Indexed text attachment
galois-theory-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Galois Theory in Higher Categories
View paper · Download original file
Lines 2611–2710 of 4071. Source text is displayed literally.
2611 2612\begin{example}[An extension with a higher obstruction class]2613In spaces take $G=\Omega S^3$ and $A=K(\mathbb Z,1)$. Let $c\colon S^3\to B^2A=K(\mathbb Z,3)$ represent the integral generator. The map on $\pi_3$ induced by $c$ is an isomorphism, so the boundary $\pi_3(S^3)\to\pi_2(BA)$ in the fiber sequence $BA\to P\to S^3$ is an isomorphism. This gives $\pi_2(P)=0$. For the zero class the total object is $BA\times S^3$ and has $\pi_2\cong\mathbb Z$. Both looped extensions have trivial component groups. The principal class distinguishes them and is detected by higher homotopy.2614\end{example}2615 2616Normalization of the band is essential to the comparison with abelianization. For ordinary central group extensions the conjugation action on $A$ is trivial, with no higher choices of coherence. In the higher case it is possible to ask for a neutralizable coefficient system, a chosen null homotopy of an action, or a specified principal $BA$-bundle. Definition~\ref{def:framed-higher-central} chooses the principal-bundle condition. The classifying theorem concerns that structure and its morphisms.2617 2618\section{Abelianization after passing to group objects in spaces}2619 2620Two extensions of the abelianization functor illustrate why the band construction has an independent role. The first applies ordinary abelianization to $\pi_0$. The second uses the left adjoint to the forgetful functor from infinite loop spaces to group objects in spaces. The first is a reflection onto a discrete subcategory. The second has a counit that can change the positive homotopy groups of a connective spectrum.2621 2622\index{abelianization!discrete reflection}2623\begin{proposition}[A discrete reflection on higher group objects]2624The functor from group objects in spaces to ordinary abelian groups given by $G\mapsto(\pi_0G)_{\mathrm{ab}}$ is an admissible reflection when the allowed maps are surjective on $\pi_0$ in the source and surjective in the target. A map split for this structure by an allowed effective descent map has $0$-truncated fibers.2625\end{proposition}2626 2627\begin{proof}2628Maps into a discrete abelian group factor through $\pi_0$ and abelianization by the two respective universal properties. This proves the reflection assertion. Given an allowed abelian group surjection $D\to(\pi_0G)_{\mathrm{ab}}$, the underlying space of the slice right adjoint is the pullback $G\times_{(\pi_0G)_{\mathrm{ab}}}D$. Since its base is discrete, its component set is $\pi_0G\times_{(\pi_0G)_{\mathrm{ab}}}D$. Lemma~\ref{lem:abelianization-admissible} then computes the counit. Closure of the allowed maps under pullback follows from stability of effective epimorphisms of spaces. Surjectivity of the projection to $G$ follows from the same stability. The sliced adjunction is admissible.2629 2630Every trivial map is a pullback from a map of discrete abelian groups, so has discrete fibers. If an allowed map becomes trivial along a descent map $U\to G$, the underlying map of spaces $U\to G$ is an effective epimorphism since it is surjective on components. Truncation of fibers descends along such a map by Chapter~\ref{ch:reflections}.2631\end{proof}2632 2633In fact, in this structure each allowed base change map is effective for the restricted \v{C}ech comparison. In the functor $\infty$-topos of simplicial spaces, the map of group nerves associated to $U\to G$ is an effective epimorphism. This holds pointwise because the map in simplicial degree $r$ is $U^r\to G^r$. Descent in that functor category provides a simplicial object over the group nerve of $G$. The degree-zero condition is unchanged under pullback since both group nerves have terminal object in degree zero. The Segal comparisons over $G^r$ and the invertibility comparison over $G^2$ become equivalences when pulled back along the effective epimorphisms $U^r\to G^r$ and $U^2\to G^2$, respectively. Here the invertibility comparison is the shear $(d_2,d_1)$, transported along the shear equivalence for the base group nerve. They are therefore equivalences prior to pullback. The descended object is a group nerve, and the required surjectivity on $\pi_0$ in degree one is