Indexed text attachment
galois-theory-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Galois Theory in Higher Categories
View paper · Download original file
Lines 2891–2990 of 4071. Source text is displayed literally.
2891\label{prop:exit-sections}2892Under the hypotheses of Theorem~\ref{thm:exit-space-coefficients}, let \(F\) be the hypersheaf corresponding to \(M:\operatorname{Exit}_P(X)\to\mathcal S\). For an open \(U\subseteq X\) with the induced stratification,2893\[2894 F(U)\simeq \lim_{\operatorname{Exit}_P(U)} M|_{\operatorname{Exit}_P(U)}.2895\]2896The limits retain every compatibility with the noninvertible arrows of the exit category.2897\end{proposition}2898 2899\begin{proof}2900The strata of an open subspace inherit the required local bases and conical charts. Naturality of exodromy for open inclusions identifies hypersheaf restriction with precomposition by \(\operatorname{Exit}_P(U)\to\operatorname{Exit}_P(X)\) \cite[Proposition~6.2.3]{portateyssier}. Sections are maps from the terminal hypersheaf. The terminal hypersheaf is constructible, and under an equivalence of categories it corresponds to the terminal functor, of constant value \(*\). The mapping space out of that functor is the limit being asserted, by the defining adjunction of the constant-diagram functor with the limit functor.2901\end{proof}2902 2903\section{A conical calculation with higher stalks}2904\label{sec:exit-cone}2905 2906Let \(M\) be the plane with the discrete closed subset \(\mathbb Z\times\{0\}\) removed, and let \(L=S^2\). Both are locally contractible manifolds, \(M\) with infinitely many punctures. On \(X=M\times C(L)\), put the lower stratum \(Z=M\times\{\text{vertex}\}\) and the upper stratum \(U=M\times L\times\mathbb R_{>0}\). The lower stratum has conical charts obtained by taking disks in \(M\) times cones of uniformly bounded radius. The upper stratum is open and is an ordinary manifold. This gives explicit conical and weak local contractibility hypotheses for exodromy.2907 2908Write \(K=\Pi_\infty(M)\) and \(T=\Pi_\infty(L)\). The exit category of the cone is \(T^\triangleleft\), the category obtained by adjoining an initial object to \(T\). To justify this, the nonvertex subcategory is full and equivalent to \(T\) by product with \(\mathbb R_{>0}\), while the vertex is initial by the cone lemma \cite[Lemma~2.1.8]{portateyssier}. An initial vertex determines, up to contractible choice, a coherent cone on the inclusion of the nonvertex subcategory. The resulting functor from \(T^\triangleleft\) is fully faithful. The mapping spaces out of the initial vertex are contractible and there are no arrows from a nonvertex object to the vertex, since such arrows decrease the stratum label. Mapping spaces between nonvertex objects agree by fullness. The functor is therefore an equivalence. Exit simplices of a product with an unstratified space decompose into a singular simplex in that space and an exit simplex in the stratified factor. It follows that2909\[2910 \operatorname{Exit}_P(X)\simeq K\times T^\triangleleft .2911\]2912 2913Write \(\pi:K\times T\to K\) for projection. A representation is equivalently the full coherent data2914\[2915 A:K\to\mathcal S,\qquad2916 B:K\times T\to\mathcal S,\qquad2917 \eta:\pi^*A\longrightarrow B .2918\]2919Indeed currying gives a \(K\)-indexed family of diagrams on \(T^\triangleleft\). A diagram on \(T^\triangleleft\) is a diagram on \(T\) equipped with a cone, which gives precisely the displayed data in each fiber. Natural transformations are compatible maps of the two diagrams and the comparison; the compatibility square is specified in the functor \(\infty\)-category. At a given \(k\), adjunction also writes the comparison as \(A(k)\to \lim_{t\in T} B(k,t)\). This last description shows why keeping only the monodromy on each stratum can lose a comparison even when both restrictions are known exactly.2920 2921The inclusion of \(K\) at the initial vertex is initial. For an object \((k,t)\) of the entire exit category, the category of arrows from \((k',\text{vertex})\) to it is equivalent to \(K_{/k}\), which has a terminal object. Therefore the global sections of the hypersheaf corresponding to \((A,B,\eta)\) are \(\lim_K A\) by Proposition~\ref{prop:exit-sections} and the initiality criterion. The comparison \(\eta\) still controls the behavior on neighborhoods intersecting the upper stratum.2922 2923For example, take \(A\) and \(B\) to be constant of value the Eilenberg--Mac~Lane space \(Q=K(\mathbb Z,2)\). The identity comparison and the comparison constant at the base point give inequivalent constructible hypersheaves with equivalent restrictions to both strata. A natural equivalence between the two representations would give a commutative square up to homotopy on any radial exit arrow, with equivalences on its vertical sides. On \(\pi_2(Q)\), one horizontal side is the identity and the other is zero. No such square can have invertible vertical sides.2924 2925There is also a link contribution in the direct image \(j_*B\) for \(j:U\hookrightarrow X\). In the representation category \(j_*\) corresponds to right Kan extension along \(K\times T\hookrightarrow K\times T^\triangleleft\). This can be seen directly from \(j_*B(V)=B(V\cap U)\) and the section formula. At \((k,\text{vertex})\), the comma category for right Kan extension is equivalent