Indexed text attachment
differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism
View paper · Download original file
Lines 941–1040 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.
941algebra homomorphisms in the coordinates $(x,v,w,a)$ on $TT\R^n$.942\end{exercise}943 944\begin{exercise}\label{exer:lens}945Show that composition in $\cat{Lens}$ is associative, and that the reverse derivative of a composite of $k$946maps $\R^{n_0}\to\R^{n_1}\to\dots\to\R^{n_k}$ with $n_k=1$ can be evaluated with one forward pass storing947the intermediate values and $k$ transposed Jacobian--vector products.948\end{exercise}949%% ---- end ch/02-tangent.tex ----950%% ---- begin ch/03-function.tex ----951\chapter{Function Spaces}\label{ch:function}952 953The second chapter of the source puts two topologies on the set $C^r(M,N)$, proves that the important classes954of maps are open in the stronger one, and proves approximation theorems by convolution and partitions of955unity. This is the analytic engine of the book. The mapping object $[M,N]$ of \cref{thm:embed} is a different956kind of structure on the same set, and it is important to be clear about what each is for. The strong957topology is for proving that properties are generic. The mapping object is for parametrizing, and its shape958is the homotopy type of the space of maps. The two are compatible but not interchangeable.959 960\section{Two topologies}961 962Fix $0\le r<\infty$. For $f\in C^r(M,N)$, charts $(\varphi,U)$ on $M$ and $(\psi,V)$ on $N$, a compact963$K\subset U$ with $f(K)\subset V$, and $\varepsilon>0$, let $\mathcal N^r(f;\varphi,\psi,K,\varepsilon)$ be the964set of $g\in C^r(M,N)$ with $g(K)\subset V$ and965\[\bigl\|D^k(\psi g\varphi^{-1})(x)-D^k(\psi f\varphi^{-1})(x)\bigr\|<\varepsilon966\qquad\text{for }x\in\varphi(K),\ 0\le k\le r.\]967 968\begin{definition}\label{def:topologies}969The \term{weak} (or compact-open $C^r$) topology on $C^r(M,N)$ is generated by the sets970$\mathcal N^r(f;\varphi,\psi,K,\varepsilon)$. The \term{strong} (or Whitney) topology has as a base the sets971$\bigcap_i\mathcal N^r(f;\varphi_i,\psi_i,K_i,\varepsilon_i)$ over locally finite families of charts972$(\varphi_i,U_i)$ of $M$, with arbitrary $\varepsilon_i>0$. On $C^\infty(M,N)$ each topology is the union of973the ones induced from $C^r$, $r<\infty$. The spaces are written $C^r_W(M,N)$ and $C^r_S(M,N)$.974\end{definition}975 976A weak neighbourhood controls a map and its derivatives on a compact set. A strong neighbourhood controls them977everywhere, with a tolerance that may shrink to zero at infinity as fast as one likes. If $M$ is compact the978two agree. If $M$ is not compact the strong topology is not metrizable and not even first countable, but it979is the one in which the theorems below are true.980 981\begin{theorem}[Open conditions]\label{thm:open}\Scl[Hirsch 2.1.1--2.1.6]982For $r\ge1$ the sets of immersions, submersions, embeddings, closed embeddings and diffeomorphisms are open983in $C^r_S(M,N)$. For $r\ge0$ the set of proper maps is open in $C^r_S(M,N)$.984\end{theorem}985 986\begin{example}\label{ex:weakfail}987Let $\beta\ge0$ be a bump function on $\R$ supported in $[-1,1]$, with maximum at $0$ and $\max\beta'=1$, and put988$g_n(x)=x-2\beta(x-n)$. Then $g_n$ agrees with the identity on $[-n+1,n-1]$, so $g_n\to\id$ in $C^\infty_W(\R,\R)$;989but $g_n'=1-2\beta'(x-n)$ takes the value $-1$, so no $g_n$ is a diffeomorphism or even an immersion. The990set of diffeomorphisms of $\R$ is not weakly open. In the strong topology $g_n$ does not converge to the991identity: the neighbourhood $\{g:|g(x)-x|<\beta(0)e^{-x^2}\}$ contains none of them. The script confirms both992statements numerically.993\end{example}994 995\begin{theorem}[Approximation]\label{thm:approx}\Scl[Hirsch 2.2.6]996For $0\le r<s\le\infty$, $C^s(M,N)$ is dense in $C^r_S(M,N)$. If $f$ is already $C^s$ on a neighbourhood of a997closed set $A$, the approximating maps may be taken to agree with $f$ on $A$.998\end{theorem}999 1000Since diffeomorphisms are open (\cref{thm:open}) and smooth maps are dense, a $C^r$ diffeomorphism can be1001approximated by a $C^\infty$ one once source and target carry compatible smooth structures; this is the main1002step in \cref{thm:smoothing}. The same two theorems give the first comparison of homotopy types.1003 1004\begin{corollary}\label{cor:homotopy}\Scl[Hirsch 5.1.5]1005Every continuous map between manifolds is homotopic to a smooth map, and two smooth maps that are1006continuously homotopic are smoothly homotopic.1007\end{corollary}1008 1009\section{The mapping object}1010 1011By \cref{thm:embed} the smooth set $[M,N]$ has as plots the smooth maps $F\colon\R^n\times M\to N$. A plot is1012a family $s\mapsto F_s$ of maps, smooth jointly in the parameter and the variable. Nothing is said about1013neighbourhoods. A topology can be recovered from the plots, as for any smooth set.1014 1015\begin{definition}\label{def:Dtop}1016A set $A$ of points of a smooth set $X$ is \term{$D$-open} if $p^{-1}(A)\subset\R^n$ is open for every plot1017$p$ of $X$. A subobject of $X$ is $D$-open if its set of points is and it contains every plot whose points1018lie in it.1019\end{definition}1020 1021\begin{theorem}\label{thm:CSW}\Sli[Christensen--Sinnamon--Wu \cite{CSW14}]1022On $C^\infty(M,N)$ the $D$-topology of the mapping object $[M,N]$ is finer than the weak topology and coarser1023than the strong topology. If $M$ is compact all three coincide.1024\end{theorem}1025 1026The first inequality says that a smooth family is continuous into the weak topology, which is easy. The1027second says that a $D$-open set is strongly open, which is not. For non-compact $M$ the second is not an1028equality: a plot $\R\to[M,N]$ is in particular a path, and paths in the strong topology are very restricted.1029 1030\begin{proposition}\label{prop:strongpath}\Scl1031Let $M$ be non-compact. If $t\mapsto f_t$ is a continuous path in $C^0_S(M,N)$, there is a compact $K\subset M$1032such that $f_t=f_0$ outside $K$ for all $t\in[0,1]$.1033\end{proposition}1034 1035So the path components of $C^\infty_S(M,N)$ are far smaller than homotopy classes1036(\cref{exer:strongpath}), and the strong topology does not compute the homotopy type of anything one wants.1037It is a device for stating that a set of maps is large.1038 1039\section{The homotopy type of a space of maps}1040