Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism

View paper · Download original file

Lines 2341–2440 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.

2341%% ---- begin ch/09-cobordism.tex ----2342\chapter{Cobordism}\label{ch:cobordism}2343 2344In the source, cobordism occupies a short chapter: the groups are defined, the Pontryagin--Thom construction2345is carried out, and Thom's theorem identifying cobordism groups with homotopy groups of Thom spaces is proved2346in the range the earlier chapters allow. It is the place where the three tools of the book (classifying maps,2347tubular neighbourhoods, transversality) are used together. It is also the place from which the2348higher-categorical view of manifolds grew. This chapter states the classical results and then the two2349modern ones that extend them: the homotopy type of the cobordism category, and the cobordism hypothesis.2350 2351\section{Cobordism groups}2352 2353\begin{definition}\label{def:cob}2354Closed $n$-manifolds $M_0,M_1$ are \term{cobordant} if there is a compact $(n+1)$-manifold $W$ with2355$\partial W\cong M_0\sqcup M_1$. The set of classes is $\mathfrak N_n$. For oriented manifolds one requires2356$W$ oriented with $\partial W\cong M_1\sqcup-M_0$, and the set of classes is $\Omega_n$.2357\end{definition}2358 2359\begin{theorem}\label{thm:cobring}\Scl[Thom; Hirsch 7.1.1]2360Disjoint union makes $\mathfrak N_n$ and $\Omega_n$ abelian groups, and product makes2361$\mathfrak N_*$ and $\Omega_*$ graded rings, commutative in the graded sense. Every element of2362$\mathfrak N_*$ has order $2$.2363\end{theorem}2364 2365Transitivity of the relation uses \cref{thm:gluing}; the inverse of $[M]$ is $[-M]$, with $M\times I$ as the2366null-cobordism of $M\sqcup-M$. In low dimensions $\mathfrak N_0=\Z/2$, $\Omega_0=\Z$,2367$\mathfrak N_1=\Omega_1=0$, and $\mathfrak N_2=\Z/2$, $\Omega_2=0$ by the classification of surfaces2368(\cref{ch:surfaces}).2369 2370\section{The Pontryagin--Thom theorem}2371 2372Let $M\subset\R^{n+k}$ be a closed $n$-manifold. The collapse of \cref{ch:tubular}, followed by the map of2373Thom spaces induced by the classifying map of the normal bundle (\cref{ch:bundles}), is a map2374\[S^{n+k}\longrightarrow\Th(\nu)\longrightarrow\Th(\gamma_k),\]2375where $\gamma_k$ is the tautological bundle over $\Gr_k(\R^s)$ for $s$ large.2376 2377\begin{theorem}[Pontryagin--Thom]\label{thm:PT}\Scl[Pontryagin \cite{Pon55}; Thom \cite{Tho54}; Hirsch 7.2.3]2378For $f\colon S^{n+k}\to\Th(\gamma_k)$ transverse to the zero section, $f\mapsto[f^{-1}(\Gr_k(\R^s))]$ defines a2379homomorphism $\pi_{n+k}\bigl(\Th(\gamma_k\to\Gr_k(\R^s))\bigr)\to\mathfrak N_n$ that is surjective if $k>n$ and2380$s\ge k+n$ and bijective if $k>n+1$ and $s\ge k+n+1$; the construction above is its inverse. Stably,2381\[\mathfrak N_n\cong\pi_n(MO),\qquad\Omega_n\cong\pi_n(MSO),\qquad\Omega^{\mathrm{fr}}_n\cong\pi_n(\mathbb S),\]2382and in general $\Omega^\theta_n\cong\pi_n(M\theta)$ for a stable tangential structure $\theta\colon B\to B\Or$,2383where $M\theta$ is the Thom spectrum of $\theta$.2384\end{theorem}2385 2386\begin{proof}[Structure of the proof]2387Well-definedness: the embedding and the tubular neighbourhood are contractible choices2388(\cref{thm:embcontract,thm:tubcontract}), and a cobordism embedded in $\R^{n+k}\times I$ collapses to a2389homotopy. Inverse: a map $f\colon