Indexed text attachment
galois-theory-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Galois Theory in Higher Categories
View paper · Download original file
Lines 1011–1110 of 4071. Source text is displayed literally.
1011some further refinement, by the description of filtered colimits1012of sets. The same argument with finitely many pointwise equalities1013proves uniqueness in the colimit of mapping sets. Thus the category1014of all continuous discrete actions is the ind-completion of its1015finite subcategory.1016 1017The difference between stage representations and this ind-completion1018already occurs for \(H=\mathbb Z_p\). On the disjoint union1019\(\coprod_{m\geq 1}\mathbb Z/p^m\mathbb Z\), the translation1020action is continuous and requires arbitrarily deep quotients.1021Its kernel is trivial, which is a closed subgroup that is1022not open. This object is built from stage actions by taking1023a filtered union, but no single stage represents it.1024 1025A different construction first discards the topology and takes1026\(B(H^{\delta})\), the delooping of the underlying discrete group.1027For \(H=\prod_{m\geq 1}\mathbb F_2\), there is an abstract1028homomorphism \(H\to\mathbb F_2\) that annihilates1029\(\bigoplus_{m\geq 1}\mathbb F_2\) and takes the all-ones sequence1030to \(1\). Indeed, that sequence defines a nonzero vector in the1031quotient by the direct sum. Extend this vector to an algebraic basis1032and project to its coordinate. The resulting homomorphism is1033discontinuous because its kernel is dense and proper. Its action1034by translations on \(\mathbb F_2\) is an action of1035\(H^{\delta}\) with no continuous counterpart. Thus using the1036abstract classifying space instead of the pro-classifying space can1037change even the finite-coefficient theory.1038 1039\section[Closed stabilizers]{Closed stabilizers and the infinite correspondence}1040\index{profinite group!closed subgroup}\index{Galois correspondence!infinite}1041 1042The compact Hausdorff replacement of a finite discrete transitive1043action is a transitive action on a profinite space. For every1044closed subgroup \(L\leq H\), there is a homeomorphism of1045\(H\)-spaces1046\begin{equation}1047\label{eq:closed-stabilizer}1048 H/L\longrightarrow\lim_i (H/U_i)/(LU_i/U_i).1049\end{equation}1050Here \(H/L\) denotes the left \(H\)-space of cosets \(hL\), with1051the quotient topology. To prove injectivity use1052\(L=\bigcap_i LU_i\). Indeed, if \(h\notin L\), some coset1053neighborhood \(hU_i\) is disjoint from \(L\), by closedness and1054the neighborhood basis at the identity. A compatible point of the1055inverse limit specifies a family of closed cosets of the groups1056\(LU_i\). Any finite subfamily intersects by refining the indices.1057Compactness gives a point in their intersection, proving surjectivity.1058A continuous bijection from a compact space to a Hausdorff space1059is a homeomorphism.1060 1061Conversely, given a transitive continuous action on a nonempty1062profinite space \(Y\) and a point \(y\in Y\), its stabilizer \(L\)1063is closed as the inverse image of \(\{y\}\) under the orbit map.1064The induced continuous bijection \(H/L\to Y\) is again a1065homeomorphism. Between pointed homogeneous spaces \((H/L,L)\)1066and \((H/M,M)\) there is a unique pointed equivariant map precisely1067when \(L\subseteq M\). In fact its value at \(hL\) is forced to be1068\(hM\), and the subgroup condition makes this formula well defined1069and continuous. An unpointed equivariant map can send \(L\) to any1070coset \(hM\) with \(L\subseteq hMh^{-1}\); the map is then1071determined by its value there. In the discrete continuous theory,1072transitive objects instead correspond to open stabilizers.1073 1074For a Galois field extension \(K\subseteq L\), the ordinary1075subextension correspondence uses closed subgroups of1076\(H=\operatorname{Gal}(L/K)\). The equality of a subgroup1077with the limit of its finite images in \eqref{eq:closed-stabilizer}1078shows why closedness is the condition visible to all finite1079subextensions. In greater algebraic generality the stages of the1080classical correspondence can likewise assemble into profinite1081\(H\)-spaces, as in \cite[\S3.5]{bj}. Continuous actions on1082profinite spaces and continuous actions on discrete sets therefore1083enter at different points of infinitary Galois theory. Replacing1084both by one category of \(H^\delta\)-sets identifies constructions1085that have different stabilizers and different colimits.1086 1087\section{Continuous cochains and twisted coefficients}1088\index{cohomology!continuous}\index{local coefficients}1089 1090For a discrete continuous \(H\)-module \(M\), consider the cochain1091groups1092\[1093 C^q_{\mathrm{cts}}(H,M)=\operatorname{Cont}(H^q,M)1094 \qquad(q\geq0)1095\]1096with the group-cohomology differential. For a fixed cochain the1097image is finite, since a compact space has finite image in a discrete1098space. Moreover continuity implies that the cochain factors as a1099function through some \((H/U_i)^q\). Pulling back its finitely many1100fibers gives a clopen partition of \(H^q\). Each point has an open1101product of cosets contained in its partition member. A finite1102subcover by such products exists, and refining all the coset1103neighborhoods to one \(U_i\) proves the factorization.1104After shrinking \(U_i\) further, it fixes every element of the image.1105Thus the cochain corresponds to an element of1106\(C^q(H/U_i,M^{U_i})\). In degree \(0\) the identical conclusion1107holds by openness of the stabilizer of the single value. The1108differentials respect refinement of the quotient and inclusion of1109the fixed submodules, giving an isomorphism of complexes1110\[