Indexed text attachment
galois-theory-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Galois Theory in Higher Categories
View paper · Download original file
Lines 2071–2170 of 4071. Source text is displayed literally.
2071 G_n =P(B_n)2072\]2073is an internal groupoid. The opposite of the full subcategory of \(\operatorname{CAlg}_A\) on those \(D\) for which \(B\otimes_A D\) is Pierce-split is equivalent to the category of internal \(G_\bullet\)-actions in Stone spaces. The underlying space of the action associated to \(D\) is \(P(B\otimes_A D)\) over \(G_0=P(B)\).2074\end{theorem}2075 2076\begin{proof}2077The tensor-power algebra in degree \(n\), with its map from the factor at any vertex, is the \(n\)-fold tensor product over \(B\) of \(B\otimes_A B\) with a common selected factor. Normality and Corollary~\ref{cor:pierce-base-change} make it Pierce-split over that vertex. The usual Segal decomposition of the affine \Cech{} nerve expresses its degree \(n\) as the iterated pullback of \(n\) consecutive arrows over \(\operatorname{Spec}(B)\), where \(\operatorname{Spec}\) here denotes passage to opposite algebras. Each pullback can use a Pierce-split leg at its vertex. Corollary~\ref{cor:pierce-base-change} therefore identifies \(G_n\) with the corresponding Stone pullback of composable arrows. Applying the same corollary to the first and last vertices of a triangle, or to either pair of edges with a common tail or head, gives the outer horn isomorphisms for inverses. Concretely, the exchange of the two factors in \(B_1\) supplies inversion, and its identities with multiplication follow from the corresponding identities in the affine \Cech{} groupoid. Thus \(G_\bullet\) is a groupoid object.2078 2079Under \eqref{eq:affine-alg-desc}, requiring the object at degree zero to be Pierce-split is equivalent to requiring it at all degrees. Indeed each comparison with a vertex identifies the object at degree \(n\) with an extension of scalars of its degree-zero value, and Pierce splitting is preserved by extension of scalars. The equivalence of Theorem~\ref{thm:pierce-relative} is natural for precisely these transition functors by Corollary~\ref{cor:pierce-base-change}. Taking opposites therefore identifies the desired category with2080\[2081 \lim_{[n]\in\Delta} \mathsf{Stone}_{/G_n}.2082\]2083For an internal groupoid this limit is the category of internal actions. Given an object \(V\to G_0\), an identification of its two pullbacks to \(G_1\) is an arrowwise transport map. The degenerate arrows impose its unit law and the pullbacks over \(G_2\) impose composition. The Segal isomorphisms identify all further compatibilities with iteration of these two laws. Conversely a unitary associative action gives that identification and all its extensions by pullback. Morphisms are maps over \(G_0\) commuting with the transport. This proves the equivalence and the claim about the underlying space.2084\end{proof}2085 2086The condition on \(B\otimes_A B\) also gives the closure of the trivial objects under the special base change that transports a \(B\)-algebra along \(A\to B\). For \(D=B\langle Y\rangle\), first apply Corollary~\ref{cor:pierce-base-change} with the second \(B\)-structure on \(B\otimes_A B\). The resulting algebra is Pierce-split over \(B\otimes_A B\). If the latter, with its first \(B\)-structure, corresponds to a Stone space \(T\) over \(P(B)\), the composite is Pierce-split over the first \(B\). To verify this last assertion, express each algebra over \(B\otimes_A B\) using \eqref{eq:pierce-relative}. A finite product of clopen factors of \(B\langle T\rangle\) corresponds over \(B\) to a finite union of clopen subspaces of \(T\), by the relative mapping formula. Filtered colimits of these algebras correspond to inverse limits of their Stone spaces by that same formula. Conversely, taking \(D=B\) in the closure condition recovers normality. In the ordinary ring setting, these are the split-object and groupoid mechanisms in \cite[Sections~4.5--4.7]{bj}.2087 2088\section{Flat descent and