S^{n+k}\to\Th(\gamma_k)$ can be made transverse to the zero section2390(\cref{thm:transversality}), and $M=f^{-1}(\Gr_k)$ is a closed $n$-manifold with normal bundle pulled back from2391$\gamma_k$; a homotopy made transverse gives a cobordism (\cref{lem:fibre}). The dimension restrictions come2392from \cref{thm:whitney,thm:classify}.2393\end{proof}2394 2395The theorem is \cref{prin:generic} for the cospan $S^{n+k}\to\Th(\gamma_k)\leftarrow\Gr_k$: every map to a Thom2396space has a derived preimage of the zero section, which has a cobordism class, and the class determines the2397map up to homotopy.2398 2399\section{Thom's computation}2400 2401\begin{theorem}[Thom]\label{thm:thom}\Scl[\cite{Tho54}]2402$MO$ is a wedge of suspensions of the Eilenberg--MacLane spectrum $H\Z/2$, and2403\[\mathfrak N_*\cong\Z/2\,[x_i:\ i\ge2,\ i\ne2^j-1],\qquad|x_i|=i,\]2404with $x_{2i}$ the class of $\RP^{2i}$. A closed manifold is a boundary if and only if all its Stiefel--Whitney2405numbers vanish.2406\end{theorem}2407 2408So $\dim_{\Z/2}\mathfrak N_n$ is the number of partitions of $n$ into parts not of the form $2^j-1$: for2409$n=0,\dots,10$ these are $1,0,1,0,2,1,3,1,5,3,8$. For a partition $n=i_1+\dots+i_r$ the2410\term{Stiefel--Whitney number} is $\langle w_{i_1}\cdots w_{i_r}(TM),[M]\rangle\in\Z/2$. It vanishes on a2411boundary $M=\partial W$ because $TW|_M=TM\oplus\R$, so the class being evaluated is restricted from $W$, and2412the fundamental class of a boundary maps to zero in the homology of $W$.2413 2414\begin{example}\label{ex:sw}2415The total Stiefel--Whitney class of $\RP^n$ is $(1+a)^{n+1}$ with $a$ the generator of $H^1$. For $\RP^2$,2416$w=1+a+a^2$, and $w_2[\RP^2]=w_1^2[\RP^2]=1$: not a boundary. For $\RP^3$, $w=(1+a)^4=1$: all numbers vanish2417and $\RP^3$ bounds. In dimension $4$ the numbers $(w_1^4,w_1^2w_2,w_2^2,w_1w_3,w_4)$ are $(1,0,0,0,1)$ for2418$\RP^4$ and $(0,0,1,0,1)$ for $\RP^2\times\RP^2$. The two manifolds are independent in2419$\mathfrak N_4=(\Z/2)^2$; they are $x_4$ and $x_2^2$. The script computes these numbers and the ranks above.2420\end{example}2421 2422\begin{theorem}\label{thm:oriented}\Scl[Thom; Hirsch 7.2.4]2423$\Omega_n$ is finite if $n$ is not divisible by $4$, and $\Omega_{4k}$ has rank equal to the number of2424partitions of $k$. Rationally, $\Omega_*\otimes\mathbb Q=\mathbb Q[\CP^2,\CP^4,\dots]$.2425\end{theorem}2426 2427\section{Thom spectra as colimits}2428 2429The spectra $MO$, $MSO$, $M\theta$ were defined by Thom spaces of bundles over Grassmannians. There is a2430description in which no bundle appears.2431 2432\begin{theorem}\label{thm:ABGHR}\Sli[Ando--Blumberg--Gepner--Hopkins--Rezk \cite{ABGHR14}]2433Let $\operatorname{Pic}(\mathbb S)$ be the $\infty$-groupoid of invertible spectra. A stable vector bundle on a2434space $X$ determines a map $X\to B\Or\xrightarrow{J}\operatorname{Pic}(\mathbb S)$, sending a point to the2435one-point compactification of the fibre, and its Thom spectrum is the colimit of the composite functor2436$X\to\operatorname{Pic}(\mathbb S)\subset\Sp$. In particular $MO=\colim(B\Or\to\Sp)$ is the homotopy2437quotient of the sphere spectrum by the stable orthogonal group, and it is an $E_\infty$-ring because $J$ is2438an infinite loop map. For an $E_\infty$-ring $R$, $E_\infty$-ring maps $MO\to R$ correspond to2439null-homotopies of $B\Or\to B\GL_1(R)$ as infinite loop maps.2440\end{theorem}