Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

galois-theory-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Galois Theory in Higher Categories

View paper · Download original file

Lines 2131–2230 of 4071. Source text is displayed literally.

2131At a finite stage the first isomorphism is the splitting of a separable Galois tensor product. For the second, a continuous function to the discrete field has finitely many clopen fibers by compactness, and a common finite-stage refinement detects all of them. Thus \(HL\) is normal over \(HK\). The Pierce image of the Amitsur nerve is the groupoid with one object and arrow group \(G\), and Theorem~\ref{thm:pierce-galois} classifies split algebras by continuous \(G\)-actions on Stone spaces, as in \cite[Chapter~3]{bj}. All tensor powers here are flat over \(K\), so passing to Eilenberg--Mac Lane spectra preserves their discreteness.2132 2133% End chapters/05-algebra.tex2134% Begin chapters/06-spectral.tex2135\chapter{Spectral Galois extensions and stable monodromy}\label{ch:spectral}2136 2137A categorical Galois theory depends on which objects count as covers. For a commutative ring spectrum, ordinary \'etaleness of degree zero together with the flat homotopy base-change formula gives one answer. A different answer asks for commutative algebra objects that become products of components of the unit after an effective extension of scalars. The second answer extends the split-algebra construction of \cite{bj} into stable homotopy theory. It permits torsors such as the complexification map in periodic topological \(K\)-theory, which fail the homotopy flatness test. The two theories are related by descent, with different input conditions.2138 2139\section{Three effectivity inputs}2140\index{descendability}\index{nilpotence!tensor}2141 2142A \emph{stable homotopy theory} here means a presentable symmetric monoidal stable \(\infty\)-category \(\mathcal C\) in which the tensor product preserves colimits separately. Write \(\mathbf 1\) for its unit. An algebra \(B\in\operatorname{CAlg}(\mathcal C)\) is \emph{faithful} if \(B\otimes-\) is conservative. In a stable category this is equivalent to requiring \(B\otimes M\simeq0\) to imply \(M\simeq0\), by applying the test to cofibers. It is \emph{descendable} if the thick tensor ideal it generates contains \(\mathbf 1\). A thick tensor ideal is closed under finite cofiber sequences, retracts, and tensor products with any object of \(\mathcal C\).2143 2144The following criterion gives the difference between a conservative test and a finite proof of descent. Put \(I=\operatorname{fib}(\mathbf 1\to B)\), with its map \(u:I\to\mathbf 1\). Write \(u_n:I^{\otimes n}\to\mathbf 1\) for the tensor power of \(u\).2145 2146\begin{proposition}[Nilpotence criterion]\label{prop:spectral-nil}2147The algebra \(B\) is descendable if and only if \(u_n\) is nullhomotopic for some \(n\geq 1\).2148\end{proposition}2149 2150\begin{proof}2151Say an object \(M\) belongs to \(\mathcal N\) if \(u_n\otimes M\) is nullhomotopic for some \(n\). It is closed under tensoring with an arbitrary object and under retracts. Suppose \(M_1\to M\to M_2\) is a cofiber sequence and powers \(n\) and \(m\) annihilate the terms \(M_1\) and \(M_2\), respectively. The map \(I^{\otimes m}\otimes M\to M\) becomes null after composition to \(M_2\), by naturality. It lifts along \(M_1\to M\). Tensor that lift with \(I^{\otimes n}\) and apply \(u_n\) on its target. The resulting composite factors through \(u_n\otimes M_1\), hence vanishes. By naturality this equals \(u_{n+m}\otimes M\). This shows extension closure, and suspension, desuspension and rotation of a cofiber sequence give the other two-out-of-three cases. Thus \(\mathcal N\) is thick. It contains \(B\) since multiplication splits \(B\to B\otimes B\) and hence \(B\otimes u\) is null. If \(B\) is descendable, \(\mathbf 1\in\mathcal N\).2152 2153Conversely, the cofiber of \(u_n\) is built from the cofibers in the chain2154\[2155 I^{\otimes n}\longrightarrow I^{\otimes(n-1)}2156     \longrightarrow \cdots\longrightarrow I\longrightarrow\mathbf 1.2157\]2158These cofibers are \(I^{\otimes j}\otimes B\) for \(0\leq j<n\), since the arrows are tensorings of \(u\). Repeated use of the cofiber sequence for a composite puts the cofiber of \(u_n\) in the thick tensor ideal generated by \(B\). If \(u_n\) is null, \(\mathbf 1\) is a retract of that cofiber.2159\end{proof}2160 2161A descendable algebra is faithful. For a fixed \(M\), the objects \(X\) satisfying \(X\otimes M\simeq 0\) form a thick tensor ideal, so if that ideal contains \(B\), it contains the unit. Descendability moreover implies effective Amitsur descent for \(\mathcal C\) as a symmetric monoidal category \cite[Proposition~3.22]{mathew}. The decisive step in the comonadicity proof concerns a cosimplicial diagram that becomes split after tensoring with \(B\). After this tensoring its partial-totalization tower is pro-constant. The objects \(X\) such that the tower for the diagram tensored by \(X\) is pro-constant form a thick tensor ideal. Finite limits commute with tensoring, and