detected after base change. The whole comparison is an equivalence on the selected full subcategories, with all spaces of morphisms.2634 2635Consequently a higher principal extension with a nondiscrete kernel, such as the preceding example, may have no interpretation as a covering for this discrete Galois structure. Its fibers already prevent that comparison. The discrete reflection retains the ordinary group case proved above and provides one admissible choice when the intended fibers have no higher homotopy.2636 2637\index{abelianization!infinite-loop}2638\begin{proposition}[Infinite-loop abelianization in spaces]2639Write $U$ for the forgetful functor from commutative group objects to group objects in spaces. Under the equivalence between commutative group objects and connective spectra, a left adjoint to $U$ is2640\[2641 F(G)=\Sigma^{-1}\Sigma^\infty BG.2642\]2643Here $\Sigma^\infty$ is reduced suspension spectrum. The zeroth homotopy group of $F(G)$ is $(\pi_0G)_{\mathrm{ab}}$. The counit is noninvertible at $H(\mathbb Z^2)$, so full faithfulness fails for $U$.2644\end{proposition}2645 2646\begin{proof}2647Under infinite-loop recognition, a connective spectrum $V$ gives the infinite loop space $\Omega^\infty V$, with delooping $\Omega^\infty\Sigma V$ \cite[Remark~5.2.6.26]{ha}. For pointed connected $BG$, the adjunction between reduced suspension spectrum and infinite loop space gives2648\[2649 \begin{split}2650 \operatorname{Map}_{\operatorname{Grp}(\SSet)}(G,U(V))2651 &\simeq \operatorname{Map}_{\SSet_*}(BG,\Omega^\infty\Sigma V)\\2652 &\simeq \operatorname{Map}_{\operatorname{Sp}}(\Sigma^\infty BG,\Sigma V)\\2653 &\simeq \operatorname{Map}_{\operatorname{Sp}}(\Sigma^{-1}\Sigma^\infty BG,V).2654 \end{split}2655\]2656The spectrum in the last source is connective because $BG$ is connected. Its zeroth homotopy group is the degree-one stable homotopy group of $BG$, and stable Hurewicz identifies this with $H_1(BG;\mathbb Z)\cong(\pi_0G)_{\mathrm{ab}}$.2657 2658For a counterexample to full faithfulness, use the connective Eilenberg--Mac Lane spectrum $H(\mathbb Z^2)$. Its underlying group object is discrete $\mathbb Z^2$, with delooping $S^1\times S^1$. There is a stable splitting2659\[2660 \Sigma^\infty(S^1\times S^1)2661 \simeq \Sigma^\infty S^1\oplus\Sigma^\infty S^1\oplus\Sigma^\infty S^2.2662\]2663Indeed the stable cofiber of the wedge inclusion is the suspension spectrum of the smash product, and the two projections split the wedge inclusion in spectra. Thus $F(U(H(\mathbb Z^2)))$ has a sphere spectrum suspended once as a summand. It has nonzero first homotopy group, while $H(\mathbb Z^2)$ has zero first homotopy group. The counit cannot be an equivalence, contrary to what full faithfulness would imply.2664\end{proof}2665 2666The two constructions agree on the zeroth homotopy group and differ even when the input is discrete and already abelian. The higher band theorem uses delooping and effective groupoid descent directly, so its classifying space requires neither an admissible infinite-loop reflection nor a presentation by fiberwise discrete data.2667 2668% End chapters/08-central.tex2669\part{Directed Galois theories}2670% Begin chapters/09-directed.tex2671\chapter{Directed symmetries and generalized descent}2672\label{ch:directed}2673 2674A passage from a splitting object to its groupoid of changes of trivialization discards no information when all transports are invertible. There are also settings where a comparison has an intrinsic direction. A specialization of points can induce a map of fibers which is far from an equivalence. The directed analog of a Galois action is then a functor on a category with genuine noninvertible morphisms. This chapter distinguishes that construction from the generalized descent on precategories in \cite[Chapter~7]{bj}, and gives a higher form of both constructions.2675 2676\section{Complete Segal objects and groupoid objects}\index{complete Segal object}2677 2678Let \(\mathcal B\) be an \(\infty\)-topos. A simplicial object \(C_\bullet\) in \(\mathcal B\) is a Segal object if the canonical map2679\[2680 C_n\longrightarrow C_1\times_{C_0}C_12681 \times_{C_0}\cdots\times_{C_0}C_12682\]2683is an equivalence for \(n\geq 2\). The maps in each pullback are the target and the source of successive arrows. Here \(d_1\) is the source and \(d_0\) the target. The simplicial identities give identity