Indexed text attachment
galois-theory-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Galois Theory in Higher Categories
View paper · Download original file
Lines 2691–2790 of 4071. Source text is displayed literally.
2691Working contextually is important. Global elements of objects of an \(\infty\)-topos need not detect equivalences. For example, a statement about fibers over all \(c:T\to C_0\) can be tested at the generic point \(c=\operatorname{id}_{C_0}\) in context \(C_0\). A statement about fibers over all \(1\to C_0\) can hold vacuously while the assertion over \(C_0\) fails. The recovery of internal constructions from their underlying global categories requires its own hypotheses.2692 2693\section{Coherent presheaves and direction}\index{right fibration}\index{left fibration}2694 2695\begin{definition}2696A right fibration over an internal category \(C_\bullet\) is a map \(q:E_\bullet\to C_\bullet\) of complete Segal objects such that each terminal-vertex map gives a pullback square2697\[2698 \begin{array}{ccc}2699 E_n &\longrightarrow& E_0\\2700 \downarrow && \downarrow\\2701 C_n &\longrightarrow& C_0 .2702 \end{array}2703\]2704A left fibration uses the initial vertex instead. Write \(\operatorname{RFib}_{\mathcal B}(C)\) and \(\operatorname{LFib}_{\mathcal B}(C)\) for the respective full subcategories over \(C\).2705\end{definition}2706 2707For a generalized edge \(f:x\to y\) with parameters in \(T\), the right-fibration square in degree one identifies a lift ending at an element of \(E_y\) with that element. Taking the source of such lifts defines a map \(f^*:E_y\to E_x\) in \(\mathcal B_{/T}\). In degree two, lifting the two-simplex ending at \(z\) identifies \((gf)^*\) with \(f^*g^*\) on the fiber over \(z\). Higher terminal-vertex squares provide the compatible homotopies for longer strings. A left fibration instead gives an operation \(f_!:E_x\to E_y\). The object \(E_\bullet\) stores the transport as a coherent system, even when no levelwise representatives of its homotopies have been chosen.2708 2709There is a large internal universe \(\Omega_{\mathcal B}\) of objects in slices of \(\mathcal B\), taking \(T\) to \(\mathcal B_{/T}\) with reindexing by pullback, in a suitable enlargement of universes. The internal Grothendieck construction identifies the internal category of small right fibrations with the internal functor category from \(C^{\mathrm{op}}\) to \(\Omega_{\mathcal B}\). The left-fibration version is obtained by taking the opposites of the total category and the base. This theorem and internal Yoneda are developed in \cite[\S\S4.5--4.7]{martini}. For a contextual point \(c:T\to C_0\), the representable right fibration is the slice \(C_{/c}\to C|_T\), formed in \(\mathcal B_{/T}\). The Yoneda comparison evaluates a map of right fibrations on the identity of \(c\). The lift of an arrow into \(c\) then recovers its value by pullback transport. Coherence makes this a universal description of the mapping object, including in families over \(T\).2710 2711Externally the constructions specialize to straightening in spaces,2712\[2713 \operatorname{RFib}_{\mathcal S}(C)\simeq2714 \operatorname{Fun}(C^{\mathrm{op}},\mathcal S),\qquad2715 \operatorname{LFib}_{\mathcal S}(C)\simeq2716 \operatorname{Fun}(C,\mathcal S).2717\]2718We use the right-hand convention for ordinary presheaves and the second convention for covariant representations. An equivalence \(C\to D\) induces equivalent categories of either sort. In the special case of a groupoid, inversion identifies the two conventions. For a general \(C\), reversing \(C\) has mathematical content, and the relevant variance has to be part of any classification theorem \cite[\S2.2]{htt}.2719 2720\begin{proposition}[Inverting the transport]2721\label{prop:directed-localization}2722Let \(W\) be a set of arrows of a small \(\infty\)-category \(C\). Restriction along \(C\to C[W^{-1}]\) identifies2723\[2724 \operatorname{Fun}(C[W^{-1}]^{\mathrm{op}},\mathcal S)2725\]2726with the full subcategory of right fibrations on \(C\) in which transport along \(W\) is by equivalences. The corresponding statement holds for left fibrations.2727\end{proposition}2728 2729\begin{proof}2730The universal property of localization applies to \(C^{\mathrm{op}}\) and the reversals of the arrows in \(W\). It identifies its entire functor category into \(\mathcal S\) with the indicated full subcategory of \(\operatorname{Fun}(C^{\mathrm{op}},\mathcal S)\). Under straightening, sending a reversed arrow to an equivalence is precisely the