Indexed text attachment
galois-theory-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Galois Theory in Higher Categories
View paper · Download original file
Lines 2331–2430 of 4071. Source text is displayed literally.
2331where the first arrow is $\eta_B$ and the other is the image of $D\to LB$. In this assertion a preserved pullback has comparison map $L(B\times_{RLB}RD)\to D$.2332\end{lemma}2333 2334\begin{proof}2335Under the counit equivalences $LRD\simeq D$ and $LRLB\simeq LB$, the image of the cospan has first arrow equivalent to the identity of $LB$ by the triangle identity. Its limit is $D$. The comparison is precisely the counit of $L_B\dashv R_B$. Invertibility of these counits for all $B,D$ is the assertion.2336\end{proof}2337 2338Admissibility can be checked with a smaller class $\mathcal F$ when the problem concerns only extensions. For instance, a reflection may be useful on slices of surjections even if its behavior on slices of all arrows has not been established. Effective descent on the selected slices requires both unrestricted descent and detection of the selected arrow condition, or a descent proof directly on the selected slices.2339 2340\section{The comparison over one descent map}2341 2342For $p\colon U\to B$ in $\mathcal E$, let $U_\bullet$ be its \v{C}ech nerve, with $U_k=U^{\times_B(k+1)}$. Use the pullback functors along its simplicial structure maps to form a cosimplicial diagram of restricted slices. Say that $p$ is an effective descent map for $\mathcal E$ if the comparison2343\[2344 \mathcal C_{\mathcal E/B}\longrightarrow2345 \lim_{[k]\in\Delta}\mathcal C_{\mathcal E/U_k}2346\]2347is an equivalence. When every map is allowed and $\mathcal C$ is an $\infty$-topos, every effective epimorphism satisfies this condition by the van Kampen property of its \v{C}ech realization \cite[Section~6.1]{htt}. More generally, if unrestricted descent holds and membership in $\mathcal E$ is detected after pullback along $p$, restricting the equivalence gives the indicated condition.2348 2349\begin{theorem}[Relative higher Galois comparison]2350\label{thm:relative-higher-galois}2351In an admissible structure, let $p\colon U\to B$ be an effective descent map for $\mathcal E$. The full subcategory $\operatorname{Split}(p)$ of maps split by $p$ satisfies2352\[2353 \operatorname{Split}(p)\simeq2354 \lim_{[k]\in\Delta}\mathcal D_{\mathcal F/LU_k}.2355\]2356The diagram on the right is formed with pullbacks along maps of $L(U_\bullet)$.2357\end{theorem}2358 2359\begin{proof}2360Restrict the unrestricted comparison for the selected slices to the full subcategories $\operatorname{Triv}(U_k)$. A point of the limit of the slices is a coherent family whose object in any degree $k$ is equivalent to the pullback of the degree-zero object along any vertex. Consequently, if its object in degree zero is trivial, all its objects are trivial. Conversely a family consisting of trivial objects has a trivial degree-zero object. Limits of diagrams of full subcategories are full in the limit of the ambient diagrams. These observations give the full essential image of $\operatorname{Split}(p)$ and preserve its mapping spaces. Finally the equivalences $R_{U_k}\colon\mathcal D_{\mathcal F/LU_k}\simeq\operatorname{Triv}(U_k)$ respect restriction by Proposition~\ref{prop:relative-slice-adjunction}. Taking their limit gives the result.2361\end{proof}2362 2363At degree one the family has an equivalence between two pullbacks of a single object over $LU$. At degree two it gives a specified homotopy between composite gluing and direct gluing. The comparison retains the higher data as well. An ordinary category of strict descent isomorphisms is sufficient in a nerve of an ordinary category, where the mapping spaces are discrete. In that case the degree-two relation is an equality and determines all the higher compatibility for an object. In categories with nondiscrete mapping spaces