Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

galois-theory-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Galois Theory in Higher Categories

View paper · Download original file

Lines 451–550 of 4071. Source text is displayed literally.

451\begin{array}{ccc}452 E_0&\longrightarrow&1\\453 \downarrow&&\downarrow\\454 Y&\longrightarrow&BG455\end{array}456\]457is cartesian. To see this, test the comparison \(E_0\to Y\times_{BG}1\) after pullback along the effective epimorphism \(E_0\to Y\). The resulting map is458\[459 E_0\times_Y E_0\longrightarrow E_0\times_{BG}1.460\]461Under the identifications above it is exactly the degree-one vertex equivalence \(E_1\simeq E_0\times G_1\), using the first projection to \(E_0\). Equivalences can be tested after an effective epimorphism, as follows by reconstructing both source and target by the base changes of its \v{C}ech nerve and realizing. The vertex equivalence now gives \(E_\bullet\simeq G_\bullet\times_{BG}Y\) in all degrees. In the other direction, universality of colimits implies \(|G_\bullet\times_{BG}Y|\simeq Y\). All comparisons are natural in the diagrams, so they give inverse equivalences of \(\infty\)-categories.462\end{proof}463 464A \(G\)-torsor over \(T\) is an action in \(\mathcal X_{/T}\) on an object \(P\to T\) such that \(P\to T\) is an effective epimorphism and the transport map465\[466       P\times G\longrightarrow P\times_T P,467       \qquad (x,g)\longmapsto(x,g\cdot x)468\]469is an equivalence over \(T\). The universal torsor has underlying object \(1\to BG\). Its action is specified by the identification of its \v{C}ech groupoid with the bar groupoid of \(G\). Conventions using right actions give the same classifier via inversion.470 471\begin{corollary}[Torsor classification]472\label{cor:torsor-classification}473The space of \(G\)-torsors over \(T\), with equivariant equivalences as arrows, is naturally equivalent to \(\operatorname{Map}_{\mathcal X}(T,BG)\). Pullback in \(T\) corresponds to precomposition with the classifying map.474\end{corollary}475 476\begin{proof}477The classifying equivalence of Theorem~\ref{thm:actions-delooping} in \(\mathcal X_{/T}\) sends an action on \(P\) to an object \(P//G\to T\times BG\) over \(T\). The comparison from its action groupoid to the \v{C}ech nerve of \(P\to T\) is an equivalence in degree one by the torsor condition. The two Segal properties make it an equivalence in every degree. Since \(P\to T\) is effective, this means \(P//G\simeq T\) over \(T\). Conversely, if \(P//G\simeq T\), effectivity identifies the action groupoid with the \v{C}ech nerve of \(P\to T\), giving both torsor conditions. The core of objects \(Y\to T\times BG\) over \(T\) with \(Y\to T\) an equivalence is \(\operatorname{Map}_{\mathcal X}(T,BG)\), by replacing the source by \(T\). This identification and the resulting pullback of the universal torsor commute with base change.478\end{proof}479 480This formulation retains automorphisms of a torsor and their higher homotopies. At a classifying map \(c:T\to BG\), the loop space of the mapping space in Corollary~\ref{cor:torsor-classification} is the space of equivariant automorphisms of the classified torsor. Choosing a section of the torsor identifies it with the trivial torsor through the transport equivalence. Changing the section can change that identification. For an ordinary nonabelian group the induced change is conjugation. For an internal abelian group \(A\) with Eilenberg--Mac Lane deloopings, the same corollary applied to \(G=K(A,m)\) identifies torsors with maps to \(K(A,m+1)\). With the convention \(H^i(\mathcal X,A)=\pi_0\operatorname{Map}_{\mathcal X}(1,K(A,i))\), global isomorphism classes form \(H^{m+1}(\mathcal X,A)\). The based homotopy groups of the torsor space at the trivial class recover lower degrees, because looping mapping spaces commutes with looping the target.481 482\section{Transport over a space}483\index{monodromy}\index{homotopy orbits}\index{homotopy fixed points}484 485For a space \(B\) there is a canonical equivalence486\begin{equation}487\label{eq:transport-space}488       \mathcal S_{/B}\simeq \operatorname{Fun}(B,\mathcal S).489\end{equation}490The functor associated to \(Y\to B\) sends \(b\) to \(Y_b=\{b\}\times_B Y\). Its maps are transport along paths, and homotopies of paths act through the higher coherences of transport. One construction uses straightening of left fibrations \cite[Section 2.2.1]{htt}. Over a groupoidal base, the Grothendieck construction of a space-valued functor has only invertible arrows. Its total space is the homotopy sum \(\operatorname{colim}_{b\in B}F(b)\) over \(\operatorname{colim}_{b\in B}*\simeq B\). In the other direction an arbitrary map of spaces can be represented by a Kan fibration, which in particular is a left fibration. Thus the straightening correspondence restricts to the displayed equivalence.491 492For connected \(B\) the point \(b\) is an effective epimorphism in \(\mathcal S\), and the space \(B\) is the delooping of \(\Omega_bB\). Equation~\eqref{eq:transport-space} and