the geometric \'etale site}2089\index{descent!faithfully flat}\index{etale algebra@\'etale algebra!spectral}2090 2091Call \(A\to B\) faithfully flat when \(\pi_0 A\to\pi_0 B\) is faithfully flat and2092\[2093 \pi_t A\otimes_{\pi_0 A}\pi_0 B\xrightarrow{\ \sim\ }\pi_t B2094 \qquad (t\in\mathbf Z).2095\]2096For any \(A\)-module \(M\), flat base change gives \(\pi_t(M\otimes_A B)=\pi_t M\otimes_{\pi_0 A}\pi_0 B\). One way to establish this formula is to compare the two homological functors in \(M\). The candidate assembled from the homotopy groups and a flat module is exact and preserves coproducts, and the comparison is an isomorphism on all suspended copies of \(A\). The ordinary ring \(\pi_0 A\) acts on the homotopy groups, so the comparison is balanced. The class of modules for which it is an isomorphism in every degree is stable and closed under coproducts. The suspended unit generates \(\operatorname{Mod}_A\) as a localizing subcategory. In particular extension of scalars detects equivalences and concentration of homotopy groups.2097 2098Faithfully flat spectral descent identifies \(\operatorname{Mod}_A\) with the Amitsur limit of \(\operatorname{Mod}_{B_n}\) by extension of scalars \cite[Theorem~3.1]{mathew}. The functors are symmetric monoidal, so the equivalence is symmetric monoidal with the pointwise structures on the limit. Passing to commutative algebra objects yields \eqref{eq:affine-alg-desc}. Indeed an algebra is given by a functor out of the commutative operad satisfying the inert-arrow conditions, and functor formation and these conditions are checked in every coordinate of a limit. For ordinary rings, concentrate all homotopy groups in degree zero. A differential degree cannot survive base change and then become zero by faithful flatness. This recovers the affine statement of classical fpqc descent \cite{stacks}. The symmetric monoidal comparison carries the multiplication and unit operations through module descent.2099 2100There is a different restriction of the same descent formula. An \(A\)-algebra \(C\) is \emph{spectrally \'etale} in the geometric sense when \(\pi_0 C\) is \'etale over \(\pi_0 A\) in the ordinary sense and2101\[2102 \pi_t C\cong\pi_t A\otimes_{\pi_0 A}\pi_0 C2103 \qquad(t\in\mathbf Z).2104\]2105It is finite \'etale when this ordinary algebra is also finite as a module. Lurie's \'etale lifting theorem gives an equivalence2106\begin{equation}\label{eq:etale-pi0}2107 \operatorname{CAlg}_A^{\mathrm{et}}2108 \simeq N(\operatorname{Alg}_{\pi_0 A}^{\mathrm{et}})2109\end{equation}2110and gives discrete mapping spaces from \'etale sources into any \(A\)-algebra, with mapping sets computed on \(\pi_0\) \cite[Theorem~7.5.0.6 and Corollary~7.5.4.6]{ha}. Formula \eqref{eq:etale-pi0} applies also to the finite \'etale subcategory. It is compatible with base change because pushouts of \'etale maps remain \'etale and the degree-zero comparison is ordinary base change. For connective bases, the corresponding spectral affine small \'etale sites agree with the classical sites for \(\pi_0 A\). Their generating covers are tested by joint surjectivity on the same underlying spectra of ordinary rings \cite{dag}. The equivalence of sites yields an equivalence of their \(\infty\)-topoi of space-valued sheaves, which still have higher sheaf cohomology even though the affine \'etale probes and their maps are discrete.2111 2112\begin{proposition}\label{prop:spectral-etale-desc}2113If \(A\to B\) is faithfully flat, the \(\infty\)-categories of \'etale and finite \'etale \(A\)-algebras are the respective Amitsur limits of the same subcategories over \(B_n\).2114\end{proposition}2115 2116\begin{proof}2117Both properties are stable under extension of scalars. Conversely let \(C\) be an \(A\)-algebra whose base change to \(B\) has either property. Ordinary faithfully flat descent of the \'etale and finite properties, together with \(\pi_0(B\otimes_A C)\cong\pi_0 B\otimes_{\pi_0 A}\pi_0 C\), yields the required condition on degree zero \cite{stacks}. For each \(t\), tensor the homotopy