Indexed text attachment
differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism
View paper · Download original file
Lines 2611–2710 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.
2611$V$ the quotient of $\Emb(V,M)$ by $\Diff(V)$ is the space of submanifolds of $M$ diffeomorphic to $V$, and the2612theorem says that the group $\Diff_c(M)$ acts on it with orbits that are unions of components.2613 2614Compactness is essential. Let $F_t\colon\R\to\R^3$ be a long knot whose knotted part sits at distance2615$1/(1-t)$ along the line, for $t<1$, and let $F_1$ be the straight line. This is an isotopy in the sense of2616\cref{def:isotopy}, smooth because on every compact set it is eventually constant, from a knotted line to an2617unknotted one; it cannot be ambient (\cref{exer:noncompact}). In the language of \cref{ch:function}, it is a2618plot of the mapping object that is not a path in the strong topology (\cref{prop:strongpath}).2619 2620\section{Embeddings of discs}2621 2622\begin{theorem}[Discs]\label{thm:discs}\Scl[Cerf, Palais; Hirsch 8.3.1 on $\pi_0$]2623For an $n$-manifold $M$, the map $\Emb(D^n,M)\to\Fr(TM)$, $f\mapsto(f(0),df_0)$, to the frame bundle is a2624homotopy equivalence. More generally $\Emb(D^k,M)$ is equivalent to the bundle of $k$-frames in $TM$, and2625$\Emb(\coprod_jD^n,M)$ to the pullback of $\Fr(TM)^j$ to the configuration space $\Conf_j(M)$.2626\end{theorem}2627 2628The proof is the Alexander-type shrinking of \cref{thm:tubcontract}: $f_t(x)=f(tx)$ rescaled deforms an2629embedding to its linear part (\cref{exer:discRn}). On components this is Hirsch's theorem that two2630embeddings of $D^k$ in a connected $M$ are isotopic, provided, when $k=n$ and $M$ is orientable, they induce2631the same orientation: the bundle of $k$-frames is connected for $k<n$, and $\Fr(TM)$ has one or two2632components according as $M$ is non-orientable or orientable. With \cref{thm:gluing} it makes the connected2633sum of connected oriented manifolds well defined.2634 2635For $M=\R^n$ the theorem identifies the spaces of embeddings of several discs in one:2636\[\Emb\bigl(\textstyle\coprod_j\R^n,\R^n\bigr)\ \simeq\ \Conf_j(\R^n)\times\Or(n)^j .\]2637These spaces, with composition of embeddings, form the framed little $n$-discs operad; restricting to2638embeddings that are rectilinear, or equivalently equipped with a trivialization of the derivative, gives the2639operad $E_n$. Write $\cat{Disc}_n$ for the symmetric monoidal $\infty$-category of finite disjoint unions of2640copies of $\R^n$ and their embeddings. Every $n$-manifold $M$ defines a presheaf2641$E_M=\Emb(-,M)$ on it, and \cref{thm:discs} says that this presheaf is assembled from the configuration2642spaces of $M$ and its tangent bundle.2643 2644\section{Diffeomorphisms of spheres}2645 2646\begin{theorem}\label{thm:spheres}\Scl[Hirsch 8.3.3; Smale; Hatcher; Cerf; Kervaire--Milnor]2647The inclusion $\Or(n+1)\to\Diff(S^n)$ is a homotopy equivalence for $n=1,2,3$. For $n\ge5$ the group2648$\pi_0\Diff^+(S^n)$ is isomorphic to the group $\Theta_{n+1}$ of exotic $(n+1)$-spheres, and is in general2649not trivial.2650\end{theorem}2651 2652Hirsch proves the statement on $\pi_0$ for $n=1$: every diffeomorphism of the circle is isotopic to the2653identity or to a reflection. The case $n=2$ is Smale's, $n=3$ is Hatcher's, and for $n=4$ the inclusion is2654known not to be an equivalence. The contrast with \cref{thm:discs} is instructive. Embeddings