Theorem~\ref{thm:actions-delooping} identify evaluation at \(b\) with the forgetful functor from \(\Omega_bB\)-actions. The point \(b: *\to B\) has fiber \(\Omega_bB\). Under the equivalence it is the regular action, also characterized as the free action on the point. Indeed maps \(*\to Y\) over \(B\) are points of \(Y_b\), and the Yoneda lemma in \(\operatorname{Fun}(B,\mathcal S)\) characterizes the free action by the representable functor \(\operatorname{Map}_B(b,-)\).493 494Pullback along a map \(f:C\to B\) corresponds to restriction of representations. Both adjoints to restriction exist and are computed by Kan extension. At \(b\), left Kan extension of \(F:C\to\mathcal S\) takes the homotopy sum of \(F\) over the groupoid of pairs \((c,f(c)\to b)\). Right Kan extension takes the limit over pairs \((c,b\to f(c))\). Inversion identifies the two indexing groupoids. The left adjoint is composition of total-space maps over the base, since giving a map from that composite is equivalent to giving a map to the pullback by the universal property of a fiber product. In the right adjoint the fiber over \(b\) is the space of sections of the restricted family over the fiber of \(f\). In particular the two adjoints along \(B\to *\) are homotopy orbits and homotopy fixed points.495 496If a connected space \(B\) has a fiber \(F\) at \(b\), then after choosing an identification with a specified space \(K\), the action can be expressed by a based map497\[498        B\longrightarrow B\operatorname{Aut}(K).499\]500Here \(\operatorname{Aut}(K)\) is the space of equivalences \(K\to K\) with composition. To verify the classification, take the core \(\mathcal S^\simeq\) in a universe containing the given fibers, choose the component containing \(K\), and use Proposition~\ref{prop:loop-delooping} to identify the component with \(B\operatorname{Aut}(K)\). Every functor from a space lands in the core, since all its arrows are invertible, and connectedness forces the selected component. Taking the homotopy fiber of evaluation at \(b\) gives the based mapping space and records the chosen identification. Forgetting the identification gives the unpointed mapping space. Taking \(\pi_0\) of \(\operatorname{Aut}(K)\) loses the higher transition data. For instance, let \(K=S^1\). The identity component of \(\operatorname{Aut}(S^1)\) is equivalent to \(S^1\), as follows by evaluating a degree-one map at a point and noting that the degree-one component of the based mapping space is contractible. Consequently501\[502       \pi_2\bigl(B\operatorname{Aut}(S^1)\bigr)\cong \mathbb Z.503\]504There are based families with fiber \(S^1\) over \(S^2\) whose classifying maps represent a nonzero integer, even though \(\pi_1(S^2)\) is trivial.505 506\section{The subgroup correspondence and its higher replacement}507\index{subgroup correspondence}\index{covering!pointed}508 509Fix a pointed connected space \((B,b)\). A pointed intermediate object is a factorization510\[511                  *\xrightarrow{y}Y\xrightarrow{q}B512\]513of \(b\), including an identification of the composite with \(b\). Its morphisms are maps of such factorizations, with coherent triangles. By \eqref{eq:transport-space} the category of factorizations is the category of actions equipped with a map from the regular action, or equivalently the category of actions with a specified point of the fiber over \(b\). This statement is true whether or not \(Y\) is connected. It follows because taking the undercategory of a given object preserves equivalences of \(\infty\)-categories.514 515\begin{proposition}[Connected intermediates]516\label{prop:connected-intermediates}517The full subcategory of pointed intermediate objects with connected \(Y\) is equivalent to the slice of group objects in spaces over \(G=\Omega_b B\). Under the equivalence \(Y\to B\) corresponds to \(H=\Omega_yY\to G\). Its fiber over \(b\), with the distinguished point, is the homotopy quotient \(G//H\) of the right \(H\)-action on \(G\) through \(H\to G\).518\end{proposition}519 520\begin{proof}521Slicing the equivalence of Proposition~\ref{prop:loop-delooping} gives the categorical claim. For the fiber, model the map as \(BH\to BG\). Pull back the family \(*\to BG\) to \(BH\). Its fiber at the point of \(BH\) is \(G\). Choose the path coordinate of a point in this family to run from the image of the moving point of \(BH\) to the fixed point of \(BG\). If \(\phi:H\to G\) is the homomorphism, transport in this coordinate along \(h\) sends \(g\) to \(g\phi(h)^{-1}\). This is the covariant presentation of the right action \(g\cdot h=g\phi(h)\). The total space is its homotopy quotient \(G//H\), and the chosen point comes from the identity in \(G\). Equivalently, this quotient is the realization obtained by pulling the augmented bar diagram of \(H\) back along \(*\to BG\), so its description fixes the same map and basepoint without choosing path coordinates.522\end{proof}523 524The connectedness condition on the total space is the homotopy-theoretic transitivity condition. In