Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

galois-theory-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Galois Theory in Higher Categories

View paper · Download original file

Lines 2411–2510 of 4071. Source text is displayed literally.

2411\]2412The factorizations are functorial and $\mathcal W$ is stable under pullback along $\mathcal M$.2413\end{theorem}2414 2415\begin{proof}2416The right arrow is $R_B(L_Bf)$. Admissibility makes its $L$-image the arrow $LA\to LB$ up to equivalence, with counit inverse to the image of the left arrow by the triangle identity. Hence the left arrow lies in $\mathcal W$. To see orthogonality, take a lifting problem against $X=Y\times_{LY}LX\to Y$. For a fixed bottom arrow $B\to Y$, lifts amount to compatible maps $B\to LX$ over $LY$. For $a\in\mathcal W$, restriction along $a$ is an equivalence on maps into either of the local objects $LX,LY$. It is therefore an equivalence on their homotopy fibers over the prescribed composite to $LY$, proving orthogonality. The class $\mathcal W$ is closed under retracts, and so is $\mathcal M$, since the natural comparison from an object to its slice reflection carries retract diagrams to retract diagrams. The usual orthogonality-retract argument now identifies each class with the full orthogonal of the other. Functoriality follows from the units and pullback universal properties.2417 2418For the stability statement let $m\colon C\to B$ be trivial and $a\colon A\to B$ inverted. Write $C\simeq B\times_{LB}D$ for $D\in\mathcal D_{/LB}$. Then $A\times_BC\simeq A\times_{LA}(LA\times_{LB}D)$. Applying admissibility at $A$ and $B$ gives the comparison $LA\times_{LB}D\to D$ under $L$, an equivalence.2419\end{proof}2420 2421\index{stable units}Stable units mean that $L$ preserves pullbacks over every local object in the ambient category, including pullbacks in which neither of the objects over that base is local. This implies admissibility by the practical criterion. Left exactness requires finite-limit preservation over arbitrary bases and is stronger. If $L$ is left exact, $\mathcal W$ is stable under arbitrary pullback. Conversely, if $\mathcal C$ has finite limits and $\mathcal W$ is pullback stable, $L$ is left exact. Indeed the reflection fixes the terminal object, since it is local. For a pullback $A\times_BC$, the map to $A\times_{LB}C$ is a pullback of the diagonal of $B\to LB$. That diagonal lies in $\mathcal W$ by pullback stability and two-out-of-three, since either projection $B\times_{LB}B\to B$ lies in $\mathcal W$ and the composite with the diagonal is the identity. The map2422\[2423 A\times_{LB}C\longrightarrow LA\times_{LB}LC2424\]2425is the composite of pullbacks of the two units, so is also in $\mathcal W$. The final object is local, since the right adjoint preserves limits. This proves preservation of pullbacks.2426 2427\begin{corollary}[Left-exact localizations]2428Let $L\colon\mathcal X\to\mathcal Y$ be an accessible left-exact localization of an $\infty$-topos, and allow all arrows. For any effective epimorphism $p\colon U\to B$, a map over $B$ is split by $p$ if and only if it is already trivial.2429\end{corollary}2430 2431\begin{proof}2432The localized category $\mathcal Y$ is an $\infty$-topos. Left exactness identifies $L(U_\bullet)$ with the \v{C}ech nerve of $Lp$. Since $L$ is a left adjoint, it preserves the colimit of the original nerve, so $Lp$ is also an effective epimorphism. The right-hand side of Theorem~\ref{thm:relative-higher-galois} is therefore equivalent to $\mathcal Y_{/LB}$ by effective descent there. Under that equivalence the trivial object $R_B(D)$ corresponds to the descent datum of $D$, since the base-change formula of Proposition~\ref{prop:relative-slice-adjunction} identifies its restriction in every degree. Thus the equivalence on slices realizes the inclusion of the trivial objects into the split objects as an equivalence.2433\end{proof}2434 2435\index{truncation!relative}\index{modality!truncation}2436\begin{definition}[Relative truncation]2437For $n\geq -1$ and an $\infty$-topos $\mathcal X$, the relative $n$-truncation of $f\colon A\to B$ is the reflection of $A$ into the full subcategory of $n$-truncated objects in $\mathcal X_{/B}$. Write its total object as $\tau_{\leq n}^{B}A$. A map is $n$-connected if its relative $n$-truncation is terminal in its target slice.2438\end{definition}2439 2440The pair of $n$-connected and $n$-truncated maps is an orthogonal factorization system in an $\infty$-topos, with both classes stable under pullback \cite[Sections~5.5.6 and~6.5.1]{htt}. A lifting problem with an $n$-truncated right arrow over $B$ depends only on the relative $n$-truncation of the left arrow by the slice universal property. For $A\to B$, the first map in the relative truncation factorization is $n$-connected, and the second is $n$-truncated. The factorization and lifting conditions are often called the truncation modality \cite{modalities}. The indexing here pairs $n$-connected maps with $n$-truncated maps, and an effective epimorphism is $(-1)$-connected.2441 2442Global $n$-truncation, with codomain the $n$-truncated objects, has stable units. Indeed, given $A\to D\leftarrow C$ with $D$ $n$-truncated, factor the comparison2443\[2444 A\times_D C\longrightarrow \tau_{\leq n} A\times_D \tau_{\leq n} C2445\]2446as two pullbacks of $n$-connected units. The target is $n$-truncated because the full subcategory of truncated objects is closed under limits, and the composite is $n$-connected. This identifies the comparison with a truncation. The reflective factorization of Theorem~\ref{thm:admissible-reflective-factorization} therefore applies. Its intermediate object2447\[2448 B\times_{\tau_{\leq n}B}\tau_{\leq n}A2449\]2450is constructed from the global truncations. Relative truncation uses $\tau_{\leq n}^{B}A$. They have different universal properties over the unreplaced $B$.2451 2452\begin{example}[Relative components of paths]2453Take $\mathcal X=\SSet$, $B=S^1$ and $A=*$ with the basepoint. The global $0$-truncations of $A$ and $B$ coincide, so the global reflective factorization has intermediate object $S^1$. The fiber of $*\to S^1$ over the basepoint is $\Omega S^1\simeq\mathbb Z$, where $\mathbb Z$ is discrete. Thus $*\to S^1$ is already $0$-truncated over $S^1$, and the relative factorization has intermediate object $*$. Since this fiber has infinitely many components, the map cannot be $0$-connected. Pullback to the basepoint also exhibits failure of pullback stability for the maps inverted by global $0$-truncation.2454\end{example}2455 2456\section{Localizing the reflective pair}2457 2458For global $n$-truncation, its trivial maps are the base changes of maps between $n$-truncated objects. Their fibers are $n$-truncated. When the base admits a cover by an $n$-truncated object, the converse holds after passing to that cover. This includes every base space for $n\geq0$, since the coproduct of basepoints of its components gives a discrete effective epimorphism.2459 2460\begin{proposition}[Local triviality and stable inversion]2461\label{prop:localizing-reflective-pair}2462Fix $n\geq-1$ in an $\infty$-topos $\mathcal X$. Every $n$-connected arrow is inverted by global $n$-truncation after arbitrary pullback. Every arrow that becomes trivial for global $n$-truncation over an effective epimorphism is $n$-truncated. Over a base admitting an effective epimorphism from an $n$-truncated object, both converses hold.2463\end{proposition}2464 2465\begin{proof}2466If $f$ is $n$-connected, its pullbacks are $n$-connected. For any such pullback $a\colon X\to Y$ and any globally $n$-truncated object $D$, the projection $Y\times D\to Y$ is an $n$-truncated arrow. Orthogonality then identifies maps $X\to D$ with maps $Y\to D$. Global truncation thus inverts $a$.2467 2468For the reverse implication over a base of the indicated kind, write $f$ as $A\xrightarrow{e}T\xrightarrow{m}B$ in the relative $n$-connected, $n$-truncated factorization. If every pullback of $f$ is inverted by global truncation, the same holds for $m$ since it holds for $e$. Pull back to an effective epimorphism $U\to B$ with $U$ $n$-truncated. The pullback of $m$ has $n$-truncated domain and codomain, so inversion by global truncation makes it an equivalence already. Then $m$ is an equivalence by effective descent, proving $f$ is $n$-connected.2469 2470Trivial arrows are $n$-truncated since relative truncation is stable under pullback. This property descends along effective epimorphisms by induction on the truncation of the relative diagonal, starting with descent of equivalences. Descent of equivalences is immediate from the slice comparison over the \v{C}ech nerve. Finally, if $U\to B$ is an effective epimorphism with $U$ $n$-truncated and $f$ is $n$-truncated, then $U\times_B A$ is $n$-truncated by composition with $U\to 