Indexed text attachment
galois-theory-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Galois Theory in Higher Categories
View paper · Download original file
Lines 561–660 of 4071. Source text is displayed literally.
561\label{prop:delooped-quotient}562Let \(i:H\to G\) be a map of group objects in spaces and let \(Q\) be another group object. For a homomorphism \(\phi:G\to Q\), there is a pointed equivalence over \(BG\)563\[564 BH\simeq BG\times_{BQ}*565\]566if and only if \(G//H\), as a pointed left \(G\)-space, is equivalent to the regular left \(Q\)-space restricted along \(\phi\). In the pointed actions the specified points are those induced by the identities.567\end{proposition}568 569\begin{proof}570The object \(*\to BQ\) corresponds to the regular action by \eqref{eq:transport-space}. Pullback along \(B\phi\) restricts the action. Proposition~\ref{prop:connected-intermediates} computes the fiber of \(BH\to BG\) as \(G//H\). Transport from the fixed base along loops of \(BG\) acts on this fiber by left multiplication. This action commutes coherently with the right \(H\)-action used to form the quotient. Specifying a point in the fiber is the same as giving a pointed map from the regular action of \(G\). Hence \eqref{eq:transport-space}, applied also to the undercategory of the point, gives the stated equivalence of conditions.571\end{proof}572 573For a solution \(\phi\), the action on components of \(Q\) is transitive because \(BH\) is connected. Thus \(\pi_0 G\to \pi_0 Q\) is surjective. This condition is automatic for the ordinary quotient by a normal subgroup, but the full equivalence of pointed actions in Proposition~\ref{prop:delooped-quotient} probes every homotopy group of the fiber and its transport.574 575% End chapters/01-torsors.tex576% Begin chapters/02-descent.tex577\chapter{Effective descent and \v{C}ech actions}578\label{ch:descent}579 580The split-algebra equivalence in \cite[Chapter 2]{bj} classifies objects by transport among their trivializations. Later chapters of that book make the descent morphism explicit and replace a single group by an internal groupoid. In a higher topos this construction starts with the entire \v{C}ech nerve of an effective epimorphism. Each composable string of changes of trivialization comes with its own coherence, and these coherences are part of the gluing datum.581 582\section{Descent data and their realization}583\index{descent!effective}\index{effective epimorphism}\index{Cech nerve@\v{C}ech nerve}584 585For a map \(q:U\to B\), put \(U_n=U^{\times_B(n+1)}\). The cosimplicial diagram of slices586\[587 [n]\longmapsto \mathcal X_{/U_n}588\]589acts on a simplex operator by pullback. Define \(\operatorname{Desc}(q)\) to be its limit in \(\infty\)-categories. This limit can be described as the category of simplicial objects \(V_\bullet\to U_\bullet\) such that for every map \([m]\to[n]\) in the simplex category the square590\[591\begin{array}{ccc}592 V_n&\longrightarrow&V_m\\593 \downarrow&&\downarrow\\594 U_n&\longrightarrow&U_m595\end{array}596\]597is cartesian. Indeed the straightening of a diagram taking an object \(A\) to \(\mathcal X_{/A}\) is the target projection of the arrow category with its cartesian morphisms the pullback squares. A limit of such a diagram classifies its cartesian sections. In this description the two vertex identifications in degree one give an equivalence of the two pullbacks of \(V_0\) to \(U_1\). The higher simplices specify coherent composition of those equivalences.598 599\begin{theorem}[Effective descent]600\label{thm:effective-descent}601For an effective epimorphism \(q:U\to B\) in an \(\infty\)-topos, the comparison602\[603 \mathcal X_{/B}\longrightarrow \operatorname{Desc}(q),604 \qquad E\longmapsto (E\times_B U_n)_{n\geq 0},605\]606is an equivalence. Its inverse is geometric realization over \(B\).607\end{theorem}608 609\begin{proof}610The realization of the displayed diagram for \(E\) is \(E\), by universality of colimits and \(|U_\bullet|\simeq B\). For the other composite let \(V_\bullet\) be a descent datum and put \(Y=|V_\bullet|\). First, \(V_\bullet\) is a groupoid object. The Segal squares can be checked using a vertex at the beginning of a string together with cartesian transport to each next vertex. A composable string of arrows from \(V_0\) then consists of its initial point and the underlying composable string in \(U_\bullet\). Transport along the inverse of a base arrow gives the inverse arrow of \(V_\bullet\), again by the cartesian vertex condition.611 612By effectivity \(V_0\to Y\) is an effective epimorphism and \(V_1\simeq V_0\times_Y V_0\). There is a canonical comparison \(V_0\to Y\times_B U\) over \(Y\). After pullback along \(V_0\to Y\), this comparison becomes613\[614 V_0\times_Y V_0\longrightarrow V_0\times_B U.615\]616The source is \(V_1\), and the target is \(V_0\times_U U_1\) where \(U_1\to U\) uses the initial vertex. The comparison is therefore the cartesian vertex equivalence of the datum. To