Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

galois-theory-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Galois Theory in Higher Categories

View paper · Download original file

Lines 2481–2580 of 4071. Source text is displayed literally.

2481Categorical centrality in the ordinary group calculation arises by splitting for abelianization. A higher central extension also has an interpretation as a principal bundle over a delooping, where its band keeps track of all the homotopy of the kernel. The constructions are compatible for discrete groups. To compare them in higher degrees, it is useful to prove the ordinary result first and to keep the higher notion of a band explicit.2482 2483\section{The ordinary abelianization comparison}\index{abelianization!ordinary}2484 2485Use $E_{\mathrm{ab}}=E/[E,E]$ and write $a_E\colon E\to E_{\mathrm{ab}}$. For groups, admit surjections in both the source and target of the abelianization reflection. Its slice right adjoint over $G$ takes a surjection $D\to G_{\mathrm{ab}}$ of abelian groups to $G\times_{G_{\mathrm{ab}}}D\to G$. The following computation works for this class and makes the admissibility criterion concrete.2486 2487\begin{lemma}[Abelianization over a discrete base]2488\label{lem:abelianization-admissible}2489Let $P=G\times_{G_{\mathrm{ab}}}D$, with $D\to G_{\mathrm{ab}}$ surjective and $D$ abelian. Then2490\[2491 [P,P]=[G,G]\times\{1\}\qquad\text{and}\qquad P_{\mathrm{ab}}\cong D.2492\]2493In particular, abelianization is admissible on these surjective slices.2494\end{lemma}2495 2496\begin{proof}2497The two projections from $P$ are surjective. Every commutator in $P$ has second coordinate $1$ since $D$ is abelian. Conversely, given $x,y\in G$, choose lifts $(x,d),(y,d')\in P$. Their commutator is $([x,y],1)$. Since such commutators generate $[G,G]$, this proves the first equality. The second projection has kernel $[G,G]\times\{1\}$ and is surjective, yielding the second assertion. This identifies the slice counit with an isomorphism.2498\end{proof}2499 2500Every surjection of ordinary groups is an effective descent map for surjective arrows. One can see this directly by viewing a group as a reduced simplicial set satisfying the Segal conditions and the invertibility condition. A surjection $U\to G$ induces a pointwise surjection between their group nerves, since the map in degree $r$ is $U^r\to G^r$. Ordinary effective descent for a surjection of sets comes from forming equivalence classes under its compatible gluing relation. Applied degree by degree, this gives descent for diagrams of sets, hence a descended simplicial set over the nerve of $G$. The Segal comparisons are maps over the products $G^r$. Their pullbacks to $U^r$ are isomorphisms, so they are isomorphisms. The same argument shows that the shear comparison $(d_2,d_1)$ in degree two is an isomorphism, which recovers invertibility in the descended monoid. Surjectivity in degree one is also detected after pullback. Thus the descended object is an allowed group surjection, with morphisms descending by the same degreewise argument.2501 2502\begin{theorem}[Trivial, split, and central group extensions]2503\label{thm:ordinary-central}2504For a group surjection $e\colon E\to G$ with kernel $K$, the following statements hold.2505\begin{enumerate}2506\item The surjection is trivial for abelianization exactly when $K\cap[E,E]=1$.2507\item The surjection is split by some surjection exactly when $K$ is central in $E$.2508\item A central surjection is split by itself and thus is normal for this Galois structure.2509\end{enumerate}2510The reflection of $e$ into central extensions over $G$ is the quotient $E/[K,E]\to G$.2511\end{theorem}2512 2513\begin{proof}2514Consider the unit comparison2515\[2516 \phi\colon E\longrightarrow G\times_{G_{\mathrm{ab}}}E_{\mathrm{ab}}.2517\]2518It is surjective. To lift $(g,u)$, first choose $x$ lifting $g$. The difference between $u$ and $a_E(x)$ lies in the kernel of $E_{\mathrm{ab}}\to G_{\mathrm{ab}}$. This kernel is the image of $K$ because the surjection $[E,E]\to[G,G]$ allows any representative mapping to $[G,G]$ to be corrected to an element of $K$ without changing its abelianized class. Multiplying $x$ by a lift of the difference in $K$ gives the desired lift. The kernel of $\phi$ is visibly $K\cap[E,E]$. This proves the first statement. It also implies that any trivial extension is central, since $[K,E]\subseteq K\cap[E,E]$ by normality of the kernel.2519 2520Suppose $p\colon U\to G$ splits $e$. The kernel of $U\times_GE\to U$ is canonically $K$ and is central in $U\times_GE$ by the first statement. The second projection $U\times_GE\to E$ is surjective, so each $y\in E$ is the image of an element commuting with every element of the lifted $K$. Therefore $K$ is central in $E$.2521 2522Conversely, centrality makes the map2523\[2524 E\times K\longrightarrow E\times_GE,\qquad2525 (x,k)\longmapsto(x,xk)2526\]2527a group isomorphism over $E$. The projection $E\times K\to E$ is trivial by the first statement, since $K$ is abelian and $[E\times K,E\times K]=[E,E]\times\{1\}$. Hence $e$ is split by itself.2528 2529Finally, $[K,E]$ is a normal subgroup of $E$ contained in $K$. In the quotient by this subgroup the image of $K$ commutes with the image of $E$. Every map from $e$ to a central extension over $G$ kills each commutator $[k,x]$, since $k$ maps into the central kernel of the target. It therefore factors uniquely through this quotient. This proves the universal property.2530\end{proof}2531 2532This gives the ordinary relative comparison and its algebraic content \cite[Section~5.2]{bj}. A general treatment of categorical centrality for admissible reflections appears in \cite{jkcentral}. The split object in the sense of Chapter~\ref{ch:reflections} is an extension that becomes trivial after a chosen change of base. An ordinary group splitting