the totalization is intrinsic to the assertion.2364 2365There are two distinct possible simplifications of this comparison. If $L$ preserves the pullbacks that form $U_\bullet$, the simplicial object $L(U_\bullet)$ is the \v{C}ech nerve of $Lp$. If it further presents an effective groupoid in a suitable category $\mathcal D$, the totalization can be expressed as its category of actions. If unrestricted descent also holds for $Lp$ in $\mathcal D$, then the result is the entire unrestricted slice over $LB$. Each step uses a separate property. Applying a reflection termwise to a \v{C}ech nerve is meaningful even if its image fails the groupoid Segal conditions, and the comparison theorem still holds in the form given above.2366 2367\index{descent!monadic}2368\begin{proposition}[The monadic comparison]2369Suppose that $p^*$ on the selected slices is monadic and admits the restricted left adjoint $\Sigma_p$. Let $T=p^*\Sigma_p$ be its monad on $\mathcal C_{\mathcal E/U}$. If $T$ sends trivial objects to trivial objects, it restricts to a monad $T_{\mathrm{triv}}$, and2370\[2371 \operatorname{Split}(p)\simeq2372 \operatorname{Alg}_{T_{\mathrm{triv}}}(\operatorname{Triv}(U)).2373\]2374\end{proposition}2375 2376\begin{proof}2377The full subcategory of trivial objects contains every iterate of $T$ on any one of its objects. Hence the unit and multiplication of the monad restrict to it with their coherences. A coherent algebra structure on such an object uses only these iterates and maps between them. Full faithfulness gives the same spaces for the operations, compatibility diagrams, and algebra morphisms in the smaller and larger categories. The restricted algebra category is thus the full subcategory of $\operatorname{Alg}_{T}(\mathcal C_{\mathcal E/U})$ on algebras whose underlying objects are trivial. By monadic comparison, underlying objects correspond to pullbacks of objects over $B$. This is exactly the splitting condition.2378\end{proof}2379 2380The stability hypothesis is equivalent to requiring that $\Sigma_p R_U(D)$ be split by $p$ for every allowed $D\to LU$. This recovers the extra condition in the monadic Galois-descent version of the ordinary theorem \cite[Section~5.1]{bj}. The \v{C}ech comparison uses a different stated hypothesis, namely an effective descent comparison to the full cosimplicial diagram. This formulation avoids assuming that every monad arising from a chosen class already has an identified groupoid model.2381 2382\begin{proposition}[Change of splitting cover]2383Suppose the specified descent maps are stable under pullback and composition. Coverings are stable under base change. If $q\colon V\to B$ is a specified descent map and $q^*f$ is a covering over $V$, then $f$ is a covering whenever $f$ is allowed. If $V\to U$ is a map over $B$, then $\operatorname{Split}(p)\subseteq\operatorname{Split}(V\to B)$.2384\end{proposition}2385 2386\begin{proof}2387For a new base $B'\to B$, pull back a splitting map $U\to B$ and use stability of triviality. If $W\to V$ splits $q^*f$, its composite $W\to B$ is a specified descent map that splits $f$. The refinement statement follows from the same stability of triviality. All assertions concern full subcategories and respect the coherent pullback functors between their comparisons.2388\end{proof}2389 2390An allowed effective descent map $p$ is \emph{normal} for this structure when $p^*p$ is trivial. This belongs to the relative terminology. A normal splitting cover is a descent map that splits itself, and its pullbacks are again normal whenever the descent class is stable under pullback. The definition has no dependence on a choice of geometric point or separable closure. Chapter~\ref{ch:central} relates it to centrality in the ordinary group calculation.2391 2392\section{Two factorization systems arising from truncation}2393 2394Return to a reflection, using all arrows and identifying $R$ with inclusion. Write $L$ also for the endofunctor $RL$ under this convention. Let $\mathcal M$ be the trivial maps and $\mathcal W$ the maps inverted by $L$.2395 2396Every orthogonality assertion below concerns a contractible space of fillers in every coherent commutative square. Equivalently, $a\colon A\to B$ is orthogonal to $m\colon X\to Y$ if the natural map2397\[2398 \operatorname{Map}(B,X) \longrightarrow2399 \operatorname{Map}(A,X)\times_{\operatorname{Map}(A,Y)}2400 \operatorname{Map}(B,Y)2401\]2402is an equivalence. This definition retains the space of commutativity data of a square as well as the space of diagonals.2403 2404\index{factorization system!reflective}\index{orthogonality}2405\begin{theorem}[Admissible reflective factorization]2406\label{thm:admissible-reflective-factorization}2407For an unrestricted admissible reflection there is an orthogonal factorization system $(\mathcal W,\mathcal M)$ with factorization2408\[2409 A\longrightarrow B\times_{LB}LA\longrightarrow B2410 \qquad (f\colon A\to B).2411\]2412The factorizations are functorial and $\mathcal W$ is stable under pullback along $\mathcal M$.2413\end{theorem}2414 2415\begin{proof}2416The right arrow is $R_B(L_Bf)$. Admissibility makes its $L$-image the arrow $LA\to LB$ up to equivalence, with counit inverse to the image of the left arrow by the triangle identity. Hence the left arrow lies in $\mathcal W$. To see orthogonality, take a lifting problem against $X=Y\times_{LY}LX\to Y$. For a fixed bottom arrow $B\to Y$, lifts amount to compatible maps $B\to LX$ over $LY$. For $a\in\mathcal W$, restriction along $a$ is an equivalence on maps into either of the local objects $LX,LY$. It is therefore an equivalence on their homotopy fibers over the prescribed composite to $LY$, proving orthogonality. The class $\mathcal W$ is closed under retracts, and so is $\mathcal M$, since the natural comparison from an object to its slice reflection carries retract diagrams to retract diagrams. The usual orthogonality-retract argument now identifies each class with the full orthogonal of the other. Functoriality follows from the units and pullback universal properties.2417 2418For the stability statement let $m\colon C\to B$ be trivial and $a\colon A\to B$ inverted. Write $C\simeq B\times_{LB}D$ for $D\in\mathcal D_{/LB}$. Then $A\times_BC\simeq A\times_{LA}(LA\times_{LB}D)$. Applying admissibility at $A$ and $B$ gives the comparison $LA\times_{LB}D\to D$ under $L$, an equivalence.2419\end{proof}2420 2421\index{stable units}Stable units mean that $L$ preserves pullbacks over every local object in the ambient category, including pullbacks in which neither of the objects over that base is local. This implies admissibility by the practical criterion. Left exactness requires finite-limit preservation over arbitrary bases and is stronger. If $L$ is left exact, $\mathcal W$ is stable under arbitrary pullback. Conversely, if $\mathcal C$ has finite limits and $\mathcal W$ is pullback stable, $L$ is left exact. Indeed the reflection fixes the terminal object, since it is local. For a pullback $A\times_BC$, the map to $A\times_{LB}C$ is a pullback of the diagonal of $B\to LB$. That diagonal lies in $\mathcal W$ by pullback stability and two-out-of-three, since either projection $B\times_{LB}B\to B$ lies in $\mathcal W$ and the composite with the diagonal is the identity. The map2422\[2423 A\times_{LB}C\longrightarrow LA\times_{LB}LC2424\]2425is the composite of pullbacks of the two units, so is also in $\mathcal W$. The final object is local, since the right adjoint preserves limits. This proves preservation of pullbacks.2426 2427\begin{corollary}[Left-exact localizations]2428Let $L\colon\mathcal X\to\mathcal Y$ be an accessible left-exact localization of an $\infty$-topos, and allow all arrows. For any effective epimorphism $p\colon U\to B$, a map over $B$ is split by $p$ if and only if it is already trivial.2429\end{corollary}2430