of a disc into2655a manifold are governed by linear algebra in every dimension; diffeomorphisms of a disc fixing the boundary2656are not, and the difference is the subject of pseudoisotopy theory.2657 2658\section{Immersions}2659 2660For immersions the passage from differential conditions to homotopy theory is complete.2661 2662\begin{theorem}[Smale--Hirsch]\label{thm:SH}\Scl[Smale \cite{Sma59}; Hirsch \cite{Hir59}]2663Let $\dim V<\dim M$, or $\dim V=\dim M$ with $V$ having no closed component. Then the differential2664\[\Imm(V,M)\longrightarrow\operatorname{Mono}(TV,TM)\]2665to the space of fibrewise injective bundle maps is a weak homotopy equivalence.2666\end{theorem}2667 2668In the diagram at the end of \cref{ch:function}, this says that for the open relation2669$\mathcal R\subset J^1(V,M)$ of injective $1$-jets the inclusion of holonomic sections into all sections2670induces an equivalence of shapes. Gromov's formulation explains why. The presheaf $U\mapsto\Imm(U,M)$ on2671the open subsets of $V$ takes unions of open sets along handles to homotopy pullbacks, by a restriction2672theorem like \cref{thm:palais} that holds for immersions without any compactness hypothesis on the2673complement; so it is a homotopy sheaf, determined by its values on discs; and on a disc2674$\Imm(D^m,M)\simeq\Emb(D^m,M)$ is the bundle of $m$-frames by \cref{thm:discs}. A homotopy sheaf with those2675values is the sheaf of sections of a bundle, namely $\operatorname{Mono}(TV,TM)$.2676 2677\begin{corollary}\label{cor:WG}\Scl[Whitney--Graustein; Smale]2678Regular homotopy classes of immersions $S^1\to\R^2$ are classified by the rotation number, an integer. All2679immersions $S^2\to\R^3$ are regularly homotopic; in particular the sphere can be turned inside out.2680\end{corollary}2681 2682\begin{proof}2683Up to homotopy $\operatorname{Mono}(TS^1,T\R^2)$ is the free loop space of the circle of unit vectors, whose2684components are indexed by degree. For the sphere the relevant group is $\pi_2$ of the space of $2$-frames in2685$\R^3$, which is $\pi_2(\SO(3))=0$.2686\end{proof}2687 2688The rotation numbers of the circle, the figure eight and the limaçon $r=1+2\cos\theta$ are $1$, $0$ and $2$;2689the script computes them by accumulating the angle of the tangent.2690 2691\section{Embeddings, codimension, and calculus}2692 2693Embeddings do not satisfy an h-principle. Whether two embeddings are isotopic depends on the2694codimension, and the two extremes are classical.2695 2696\begin{theorem}\label{thm:whitneyiso}\Scl[Whitney; Wu; Haefliger]2697Let $V$ be a compact $m$-manifold. If $n\ge2m+2$, any two embeddings $V\to\R^n$ are isotopic. If $V$ is2698connected, $m\ge2$ and $n=2m+1$, the same holds.2699\end{theorem}2700 2701\begin{proof}[Proof of the first statement]2702Join the embeddings by the straight-line homotopy and regard it as a family2703$F\colon V\times I\to\R^n$. By the multijet transversality theorem one may perturb $F$, fixing the ends, so2704that the set $\{(x,y,t):x\ne y,\ F_t(x)=F_t(y)\}$, of expected dimension $2m+1-n<0$, is empty, and so that the2705set where $dF_t$ drops rank, of expected dimension $(m+1)-(n-m+1)<0$, is empty. Then every $F_t$ is an2706embedding.2707\end{proof}2708 2709This is the argument of \cref{cor:counts} with one more parameter. In codimension $2$ nothing of the kind2710holds: $\pi_0\Emb(S^1,\R^3)$ is the set of knot types. Between the extremes there is a systematic theory.