transport condition. The covariant proof uses \(C\) itself.2731\end{proof}2732 2733For \(W\) consisting of all arrows, \(C[W^{-1}]\) is the groupoidification \(C^{\mathrm{gpd}}\). It represents the subtheory with invertible transport. In particular it does not generally classify all right or all left fibrations on \(C\).2734 2735\section{Two factorization systems}2736 2737The factorization developed in \cite[\S7.3]{bj} first sends a functor to its essential image, then embeds that image fully faithfully. This has a direct higher analog. For an \(\infty\)-category \(B\), write \(B^\simeq\) for its maximal subgroupoid.2738 2739\begin{proposition}2740\label{prop:ess-image-factor}2741Every functor \(f:A\to B\) factors as an essentially surjective functor followed by a fully faithful functor. These classes form an orthogonal factorization system on \(\operatorname{Cat}_\infty\).2742\end{proposition}2743 2744\begin{proof}2745Choose the full subcategory \(I\subseteq B\) on the union of the components of \(B^\simeq\) meeting \(f(A^\simeq)\). It contains the image of \(f\), every object is equivalent to one from \(A\), and inclusion is fully faithful.2746 2747For orthogonality, take an essentially surjective \(e:A\to B\) and a fully faithful \(m:X\to Y\). Replace \(X\) over \(Y\) by its full essential image using the preceding construction and full faithfulness. Given a square with \(e\) on the left and \(m\) on the right, the map \(B\to Y\) sends every object into this full subcategory since every object is equivalent to one in the image of \(A\). A full subcategory is determined by its allowed vertices and includes every simplex of \(Y\) with those vertices in a quasicategory model. The map \(B\to Y\) thus lifts. Postcomposition with a full inclusion gives a fully faithful functor \(\operatorname{Fun}(B,X)\to\operatorname{Fun}(B,Y)\). On cores the space of a lift with its prescribed identification is empty or contractible. The existence just proved, and the same full faithfulness for \(A\), show that imposing the rest of the square leaves a contractible space of lifts. Closure under retracts follows from the intrinsic definitions. Existence and orthogonality give the factorization system.2748\end{proof}2749 2750A second factorization has a different right class. Given \(f:A\to B\), let \((b\downarrow f)\) be the comma category of objects \((a,b\to f(a))\), with arrows over \(b\). Write \(|D|\) for the groupoidification of \(D\). We call \(f\) final if every \(|b\downarrow f|\) is contractible. By the higher form of Quillen's Theorem~A, this is equivalent to \(f\) preserving colimit computations by restriction \cite[\S4.1.3]{htt}. An initial functor is one whose opposite is final. Its test uses the comma categories of arrows \(f(a)\to b\).2751 2752\index{comprehensive factorization}\begin{theorem}[Comprehensive factorization]2753\label{thm:comprehensive-factor}2754There is an orthogonal factorization system on \(\operatorname{Cat}_\infty\) with left class the final functors and right class the right fibrations, taken up to equivalence of arrows. The right-fibration factor of \(f:A\to B\) is classified by the presheaf2755\[2756 L_f=\operatorname{Lan}_{f^{\mathrm{op}}}\mathbf 1_A,\qquad2757 L_f(b)\simeq |b\downarrow f|.2758\]2759Dually, the initial functors and the left fibrations form an orthogonal factorization system.2760\end{theorem}2761 2762\begin{proof}2763Here \(\mathbf 1_A\) is the terminal presheaf. The pointwise formula for left Kan extension has indexing category \((b\downarrow f)^{\mathrm{op}}\). The colimit of the constant point diagram is its groupoidification, canonically equivalent to that of the opposite category. In these terms the action of \(L_f\) is precomposition on comma categories. Let \(p:E_f\to B\) be the right fibration classified by \(L_f\). The Kan unit \(\mathbf 1_A\to (f^{\mathrm{op}})^*L_f\) corresponds to a section of \(f^*E_f\) over \(A\), giving \(j:A\to E_f\) with \(pj=f\). Under the comma description, \(j(a)\) is the point represented by \((a,\operatorname{id}_{f(a)})\).2764 2765To prove finality of \(j\), fix \(e=(b,z)\) in \(E_f\). A lift of \(\beta:b\to f(a)\) from \(e\) to \(j(a)\) is specified by a path between \(z\) and the transported point \(L_f(\beta)(j(a))\) in \(L_f(b)\). This description is natural in \((a,\beta)\), since an arrow of this comma category supplies a homotopy relating the two transported points. Consequently \((e\downarrow j)\) is classified over \((b\downarrow f)\) by the family of path spaces \(\operatorname{Map}_{L_f(b)}(z,\lambda(a,\beta))\), where \(\lambda:(b\downarrow f)\to |b\downarrow f|\) is the localization map. This family sends every arrow to an equivalence. Its total groupoidification is the colimit of the family in spaces by straightening and the universal property of a colimit. Universality of colimits in spaces computes this colimit by pulling the colimit of the points \(\lambda(a,\beta)\) in \(\mathcal S_{/L_f(b)}\) back along \(z\). That colimit is \(\operatorname{id}_{L_f(b)}\), so the pullback is contractible. This is the comma criterion for \(j\).2766 2767For orthogonality, pull a right fibration back along the bottom map \(B\to C\) of a square and let the resulting fibration over \(B\) correspond to \(F\). A top map lifting a given arrow \(e:A\to B\) gives a section over \(A\), equivalently an element of \(\operatorname{Map}(\mathbf 1_A,(e^{\mathrm{op}})^*F)\). The space of fillers is the fiber of the restriction map from \(\operatorname{Map}(\mathbf 1_B,F)\) over this element. The left Kan extension adjunction identifies restriction with precomposition by \(L_e\to\mathbf 1_B\). This arrow is an equivalence when \(e\) is final, so the fiber is contractible. Finally final functors and right fibrations are each closed under retracts. For the right class this follows directly from the defining pullback condition, or from its lifting tests against terminal-vertex inclusions. Thus the factorizations and mutual orthogonality identify both classes. Taking opposites proves the dual assertion.2768\end{proof}2769 2770The distinction between the two factorizations is visible on a category with indefinitely composable arrows. Take \(\mathbb Z\) with its usual order, viewed as an \(\infty\)-category. The inclusion of the even integers is final since the even integers above each given \(b\) form a poset with a least element. It is fully faithful and fails essential surjectivity. Conversely \(\mathbb Z_{\mathrm{disc}}\to\mathbb Z\) is essentially surjective, whereas \((b\downarrow f)\) is a discrete infinite ray for this \(f\) and has noncontractible groupoidification. Even a groupoidification equivalence need not be final. The inclusion of \(0\) in \(\mathbb Z\) induces an equivalence on groupoidifications because \(\mathbb Z\) is filtered and nonempty, yet \((1\downarrow f)\) is empty.2771 2772The internal versions of the comprehensive factorization and of the comma criterion are established in \cite[\S4.4]{martini}. The tests there use every context \(T\) and take groupoidification internally. Applying the preceding external criterion only to global points of \(B\) would not give that result.2773 2774\section{Descent along an augmented diagram}2775 2776The precategories of \cite[\S\S7.1--7.5]{bj} are diagrams retaining a small amount of categorical incidence data, before enforcing the Segal pullback conditions. Their coefficient presheaves are formed by a two-dimensional limit. The corresponding higher construction can start from an arbitrary indexing \(\infty\)-category. This preserves the distinction the original book makes between a limit of change-of-base categories and the category of ordinary directed presheaves on an internal category.2777 2778Let \(I\) be small, let \(D:I^\triangleright\to\mathcal A\) be an augmented diagram with cone point \(a\), and let \(F,G:\mathcal A^{\mathrm{op}}\to\operatorname{Cat}_\infty\) be contravariant coefficient systems. The natural transformations between them are homotopy coherent. We call the augmentation effective for \(G\) when the canonical comparison2779\[2780 G(a)\longrightarrow \operatorname*{lim}_{i\in I^{\mathrm{op}}}G(D_i)2781\]2782is an equivalence. An object of the limit includes objects in the coefficient categories and equivalences relating every pullback of them, together with higher coherences. The maps between the objects of a compatible family are likewise compared in the entire mapping spaces.2783 2784\index{relative splitting}\begin{theorem}[Relative splitting along a diagram]2785\label{thm:relative-indexed-split}2786Suppose \(F\to G\) is pointwise fully faithful, the augmentation \(D\) is effective for \(G\), and there is an object \(i_0\) such that every \(i\) admits an arrow \(i\to i_0\) in \(I\). The choices of those arrows are immaterial. Let \(\operatorname{Split}_F(D)\subseteq G(a)\) consist of those \(x\) whose restriction to \(D_{i_0}\) belongs to the essential image of \(F(D_{i_0})\). Then comparison induces an equivalence2787\[2788 \operatorname{Split}_F(D)\simeq2789 \operatorname*{lim}_{i\in I^{\mathrm{op}}} F(D_i).2790\]