Indexed text attachment
differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism
View paper · Download original file
Lines 2371–2470 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.
2371 2372Let $M\subset\R^{n+k}$ be a closed $n$-manifold. The collapse of \cref{ch:tubular}, followed by the map of2373Thom spaces induced by the classifying map of the normal bundle (\cref{ch:bundles}), is a map2374\[S^{n+k}\longrightarrow\Th(\nu)\longrightarrow\Th(\gamma_k),\]2375where $\gamma_k$ is the tautological bundle over $\Gr_k(\R^s)$ for $s$ large.2376 2377\begin{theorem}[Pontryagin--Thom]\label{thm:PT}\Scl[Pontryagin \cite{Pon55}; Thom \cite{Tho54}; Hirsch 7.2.3]2378For $f\colon S^{n+k}\to\Th(\gamma_k)$ transverse to the zero section, $f\mapsto[f^{-1}(\Gr_k(\R^s))]$ defines a2379homomorphism $\pi_{n+k}\bigl(\Th(\gamma_k\to\Gr_k(\R^s))\bigr)\to\mathfrak N_n$ that is surjective if $k>n$ and2380$s\ge k+n$ and bijective if $k>n+1$ and $s\ge k+n+1$; the construction above is its inverse. Stably,2381\[\mathfrak N_n\cong\pi_n(MO),\qquad\Omega_n\cong\pi_n(MSO),\qquad\Omega^{\mathrm{fr}}_n\cong\pi_n(\mathbb S),\]2382and in general $\Omega^\theta_n\cong\pi_n(M\theta)$ for a stable tangential structure $\theta\colon B\to B\Or$,2383where $M\theta$ is the Thom spectrum of $\theta$.2384\end{theorem}2385 2386\begin{proof}[Structure of the proof]2387Well-definedness: the embedding and the tubular neighbourhood are contractible choices2388(\cref{thm:embcontract,thm:tubcontract}), and a cobordism embedded in $\R^{n+k}\times I$ collapses to a2389homotopy. Inverse: a map $f\colon S^{n+k}\to\Th(\gamma_k)$ can be made transverse to the zero section2390(\cref{thm:transversality}), and $M=f^{-1}(\Gr_k)$ is a closed $n$-manifold with normal bundle pulled back from2391$\gamma_k$; a homotopy made transverse gives a cobordism (\cref{lem:fibre}). The dimension restrictions come2392from \cref{thm:whitney,thm:classify}.2393\end{proof}2394 2395The theorem is \cref{prin:generic} for the cospan $S^{n+k}\to\Th(\gamma_k)\leftarrow\Gr_k$: every map to a Thom2396space has a derived preimage of the zero section, which has a cobordism class, and the class determines the2397map up to homotopy.2398 2399\section{Thom's computation}2400 2401\begin{theorem}[Thom]\label{thm:thom}\Scl[\cite{Tho54}]2402$MO$ is a wedge of suspensions of the Eilenberg--MacLane spectrum $H\Z/2$, and2403\[\mathfrak N_*\cong\Z/2\,[x_i:\ i\ge2,\ i\ne2^j-1],\qquad|x_i|=i,\]2404with $x_{2i}$ the class of $\RP^{2i}$. A closed manifold is a boundary if and only if all its Stiefel--Whitney2405numbers vanish.2406\end{theorem}2407 2408So $\dim_{\Z/2}\mathfrak N_n$ is the number of partitions of $n$ into parts not of the form $2^j-1$: for2409$n=0,\dots,10$ these are $1,0,1,0,2,1,3,1,5,3,8$. For a partition $n=i_1+\dots+i_r$ the2410\term{Stiefel--Whitney number} is $\langle w_{i_1}\cdots w_{i_r}(TM),[M]\rangle\in\Z/2$. It vanishes on a2411boundary $M=\partial W$ because $TW|_M=TM\oplus\R$, so the class being evaluated is restricted from $W$, and2412the fundamental class of a boundary maps to zero in the homology of $W$.2413 2414\begin{example}\label{ex:sw}2415The total Stiefel--Whitney class of $\RP^n$ is $(1+a)^{n+1}$ with $a$ the generator of $H^1$. For $\RP^2$,2416$w=1+a+a^2$, and $w_2[\RP^2]=w_1^2[\RP^2]=1$: not a boundary. For $\RP^3$, $w=(1+a)^4=1$: all numbers vanish2417and $\RP^3$ bounds. In dimension $4$ the numbers $(w_1^4,w_1^2w_2,w_2^2,w_1w_3,w_4)$ are $(1,0,0,0,1)$ for2418$\RP^4$ and $(0,0,1,0,1)$ for $\RP^2\times\RP^2$. The two manifolds are independent in2419$\mathfrak N_4=(\Z/2)^2$; they are $x_4$ and $x_2^2$. The script computes these numbers and the ranks above.2420\end{example}2421 2422\begin{theorem}\label{thm:oriented}\Scl[Thom; Hirsch 7.2.4]2423$\Omega_n$ is finite if $n$ is not divisible by $4$, and $\Omega_{4k}$ has rank equal to the number of2424partitions of $k$. Rationally, $\Omega_*\otimes\mathbb Q=\mathbb Q[\CP^2,\CP^4,\dots]$.2425\end{theorem}2426 2427\section{Thom spectra as colimits}2428 2429The spectra $MO$, $MSO$, $M\theta$ were defined by Thom spaces of bundles over Grassmannians. There is a2430description in which no bundle appears.2431 2432\begin{theorem}\label{thm:ABGHR}\Sli[Ando--Blumberg--Gepner--Hopkins--Rezk \cite{ABGHR14}]2433Let $\operatorname{Pic}(\mathbb S)$ be the $\infty$-groupoid of invertible spectra. A stable vector bundle on a2434space $X$ determines a map $X\to B\Or\xrightarrow{J}\operatorname{Pic}(\mathbb S)$, sending a point to the2435one-point compactification of the fibre, and its Thom spectrum is the colimit of the composite functor2436$X\to\operatorname{Pic}(\mathbb S)\subset\Sp$. In particular $MO=\colim(B\Or\to\Sp)$ is the homotopy2437quotient of the sphere spectrum by the stable orthogonal group, and it is an $E_\infty$-ring because $J$ is2438an infinite loop map. For an $E_\infty$-ring $R$, $E_\infty$-ring maps $MO\to R$ correspond to2439null-homotopies of $B\Or\to B\GL_1(R)$ as infinite loop maps.2440\end{theorem}2441 2442For a trivial bundle the diagram is constant and the colimit is $\Sigma^\infty_+X$, which is2443\cref{prop:thom}. The description makes the Thom isomorphism a formal consequence of an orientation, a2444trivialization of the diagram after smashing with $R$. And it gives a reading of \cref{thm:PT}: framed2445cobordism is the sphere spectrum, and unoriented cobordism is what is left when one divides by all changes2446of framing.2447 2448\section{Cobordism categories}2449 2450The groups $\mathfrak N_n$ remember that a cobordism exists. The cobordism category remembers the2451cobordisms.2452 2453\begin{definition}\label{def:cobcat}2454$\Cob_d$ is the $\infty$-category whose objects are closed $(d-1)$-manifolds and whose space of morphisms2455from $M_0$ to $M_1$ is $\coprod_{[W]}B\Diff(W\text{ rel }\partial W)$, the union over diffeomorphism classes2456of cobordisms. Composition is gluing (\cref{thm:gluing}). Disjoint union makes it symmetric monoidal. With a2457tangential structure $\theta\colon B\to B\Or(d)$ on the cobordisms one writes $\Cob^\theta_d$.2458\end{definition}2459 2460A concrete model takes objects to be closed submanifolds of $\R^\infty$ and morphisms to be submanifolds of2461$[a_0,a_1]\times\R^\infty$ that are products near the ends; by \cref{thm:embcontract} the embeddings add2462nothing, and by \cref{thm:collar} neither do the product conditions. The set of components of the2463classifying space $B\Cob_d$ is the set of objects modulo the relation generated by morphisms, which is2464$\mathfrak N_{d-1}$.2465 2466\begin{theorem}[Galatius--Madsen--Tillmann--Weiss]\label{thm:GMTW}\Sli[\cite{GMTW09}]2467Let $MTO(d)$ be the Thom spectrum of the virtual bundle $-\gamma_d$ over $B\Or(d)$. Then2468\[B\Cob_d\ \simeq\ \Omega^{\infty-1}MTO(d),\]2469and likewise $B\Cob^\theta_d\simeq\Omega^{\infty-1}MT\theta(d)$ for every tangential structure $\theta$.2470\end{theorem}