Indexed text attachment
differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism
View paper · Download original file
Lines 1751–1850 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.
1751\toprule1752choice & what it makes well defined\\1753\midrule1754inner product on a vector bundle & reduction $B\GL_k\simeq B\Or(k)$; sphere and disc bundles\\1755Riemannian metric on $M$ & exponential maps, gradients\\1756connection on a bundle & parallel transport, \cref{thm:bundlehomotopy}\\1757partition of unity subordinate to a cover & gluing of local constructions\\1758tubular neighbourhood of $M\subset N$ & collapse maps, normal data\\1759collar of $\partial M$ & gluing, composition of cobordisms\\1760embedding $M\to\R^\infty$ & stable normal bundle; a model of $B\Diff(M)$\\1761\bottomrule1762\end{tabular}1763\caption{Contractible spaces of choices.}\label{tab:choices}1764\end{table}1765 1766\begin{theorem}\label{thm:embcontract}\Scl[Whitney]1767For every manifold $M$ the space $\Emb(M,\R^\infty)=\colim_q\Emb(M,\R^q)$ is weakly contractible.1768\end{theorem}1769 1770It is non-empty by \cref{thm:whitney}. Contractibility is a two-step linear homotopy: move a family of1771embeddings into the odd coordinates, then slide it to a fixed embedding placed in the even coordinates1772(\cref{exer:shift}). The group $\Diff(M)$ acts freely on $\Emb(M,\R^\infty)$, and the quotient, the space of1773submanifolds of $\R^\infty$ diffeomorphic to $M$, is therefore a model for the classifying space1774$B\Diff(M)$. A map $B\to B\Diff(M)$ is a family of submanifolds of $\R^\infty$ parametrized by $B$, that is, a1775bundle of manifolds with fibre $M$; this is the last row of \cref{tab:oka}.1776 1777\section{The collapse map and Thom spaces}1778 1779\begin{definition}\label{def:thom}1780The \term{Thom space} $\Th(\xi)$ of a vector bundle $\xi$ over a compact base is the one-point1781compactification of its total space; equivalently the quotient $D(\xi)/S(\xi)$ of the unit disc bundle by1782the unit sphere bundle, for any inner product.1783\end{definition}1784 1785\begin{proposition}\label{prop:thom}\Scl1786$\Th(\xi\times\eta)\cong\Th(\xi)\wedge\Th(\eta)$; $\Th(\xi\oplus\R^j)\cong\Sigma^j\Th(\xi)$; the Thom space of1787the trivial bundle $M\times\R^k$ is $\Sigma^kM_+$; and the Thom space of the tautological line bundle over1788$\RP^n$ is $\RP^{n+1}$.1789\end{proposition}1790 1791Let $M\subset\R^{n+k}$ be a closed submanifold of dimension $n$ with a tubular neighbourhood1792$\varphi\colon\nu\to U$. The \term{Pontryagin--Thom collapse} is the map1793\[c\colon S^{n+k}=\R^{n+k}\cup\{\infty\}\longrightarrow U^+\cong\Th(\nu)\]1794that is $\varphi^{-1}$ on $U$ and sends everything else to the point at infinity. More generally an1795embedding $M\subset N$ of closed manifolds gives $N_+\to\Th(\nu(M,N))$. By \cref{thm:tubcontract} and1796\cref{prin:choices} the collapse is a well-defined point of a mapping space, not merely a homotopy1797class. It is a map in the wrong direction, from the ambient manifold to (a twisted suspension of) the1798submanifold, and it is the geometric source of all wrong-way maps in cohomology.1799 1800The Thom space depends on the embedding only through a suspension. By \cref{thm:embcontract} the1801desuspended suspension spectrum1802\[M^{-TM}=\Sigma^{-(n+k)}\Sigma^\infty\Th(\nu)\]1803is well defined; it is the Thom spectrum of the stable normal bundle $\nu_M=-TM$.1804 1805\begin{theorem}[Atiyah duality]\label{thm:atiyah}\Scl[Atiyah \cite{Ati61}; Milnor--Spanier]1806For a closed manifold $M$ the suspension spectrum $\Sigma^\infty_+M$ is dualizable in the stable homotopy1807category, with dual $M^{-TM}$. The coevaluation $\mathbb S\to\Sigma^\infty_+M\wedge M^{-TM}$ is the collapse1808$S^{n+k}\to\Th(\nu)$ followed by the diagonal $\Th(\nu)\to M_+\wedge\Th(\nu)$. The evaluation is the collapse1809for the diagonal embedding $M\to M\times M$, whose normal bundle is $TM$.1810\end{theorem}1811 1812Dualizability and its use are recalled in \cref{app:toolkit}. The theorem is the homotopy-theoretic form of1813Poincaré duality, and \cref{ch:degree} uses it to compute Euler characteristics.1814 1815\section{The normal bundle without choices}1816 1817There is a short exact sequence $0\to TM\to TN|_M\to\nu\to0$, so the normal bundle is the cofibre of the1818map of tangent bundles; in the notation of \cref{ch:transversality} it is the degree-$1$ part of the1819relative tangent complex of $M\to N$. The tubular neighbourhood theorem says that the germ of $N1820$ along $M$ is diffeomorphic to the germ of $\nu$ along its zero section. There is a canonical object behind1821the non-canonical diffeomorphism.1822 1823\begin{proposition}[Deformation to the normal bundle]\label{prop:deformation}\Scl1824There is a manifold $\mathcal D(M,N)$ with a submersion to $\R$ whose fibre over $t\ne0$ is $N$ and whose1825fibre over $0$ is $\nu(M,N)$, containing $M\times\R$ as a closed submanifold. It is functorial for maps of1826pairs. A tubular neighbourhood is a trivialization of this family near $M\times\R$.1827\end{proposition}1828 1829For the diagonal $M\subset M\times M$ this is Connes's tangent groupoid, interpolating between the pair1830groupoid of $M$ and the tangent bundle. The proposition illustrates a general pattern: where the classical1831text makes a choice and proves uniqueness up to isotopy, there is usually a canonical object in a larger1832category of which the choices are trivializations.1833 1834By \cref{ex:derived}(c) the derived self-intersection $M\times^h_NM$ depends only on the normal bundle: its1835functions are $\Gamma(\Lambda^\bullet\nu^\vee)$. Its virtual dimension is $2\dim M-\dim N$, and its cobordism1836class is that of the zero set of a generic section of $\nu$ (\cref{prop:clean}).1837 1838\section*{Notes}1839 1840Hirsch's proofs of uniqueness of tubular neighbourhoods and collars give isotopies depending continuously on1841the data, which is most of the way to contractibility; the statements with parameters are spelled out in1842\cite{God07} and in the literature on cobordism categories \cite{GMTW09}. The collapse map is Pontryagin's1843for framed submanifolds and Thom's in general. For Thom spectra of virtual bundles and their multiplicative1844properties see \cite{ABGHR14}. The deformation to the normal cone is due to Fulton and MacPherson in1845algebraic geometry; the smooth version is in Connes's and Higson's work on index theory.1846 1847\section*{Exercises}1848 1849\begin{exercise}\label{exer:gram}1850Show that the space of inner products on a finite-dimensional real vector space is convex, and that