a pointed factorization, the map from the regular action to the fiber is the orbit map induced by the distinguished point. It is an effective epimorphism exactly when \(Y\) is connected. In one direction the orbit map is the base change of \(*\to Y\) along \(Y_b\to Y\), and in the other direction effective epimorphisms descend along the effective epimorphism \(Y_b\to Y\). The latter map is a base change of \(*\to B\). To justify the descent assertion, factor a map into its effective epimorphism and monomorphism. The subobject given by the second factor is terminal after base change precisely if it was terminal before base change, since base change along an effective epimorphism detects equivalences. For spaces this criterion says that the regular orbit is surjective on components and places no discreteness condition on the fiber.525 526\begin{theorem}[Subgroups at the covering level]527\label{thm:subgroup-cover}528The category of pointed factorizations over \((B,b)\) with \(Y\) connected and \(q:Y\to B\) \(0\)-truncated is equivalent to the poset of subgroups of \(\pi_1(B,b)\), ordered by inclusion.529\end{theorem}530 531\begin{proof}532Under \eqref{eq:transport-space}, the condition on \(q\) says every value of the functor is discrete. Such functors factor through the ordinary fundamental groupoid of \(B\). This follows from the universal property of the homotopy category, since the category of sets is ordinary and a functor on a groupoid takes its arrows to bijections. Choosing the object \(b\) of the connected fundamental groupoid gives a \(\pi_1(B,b)\)-action on the fiber. The distinguished point \(x\) and connectedness make the action transitive, by the orbit criterion above. The stabilizer \(K\) of \(x\) is a subgroup, and the pointed action is isomorphic to the left action on \(\pi_1(B,b)/K\) via \(gK\mapsto g\cdot x\). A pointed equivariant map exists from the quotient by \(K\) to the quotient by \(L\) precisely when \(K\subseteq L\), and is then uniquely determined by the displayed formula. Mapping spaces between the pointed actions are discrete because maps between discrete fibers form discrete spaces and naturality is imposed by a limit of such spaces. The result is the stated equivalence of categories.533\end{proof}534 535This is the regular-quotient argument of \cite[Proposition 2.4.1]{bj} at the covering level. The opposite category reverses its containment order, as for intermediate fields. Subgroups up to conjugacy classify connected covers up to equivalence when the point in each intermediate cover is forgotten. For example, the equivariant endomorphisms of the transitive set \(\pi_1(B,b)/K\) correspond to the cosets fixed under \(K\). The group of invertible endomorphisms is \(N_{\pi_1(B,b)}(K)/K\), up to inversion in the convention for right translation.536 537The loop homomorphism for a connected covering is the inclusion of a union of components of \(G\). Indeed its fiberwise description as the stabilizer is the pullback of the orbit map \(G\to Y_b\) along the point \(x\), and \(Y_b\) is discrete. For a general intermediate object the same pullback is a homotopy fiber with a chosen nullhomotopy of motion of \(x\). Such a fiber need not be a union of components. Take \(B=*\) and \(Y=K(\mathbb Z,2)\). The map of loop groups is \(K(\mathbb Z,1)\to *\), whose only homotopy fiber is neither empty nor contractible. Hence it fails to be a monomorphism in spaces. Proposition~\ref{prop:connected-intermediates} accommodates this data by allowing arbitrary homomorphisms into \(G\).538 539\begin{corollary}[Relative truncation of the stabilizer]540For \(n\geq 0\), a map \(BH\to BG\) of pointed connected spaces is \(n\)-truncated if and only if \(H\to G\) is \((n-1)\)-truncated.541\end{corollary}542 543\begin{proof}544Set \(F=BH\times_{BG}*\), pointed by the chosen points. The homotopy fiber of \(H\to G\) over the identity is \(\Omega F\), since based loops preserve limits. Every fiber of \(H\to G\) over a point in its image on components is equivalent to the identity fiber by translation, and all other fibers are empty. The degree-one orbit argument also shows that \(G\to F\) meets every component of \(F\), and the left \(G\)-action on \(F\) gives equivalences carrying the distinguished point into each component. Thus \(F\) is \(n\)-truncated if and only if its loop space at that point is \((n-1)\)-truncated. The fibers of \(BH\to BG\) are all equivalent to \(F\) since \(BG\) is connected. Combining these observations proves the claim.545\end{proof}546 547For \(n=0\), this identifies the covering condition with monomorphisms of loop groups. For \(n=1\), the stabilizer map can have nontrivial discrete homotopy fibers, as for \(Y=B\mathbb Z\) over \(B=*\). A classification by subgroup inclusions already fails at this level. The full slice of group objects records how the stabilizer maps into the ambient group, including the coherent data through which it acts.548 549\section{Regular intermediates and delooped quotients}550\index{covering!regular}\index{quotient!delooped}