Indexed text attachment
differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism
View paper · Download original file
Lines 1331–1430 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.
1331 1332Locally every derived fibre product of manifolds is a derived zero locus, and those can be written down.1333 1334\begin{proposition}[Koszul model]\label{prop:koszul}\Sli[\cite{Spi10}, \cite{CS19}]1335Let $E\to M$ be a vector bundle of rank $k$ with a section $s$, and let1336$Z(s)=M\times^h_{s,E,0}M$ be the derived zero locus. Its simplicial $C^\infty$-ring corresponds to the1337commutative differential graded algebra1338\[\bigl(\Gamma(\Lambda^\bullet E^\vee),\ \iota_s\bigr):\qquad1339\cdots\to\Gamma(\Lambda^2E^\vee)\xrightarrow{\ \iota_s\ }\Gamma(E^\vee)\xrightarrow{\ \iota_s\ }C^\infty(M),\]1340so $\pi_0=C^\infty(M)/(s)$. If $s$ is transverse to the zero section then $\pi_k=0$ for $k>0$ and1341$Z(s)=i\bigl(s^{-1}(0)\bigr)$. For maps $f\colon M\to N$ and $g\colon P\to N$, the derived fibre product1342$M\times^h_NP$ is the derived zero locus of a section of $(f\times g)^*TN$ over a neighbourhood of1343$M\times_NP$ in $M\times P$.1344\end{proposition}1345 1346The number $\vdim Z(s)=\dim M-k$ is the \term{virtual dimension}; for a derived fibre product it is1347$\dim M+\dim P-\dim N$ whether or not the maps are transverse.1348 1349\begin{example}\label{ex:derived}1350(a) $M=\R$, $E$ trivial of rank $1$, $s=x^2$. The complex is $C^\infty(\R)\xrightarrow{x^2}C^\infty(\R)$, which1351is injective, so $\pi_1=0$ and $Z(s)$ is the classical object $\R[\varepsilon]/(\varepsilon^2)$ of virtual1352dimension $0$: not a manifold, and not derived either.1353 1354(b) $M=\pt$, $E=\R$, $s=0$. The complex is $\R\xrightarrow{0}\R$; $\pi_0=\pi_1=\R$. This is the point of1355virtual dimension $-1$ in \cref{tab:four}.1356 1357(c) $s=0$ on any $E\to M$: the algebra is $\Gamma(\Lambda^\bullet E^\vee)$ with zero differential, of virtual1358dimension $\dim M-k$. It is the derived self-intersection of the zero section, and by the tubular1359neighbourhood theorem the derived self-intersection of any submanifold with normal bundle $E$.1360 1361(d) The diagonal: $M\times^h_{M\times M}M$ has functions $\Gamma(\Lambda^\bullet T^*M)$, the differential forms1362placed in homological degrees, and virtual dimension $0$. Its ``number of points'' will turn out to be the1363Euler characteristic (\cref{ch:degree}).1364\end{example}1365 1366Every object of $\DMfd$ has a tangent complex at each point. For $X=M\times^h_NP$ at $(x,y)$ over $z$ it is1367\[\mathbb T_X=\bigl[T_xM\oplus T_yP\xrightarrow{\ df-dg\ }T_zN\bigr]\]1368in degrees $0$ and $1$, with $H^0$ the fibre product of tangent spaces and $H^1$ the fibre of the excess1369bundle. Its Euler characteristic is the virtual dimension.1370 1371\begin{theorem}[Transversality, derived form]\label{thm:derivedtrans}\Srf[\cite{Spi10}, \cite{CS19}]1372For smooth maps $f\colon M\to N$ and $g\colon P\to N$, the derived fibre product $M\times^h_NP$ lies in the1373essential image of $i\colon\Mfd\to\DMfd$ if and only if $f\trans g$.1374\end{theorem}1375 1376\begin{proof}1377If $f\trans g$, then $i$ preserves the fibre product by \cref{thm:CS}. Conversely, if1378$M\times^h_NP\simeq i(Z)$ for a manifold $Z$, its tangent complex is concentrated in degree $0$ at every1379point, so $H^1=T_zN/(df\,T_xM+dg\,T_yP)$ vanishes at every point of the fibre product, which is1380transversality.1381\end{proof}1382 1383Compare the situation in $\Mfd$. There a fibre product may fail to exist, or exist and be wrong, or exist1384and be right without one's knowing which. In $\DMfd$ it always exists and is always right, and it is a1385manifold in exactly the transverse case.1386 1387\section{Genericity as a statement about derived manifolds}1388 1389\begin{theorem}\label{thm:spivak}\Sli[Spivak \cite{Spi10}]1390Compact derived manifolds that are locally derived zero loci have a cobordism theory, and1391$i$ induces an isomorphism from the cobordism ring of manifolds to it. In particular a compact1392$X=M\times^h_NP$ has a class $[X]$ in the cobordism group $\mathfrak N_d$ of dimension1393$d=\dim M+\dim P-\dim N$ (\cref{ch:cobordism}), represented by $M\times_NP'$ for any $g'\trans f$ sufficiently1394close to $g$.1395\end{theorem}1396 1397Surjectivity is the transversality theorem: perturb. Injectivity, and the independence of the perturbation,1398is \cref{lem:fibre} applied to a path of perturbations: the fibre product of the path with $A$ is a manifold1399with boundary whose two ends are the two candidates. Putting \cref{thm:CS,thm:derivedtrans,thm:spivak}1400together gives a statement of the method of the source that makes no mention of perturbation until the1401end.1402 1403\begin{principle}[Generic position]\label{prin:generic}\Srf[Hirsch, Ch.~3; \cite{Spi10}]1404Every finite diagram of manifolds has a limit in $\DMfd$. If the limit is compact it has a well-defined1405cobordism class. The class is represented by the honest limit of any sufficiently generic perturbation of1406the diagram, and two such representatives are cobordant by the limit of a generic path between the1407perturbations.1408\end{principle}1409 1410\begin{example}\label{ex:xsqagain}1411The zero set of $x^2-\varepsilon$ on $\R$, as an oriented $0$-manifold, is $\{+\sqrt\varepsilon\}$ with sign1412$+$ and $\{-\sqrt\varepsilon\}$ with sign $-$ for $\varepsilon>0$, and empty for $\varepsilon<0$. Both have1413class $0\in\Omega_0=\Z$, and the cobordism between them is the parabola $\{x^2=\varepsilon\}$ in the1414$(\varepsilon,x)$-plane, a manifold by \cref{lem:fibre}. The derived zero set at $\varepsilon=0$ is the dual1415numbers, with class $0$. Its length as an algebra is $2$, which is the count of complex roots; the1416cobordism class and the length are different invariants and only the first is stable under real1417perturbation.1418\end{example}1419 1420An object of negative virtual dimension, such as \cref{ex:derived}(b), has class zero for trivial reasons1421and is nevertheless not empty. The cobordism class is the part of a derived manifold that perturbation can1422reach, and it is the only part the classical theory uses.1423 1424\section*{Notes}1425 1426Transversality is Thom's; the parametric form and its use as the organizing principle are the substance of1427Hirsch's Chapter~3 and of Abraham's work. Derived manifolds were introduced by Spivak, after Lurie's sketch1428in his work on derived algebraic geometry; variants are due to Borisov and Noel and to Joyce, and the1429universal property is \cite{CS19}, building on \cite{Mac17}. Clean intersections are Bott's. The excess1430bundle and the associated formula are Quillen's in cobordism and Fulton--MacPherson's in algebraic