Indexed text attachment
differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism
View paper · Download original file
Lines 591–690 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.
591the zero set of a submersion $\phi\colon V\to\R^k$, and transversality says that $\phi h$ is a submersion at592the points of $W$. The implicit function theorem then gives charts in which $W$ is a coordinate subspace of593codimension $k$ and $T_xW=\ker d(\phi h)_x=dh_x^{-1}(T_{h(x)}A)$. A smooth map into $M\times P$ with image in an594embedded submanifold is smooth into the submanifold, which gives the universal property.595\end{proof}596 597The theorem identifies a class of cospans whose limits exist, are preserved by $T$, and by \cref{thm:MR} are598preserved by passage to function algebras. \Cref{ch:transversality} shows that this class is large (every599cospan is arbitrarily close to one in it) and that it determines a universal completion.600 601\begin{example}\label{ex:On}602Let $f\colon\R^{n\times n}\to\cat{Sym}_n$, $f(A)=A^{\mathsf T}A$. At $A\in\Or(n)$ the differential603$H\mapsto A^{\mathsf T}H+H^{\mathsf T}A$ is onto: $H=\tfrac12AS$ maps to $S$. So $\Or(n)=f^{-1}(I)$ is a604manifold of dimension $n^2-\tfrac12n(n+1)=\tfrac12n(n-1)$. The script checks the rank numerically for605$n\le4$.606\end{example}607 608\section{Embeddings and idempotents}609 610\begin{theorem}[Whitney]\label{thm:whitney}\Scl[Hirsch 1.3.5, 2.2.14]611Every manifold of dimension $n$ admits an embedding into $\R^{2n+1}$ with closed image.612\end{theorem}613 614Combined with the tubular neighbourhood theorem (\cref{thm:tubular}), this says that every manifold is a615smooth retract of an open subset of a Euclidean space. The converse also holds, and together they give a616description of $\Mfd$ in which charts and atlases do not appear.617 618\begin{theorem}\label{thm:karoubi}\Scl[attributed to Lawvere]619$\Mfd$ is the idempotent completion of $\cat{Open}$: every idempotent in $\Mfd$ splits, and every manifold is620a retract of an object of $\cat{Open}$.621\end{theorem}622 623\begin{proof}624The second statement was just explained. For the first, let $e\colon M\to M$ be smooth with $e^2=e$; we show625that $e(M)=\Fix(e)$ is a submanifold (\cref{exer:idem} asks for the details). At a fixed point $x$ the626differential $de_x$ is an idempotent matrix, so its rank equals its trace, which is continuous and627integer-valued along $\Fix(e)$; let it be $k$ near $x$. Rank is lower semicontinuous, so $\rk de_y\ge k$ for628$y$ near $x$, and $de_{e(y)}de_y=de_y$ gives $\rk de_y\le\rk de_{e(y)}=k$. So $e$ has constant rank $k$ near629$x$, and its image near $x$ is a $k$-dimensional submanifold.630\end{proof}631 632The theorem explains two features of what follows. A product-preserving functor on $\Cart$, such as a633$C^\infty$-ring, has a canonical value on every manifold, because the manifold is a retract of an open subset634of some $\R^q$. And the universal completion of \cref{thm:CS} has to be required to be idempotent complete.635 636\section{Boundaries}637 638Hirsch allows manifolds with boundary from the start, since cobordisms need them. A manifold with boundary is639modelled on the half-space $\R^n_+=\{x_n\ge0\}$; its boundary $\partial M$ is a manifold of dimension $n-1$.640The category $\Mfd^\partial$ is less well behaved than $\Mfd$: the product of two objects has corners, and641$\partial$ is not a functor on all smooth maps. The notion that makes the regular value theorem work is the642following.643 644\begin{definition}\label{def:neat}645A submanifold $A\subset M$ of a manifold with boundary is \term{neat} if $\partial A=A\cap\partial M$ and $A$646is not tangent to $\partial M$ at any point of $\partial A$.647\end{definition}648 649\begin{theorem}\label{thm:neat}\Scl[Hirsch 1.4.2]650Let $f\colon M\to N$ be smooth, with $\partial N=\emptyset$, and let $z$ be a regular value of both $f$ and651$f|_{\partial M}$. Then $f^{-1}(z)$ is a neat submanifold of $M$ with boundary652$(f|_{\partial M})^{-1}(z)$.653\end{theorem}654 655In smooth sets the half-line is the subobject $[0,\infty)\subset\R$, and a function on it is smooth in the656sheaf sense exactly when it is the restriction of a smooth function on $\R$ \cite[\S24]{KM97}. So657manifolds with boundary embed fully faithfully in $\Dflg$ as well. The boundary is recovered from658the object, as the set of points at which it is not locally Euclidean, although not functorially.659 660\section*{Notes}661 662Diffeological spaces are due to Souriau; the standard reference is \cite{IZ13}, and the identification with663concrete sheaves is in \cite{BH11}. $C^\infty$-rings come from Lawvere's programme for synthetic differential664geometry; see \cite{MR91}, \cite{Koc06} and \cite{Joy19}. The $\infty$-topos $\mathbf{H}$ and its shape are665developed in \cite{Sch13}; the formula of \cref{thm:shape} is proved in \cite{BEBP24} and in work of666Pavlov and of Bunk. Manifolds with corners as a category are treated by Melrose and by Joyce.667 668\section*{Exercises}669 670\begin{exercise}\label{exer:xsq}671Verify the second row of \cref{tab:four}: the fibre product of $x\mapsto x^2$ and $0\colon\pt\to\R$ is a672point in $\Mfd$ and in $\SmSet$, and is corepresented by $\R[\varepsilon]/(\varepsilon^2)$ in $\CinfRing$.673Show that a map of $C^\infty$-rings $C^\infty(M)\to\R[\varepsilon]/(\varepsilon^2)$ is a tangent vector to674$M$.675\end{exercise}676 677\begin{exercise}\label{exer:idem}678Complete the proof of \cref{thm:karoubi}: if $e\colon M\to M$ is a smooth idempotent then $\Fix(e)$ is a679closed submanifold of $M$ and $e\colon M\to\Fix(e)$ is smooth. Give an example in which $\Fix(e)$ has680components of different dimensions.681\end{exercise}682 683\begin{exercise}\label{exer:On}684Carry out \cref{ex:On} in detail, and show that $T_I\Or(n)$ is the space of skew-symmetric matrices.685\end{exercise}686 687\begin{exercise}\label{exer:exp}688Let $M,N$ be manifolds. Show that the smooth set $[M,N]$ is concrete, that its points are the smooth maps689$M\to N$, and that $\Hom(S,[M,N])\cong\Hom(S\times M,N)$ for every smooth set $S$.690\end{exercise}