constant pro-objects form a stable full subcategory closed under retracts. Tensoring a pro-constant tower produces a pro-constant tower because tensoring defines a levelwise functor on pro-objects. Descendability puts the unit in the ideal. For a pro-constant tower, passage to the limit commutes with tensoring by \(B\). The dual form of Barr--Beck then gives comonadicity, and the iterated base-change diagram gives the Amitsur limit.2162 2163Two other effectivity inputs serve different purposes. Faithfulness plus dualizability suffices for comonadicity without an assumption about compactness of the unit, because tensoring with a dualizable object preserves all limits. When the unit is compact these two conditions also imply descendability \cite[Theorem~3.38]{mathew}. Flat faithful descent of ring spectra, used in Chapter~\ref{ch:algebra}, is still another criterion. Its hypotheses are expressed on all homotopy groups and it establishes the Amitsur equivalence directly. In particular, a proof of equivalence of module categories via conservative, limit-preserving tensoring is available without checking homotopy flatness.2164 2165\section{The Amitsur complex of a Rognes extension}2166\index{Amitsur complex!coherent group action}\index{Galois extension!spectral}2167 2168Let \(G\) be a finite group and let \(A\to B\) be a map of \(E_\infty\)-rings with a coherent action of \(G\) on \(B\) by \(A\)-algebra maps. Its characteristic comparisons are2169\begin{equation}\label{eq:rognes-galois-comparisons}2170 A\longrightarrow B^{hG},2171 \qquad2172 \gamma:B\otimes_A B\longrightarrow\prod_{g\in G}B,2173 \qquad2174 \gamma_g=\mu\circ(1\otimes g).2175\end{equation}2176Here \(B^{hG}\) is the homotopy limit of the action diagram over \(BG\), computed in ring spectra, and \(\mu\) is multiplication. If both maps are equivalences, the extension is \(G\)-Galois in the sense of Rognes. It is \emph{faithful} if \(B\) is faithful as an \(A\)-module \cite[Sections~4 and~6]{rognes}. The faithfulness condition matters to the following categorical comparison. The fixed-point equation only describes the algebra of invariants, while descent must detect every module.2177 2178\begin{lemma}[Bar description of the tensor powers]\label{lem:spectral-bar}2179If \(\gamma\) is an equivalence, there is an equivalence of cosimplicial algebras2180\[2181 B^{\otimes_A(\bullet+1)} \simeq2182 \left([n]\longmapsto\prod_{(g_1,\ldots,g_n)\in G^n} B\right),2183\]2184where the right side is the cochain diagram of the \(G\)-action. The degree-\(n\) component at \((g_1,\ldots,g_n)\) is the map that multiplies the factors after twisting factor \(i\) by \(g_1\cdots g_i\), with the first factor untwisted.2185\end{lemma}2186 2187\begin{proof}2188For fixed \(n\), use the first factor as a common \(B\)-base and write the tensor power as the \(n\)-fold tensor product over \(B\) of \(B\otimes_A B\). Apply \(\gamma\) to each factor. Finite products of \(B\)-algebras are taken to finite products by base change, as can be checked on underlying modules, where finite products are also coproducts. This gives an equivalence indexed by independent elements \((h_1,\ldots,h_n)\), with factor \(i\) twisted by \(h_i\). Reindex by \(h_i=g_1\cdots g_i\), a bijection of indexing sets.2189 2190For the first coface, the inserted unit in factor zero makes every later factor share the twist \(g_1\). This is the coface applying \(g_1\) after deleting it from the coordinate tuple. An interior insertion replaces adjacent group entries by their product. Insertion at the final position drops the last entry. A codegeneracy multiplies two adjacent factors and is identified with inserting the group identity at that place. These formulas are equalities for strict actions and are identities of composites of the multiplication and the action structure maps for a coherent action. Equivalently, the comparison is induced from the map of simplicial diagrams from the action groupoid of \(G\) on the affine represented by \(B\) to its affine \Cech{} nerve, where an arrow and its first object determine the second. This construction gives the whole family with its coherences.2191\end{proof}2192 2193\begin{theorem}[Stable Galois descent]\label{thm:spectral-galois-descent}2194For a faithful \(G\)-Galois extension of \(E_\infty\)-rings, extension of scalars induces symmetric monoidal equivalences2195\[2196 \operatorname{Mod}_A\simeq(\operatorname{Mod}_B)^{hG},2197 \qquad2198 \operatorname{CAlg}_A\simeq(\operatorname{CAlg}_B)^{hG}.2199\]2200The group acts on the categories on the right by extension of scalars along its automorphisms of \(B\). A module or algebra there has semilinear transport with respect to the action on its scalars.2201\end{theorem}2202 2203\begin{proof}2204Rognes's dualizability theorem makes \(B\) a dualizable \(A\)-module \cite[Proposition~6.2.1]{rognes}. Tensoring with it is therefore both conservative and limit-preserving. To check the latter, regard tensoring as an endofunctor of \(\operatorname{Mod}_A\) and use its left adjoint, tensoring with the dual \(B^\vee\). Limits of \(B\)-modules are computed