Independent scholarship · Open accessThe monthly digest

Indexed text attachment

differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex

Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism

View paper · Download original file

Lines 1671–1770 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.

1671 1672The second half of Hirsch's fourth chapter proves that a submanifold has a tubular neighbourhood, that the1673boundary of a manifold has a collar, and that each is unique up to isotopy. The uniqueness statements are1674what allow later constructions (connected sums, gluing of cobordisms, the Pontryagin--Thom collapse) to be1675called well defined. ``Unique up to isotopy'' says that a space of choices is connected. In every case in1676this chapter the space of choices is in fact contractible, and that stronger statement is what makes the1677constructions functorial.1678 1679\section{Tubular neighbourhoods}1680 1681\begin{definition}\label{def:tub}1682Let $M\subset N$ be a submanifold, both without boundary. A \term{tubular neighbourhood} of $M$ in $N$ is a1683vector bundle $\xi=(p,E,M)$ with an embedding $\varphi\colon E\to N$ onto an open set that restricts to the1684identity on the zero section. The \term{normal bundle} is $\nu=\nu(M,N)=TN|_M/TM$.1685\end{definition}1686 1687The differential of $\varphi$ along the zero section identifies $\xi$ with $\nu$, so one may take $\xi=\nu$.1688 1689\begin{theorem}[Tubular neighbourhoods]\label{thm:tubular}\Scl[Hirsch 4.5.2, 4.5.3]1690Every submanifold $M\subset N$ has a tubular neighbourhood, and any two are isotopic relative to $M$.1691\end{theorem}1692 1693The existence proof embeds $N$ in a Euclidean space, uses the normal exponential map1694$(x,v)\mapsto x+v$ there, which is a local diffeomorphism along the zero section by the inverse function1695theorem, and retracts back to $N$. For the unit circle in the plane the map is1696$(\theta,t)\mapsto(1+t)(\cos\theta,\sin\theta)$, with Jacobian determinant $1+t$; it is an embedding for1697$t>-1$. In general the radius is limited by the focal points of $M$ (\cref{exer:focal}).1698 1699\begin{theorem}\label{thm:tubcontract}\Sli[folklore; see \cite{God07}]1700The space $\Tub(M,N)$ of tubular neighbourhoods $\varphi\colon\nu\to N$ whose differential along the zero1701section induces the identity of $\nu$ is contractible.1702\end{theorem}1703 1704\begin{proof}[Idea of proof]1705Given two, first shrink one fibrewise until its image lies in the image of the other; this is a canonical1706path. Then $\psi=\varphi_0^{-1}\varphi_1$ is an embedding of $\nu$ in itself, fixing the zero section, with1707fibre derivative the identity there, and $\psi_t(v)=\psi(tv)/t$ for $0<t\le1$ extends smoothly to $t=0$ by the1708identity. Both steps depend continuously on parameters.1709\end{proof}1710 1711With boundary, the right notion is that of a neat submanifold (\cref{def:neat}), and the theorems hold with1712tubular neighbourhoods that restrict to tubular neighbourhoods in the boundary (Hirsch 4.6.3, 4.6.4).1713 1714\section{Collars and gluing}1715 1716\begin{theorem}[Collars]\label{thm:collar}\Scl[Brown; Hirsch 4.6.1]1717For a manifold $M$ with boundary there is an embedding $\partial M\times[0,\infty)\to M$ extending the1718identity of $\partial M\times0$. Any two are isotopic, and the space of collars is contractible.1719\end{theorem}1720 1721\begin{theorem}[Gluing]\label{thm:gluing}\Scl[Hirsch 8.2.1, 8.2.3]1722Let $P,Q$ be manifolds with boundary and $f\colon\partial Q\to\partial P$ a diffeomorphism. The space1723$P\cup_fQ$ has a smooth structure restricting to the given ones on $P$ and $Q$; any two such structures are1724diffeomorphic by a diffeomorphism supported near the seam; and isotopic gluing maps give diffeomorphic1725results.1726\end{theorem}1727 1728The smooth structure is built by choosing collars on both sides and declaring the union of the two collars1729to be a product neighbourhood of the seam. So composition of cobordisms is defined only after a choice, and1730the choice is from a contractible space. A category whose composition depends on contractible choices is1731an $\infty$-category presented in the usual way, and this is the elementary reason that cobordism categories1732are $\infty$-categories (\cref{ch:cobordism}). The dependence on the isotopy class of $f$ is real: gluing two1733discs along a diffeomorphism of $S^{n-1}$ not isotopic to one that extends over the disc can give an exotic1734sphere (\cref{exer:alexander}).1735 1736\section{Contractible spaces of choices}1737 1738\begin{principle}[Choices]\label{prin:choices}\Srf1739Let $p\colon\mathcal E\to\mathcal B$ be a map of spaces whose fibres are contractible. Then $p$ is an1740equivalence, and every functor on $\mathcal E$ factors essentially uniquely through $\mathcal B$. A1741construction on objects $b$ that requires a choice $c$ from a contractible space $\mathcal E_b$ is1742therefore as good as a construction on the objects alone.1743\end{principle}1744 1745\Cref{tab:choices} lists the cases used in this book. The first four are convex or affine and need no1746argument. The fifth and sixth are \cref{thm:tubcontract,thm:collar}. The seventh is Whitney's theorem with1747parameters.1748 1749\begin{table}[ht]\centering\small1750\begin{tabular}{@{}p{0.42\textwidth}p{0.46\textwidth}@{}}1751\toprule1752choice & what it makes well defined\\1753\midrule1754inner product on a vector bundle & reduction $B\GL_k\simeq B\Or(k)$; sphere and disc bundles\\1755Riemannian metric on $M$ & exponential maps, gradients\\1756connection on a bundle & parallel transport, \cref{thm:bundlehomotopy}\\1757partition of unity subordinate to a cover & gluing of local constructions\\1758tubular neighbourhood of $M\subset N$ & collapse maps, normal data\\1759collar of $\partial M$ & gluing, composition of cobordisms\\1760embedding $M\to\R^\infty$ & stable normal bundle; a model of $B\Diff(M)$\\1761\bottomrule1762\end{tabular}1763\caption{Contractible spaces of choices.}\label{tab:choices}1764\end{table}1765 1766\begin{theorem}\label{thm:embcontract}\Scl[Whitney]1767For every manifold $M$ the space $\Emb(M,\R^\infty)=\colim_q\Emb(M,\R^q)$ is weakly contractible.1768\end{theorem}1769 1770It is non-empty by \cref{thm:whitney}. Contractibility is a two-step linear homotopy: move a family of