Indexed text attachment
differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism
View paper · Download original file
Lines 2881–2980 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.
2881\begin{example}\label{ex:frob}2882(a) $A=k[x]/(x^2)$ with $\varepsilon(1)=0$, $\varepsilon(x)=1$: the cohomology of the sphere. The dual basis2883of $(1,x)$ is $(x,1)$, so $w=2x$ and $Z(S^2)=0$, $Z(T^2)=2$, $Z(\Sigma_g)=0$ for $g\ge2$. The handle element is2884the Euler class.2885 2886(b) $A=\C[G]$ for a finite abelian group $G$ of order $n$, with $\varepsilon(g)=\delta_{g,e}/n$. The dual2887basis of $(g)$ is $(n\,g^{-1})$, so $w=n^2e$ and $Z(\Sigma_g)=\varepsilon(n^{2g}e)=n^{2g-1}$. This is2888$\#\Hom(\pi_1\Sigma_g,G)/\#G$, the number of principal $G$-bundles on $\Sigma_g$ counted with weight one over2889the order of the automorphism group.2890 2891In every case $Z(T^2)=\dim A$: the torus is the trace of the identity of $Z(S^1)$, as in \cref{thm:CH} for2892$d=1$. The script checks the Frobenius relation and these values from the structure constants.2893\end{example}2894 2895\section{Extended theories}2896 2897A field theory in the sense above assigns nothing to a point, and circles cannot be cut. Allowing2898$1$-manifolds with boundary and surfaces with corners gives a symmetric monoidal bicategory $\Bord_2$.2899 2900\begin{theorem}\label{thm:SP}\Sli[Schommer-Pries \cite{SP09}]2901The oriented bordism bicategory $\Bord^{\mathrm{or}}_2$ has a finite presentation by generators and relations,2902obtained from the classification of the generic singularities of maps from surfaces to the plane and of2903one-parameter families of them. Consequently, extended oriented two-dimensional field theories with values2904in the bicategory of algebras, bimodules and bimodule maps are classified by separable symmetric Frobenius2905algebras.2906\end{theorem}2907 2908The proof is the method of \cref{thm:2cob} with $\R$ replaced by $\R^2$: a generic map to the plane has folds2909and cusps where a Morse function has critical points, and the jet transversality theorem in one and two2910parameters supplies the relations. For framed theories the theorem confirms \cref{thm:CH} in dimension two:2911the fully dualizable algebras are the separable ones.2912 2913\section{Moduli}2914 2915By \cref{thm:ehresmann} the stack of bundles of closed connected surfaces has shape2916\[\mathcal M_2\ \simeq\ \coprod_{g\ge0}B\Diff(\Sigma_g)\ \sqcup\ \coprod_{h\ge1}B\Diff(N_h),\]2917and \cref{thm:classification} is the computation of $\pi_0\mathcal M_2$. The next question is the homotopy2918type of each component.2919 2920\begin{theorem}\label{thm:EE}\Scl[Smale; Earle--Eells \cite{EE69}; Gramain]2921The identity component of $\Diff(\Sigma_g)$ is contractible for $g\ge2$, is homotopy equivalent to the torus2922for $g=1$, and to $\SO(3)$ for $g=0$. The identity component of $\Diff(N_h)$ is contractible for $h\ge3$, a2923circle for the Klein bottle, and $\SO(3)$ for $\RP^2$.2924\end{theorem}2925 2926So for $g\ge2$ the component $B\Diff^+(\Sigma_g)$ is the classifying space $B\Gamma_g$ of the mapping class2927group $\Gamma_g=\pi_0\Diff^+(\Sigma_g)$: a surface bundle is determined by its monodromy. It is also the2928shape of the moduli stack of Riemann surfaces of genus $g$, since the space of complex structures on a2929surface is contractible (a choice in the sense of \cref{prin:choices}).2930 2931\begin{theorem}[Madsen--Weiss]\label{thm:MW}\Sli[\cite{MW07}; Harer; \cite{GMTW09}]2932The cohomology of $B\Gamma_g$ is independent of $g$ in a range of degrees growing linearly with $g$, and the2933stable cohomology is that of a component of $\Omega^\infty MTSO(2)$. Rationally,2934\[H^*(B\Gamma_\infty;\mathbb Q)\cong\mathbb Q[\kappa_1,\kappa_2,\dots],\qquad|\kappa_i|=2i .\]2935\end{theorem}2936 2937The second statement is \cref{thm:GMTW} for oriented surfaces together with the stability theorem; the2938classes $\kappa_i$ are the characteristic classes of surface bundles defined by Mumford, Morita and Miller,2939and the theorem was Mumford's conjecture.2940 2941\section{What the classification is the \texorpdfstring{$\pi_0$}{pi-0} of}2942 2943\Cref{tab:surfaces} collects the chapter. In each row the first entry is a statement of the source or a2944direct consequence, and the second is the statement about a space or a category of which it is the shadow on2945components.2946 2947\begin{table}[ht]\centering\small2948\begin{tabular}{@{}p{0.43\textwidth}p{0.47\textwidth}@{}}2949\toprule2950classical statement & of which it is $\pi_0$ or the homotopy category\\2951\midrule2952closed surfaces are $\Sigma_g$, $N_h$ & $\mathcal M_2\simeq\coprod B\Diff$; \cref{thm:EE}\\2953$\mathfrak N_2=\Z/2$, $\Omega_2=0$ & $B\Cob_2\simeq\Omega^{\infty-1}MTO(2)$; \cref{thm:GMTW}\\2954generators and relations for $2\cat{Cob}$ & presentation of $\Bord_2$; \cref{thm:SP,thm:CH}\\2955a diffeomorphism of $S^1$ is isotopic to an isometry & $\Diff(S^1)\simeq\Or(2)$\\2956connected sum is well defined & $\Emb(D^2,M)\simeq\Fr(TM)$; \cref{thm:discs}\\2957stable range for $H_*(B\Gamma_g)$ & $\Z\times B\Gamma_\infty^+\simeq\Omega^\infty MTSO(2)$; \cref{thm:MW}\\2958\bottomrule2959\end{tabular}2960\caption{Surfaces: classical statements and the homotopy types behind them.}\label{tab:surfaces}2961\end{table}2962 2963\section*{Notes}2964 2965The classification of surfaces is from the nineteenth century (Möbius, Jordan, Dyck); proofs by Morse2966theory are in Hirsch and in Gramain's notes. The equivalence between two-dimensional field theories and2967Frobenius algebras is folklore from the late 1980s; \cite{Koc04} is a careful account. The unoriented2968analogue is due to Turaev and Turner. For mapping class groups see Farb and Margalit; for the Madsen--Weiss2969theorem and its descendants, Galatius and Randal-Williams.2970 2971\section*{Exercises}2972 2973\begin{exercise}\label{exer:words}2974Identify the closed surfaces given by the words $aba^{-1}b^{-1}$, $abab$, $abab^{-1}$, $aabb$,2975$abca^{-1}b^{-1}c^{-1}$ and $abcabc$.2976\end{exercise}2977 2978\begin{exercise}\label{exer:TP}2979Deduce $T\#P\cong P\#P\#P$ from \cref{thm:classification}, using $\chi(M\#N)=\chi(M)+\chi(N)-2$.2980\end{exercise}