1$. Both domain and base of the new arrow are local, so its unit square is a pullback.2471\end{proof}2472 2473\index{monotone--light factorization}Over spaces the last result gives a homotopical form of monotone--light factorization. For $n=0$, the left class consists of maps with nonempty connected homotopy fibers, and the right class consists of maps with discrete homotopy fibers. This concerns the homotopy theory of spaces. The original result concerns compact Hausdorff spaces and ordinary point inverses \cite[Section~5.8]{bj}. Those settings have different base change, and passing from a topological map to its homotopy type need not preserve its point inverse. The corresponding constructions agree in the formal operation of testing connectedness after base change and testing the right class by local splitting.2474 2475% End chapters/07-reflections.tex2476% Begin chapters/08-central.tex2477\chapter{Central extensions and higher bands}2478\label{ch:central}2479\index{central extension}2480 2481Categorical centrality in the ordinary group calculation arises by splitting for abelianization. A higher central extension also has an interpretation as a principal bundle over a delooping, where its band keeps track of all the homotopy of the kernel. The constructions are compatible for discrete groups. To compare them in higher degrees, it is useful to prove the ordinary result first and to keep the higher notion of a band explicit.2482 2483\section{The ordinary abelianization comparison}\index{abelianization!ordinary}2484 2485Use $E_{\mathrm{ab}}=E/[E,E]$ and write $a_E\colon E\to E_{\mathrm{ab}}$. For groups, admit surjections in both the source and target of the abelianization reflection. Its slice right adjoint over $G$ takes a surjection $D\to G_{\mathrm{ab}}$ of abelian groups to $G\times_{G_{\mathrm{ab}}}D\to G$. The following computation works for this class and makes the admissibility criterion concrete.2486 2487\begin{lemma}[Abelianization over a discrete base]2488\label{lem:abelianization-admissible}2489Let $P=G\times_{G_{\mathrm{ab}}}D$, with $D\to G_{\mathrm{ab}}$ surjective and $D$ abelian. Then2490\[2491 [P,P]=[G,G]\times\{1\}\qquad\text{and}\qquad P_{\mathrm{ab}}\cong D.2492\]2493In particular, abelianization is admissible on these surjective slices.2494\end{lemma}2495 2496\begin{proof}2497The two projections from $P$ are surjective. Every commutator in $P$ has second coordinate $1$ since $D$ is abelian. Conversely, given $x,y\in G$, choose lifts $(x,d),(y,d')\in P$. Their commutator is $([x,y],1)$. Since such commutators generate $[G,G]$, this proves the first equality. The second projection has kernel $[G,G]\times\{1\}$ and is surjective, yielding the second assertion. This identifies the slice counit with an isomorphism.2498\end{proof}2499 2500Every surjection of ordinary groups is an effective descent map for surjective arrows. One can see this directly by viewing a group as a reduced simplicial set satisfying the Segal conditions and the invertibility condition. A surjection $U\to G$ induces a pointwise surjection between their group nerves, since the map in degree $r$ is $U^r\to G^r$. Ordinary effective descent for a surjection of sets comes from forming equivalence classes under its compatible gluing relation. Applied degree by degree, this gives descent for diagrams of sets, hence a descended simplicial set over the nerve of $G$. The Segal comparisons are maps over the products $G^r$. Their pullbacks to $U^r$ are isomorphisms, so they are isomorphisms. The same argument shows that the shear comparison $(d_2,d_1)$ in degree two is an isomorphism, which recovers invertibility in the descended monoid. Surjectivity in degree one is also detected after pullback. Thus the descended object is an allowed group surjection, with morphisms descending by the same degreewise argument.2501 2502\begin{theorem}[Trivial, split, and central group extensions]2503\label{thm:ordinary-central}2504For a group surjection $e\colon E\to G$ with kernel $K$, the following statements hold.2505\begin{enumerate}2506\item The surjection is trivial for abelianization exactly when $K\cap[E,E]=1$.2507\item The surjection is split by some surjection exactly when $K$ is central in $E$.2508\item A central surjection is split by itself and thus is normal for this Galois structure.2509\end{enumerate}2510The reflection of $e$ into central extensions over $G$ is the quotient $E/[K,E]\to G$.