Indexed text attachment
differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism
View paper · Download original file
Lines 411–510 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.
411The source works throughout with a differentiability class $1\le r\le\omega$. The following theorem is412the reason one may fix $r=\infty$.413 414\begin{theorem}[Smoothing of differential structures]\label{thm:smoothing}415\Scl[Whitney; Hirsch 2.2.9, 2.2.10]416Let $1\le r<\infty$. Every $C^r$ manifold is $C^r$ diffeomorphic to a $C^\infty$ manifold, and two $C^\infty$417manifolds that are $C^r$ diffeomorphic are $C^\infty$ diffeomorphic.418\end{theorem}419 420So the groupoids of $C^r$ manifolds and $C^r$ diffeomorphisms have the same sets of isomorphism classes for421all $r\ge1$. For $r=0$ the statement fails in both directions: there are topological manifolds with no smooth422structure and topological manifolds with several (Kervaire, Milnor). The theorem is proved by approximation423in the strong topology (\cref{ch:function}), and it is the first instance of the method described in the424Preface.425 426\section{What the category lacks}427 428$\Mfd$ has finite products and countable coproducts, and little else. Three429fibre products show the possibilities. In each, the cospan is $\R^k\xrightarrow{f}\R\xleftarrow{0}\pt$, so430the fibre product, if it exists, is ``the zero set of $f$''.431 432\begin{example}[Three zero sets]\label{ex:three}433(a) $f(x,y)=x^2+y^2-1$. The value $0$ is regular, the zero set is the circle, and the circle is the fibre434product in $\Mfd$.435 436(b) $f(x)=x^2$. A cone over the cospan is a manifold $S$ with a smooth $u\colon S\to\R$ such that $u^2=0$;437then $u=0$. So the fibre product exists in $\Mfd$ and is a point. It is the wrong answer: the tangent functor438does not preserve it (the fibre product of the tangent maps is $\{(x,v):x^2=0,\ 2xv=0\}$, a line), and it439is unstable, since the zero set of $x^2-\varepsilon$ is two points or none.440 441(c) $f(x,y)=xy$. The fibre product does not exist in $\Mfd$ (\cref{prop:cross}).442\end{example}443 444\begin{proposition}\label{prop:cross}\Scl445No manifold represents the functor $S\mapsto\{u\in C^\infty(S,\R^2): u_1u_2=0\}$ on $\Mfd$.446\end{proposition}447 448\begin{proof}449Suppose $P$ does, with universal map $j\colon P\to\R^2$. Evaluating on $S=\pt$ shows that $j$ is a bijection450onto the cross $X=\{xy=0\}$. Let $p_0=j^{-1}(0)$ and let $d$ be the dimension of $P$ at $p_0$. The two axes451are smooth curves in $X$ through $0$, so they lift to smooth injective curves $a,b\colon\R\to P$ through $p_0$452with $a(\R)\cap b(\R)=\{p_0\}$; hence $d\ge1$. If $d=1$, an injective continuous map between $1$-manifolds is453open, so $a(\R)$ and $b(\R)$ are both neighbourhoods of $p_0$ and meet in more than a point. If $d\ge2$, then454$j$ has rank at most $1$ everywhere, since $X$ has empty interior, and by the constant rank theorem $j$ fails455to be injective on an open dense set where its rank is locally constant.456\end{proof}457 458There are also no mapping objects: outside degenerate cases there is no manifold $N^M$ with459$\Mfd(S\times M,N)\cong\Mfd(S,N^M)$. And quotients by even very good equivalence relations leave the category.460 461\section{Smooth sets and diffeological spaces}462 463The first repair is to keep the test objects and enlarge the class of things tested.464 465\begin{definition}\label{def:smset}466A family $\{U_i\to U\}$ in $\Cart$ is a covering if it is an open cover all of whose finite non-empty467intersections are diffeomorphic to Euclidean spaces. A \term{smooth set} is a sheaf of sets on $\Cart$ for468this coverage; $\SmSet=\cat{Sh}(\Cart)$. For a smooth set $X$, the elements of $X(\R^n)$ are its \term{plots}469of dimension~$n$. A smooth set is \term{concrete}, or a \term{diffeological space}, if each plot is determined470by the function $\R^n\to X(\pt)$ it induces on points; $\Dflg\subset\SmSet$ is the full subcategory of these.471\end{definition}472 473\begin{theorem}\label{thm:embed}\Scl[Souriau, Iglesias-Zemmour \cite{IZ13}; Baez--Hoffnung \cite{BH11}]474\begin{enumerate}[label=(\roman*)]475\item The functor $\Mfd\to\SmSet$, $M\mapsto C^\infty(-,M)$, is fully faithful and takes values in $\Dflg$.476\item It preserves every limit that exists in $\Mfd$, and it sends an open cover of a manifold to a colimit477diagram.478\item $\SmSet$ is a Grothendieck topos and $\Dflg$ a quasitopos. Both are complete, cocomplete and locally479cartesian closed. The mapping object has plots480$[X,Y](\R^n)=\Hom(\R^n\times X,Y)$.481\end{enumerate}482\end{theorem}483 484\begin{proof}[Proof of (i)]485A natural transformation $\alpha\colon C^\infty(-,M)\to C^\infty(-,N)$ gives a function $f=\alpha_{\pt}\colon486M\to N$, and naturality with respect to the inclusions of points shows that $\alpha$ is composition with $f$.487For every chart $\varphi\colon\R^m\to M$ the composite $f\varphi=\alpha(\varphi)$ is smooth, so $f$ is smooth.488\end{proof}489 490By (ii), smooth sets inherit the fibre products of \cref{ex:three}(a) and (b) unchanged, and in case (c) they491supply one: the cross, with the plots being the smooth maps into $\R^2$ that land in it. By (iii) they supply492the mapping object, and its plots are exactly what the source calls a smooth family of maps. \Cref{ch:function}493is about this object. What smooth sets do not repair is (b). A sheaf on $\Cart$ is tested only by reduced494objects, and the equation $u^2=0$ has the same solutions as $u=0$ in every $C^\infty(\R^n)$.495 496\section{Function algebras}497 498The second repair goes the other way and enlarges the class of test objects, by admitting algebras of499functions that are not algebras of functions on a manifold.500 501\begin{definition}\label{def:cinf}502A \term{$C^\infty$-ring} is a functor $A\colon\Cart\to\Set$ that preserves finite products. Its underlying set503is $A(\R)$; each smooth $h\colon\R^n\to\R$ gives an $n$-ary operation $A(h)\colon A(\R)^n\to A(\R)$. The504category of these is written $\CinfRing$. For a manifold $M$, the $C^\infty$-ring $C^\infty(M)$ is505$\R^n\mapsto C^\infty(M,\R^n)$.506\end{definition}507 508Taking $h$ to be addition and multiplication shows that a $C^\infty$-ring has an underlying commutative509$\R$-algebra. The free $C^\infty$-ring on $n$ generators is $C^\infty(\R^n)$, and quotients by ideals of the510underlying algebra are again $C^\infty$-rings.