Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism

View paper · Download original file

Lines 2771–2870 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.

2771$r=1+2\cos\theta$. Which pairs are regularly homotopic?2772\end{exercise}2773 2774\begin{exercise}\label{exer:discRn}2775Show that $\Emb(D^n,\R^n)\to\R^n\times\GL_n(\R)$, $f\mapsto(f(0),df_0)$, is a homotopy equivalence.2776\end{exercise}2777 2778\begin{exercise}\label{exer:noncompact}2779Show that the isotopy of long knots described after \cref{thm:palais} is smooth, and that it is not induced2780by a diffeotopy of $\R^3$ if the knot is non-trivial.2781\end{exercise}2782 2783\begin{exercise}\label{exer:highcodim}2784Show from \cref{thm:whitneyiso} that any two embeddings of a circle in $\R^4$ are isotopic, and explain where2785the proof fails in $\R^3$.2786\end{exercise}2787%% ---- end ch/10-isotopy.tex ----2788%% ---- begin ch/11-surfaces.tex ----2789\chapter{Surfaces}\label{ch:surfaces}2790 2791The source ends by classifying compact surfaces, using everything before it: Morse functions to cut a2792surface into pieces, isotopy and gluing to recognise the pieces and put them back, the Euler characteristic2793and orientability to tell the results apart. It is the one dimension above $1$ in which the programme of the2794book can be carried to the end. The higher-categorical statements of the previous three chapters can also be2795carried to the end in dimension two, and this chapter does so. The classification theorem turns out to be the2796statement about components; the statements about higher homotopy are theorems of Earle and Eells and of2797Madsen and Weiss.2798 2799\section{The classification}2800 2801Let $\Sigma_g$ be the closed orientable surface of genus $g$, the sphere with $g$ handles, and $N_h$ the2802sphere with $h\ge1$ crosscaps.2803 2804\begin{theorem}[Classification of surfaces]\label{thm:classification}\Scl[Hirsch 9.3.5, 9.3.10, 9.3.11]2805Two compact connected surfaces are diffeomorphic if and only if they have the same Euler characteristic,2806the same number of boundary components, and are both orientable or both non-orientable. Every closed2807connected surface is diffeomorphic to exactly one $\Sigma_g$, with $\chi=2-2g$, or $N_h$, with $\chi=2-h$.2808Removing $b$ open discs lowers $\chi$ by $b$.2809\end{theorem}2810 2811Hirsch's proof takes a Morse function, orders its critical points, and inducts on the number of saddles.2812The pieces between consecutive critical levels are recognised by two lemmas: a connected surface carrying a2813Morse function with critical points only of index $0$ and $2$ and boundary a level set is a disc or an2814annulus (Hirsch 9.2), and a connected surface with a single critical point, a saddle, is a disc with two holes2815if it is orientable and a Möbius band with one hole if it is not (Hirsch 9.3.1--9.3.3; \cref{exer:pants}).2816The reassembly uses \cref{thm:gluing,thm:discs,thm:spheres}: gluing along circles depends only on the isotopy2817class of the gluing map, and a diffeomorphism of the circle is isotopic to the identity or a reflection.2818 2819\section{The monoid of surfaces}2820 2821Connected sum is well defined on connected surfaces up to diffeomorphism, by \cref{thm:discs} and the fact2822that every surface admits a diffeomorphism reversing the orientation of a small disc up to isotopy when it2823is non-orientable, and that $\Sigma_g$ admits an orientation-reversing diffeomorphism. Write $T=\Sigma_1$ and2824$P=\RP^2$.2825 2826\begin{corollary}\label{cor:monoid}\Scl[Hirsch 9.1.7]2827Under connected sum, the diffeomorphism classes of closed connected surfaces form the commutative monoid2828with unit $S^2$, generators $T$ and $P$, and the single relation $T\#P=P\#P\#P$.2829\end{corollary}2830 2831A surface is often presented by a word: a polygon with $2n$ sides labelled by $n$ letters, each occurring2832twice, with exponents giving the direction of identification. The quotient has one face and $n$ edges, so2833$\chi=V-n+1$ with $V$ the number of vertex classes, and it is orientable exactly when every letter occurs2834once with each exponent. The script computes $V$ by a union--find pass and identifies $aba^{-1}b^{-1}$ as2835the torus, $abab$ as the projective plane, $abab^{-1}$ as the Klein bottle, and so on (\cref{exer:words}).2836 2837\section{The classification as a presentation}2838 2839Let $2\cat{Cob}$ be the symmetric monoidal category whose objects are finite disjoint unions of circles and2840whose morphisms are diffeomorphism classes of compact oriented cobordisms: the homotopy category of2841$\Cob^{\mathrm{or}}_2$ of \cref{def:cobcat}. By \cref{thm:handle} every cobordism is a composite of the four2842elementary ones given by a single critical point: the disc as a cobordism $\emptyset\to S^1$ (index $0$) and2843$S^1\to\emptyset$ (index $2$), and the pair of pants as a cobordism from two circles to one and from one to2844two (index $1$).2845 2846\begin{theorem}\label{thm:2cob}\Scl[folklore; Abrams \cite{Abr96}; Kock \cite{Koc04}]2847$2\cat{Cob}$ is generated as a symmetric monoidal category by2848\[\eta\colon\emptyset\to S^1,\qquad\epsilon\colon S^1\to\emptyset,\qquad2849\mu\colon S^1\sqcup S^1\to S^1,\qquad\delta\colon S^1\to S^1\sqcup S^1,\]2850subject to the relations: $(\mu,\eta)$ is a commutative monoid, $(\delta,\epsilon)$ is a cocommutative2851comonoid, and2852$(\mu\sqcup\id)(\id\sqcup\delta)=\delta\mu=(\id\sqcup\mu)(\delta\sqcup\id)$.2853\end{theorem}2854 2855\begin{proof}[Where the classification enters]2856Generation is Morse theory. Using the relations, every connected composite of generators from $m$ circles to2857$n$ circles can be brought to the normal form $\delta^{n-1}(\mu\delta)^g\mu^{m-1}$, with $g$ the number of2858times a $\delta$ is followed by a $\mu$ that rejoins its two outputs. Two cobordisms with the same normal form2859are equal in the presented category. Conversely, two connected oriented cobordisms with the same $m$, $n$2860and $g$ are diffeomorphic by \cref{thm:classification}, since $g$ is the genus and $m+n$ the number of2861boundary components. So the functor from the presented category to $2\cat{Cob}$ is faithful as well as full.2862\end{proof}2863 2864The classification theorem is thus exactly the completeness of the relations. The same structure is visible2865one level up: by \cref{thm:cerf}, two Morse functions on the same cobordism are joined by a path with2866isolated births, deaths and crossings, and each such event is one of the relations of the theorem.2867 2868\section{Two-dimensional field theories}2869 2870A commutative \term{Frobenius algebra} over a field $k$ is a finite-dimensional commutative algebra $A$