to \(K_{k/}\times T\). In this product, restricting a limit to the slice at \(\operatorname{id}_k\) is allowed because the identity is initial in \(K_{k/}\). Therefore the value on the lower stratum is \(k\mapsto\lim_T B(k,-)\). For the constant diagram with value \(Q\), this gives2926\[2927 \operatorname{Map}_{\mathcal S}(S^2,Q)2928 \simeq Q\times \mathbb Z_{\mathrm{disc}}.2929\]2930Evaluation at a chosen point of \(S^2\) has fiber \(\Omega^2 Q\simeq\mathbb Z_{\mathrm{disc}}\). Taking \(Q\) in its abelian group space model separates a map into its value at the chosen point and a pointed map by translation, proving the product decomposition. In particular the direct image has extra components on the lower stratum although the initial value \(Q\) is connected. The higher homotopy type of the link is used in this computation. Its fundamental group is trivial.2931 2932Inverting all exit paths in this example sends \(K\times T^\triangleleft\) to \(K\). Groupoidification preserves products for these factors, as can be seen either from the existence of an initial object in the cone or by taking iterated colimits of constant points. Accordingly a functor comes from ordinary monodromy on \(X\) precisely when \(\eta\) is an equivalence. In that case \(B\simeq\pi^* A\) by \(\eta\), which already implies the factorization. Conversely any representation from a groupoid sends the exit comparisons to equivalences. This agrees with the deformation retraction of \(X\) to the lower stratum.2933 2934\section{A van Kampen principle with directed coefficients}2935 2936The right colimit for local presentations of a stratified space is a colimit of exit categories. Let \(\{U_\alpha\}\) be an open cover of a conically stratified \(X\) with locally weakly contractible strata, and let \(V_\bullet\to X\) be its open \Cech{} presentation. Its degree \(n\) can be read as the disjoint union of the intersections \(U_{\alpha_0}\cap\cdots\cap U_{\alpha_n}\). The exit-path van Kampen theorem gives2937\[2938 \operatorname{Exit}_P(X)\simeq2939 \operatorname*{colim}_{[n]\in\Delta^{\mathrm{op}}}\operatorname{Exit}_P(V_n)2940 \qquad\text{in }\operatorname{Cat}_\infty .2941\]2942For the application here this follows from the colimit-preserving exit-path functor on the hypersheaf topos, obtained by extending its values on opens \cite[\S4]{portateyssier}. Indeed the coproducts of intersections give the \Cech{} nerve in that topos, and its colimit is terminal because the cover map is an effective epimorphism. The exit functor sends this colimit to the displayed colimit. It sends a coproduct of the opens as hypersheaves to a coproduct of their exit categories, which agrees with the exit category of the disjoint union.2943 2944Proposition~\ref{prop:directed-colim-glue} now identifies constructible hypersheaves with coherent families of representations on these local exit categories. This operation compares local assignments on intersections by equivalences of representations. Their values along individual exit arrows inside an open set can be arbitrary maps. The equivalence relating two restrictions of a representation on an overlap and the map that the representation assigns to an exit arrow inside an open carry different parts of the data.2945 2946Suppose the strata are coarsened by a map of posets \(Q\to P\), and both stratifications on \(X\) are conical with locally weakly contractible strata. Let \(v:\operatorname{Exit}_Q(X)\to\operatorname{Exit}_P(X)\) be the comparison. Under these hypotheses \(v\) is the localization at the arrows whose images are equivalences \cite[Corollary~6.2.7]{portateyssier}. Therefore a \(Q\)-hyperconstructible hypersheaf is \(P\)-hyperconstructible if and only if the corresponding representation sends every such arrow to an equivalence. One implication follows by restriction from a \(P\)-representation. In the other direction the universal property of localization descends the representation to \(\operatorname{Exit}_P(X)\), and naturality of exodromy identifies its pullback with the original hypersheaf. The test is about coherent functors, so the comparison includes mapping spaces of classes that survive the coarsening. With the one-stratum coarsening, the test forces every transport to be invertible and recovers locally constant hypersheaves.2947 2948\section{Recovering the directed category from its coefficients}\index{atomic object}2949 2950Call an object \(a\) of a presentable \(\infty\)-category atomic if \(\operatorname{Map}(a,-)\) preserves all small colimits. This includes preservation of the empty colimit and is stronger than compactness, which asks only for preservation of filtered colimits. An atomic object is one on which it is possible to test arbitrary colimits by mapping out of it.2951 2952\begin{proposition}2953\label{prop:exit-atomic}2954Let \(C\) be a small \(\infty\)-category admitting a conservative functor to a poset. There is a canonical equivalence2955\[2956 C \simeq2957 \left(\operatorname{Fun}(C,\mathcal S)_{\mathrm{at}}\right)^{\mathrm{op}},2958\]2959where the subscript denotes the full subcategory of atomic objects.2960\end{proposition}2961 2962\begin{proof}2963Covariant representables \(h_c=\operatorname{Map}_C(c,-)\) are atomic since mapping out of \(h_c\) is evaluation and colimits are pointwise. Conversely every functor \(F:C\to\mathcal S\) is a colimit of