and composition laws with all their coherences. In particular choosing a representative composition at degree two gives a contractible space of choices, and degree three provides the associativity homotopy for the compatible choices.2684 2685There is an object \(C_1^{\mathrm{eq}}\) of equivalences. A generalized arrow over \(T\in\mathcal B\) belongs to this subobject when it is invertible in the category encoded by the Segal space \(\operatorname{Map}_{\mathcal B}(T,C_\bullet)\). Equivalence is an intrinsic property of an arrow. The object can be built by taking the object of coherent inverse data for the walking isomorphism. The space of choices of coherent inverses to an equivalence is contractible. Completeness means that the degeneracy map specifying identities induces an equivalence \(C_0\simeq C_1^{\mathrm{eq}}\). In contexts \(T\) this says that equivalences of objects are modeled by paths in the object space. Complete Segal objects are one model of small \(\infty\)-categories internal to \(\mathcal B\) \cite{martini}.2686 2687\begin{remark}2688An internal groupoid object can have different object and arrow objects, as happens for a nontrivial \Cech{} nerve. Such a groupoid object is a Segal object with all arrows invertible. It usually fails completeness in the complete Segal sense above. A complete Segal object with all arrows invertible is equivalent to a constant simplicial object. An effective groupoid object in an \(\infty\)-topos is a presentation of its quotient, while a constant simplicial object on the quotient is already complete.2689\end{remark}2690 2691Working contextually is important. Global elements of objects of an \(\infty\)-topos need not detect equivalences. For example, a statement about fibers over all \(c:T\to C_0\) can be tested at the generic point \(c=\operatorname{id}_{C_0}\) in context \(C_0\). A statement about fibers over all \(1\to C_0\) can hold vacuously while the assertion over \(C_0\) fails. The recovery of internal constructions from their underlying global categories requires its own hypotheses.2692 2693\section{Coherent presheaves and direction}\index{right fibration}\index{left fibration}2694 2695\begin{definition}2696A right fibration over an internal category \(C_\bullet\) is a map \(q:E_\bullet\to C_\bullet\) of complete Segal objects such that each terminal-vertex map gives a pullback square2697\[2698 \begin{array}{ccc}2699 E_n &\longrightarrow& E_0\\2700 \downarrow && \downarrow\\2701 C_n &\longrightarrow& C_0 .2702 \end{array}2703\]2704A left fibration uses the initial vertex instead. Write \(\operatorname{RFib}_{\mathcal B}(C)\) and \(\operatorname{LFib}_{\mathcal B}(C)\) for the respective full subcategories over \(C\).2705\end{definition}2706 2707For a generalized edge \(f:x\to y\) with parameters in \(T\), the right-fibration square in degree one identifies a lift ending at an element of \(E_y\) with that element. Taking the source of such lifts defines a map \(f^*:E_y\to E_x\) in \(\mathcal B_{/T}\). In degree two, lifting the two-simplex ending at \(z\) identifies \((gf)^*\) with \(f^*g^*\) on the fiber over \(z\). Higher terminal-vertex squares provide the compatible homotopies for longer strings. A left fibration instead gives an operation \(f_!:E_x\to E_y\). The object \(E_\bullet\) stores the transport as a coherent system, even when no levelwise representatives of its homotopies have been chosen.2708 2709There is a large internal universe \(\Omega_{\mathcal B}\) of objects in slices of \(\mathcal B\), taking \(T\) to \(\mathcal B_{/T}\) with reindexing by pullback, in a suitable enlargement of universes. The internal Grothendieck construction identifies the internal category of small right fibrations with the internal functor category from \(C^{\mathrm{op}}\) to \(\Omega_{\mathcal B}\). The left-fibration version is obtained by taking the opposites of the total category and the base. This theorem and internal Yoneda are developed in \cite[\S\S4.5--4.7]{martini}. For a contextual point \(c:T\to C_0\), the representable right fibration is the slice \(C_{/c}\to C|_T\), formed in \(\mathcal B_{/T}\). The Yoneda comparison evaluates a map of right fibrations on the identity of \(c\). The lift of an arrow into \(c\) then recovers its value by pullback transport. Coherence makes this a universal description of the mapping object, including in families over \(T\).2710