Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism

View paper · Download original file

Lines 741–840 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.

741\Sli[Eck, Kainz--Michor, Luciano; \cite{KMS93}, \S\S35--36]742\begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*)]743\item For every Weil algebra $A$, $T_A$ is a functor $\Mfd\to\Mfd$ that preserves finite products, with a744natural fibre bundle projection $T_A\Rightarrow\id$.745\item Every product-preserving bundle functor on $\Mfd$ is naturally isomorphic to $T_A$ for a Weil algebra746$A$, unique up to isomorphism.747\item Natural transformations $T_A\Rightarrow T_B$ correspond bijectively to algebra homomorphisms $A\to B$.748\item $T_A\circ T_B\cong T_{A\otimes B}$, and $T_A\times_{\id}T_B\cong T_{A\times_{\R}B}$.749\end{enumerate}750\end{theorem}751 752By (iii) and (iv), every natural operation on iterated tangent bundles is a homomorphism of small753algebras. \Cref{tab:weil} lists the ones that matter.754 755\begin{table}[ht]\centering\small756\begin{tabular}{@{}lll@{}}757\toprule758natural transformation & algebra homomorphism & in coordinates\\759\midrule760projection $p\colon T\Rightarrow\id$ & $W\to\R$, $\varepsilon\mapsto0$ & $(x,v)\mapsto x$\\761zero section $0\colon\id\Rightarrow T$ & $\R\to W$ & $x\mapsto(x,0)$\\762addition $+\colon T\times_{\id}T\Rightarrow T$ & $W\times_\R W\to W$, $\varepsilon_1,\varepsilon_2\mapsto\varepsilon$ & $(x,v_1,v_2)\mapsto(x,v_1+v_2)$\\763vertical lift $\ell\colon T\Rightarrow TT$ & $W\to W\otimes W$, $\varepsilon\mapsto\varepsilon\eta$ & $(x,v)\mapsto(x,0,0,v)$\\764flip $c\colon TT\Rightarrow TT$ & $W\otimes W\to W\otimes W$, $\varepsilon\leftrightarrow\eta$ & $(x,v,w,a)\mapsto(x,w,v,a)$\\765\bottomrule766\end{tabular}767\caption{The structure maps of the tangent functor as homomorphisms of Weil algebras. Here768$W=\R[\varepsilon]/(\varepsilon^2)$, $W\otimes W=\R[\varepsilon,\eta]/(\varepsilon^2,\eta^2)$ and769$W\times_\R W=\R[\varepsilon_1,\varepsilon_2]/(\varepsilon_i\varepsilon_j)$.}\label{tab:weil}770\end{table}771 772\begin{proposition}[Symmetry of second derivatives]\label{prop:flip}\Srf[\cite{Koc06}, \cite{KMS93}]773The naturality of the flip $c$ with respect to a map $f$ is the equality $D^2f_x(v,w)=D^2f_x(w,v)$. It holds774because $W\otimes W$ is commutative.775\end{proposition}776 777\begin{proof}778Expanding in $W\otimes W$,779\[f(x+v\varepsilon+w\eta+a\varepsilon\eta)=f(x)+Df_x(v)\varepsilon+Df_x(w)\eta+780\bigl(Df_x(a)+D^2f_x(v,w)\bigr)\varepsilon\eta ,\]781which is the formula for $TTf$. Exchanging $\varepsilon$ and $\eta$ exchanges $v$ and $w$ on the left;782on the right it leaves the coefficient of $\varepsilon\eta=\eta\varepsilon$ in place. So $TTf\circ c=c\circ783TTf$ if and only if $D^2f_x(v,w)=D^2f_x(w,v)$, and the exchange is an algebra automorphism, hence natural by784\cref{thm:weil}(iii).785\end{proof}786 787The script evaluates polynomials in $\R[\varepsilon,\eta]/(\varepsilon^2,\eta^2)$ and confirms the expansion788and its symmetry, and checks the chain rule in $W$ against finite differences.789 790\section{Tangent categories}791 792The five maps of \cref{tab:weil} and the equations among them can be abstracted.793 794\begin{definition}\label{def:tancat}795A \term{tangent category} is a category $\mathcal X$ with an endofunctor $T$ and natural transformations796$p,0,+,\ell,c$ as in \cref{tab:weil}, such that the fibre powers of each $p_M$ exist and are preserved by797$T$; $(p,0,+)$ makes each $TM$ a commutative monoid over $M$; $\ell$ and $c$ are additive, $c^2=\id$,798$c\,\ell=\ell$, and the usual coherence equations hold; and the vertical lift is universal, in the sense799that800$TM\times_MTM\to TTM$, $(a,b)\mapsto T(+)\bigl(\ell(a),0(b)\bigr)$, is the equalizer of $T(p)$ and801$0\,p\,p$ \cite[Def.~2.3]{CC14}.802\end{definition}803 804The definition is Rosick\'y's \cite{Ros84}, revived and developed by Cockett and Cruttwell. The last axiom805says that a second-order tangent vector that is vertical is the same thing as a pair of first-order ones. It806is what makes it possible to define the Lie bracket of vector fields, connections, and solutions of807differential equations in any tangent category.808 809\begin{theorem}\label{thm:leung}\Sli[Leung \cite{Leu17}]810Let $\cat{Weil}_1$ be the monoidal category of Weil algebras generated from $W$ by $\otimes$ and811$\times_\R$. A tangent structure on $\mathcal X$ is the same thing as a strong monoidal functor812$\cat{Weil}_1\to\cat{End}(\mathcal X)$ that preserves the pullbacks expressing $\times_\R$ and the813universality of $\ell$.814\end{theorem}815 816So \cref{tab:weil} is the definition, read backwards. Examples of tangent categories include $\Mfd$;817$\CinfRing^{\op}$ and the category of affine schemes, with $T$ corepresented by $A\mapsto A[\varepsilon]$ and818Kähler differentials; every model of synthetic differential geometry; and cartesian differential categories,819which axiomatize $\Cart$ itself \cite{CC14}. The definition has an $\infty$-categorical form, in which the820Goodwillie calculus of functors is an example: the tangent bundle of an $\infty$-category is its fibrewise821stabilization \cite{BBC21}.822 823\section{Infinitesimals as objects}824 825In $\CinfRing^{\op}$ the algebra $W$ is an object, $D=\operatorname{Spec}W$, and826$T_AM$ is the set of maps $\operatorname{Spec}A\to M$. One would like $TM$ to be the mapping object $M^D$.827 828\begin{theorem}\label{thm:sdg}\Sli[Dubuc \cite{Dub79}; Kock \cite{Koc06}; Moerdijk--Reyes \cite{MR91}]829Let $\mathcal Z$ be the Cahiers topos, the topos of sheaves on the category of objects830$\R^n\times\operatorname{Spec}A$ with $A$ a Weil algebra. Then $\Mfd\to\mathcal Z$ is fully faithful and831preserves transverse fibre products; $\R^D\cong\R\times\R$ (the Kock--Lawvere axiom); and832$(T_AM)\cong M^{\operatorname{Spec}A}$ for every manifold $M$ and Weil algebra $A$.833\end{theorem}834 835In $\mathcal Z$ the tangent functor is an exponential, so it preserves all limits. The functor $(-)^D$ also836has a right adjoint there, which is a statement about how small $D$ is. None of this is available in837$\SmSet$. The restriction of $D$ to $\Cart$ is the terminal object, because a nilpotent element of838$C^\infty(\R^n)$ is zero; a sheaf on $\Cart$ cannot tell $D$ from a point. This is the same defect as in839\cref{ex:three}(b), and it is the reason that tangent functors on diffeological spaces are a subject with840several inequivalent answers.