descend that equivalence, pull it and both its domain and codomain to the entire \v{C}ech nerve of \(V_0\to Y\). The comparison is an equivalence in every such degree. Each original object is recovered by realizing its pullback diagram, by universality of colimits. Hence \(V_0\simeq Y\times_B U\). The vertex comparison in each degree identifies \(V_n\simeq Y\times_B U_n\), compatibly with all simplex operators. This gives the natural equivalences of the two composites.617\end{proof}618 619This gives the underlying mechanism of the action equivalence of Theorem~\ref{thm:actions-delooping}. When \(U=1\) and \(B=BG\), the \v{C}ech nerve is the bar groupoid of \(G\). At the other extreme, there may be no distinguished global point of \(U\) or \(B\). The internal groupoid then describes transitions between varying objects of objects. Replacing it by the loops at a chosen object would require extra hypotheses that are absent for most covers in a topos.620 621\begin{corollary}[What a general map sees]622\label{cor:descent-image}623For any \(q:U\to B\), let \(i:I\hookrightarrow B\) denote its image and \(p:U\to I\) the associated effective epimorphism. There is a canonical equivalence \(\operatorname{Desc}(q)\simeq\mathcal X_{/I}\), under which comparison from \(\mathcal X_{/B}\) is restriction along \(i\). Comparison is an equivalence if and only if \(q\) is an effective epimorphism.624\end{corollary}625 626\begin{proof}627The \\v{C}ech diagrams for \(p\) and \(q\) coincide because \(i\) is a monomorphism. More explicitly \(I\times_B I\simeq I\), so the comparison \(U\times_I U\to U\times_B U\) is an equivalence, and the same holds for every iterated pullback. Theorem~\ref{thm:effective-descent} applied to \(p\) gives the conclusion about restriction. If \(i^*\) is an equivalence, it reflects equivalences and carries \((I\to B)\to(B\to B)\) to an equivalence. Thus \(i\) is an equivalence.628\end{proof}629 630\section{Mapping spaces and properties local on the base}631\index{descent!mapping spaces}\index{truncated map}632 633Descent reconstructs morphisms as well as objects. For \(E,F\to B\) and \(q\) effective, it identifies634\begin{equation}635\label{eq:descent-mapping}636 \operatorname{Map}_{\mathcal X_{/B}}(E,F)637 \simeq638 \lim_{[n]\in\Delta}639 \operatorname{Map}_{\mathcal X_{/U_n}}640 (E\times_B U_n,F\times_B U_n).641\end{equation}642To check this directly, realize the augmented diagram \(E\times_B U_\bullet\to E\) in the slice over \(B\). Mapping into \(F\) turns its colimit into a limit of mapping spaces. The adjunction between composition and pullback along \(U_n\to B\) identifies each term of that limit with the corresponding term on the right of \eqref{eq:descent-mapping}. An element of the right-hand side specifies a local map together with compatibility homotopies over intersections and higher coherent comparisons on all iterated intersections.643 644Let \(\mathcal D(B)\subseteq \mathcal X_{/B}\) be a full subcategory closed under equivalences, for each \(B\), and assume pullback takes objects of \(\mathcal D\) to objects of \(\mathcal D\). Call membership local on the base if \(E\to B\) belongs to \(\mathcal D(B)\) whenever its pullback belongs to \(\mathcal D(U)\) along an effective epimorphism \(U\to B\).645 646\begin{proposition}[Descent for full subcategories]647\label{prop:relative-full-descent}648If membership in \(\mathcal D\) is local on the base, then for every effective epimorphism \(q:U\to B\),649\[650 \mathcal D(B)\simeq \lim_{[n]\in\Delta}\mathcal D(U_n).651\]652Conversely, if this comparison is an equivalence for all effective epimorphisms, membership is local on the base.653\end{proposition}654 655\begin{proof}656The proposed target is a full subcategory of \(\operatorname{Desc}(q)\), since limits preserve full inclusions of \(\infty\)-categories. A cartesian section lies in it exactly when its degree-zero object is in \(\mathcal D(U)\), since the other entries are equivalent to pullbacks along a vertex. Theorem~\ref{thm:effective-descent} identifies such sections with the objects over \(B\) whose pullback along \(q\) belongs to \(\mathcal D(U)\). This proves both directions.657\end{proof}658 659For example, the class of \(n\)-truncated maps is local on the base for each integer \(n\geq -2\). The case \(n=-2\) is the conservativity of pullback along an effective epimorphism. For the induction step, a map \(E\to B\) is \(n\)-truncated precisely if its diagonal \(E\to E\times_B E\) is \((n-1)\)-truncated. Forming the diagonal commutes with base change. The cover on its codomain after pullback along \(U\to B\) is effective, so the induction hypothesis applies. In particular this yields descent for monomorphisms and for covering objects with discrete fibers. Effective epimorphisms themselves are local, by applying the equivalence test to the image inclusion as in the orbit argument of Chapter~\ref{ch:torsors}. The locality proof uses finite-level properties and is valid in a nonhypercomplete topos.660