Indexed text attachment
galois-theory-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Galois Theory in Higher Categories
View paper · Download original file
Lines 1441–1540 of 4071. Source text is displayed literally.
1441\emph{protruncation} for the full finite-coefficient theory when a1442uniform truncation bound is imposed on all fiber types. Without1443a uniform bound, a single classifier can have components of1444arbitrarily high degree. In particular, the phrase1445\emph{finite-coefficient classification} must specify the1446category of coefficients and the tests of shape it claims to1447retain.1448 1449Consider the space1450\[1451 B=\coprod_{m\geq2}K(\mathbb Z/2,m).1452\]1453On each component, the based path fibration has1454\(\pi\)-finite fiber \(K(\mathbb Z/2,m-1)\). If the family came from1455\(B_{<\infty}\), it would descend to some Postnikov stage1456\(\tau_{\leq d}B\). For \(m>d\), the image of the1457\(m\)-th component in that stage is contractible, so the1458restricted family would have to be constant up to equivalence.1459The based path fibration has contractible total space, whereas1460the constant family on \(K(\mathbb Z/2,m)\) with this fiber1461has nontrivial homotopy. The family therefore uses the full1462shape. This obstruction concerns a collection of higher1463degrees rather than its fundamental group.1464 1465\section[The classifying topos]{The classifying topos and its limit}1466\index{topos!classifying}1467 1468For a space \(T\) put \(\beta(T)=\mathcal S_{/T}\).1469The classifying property needed for pro-spaces is1470\[1471 \operatorname{Map}_{\mathrm{Top}_\infty}(\mathcal X,\beta(T))1472 \simeq \operatorname{Map}_{\mathcal X}(1,\Delta T).1473\]1474This is the étale slice universal property. The right side1475classifies a lift of \(\mathcal X\to\mathcal S\) through1476\(\mathcal S_{/T}\) by sending the universal point of its1477constant \(T\) to the chosen point. For a pro-space1478\(P=\{P_i\}\), define \(\beta(P)=\lim_i\beta(P_i)\)1479in \(\mathrm{Top}_\infty\). The classifying property and1480\eqref{eq:pro-map} display an adjunction1481\[1482 \Pi_\infty\colon\mathrm{Top}_\infty1483 \rightleftarrows\operatorname{Pro}(\mathcal S)1484 :\beta .1485\]1486Its unit is \(\varphi\colon\mathcal X\to1487\beta(\Pi_\infty\mathcal X)\).1488The realization functor at \(U=1\) factors as1489\[1490 \operatorname{Rep}_{\mathcal S}(\Pi_\infty\mathcal X)1491 \longrightarrow \beta(\Pi_\infty\mathcal X)1492 \xrightarrow{\varphi^*}\mathcal X .1493\]1494The first arrow is induced by the projections from the1495topos limit, using their inverse images, while the category1496underlying that limit is computed by the direct images1497\cite[\S2]{hoyois}. Under the local \(n\)-connectedness1498hypothesis, Hoyois shows that both arrows, with \(n\)-truncated1499coefficients and objects, are fully faithful. Moreover the image1500of \(\beta(\Pi_\infty\mathcal X)_{\leq n}\) in1501\(\mathcal X\) consists of filtered colimits of locally1502constant \(n\)-truncated objects1503\cite[Thm.~3.13]{hoyois}. Theorem \ref{thm:shape-local}1504above proves the comparison on stage objects. The further1505claim about the whole classifying topos uses the fact that1506in this setting the shape admits a presentation by1507\(n\)-connected transition maps.1508 1509There is a direct description of the topos limit in degree zero1510for \(P=B_{\mathrm{pro}}H\) from Chapter~\ref{ch:profinite}.1511An object of its \(0\)-truncation is a coherent family of1512discrete \(H/U_i\)-sets \(M_i\). If \(U_j\subseteq U_i\), the1513direct image takes invariants under \(U_i/U_j\), so the compatibility1514is \(M_i\cong M_j^{U_i/U_j}\). These give compatible inclusions1515of inflated \(H\)-sets and their union is continuous. Conversely1516a continuous discrete \(H\)-set \(M\) yields the family1517of \(M^{U_i}\) and is its union. The family for the union of1518a compatible system returns that system since a fixed1519element in the union is represented by a fixed element1520at a common refinement. The construction on maps is1521by restriction and union. Thus the topos limit contains1522all continuous discrete actions, whereas the stage category1523only contains actions with a common open kernel.1524 1525The extension \(\beta\) to all pro-spaces is not fully1526faithful in general. Return to the tower of tails \(P_m\) in1527Chapter~\ref{ch:profinite}. The underlying category of1528\(\beta(P_m)\) is a product of copies of spaces, with one1529coordinate for every element of the tail. The direct images1530extend a tail-indexed family by terminal objects at the1531missing coordinates. In a compatible family, each coordinate1532is eventually missing, so the corresponding objects in1533earlier stages are terminal. Hence \(\beta(P)\) is the1534terminal category, the topos \(\beta(\varnothing)\).1535But \(P\) and \(\varnothing\) were distinguished by their1536constant empty test. This is the general pro-space obstruction1537recorded in \cite[Rem.~2.8]{hoyois}.1538 1539\section{A failure of unrestricted stage monodromy}1540\index{Cantor space}