compatibility homotopies over intersections and higher coherent comparisons on all iterated intersections.643 644Let \(\mathcal D(B)\subseteq \mathcal X_{/B}\) be a full subcategory closed under equivalences, for each \(B\), and assume pullback takes objects of \(\mathcal D\) to objects of \(\mathcal D\). Call membership local on the base if \(E\to B\) belongs to \(\mathcal D(B)\) whenever its pullback belongs to \(\mathcal D(U)\) along an effective epimorphism \(U\to B\).645 646\begin{proposition}[Descent for full subcategories]647\label{prop:relative-full-descent}648If membership in \(\mathcal D\) is local on the base, then for every effective epimorphism \(q:U\to B\),649\[650    \mathcal D(B)\simeq \lim_{[n]\in\Delta}\mathcal D(U_n).651\]652Conversely, if this comparison is an equivalence for all effective epimorphisms, membership is local on the base.653\end{proposition}654 655\begin{proof}656The proposed target is a full subcategory of \(\operatorname{Desc}(q)\), since limits preserve full inclusions of \(\infty\)-categories. A cartesian section lies in it exactly when its degree-zero object is in \(\mathcal D(U)\), since the other entries are equivalent to pullbacks along a vertex. Theorem~\ref{thm:effective-descent} identifies such sections with the objects over \(B\) whose pullback along \(q\) belongs to \(\mathcal D(U)\). This proves both directions.657\end{proof}658 659For example, the class of \(n\)-truncated maps is local on the base for each integer \(n\geq -2\). The case \(n=-2\) is the conservativity of pullback along an effective epimorphism. For the induction step, a map \(E\to B\) is \(n\)-truncated precisely if its diagonal \(E\to E\times_B E\) is \((n-1)\)-truncated. Forming the diagonal commutes with base change. The cover on its codomain after pullback along \(U\to B\) is effective, so the induction hypothesis applies. In particular this yields descent for monomorphisms and for covering objects with discrete fibers. Effective epimorphisms themselves are local, by applying the equivalence test to the image inclusion as in the orbit argument of Chapter~\ref{ch:torsors}. The locality proof uses finite-level properties and is valid in a nonhypercomplete topos.660 661\section{The descent monad}662\index{monad!descent}\index{Barr--Beck theorem}663 664Effective descent also has a monadic formulation. The functor \(q^*:\mathcal X_{/B}\to\mathcal X_{/U}\) has left adjoint \(q_!\) given by composition with \(q\). It preserves colimits by universality and detects equivalences by the \v{C}ech argument. The \(\infty\)-categorical Barr--Beck theorem then gives665\[666      \mathcal X_{/B}\simeq667      \operatorname{Alg}_{T}(\mathcal X_{/U}),668      \qquad T=q^*q_!.669\]670In the language of the Barr--Beck hypotheses, preserving all colimits implies preservation of realizations of those simplicial objects that become split after \(q^*\) \cite[Theorem 4.7.3.5]{ha}. This proves monadicity without assuming that the underlying morphism \(q\) has a section.671 672The monad can be expressed in terms of the two projections \(s,t:U_1\rightrightarrows U\), with \(s\) the source and \(t\) the target. For \(A\to U\),673\[674       T(A)\simeq t_!s^* A \simeq U\times_B A .675\]676In the last expression the first coordinate is the target in \(U\). The unit is induced by the diagonal of \(U\) over \(B\). The multiplication takes \((u_2,u_1,a)\) to \((u_2,a)\) with the prescribed composition of paths in \(B\). Its simplicial powers are indexed by strings in the \v{C}ech groupoid. For \(A=E\times_B U\), the monad action identifies the point \(e\) over the preceding vertex with the same point over the new vertex. Thus the map \(T(A)\to A\) is the transport correspondence from the canonical descent datum. The monadic comparison and the \v{C}ech comparison agree on every pullback from \(B\), and both comparisons are equivalences. This relates their coherent algebra and coherent transport descriptions without an extra hypothesis on \(q\).677 678As with the classical treatment in \cite[Section 5.1]{bj}, the monad lives on a slice over the splitting object. If a geometric problem begins with algebras and replaces them by opposite affine objects, geometric pullback usually becomes extension of scalars. Passing to opposites converts the preceding monadic expression into a comonadic one with the corresponding variance of the adjunction. In a general algebraic category, extension of scalars still must be proved to satisfy a descent theorem. The argument in this chapter uses groupoid effectivity and universal colimits in a specific ambient topos, which are the hypotheses making arbitrary effective epimorphisms work here.679 680\section{Refinements and changes of groupoid presentation}681\index{groupoid!change of presentation}682 683Every effective internal groupoid presents a base. Let \(D_\bullet\) be an internal groupoid, let \(B=|D_\bullet|\), and apply Theorem~\ref{thm:effective-descent} to \(D_0\to B\). This identifies cartesian objects over \(D_\bullet\) with \(\mathcal X_{/B}\). A map of groupoids induces a pullback functor between their cartesian action categories, and under this equivalence it is pullback along the map of realizations. In fact, pulling back \(E\times_{|D_\bullet|}D_\bullet\) along the map of groupoids gives its pullback from \(E\) degree by degree. Refinement of an effective cover is a particular case, in which the map of realizations is the identity. Restricting a datum to a refinement changes the representatives for its local objects and their transition maps while preserving its realized object.684 685The following criterion gives a specific test for changing presentations. For a map \(F_\bullet\to D_\bullet\) of internal groupoids, call it fully faithful if the comparison686\[687 F_1\longrightarrow (F_0\times F_0)\times_{D_0\times D_0}D_1688\]689is an equivalence. Call it essentially surjective if the map690\[691 F_0\times_{D_0,s}D_1\xrightarrow{\,t\,}D_0692\]693is an effective epimorphism.694 695\begin{proposition}[Change of presentation]696If a map of internal groupoids is fully faithful and essentially surjective, it induces an equivalence of realizations and an equivalence of cartesian action categories. Conversely, a map inducing an equivalence of realizations is fully faithful and essentially surjective.697\end{proposition}698 699\begin{proof}700Write \(A=|F_\bullet|\) and \(B=|D_\bullet|\). Effectivity gives701\[702 (F_0\times F_0)\times_{D_0\times D_0}D_1\simeq F_0\times_B F_0.703\]704Full faithfulness thus identifies the degree-one terms of the \v{C}ech nerves of \(F_0\to A\) and \(F_0\to B\), compatibly with both vertices. By the Segal identities their entire nerves agree. Their realizations identify \(A\) with the image of \(F_0\to B\). On the other hand \(F_0\times_{D_0,s}D_1\simeq F_0\times_B D_0\), so essential surjectivity is equivalent to \(F_0\to B\) being effective after base change along \(D_0\to B\). Effectivity descends along that cover. The image is therefore \(B\). If \(A\to B\) is an equivalence, the same formulas give full faithfulness, and essential surjectivity follows by base change from the effective map \(F_0\to A\). The result for actions follows from the descent comparisons.705\end{proof}706 707An equivalence here allows the objects of objects to change. In later applications one can replace a groupoid associated to a cover by a more convenient presentation as long as the change of realization, or the two conditions in the proposition, can be verified.708 709\section{Fixed split type and the torsor of frames}710\index{torsor!frames}\index{split object}