comparison map for \(C\) over \(\pi_0 A\) with \(\pi_0 B\). The resulting map is the homotopy comparison for \(B\otimes_A C\) as a \(B\)-algebra, by flat base change for modules. It is an isomorphism, so the original map is an isomorphism by faithful flatness. Hence the required subcategories are the restrictions of \eqref{eq:affine-alg-desc} selected in degree zero, which proves the assertion.2118\end{proof}2119 2120\section{What the two restrictions detect}2121 2122The Pierce functor is built from components, while a small \'etale site is built from flat unramified maps and contains the Zariski opens. If \(A\) has connected \(\pi_0\), the former sends its base to one point regardless of the prime spectrum. A geometrically \'etale map may have connected source and target with a genuinely different field of functions. Such a map is sent to the identity of a one-point Stone space. It can nevertheless become Pierce-split after a sufficiently large faithfully flat extension, and Theorem~\ref{thm:pierce-galois} then records its monodromy through the arrow space of that extension. Component data alone therefore cannot recover the geometric \'etale site on the base. The descent construction uses component data simultaneously on the cover and on its iterated overlaps.2123 2124Here is the field calculation at an infinite level. Let \(L/K\) be an infinite algebraic Galois extension, the union of finite Galois subextensions \(L_i/K\), with Krull group \(G=\lim_i \operatorname{Gal}(L_i/K)\). As \(L\)-algebras,2125\[2126 L\otimes_K L2127 \cong \underset{i}{\operatorname{colim}}2128 \prod_{\operatorname{Gal}(L_i/K)} L2129 \cong \{\text{continuous functions }G\to L_{\mathrm{disc}}\}.2130\]2131At a finite stage the first isomorphism is the splitting of a separable Galois tensor product. For the second, a continuous function to the discrete field has finitely many clopen fibers by compactness, and a common finite-stage refinement detects all of them. Thus \(HL\) is normal over \(HK\). The Pierce image of the Amitsur nerve is the groupoid with one object and arrow group \(G\), and Theorem~\ref{thm:pierce-galois} classifies split algebras by continuous \(G\)-actions on Stone spaces, as in \cite[Chapter~3]{bj}. All tensor powers here are flat over \(K\), so passing to Eilenberg--Mac Lane spectra preserves their discreteness.2132 2133% End chapters/05-algebra.tex2134% Begin chapters/06-spectral.tex2135\chapter{Spectral Galois extensions and stable monodromy}\label{ch:spectral}2136 2137A categorical Galois theory depends on which objects count as covers. For a commutative ring spectrum, ordinary \'etaleness of degree zero together with the flat homotopy base-change formula gives one answer. A different answer asks for commutative algebra objects that become products of components of the unit after an effective extension of scalars. The second answer extends the split-algebra construction of \cite{bj} into stable homotopy theory. It permits torsors such as the complexification map in periodic topological \(K\)-theory, which fail the homotopy flatness test. The two theories are related by descent, with different input conditions.2138 2139\section{Three effectivity inputs}2140\index{descendability}\index{nilpotence!tensor}2141 2142A \emph{stable homotopy theory} here means a presentable symmetric monoidal stable \(\infty\)-category \(\mathcal C\) in which the tensor product preserves colimits separately. Write \(\mathbf 1\) for its unit. An algebra \(B\in\operatorname{CAlg}(\mathcal C)\) is \emph{faithful} if \(B\otimes-\) is conservative. In a stable category this is equivalent to requiring \(B\otimes M\simeq0\) to imply \(M\simeq0\), by applying the test to cofibers. It is \emph{descendable} if the thick tensor ideal it generates contains \(\mathbf 1\). A thick tensor ideal is closed under finite cofiber sequences, retracts, and tensor products with any object of \(\mathcal C\).2143 2144The following criterion gives the difference between a conservative test and a finite proof of descent. Put \(I=\operatorname{fib}(\mathbf 1\to B)\), with its map \(u:I\to\mathbf 1\). Write \(u_n:I^{\otimes n}\to\mathbf 1\) for the tensor power of \(u\).2145 2146\begin{proposition}[Nilpotence criterion]\label{prop:spectral-nil}2147The algebra \(B\) is descendable if and only if \(u_n\) is nullhomotopic for some \(n\geq 1\).2148\end{proposition}2149 2150\begin{proof}2151Say an object \(M\) belongs to \(\mathcal N\) if \(u_n\otimes M\) is nullhomotopic for some \(n\). It is closed under tensoring with an arbitrary object and under retracts. Suppose \(M_1\to M\to M_2\) is a cofiber sequence and powers \(n\) and \(m\) annihilate the terms \(M_1\) and \(M_2\), respectively. The map \(I^{\otimes m}\otimes M\to M\) becomes null after composition to \(M_2\), by naturality. It lifts along \(M_1\to M\). Tensor that lift with \(I^{\otimes n}\) and apply \(u_n\) on its target. The resulting composite factors through \(u_n\otimes M_1\), hence vanishes. By naturality this equals \(u_{n+m}\otimes M\). This shows extension closure, and suspension, desuspension and rotation of a cofiber sequence give the other two-out-of-three cases. Thus \(\mathcal N\) is thick. It contains \(B\) since multiplication splits \(B\to B\otimes B\) and hence \(B\otimes u\) is null. If \(B\) is descendable, \(\mathbf 1\in\mathcal N\).2152 2153Conversely, the cofiber of \(u_n\) is built from the cofibers in the chain2154\[2155 I^{\otimes n}\longrightarrow I^{\otimes(n-1)}2156 \longrightarrow \cdots\longrightarrow I\longrightarrow\mathbf 1.2157\]2158These cofibers are \(I^{\otimes j}\otimes B\) for \(0\leq j<n\), since the arrows are tensorings of \(u\). Repeated use of the cofiber sequence for a composite puts the cofiber of \(u_n\) in the thick tensor ideal generated by \(B\). If \(u_n\) is null, \(\mathbf 1\) is a retract of that cofiber.2159\end{proof}2160 2161A descendable algebra is faithful. For a fixed \(M\), the objects \(X\) satisfying \(X\otimes M\simeq 0\) form a thick tensor ideal, so if that ideal contains \(B\), it contains the unit. Descendability moreover implies effective Amitsur descent for \(\mathcal C\) as a symmetric monoidal category \cite[Proposition~3.22]{mathew}. The decisive step in the comonadicity proof concerns a cosimplicial diagram that becomes split after tensoring with \(B\). After this tensoring its partial-totalization tower is pro-constant. The objects \(X\) such that the tower for the diagram tensored by \(X\) is pro-constant form a thick tensor ideal. Finite limits commute with tensoring, and constant pro-objects form a stable full subcategory closed under retracts. Tensoring a pro-constant tower produces a pro-constant tower because tensoring defines a levelwise functor on pro-objects. Descendability puts the unit in the ideal. For a pro-constant tower, passage to the limit commutes with tensoring by \(B\). The dual form of Barr--Beck then gives comonadicity, and the iterated base-change diagram gives the Amitsur limit.2162 2163Two other effectivity inputs serve different purposes. Faithfulness plus dualizability suffices for comonadicity without an assumption about compactness of the unit, because tensoring with a dualizable object preserves all limits. When the unit is compact these two conditions also imply descendability \cite[Theorem~3.38]{mathew}. Flat faithful descent of ring spectra, used in Chapter~\ref{ch:algebra}, is still another criterion. Its hypotheses are expressed on all homotopy groups and it establishes the Amitsur equivalence directly. In particular, a proof of equivalence of module categories via conservative, limit-preserving tensoring is available without checking homotopy flatness.2164 2165\section{The Amitsur complex of a Rognes extension}2166\index{Amitsur complex!coherent group action}\index{Galois extension!spectral}2167 2168Let \(G\) be a finite group and let \(A\to B\) be a map of \(E_\infty\)-rings with a coherent action of \(G\) on \(B\) by \(A\)-algebra maps. Its characteristic comparisons are2169\begin{equation}\label{eq:rognes-galois-comparisons}2170 A\longrightarrow B^{hG},