Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism

View paper · Download original file

Lines 2691–2790 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.

2691\section{Embeddings, codimension, and calculus}2692 2693Embeddings do not satisfy an h-principle. Whether two embeddings are isotopic depends on the2694codimension, and the two extremes are classical.2695 2696\begin{theorem}\label{thm:whitneyiso}\Scl[Whitney; Wu; Haefliger]2697Let $V$ be a compact $m$-manifold. If $n\ge2m+2$, any two embeddings $V\to\R^n$ are isotopic. If $V$ is2698connected, $m\ge2$ and $n=2m+1$, the same holds.2699\end{theorem}2700 2701\begin{proof}[Proof of the first statement]2702Join the embeddings by the straight-line homotopy and regard it as a family2703$F\colon V\times I\to\R^n$. By the multijet transversality theorem one may perturb $F$, fixing the ends, so2704that the set $\{(x,y,t):x\ne y,\ F_t(x)=F_t(y)\}$, of expected dimension $2m+1-n<0$, is empty, and so that the2705set where $dF_t$ drops rank, of expected dimension $(m+1)-(n-m+1)<0$, is empty. Then every $F_t$ is an2706embedding.2707\end{proof}2708 2709This is the argument of \cref{cor:counts} with one more parameter. In codimension $2$ nothing of the kind2710holds: $\pi_0\Emb(S^1,\R^3)$ is the set of knot types. Between the extremes there is a systematic theory.2711 2712\begin{theorem}[Manifold calculus]\label{thm:weiss}2713\Sli[Weiss \cite{Wei99}; Goodwillie--Weiss \cite{GW99}; Goodwillie--Klein \cite{GK15}]2714For a presheaf of spaces $F$ on the open subsets of an $m$-manifold $V$ that takes isotopy equivalences to2715equivalences, let $T_kF(U)$ be the homotopy limit of $F(W)$ over the open $W\subset U$ diffeomorphic to a2716disjoint union of at most $k$ discs. Then $T_kF$ is the universal approximation to $F$ by a presheaf that is2717a homotopy sheaf for covers in which every set of at most $k$ points lies in some member. For2718$F=\Emb(-,M)$ with $\dim M=n$: $T_1F=\Imm(-,M)$, and the map2719$\Emb(V,M)\to T_k\Emb(V,M)$ is $(k(n-m-2)+1-m)$-connected. In particular, if $n-m\ge3$ then2720$\Emb(V,M)\simeq\operatorname{holim}_kT_k\Emb(V,M)$.2721\end{theorem}2722 2723So the Smale--Hirsch theorem is the linear approximation, and in codimension at least three the higher2724approximations converge. The limit has a description that does not mention $V$'s open sets.2725 2726\begin{theorem}\label{thm:BdBW}\Sli[Boavida de Brito--Weiss \cite{BW13}]2727$\operatorname{holim}_kT_k\Emb(V,M)$ is the space of derived maps $E_V\to E_M$ between the presheaves on2728discs defined by $V$ and $M$.2729\end{theorem}2730 2731In codimension at least three, then, the space of embeddings of $V$ in $M$ is determined by the2732configuration spaces of the two manifolds, with their tangential data and the maps among them: by how2733finitely many points sit in each. In codimension two the tower does not converge to the embedding space,2734but its stages are still invariants of knots, related to those of finite type.2735 2736\section{Factorization homology}2737 2738Presheaves on discs classify embeddings; copresheaves on discs give invariants of manifolds. Let $A$ be an2739algebra over the operad of \cref{thm:discs} in a symmetric monoidal $\infty$-category, that is, a symmetric2740monoidal functor on $\cat{Disc}_n$. Its \term{factorization homology} over an $n$-manifold $M$ is the2741colimit $\int_MA=\colim A(U)$ over the discs $U$ embedded in $M$.2742 2743\begin{theorem}\label{thm:AF}\Sli[Ayala--Francis \cite{AF15}; Lurie]2744$M\mapsto\int_MA$ is symmetric monoidal and satisfies excision: if $M=M_-\cup_{M_0\times\R}M_+$ is a2745decomposition along a collared hypersurface, then2746$\int_MA\simeq\int_{M_-}A\otimes_{\int_{M_0\times\R}A}\int_{M_+}A$. These properties characterize it.2747\end{theorem}2748 2749Excision is where \cref{thm:collar,thm:gluing} enter: a collar of $M_0$ is what makes $\int_{M_0\times\R}A$ an2750algebra and the two sides modules over it. For $n=1$ and $M=S^1$ the invariant is Hochschild homology,2751which for the algebra of functions on a manifold returns the differential forms of \cref{prop:three}.2752 2753\section*{Notes}2754 2755The fibration theorem is due independently to Palais and to Cerf, with a short proof by Lima. For the2756homotopy types of diffeomorphism groups see Smale, Hatcher, and the survey literature on pseudoisotopy;2757the failure in dimension four is due to Watanabe. Gromov's \emph{Partial Differential Relations} and the2758book of Eliashberg and Mishachev treat the h-principle. Manifold calculus is surveyed by Munson; the2759configuration-space description is \cite{BW13}. Factorization homology is developed in \cite{AF15} and in2760Lurie's \emph{Higher Algebra}.2761 2762\section*{Exercises}2763 2764\begin{exercise}\label{exer:flowex}2765Find the diffeotopy of $\R^2$ generated by $G(x,t)=(-x_2,x_1)$, and the velocity field of the diffeotopy2766$F_t(x)=e^{t}x$. Show that $x^2\partial_x$ does not generate a diffeotopy of $\R$.2767\end{exercise}2768 2769\begin{exercise}\label{exer:rotation}2770Compute the rotation numbers of the unit circle, the figure eight $(\sin t,\sin t\cos t)$ and the limaçon2771$r=1+2\cos\theta$. Which pairs are regularly homotopic?2772\end{exercise}2773 2774\begin{exercise}\label{exer:discRn}2775Show that $\Emb(D^n,\R^n)\to\R^n\times\GL_n(\R)$, $f\mapsto(f(0),df_0)$, is a homotopy equivalence.2776\end{exercise}2777 2778\begin{exercise}\label{exer:noncompact}2779Show that the isotopy of long knots described after \cref{thm:palais} is smooth, and that it is not induced2780by a diffeotopy of $\R^3$ if the knot is non-trivial.2781\end{exercise}2782 2783\begin{exercise}\label{exer:highcodim}2784Show from \cref{thm:whitneyiso} that any two embeddings of a circle in $\R^4$ are isotopic, and explain where2785the proof fails in $\R^3$.2786\end{exercise}2787%% ---- end ch/10-isotopy.tex ----2788%% ---- begin ch/11-surfaces.tex ----2789\chapter{Surfaces}\label{ch:surfaces}2790