on their underlying \(A\)-modules, so extension of scalars also preserves them. By comonadicity, the Amitsur module comparison is an equivalence. The \Cech{} comparison is symmetric monoidal, since every extension of scalars is, and the monoidal operations in the limit are pointwise.2205 2206Apply Lemma~\ref{lem:spectral-bar}. Modules over \(\prod_J B\) with \(J\) finite are products of modules over the factors. This follows by projecting to the orthogonal central idempotents, giving an inverse to taking the direct sum with its componentwise action. The first coface on the resulting category-valued bar construction is the twist by \(g_1\), the middle cofaces compose group elements, and the last drops the last element. Thus its limit is the category of coherent semilinear descent data \((\operatorname{Mod}_B)^{hG}\). Passing to commutative algebra objects in the symmetric monoidal equivalence proves the second assertion.2207\end{proof}2208 2209A fixed-point description follows at the level of individual objects. If \(D\) is a semilinear \(B\)-algebra in the right-hand category, its inverse image is the homotopy fixed-point algebra of the underlying action, under \(A\). Indeed the right adjoint to extension of scalars with canonical descent data is formed by the limit of the forgetful diagram, including the transport. This is seen by taking mapping spaces out of any \(A\)-algebra and applying extension--restriction adjunction in every degree. The equivalence in Theorem~\ref{thm:spectral-galois-descent} identifies this right adjoint with the inverse. The module statement holds by the same argument. Thus reconstructing the underlying algebra or module uses the full homotopy limit even when a classifying category of special algebras has discrete maps.2210 2211\section{Intermediate split algebras}2212\index{homotopy fixed points!intermediate algebra}2213 2214Suppose \(\pi_0 B\) is nonzero and has only trivial idempotents. A \(B\)-algebra of the form \(B^T=\prod_{t\in T} B\), with \(T\) a finite set, has a discrete space of maps to another such algebra \(B^U\). By Lemma~\ref{lem:pierce-split-products}, that space is the set of maps \(U\to T\). Extension of scalars along each \(g:B\to B\) canonically carries \(B^T\) to a copy of \(B^T\), since it preserves these products and takes the unit to the unit. Every coherent semilinear structure on \(B^T\) then amounts to a genuine action on \(T\), by contravariance and discreteness. In formulas one may take the action on functions to be \((g\varphi)(t)=g(\varphi(g^{-1}t))\).2215 2216\begin{corollary}\label{cor:spectral-intermediate}2217Under the hypotheses of Theorem~\ref{thm:spectral-galois-descent} and connectedness of \(\pi_0 B\) as above, the opposite of the category of \(A\)-algebras becoming \(B^T\) for finite \(T\) is equivalent to the category of finite \(G\)-sets. Connected objects equipped with a map of algebras to \(B\) correspond to pointed transitive \(G\)-sets, hence to subgroups \(H\leq G\). For \(T=G/H\) with point \(H\), the associated intermediate algebra is \(B^{hH}\).2218\end{corollary}2219 2220\begin{proof}2221The full subcategory in question is preserved by the equivalence of Theorem~\ref{thm:spectral-galois-descent} and is characterized after extension by the discrete products just described. The object \(B\) corresponds to the regular \(G\)-set by \eqref{eq:rognes-galois-comparisons}. Hence a map of algebras to \(B\) gives a \(G\)-equivariant map from the regular \(G\)-set, which is specified by its value at the identity. A nonempty split object is connected precisely when the action is transitive, since a nontrivial product decomposition is exactly a disjoint union of invariant subsets. This also agrees with indecomposability of the underlying algebra. An idempotent would give a product decomposition, and each factor would remain split after base change because the idempotents of \(B^T\) are the characteristic functions of subsets of \(T\). For transitive \(T\), the stabilizer of the point yields the unique pointed isomorphism with \(G/H\). The fixed-point construction for \(B^{G/H}\) is a limit over the action groupoid \(G\ltimes(G/H)\) with value \(B\) at each object and transport induced by the group action. This groupoid is equivalent to \(BH\) by inclusion of the stabilizer at \(H\). Its limit is \(B^{hH}\). Under the same identification, the map to \(B\) is evaluation at the selected object.2222\end{proof}2223 2224The correspondence is formulated in the category of the split algebras and their maps. In spectral algebra there is generally no useful criterion for an intermediate object that simply asks for injectivity of a map on every homotopy group. Connected split objects have a categorical role inside the category defined by base change and decomposition into components. The stabilizer is read from that category.2225 2226 2227\begin{corollary}[Normal subgroups]\label{cor:spectral-normal}2228In the situation of Corollary~\ref{cor:spectral-intermediate}, if \(H\) is normal in \(G\) then \(A\to B^{hH}\) is a faithful \((G/H)\)-Galois extension.2229\end{corollary}2230