by a section is a separate property. For instance, a central extension that has a group-homomorphic section is isomorphic over its base to a direct product with its kernel, whereas the classification below also includes nonsplit group extensions.2533 2534\section{Higher central extensions as pointed principal bundles}2535 2536Work in an $\infty$-topos $\mathcal X$. Write $BG$ for the delooping of a group object $G$. The group object and pointed connected object descriptions are equivalent via $B$ and $\Omega$ \cite[Section~6.1]{htt}. If $A$ is a commutative group object, $BA$ itself has a commutative group structure, so its delooping $B^2A$ is defined. One way to construct this structure is to apply the bar construction to the grouplike commutative monoid structure on $A$. Realization preserves the finite products in the bar diagram, so the commutative structure survives and its underlying monoid is grouplike because it is connected.2537 2538\index{central extension!framed}\index{band}2539\begin{definition}[Framed central extension]2540\label{def:framed-higher-central}2541Fix a group object $G$ and a commutative group object $A$. A framed central extension of $G$ by $A$ is a principal $BA$-bundle $P\to BG$ with a point over the basepoint of $BG$. Equivalences preserve the principal structure and the chosen point, including their coherences. The associated group extension is $A\to\Omega P\to G$.2542\end{definition}2543 2544The choice of a principal action is the band in this definition. The basepoint trivialization identifies the fiber over the basepoint with $BA$ using that action. Taking loops then identifies the kernel with $A$. The structure is thus a higher analogue of prescribing an abelian coefficient group and keeping its identification with the central kernel fixed.2545 2546\begin{theorem}[Classifying space of framed extensions]2547\label{thm:higher-central-classification}2548The space of framed central extensions of $G$ by $A$ is2549\[2550 \operatorname{Map}_{\mathcal X_*}(BG,B^2A).2551\]2552For the extension specified by $c\colon BG\to B^2A$, there is a pointed fiber sequence2553\[2554 BA\longrightarrow \operatorname{hofib}(c)\longrightarrow BG2555     \xrightarrow{c} B^2A.2556\]2557Its associated group map has $\pi_0$-surjective augmentation $\pi_0\Omega\operatorname{hofib}(c)\to\pi_0G$, and the image of $\pi_0 A$ is central in $\pi_0\Omega\operatorname{hofib}(c)$.2558\end{theorem}2559 2560\begin{proof}2561The universal principal $BA$-bundle is $1\to B^2A$. Its \v{C}ech nerve is the bar construction of $BA$. Pullback classifies principal bundles, with mapping spaces, by the principal-bundle comparison, applied to $BA$ \cite{nss}. At the basepoint of $BG$ a lift to the pullback of the universal bundle is exactly a specified identification between the classifying map at that basepoint and the basepoint of $B^2A$. This gives the asserted equivalence of spaces and the fiber sequence.2562 2563The fibers of $P\to BG$ are locally $BA$, which is connected. Relative connectedness can be checked after an effective epimorphism by relative truncation and effective descent. Consequently $P\to BG$ is $0$-connected and $P$ is connected, since $BG$ is connected. Taking loops preserves the pointed pullback describing the fiber and gives the group kernel $A$. The long exact homotopy sequence, or its internal sheaf form, gives the asserted surjectivity because $BA$ has terminal $\pi_0$.2564 2565To see centrality, loop the principal action $BA\times P\to P$ and use preservation of products by loops. The resulting map $A\times\Omega P\to\Omega P$ is a morphism of group objects and its restrictions to the two factors are the kernel inclusion and the identity. The images of those factors commute on $\pi_0$, since the source is a product of groups there. The principal action records a choice of coherence beyond this equality on components.2566\end{proof}2567 2568For a general higher group $G$, the kernel of $\pi_0 A\to\pi_0\Omega P$ is the image of the connecting homomorphism $\pi_1G\to\pi_0 A$. The homotopy fiber assertion incorporates this correction to the component-level group sequence.2569 2570\begin{proposition}[Recognition from a coherent action]2571Let $p\colon E\to G$ be a map of group objects surjective on the sheaves of components. Suppose a coherent action of $A$ on $E$ over $G$ is supplied, with the simplicial action diagram $A^\bullet\times E$ formed in group objects and with $A$ carrying its specified commutative group structure. If the action shear $A\times E\to E\times_GE$ is an equivalence, the resulting pointed group extension has a framed central structure.2572\end{proposition}2573 2574\begin{proof}2575Deloop each term of the action diagram. The equivalence between group objects and pointed connected objects preserves products, so the resulting simplicial action diagram is $BA^\bullet\times BE$. The map $BE\to BG$ is $0$-connected, since the long exact sequence and surjectivity of $\pi_0p$ give connected homotopy fibers at the basepoint, and the basepoint $1\to BG$ is an effective epimorphism. In particular $BE\times_{BG}BE$ is connected. The delooped shear $BA\times BE\to BE\times_{BG}BE$ is therefore a map between pointed connected objects. Its loop comparison is the given equivalence, so it is an equivalence as well. This proves that $BE\to BG$ is a principal $BA$-bundle, with the frame given by the basepoint of $BE$.2576\end{proof}2577 2578\begin{corollary}[Ordinary central extensions and their automorphisms]2579For ordinary groups $G$ and ordinary abelian groups $A$ regarded as discrete objects of $\SSet$, framed extensions give exactly the ordinary central extensions of $G$ with kernel identified with $A$. Their isomorphism classes are $H^2(G;A)$ for the trivial action, and the automorphism group of an extension with kernel and quotient fixed is $H^1(G;A)$.2580\end{corollary}