covariant representables over its category of elements, by density. For \(F\) atomic, apply \(\operatorname{Map}(F,-)\) to one such colimit presentation of \(F\). The identity of \(F\) is in the image on components of some stage, since \(\pi_0\) preserves colimits of spaces and every element of a colimit of sets comes from a stage. Thus \(F\) is a retract of a representable, with maps \(F\to h_c\to F\) whose composite is homotopic to the identity.2964 2965Every endomorphism of an object of \(C\) maps to an identity in the poset and is an equivalence by conservativity. By Yoneda the induced endomorphism of \(h_c\) is also an equivalence. With one composite the identity and the other invertible, the two maps in the retract diagram are equivalences. Every atom is therefore representable. Covariant Yoneda is fully faithful on \(C^{\mathrm{op}}\), giving the claimed variance and equivalence.2966\end{proof}2967 2968Combining this proposition with Theorem~\ref{thm:exit-space-coefficients} recovers the exit category as the opposite of the atomic constructible hypersheaves. Under this identification the atom associated to \(x\) corepresents the stalk at \(x\). A map of atoms has variance reversed relative to an exit path. This follows from the natural transformation between evaluation functors and the contravariance of corepresenting objects. In particular the directed category can be recovered from the intrinsic colimits and arrows of the coefficient category, without a choice of a base point. If \(C\) does not admit the conservativity assumption, the general statement from the proof recovers the idempotent completion, since atoms are then retracts of representables \cite[\S5.1.6]{htt}.2969 2970Atomic generation is also a route to exodromy for stratified \(\infty\)-topoi whose geometric origin need not be conical. Take a geometric morphism to \(\operatorname{Fun}(P,\mathcal S)\), define the stratum topoi by geometric base change along the point topoi at \(p\), and define constructibility by locally constant restrictions. The formulation of \cite[Definition~2.2.10]{beyondconical} assumes atomic generation of the constructible subcategory, its closure under limits and colimits in the ambient topos, and preservation of limits by the inverse image of the stratification. The first property identifies the constructible category with a presheaf category by the free colimit completion of its atoms. The limit compatibility gives the left adjoint to stratification pullback on constructible coefficients, and this adjoint carries atoms to atoms because its right adjoint preserves colimits. Taking opposites then supplies the functor from the abstract exit category to \(P\). Thus a theorem proving these properties for a given stratified topos supplies a classifier without assuming that its simplices are represented by topological exit paths.2971 2972\section{The profinite directed case}\index{profinite exodromy}2973 2974The framework of Barwick, Glasman and Haine supplies an arithmetic counterpart \cite{exodromy}. For a coherent scheme \(Y\), in particular a quasicompact quasiseparated scheme, their category \(\operatorname{Gal}(Y)\) has geometric points as objects and \'etale specializations as morphisms. The construction equips it with a profinite categorical structure. A specialization carries incidence information, whereas endomorphisms at a geometric point account for the absolute Galois action on its residue-field data. Keeping both features is necessary to reconstruct the associated constructible coefficients.2975 2976For space coefficients in the sense of \cite[Corollary~0.5.2]{exodromy}, the theorem takes the form2977\[2978 \operatorname{Cons}(Y_{\textnormal{\'et}};\mathcal S_\pi)2979 \simeq \operatorname{Fun}_{\mathrm{cts}}2980 (\operatorname{Gal}(Y),\mathcal S_\pi),2981\]2982where on the left the constructibility condition is that of the stratified \'etale topos, and \(\mathcal S_\pi\) denotes the \(\pi\)-finite spaces. Such spaces are truncated, have finitely many components, and have finite homotopy groups in each component. The right side uses the profinite stratified shape and its continuous representation category. When a field is viewed as a one-point scheme, a chosen separable closure supplies a single geometric base point up to isomorphism, and the loop automorphisms in this classification recover its absolute Galois group with its profinite structure. General schemes may also have noninvertible specializations between points.2983 2984The classifying pro-space of the profinite stratified shape recovers the ordinary profinite shape for spectral stratified topoi \cite[Example~0.4.8]{exodromy}. This forgetful operation is the arithmetic counterpart of discarding directed transport by groupoidifying an exit category. The arithmetic theorem retains a continuity condition on representations, while Theorem~\ref{thm:exit-space-coefficients} uses an ordinary small exit \(\infty\)-category without an added profinite topology. The comparison thus relates the two generalizations through the role of coherence and direction, with the appropriate topology determined by the coefficient problem.2985 2986% End chapters/10-exodromy.tex2987\part{Higher topoi and presentation}2988% Begin chapters/11-geometric.tex2989\chapter{Geometric morphisms and the classification of sections}2990\label{ch:geometric}