Indexed text attachment
differential-topology-in-higher-categories.tex
Source for Differential Topology in Higher Categories: Mapping Objects, Derived Intersections, Spaces of Choices, and Cobordism
View paper · Download original file
Lines 981–1080 of 3851. Source text is displayed literally.
981\begin{theorem}[Open conditions]\label{thm:open}\Scl[Hirsch 2.1.1--2.1.6]982For $r\ge1$ the sets of immersions, submersions, embeddings, closed embeddings and diffeomorphisms are open983in $C^r_S(M,N)$. For $r\ge0$ the set of proper maps is open in $C^r_S(M,N)$.984\end{theorem}985 986\begin{example}\label{ex:weakfail}987Let $\beta\ge0$ be a bump function on $\R$ supported in $[-1,1]$, with maximum at $0$ and $\max\beta'=1$, and put988$g_n(x)=x-2\beta(x-n)$. Then $g_n$ agrees with the identity on $[-n+1,n-1]$, so $g_n\to\id$ in $C^\infty_W(\R,\R)$;989but $g_n'=1-2\beta'(x-n)$ takes the value $-1$, so no $g_n$ is a diffeomorphism or even an immersion. The990set of diffeomorphisms of $\R$ is not weakly open. In the strong topology $g_n$ does not converge to the991identity: the neighbourhood $\{g:|g(x)-x|<\beta(0)e^{-x^2}\}$ contains none of them. The script confirms both992statements numerically.993\end{example}994 995\begin{theorem}[Approximation]\label{thm:approx}\Scl[Hirsch 2.2.6]996For $0\le r<s\le\infty$, $C^s(M,N)$ is dense in $C^r_S(M,N)$. If $f$ is already $C^s$ on a neighbourhood of a997closed set $A$, the approximating maps may be taken to agree with $f$ on $A$.998\end{theorem}999 1000Since diffeomorphisms are open (\cref{thm:open}) and smooth maps are dense, a $C^r$ diffeomorphism can be1001approximated by a $C^\infty$ one once source and target carry compatible smooth structures; this is the main1002step in \cref{thm:smoothing}. The same two theorems give the first comparison of homotopy types.1003 1004\begin{corollary}\label{cor:homotopy}\Scl[Hirsch 5.1.5]1005Every continuous map between manifolds is homotopic to a smooth map, and two smooth maps that are1006continuously homotopic are smoothly homotopic.1007\end{corollary}1008 1009\section{The mapping object}1010 1011By \cref{thm:embed} the smooth set $[M,N]$ has as plots the smooth maps $F\colon\R^n\times M\to N$. A plot is1012a family $s\mapsto F_s$ of maps, smooth jointly in the parameter and the variable. Nothing is said about1013neighbourhoods. A topology can be recovered from the plots, as for any smooth set.1014 1015\begin{definition}\label{def:Dtop}1016A set $A$ of points of a smooth set $X$ is \term{$D$-open} if $p^{-1}(A)\subset\R^n$ is open for every plot1017$p$ of $X$. A subobject of $X$ is $D$-open if its set of points is and it contains every plot whose points1018lie in it.1019\end{definition}1020 1021\begin{theorem}\label{thm:CSW}\Sli[Christensen--Sinnamon--Wu \cite{CSW14}]1022On $C^\infty(M,N)$ the $D$-topology of the mapping object $[M,N]$ is finer than the weak topology and coarser1023than the strong topology. If $M$ is compact all three coincide.1024\end{theorem}1025 1026The first inequality says that a smooth family is continuous into the weak topology, which is easy. The1027second says that a $D$-open set is strongly open, which is not. For non-compact $M$ the second is not an1028equality: a plot $\R\to[M,N]$ is in particular a path, and paths in the strong topology are very restricted.1029 1030\begin{proposition}\label{prop:strongpath}\Scl1031Let $M$ be non-compact. If $t\mapsto f_t$ is a continuous path in $C^0_S(M,N)$, there is a compact $K\subset M$1032such that $f_t=f_0$ outside $K$ for all $t\in[0,1]$.1033\end{proposition}1034 1035So the path components of $C^\infty_S(M,N)$ are far smaller than homotopy classes1036(\cref{exer:strongpath}), and the strong topology does not compute the homotopy type of anything one wants.1037It is a device for stating that a set of maps is large.1038 1039\section{The homotopy type of a space of maps}1040 1041The homotopy type attached to the mapping object is its shape (\cref{def:shape}). By \cref{thm:shape} it is1042the realization of the simplicial set $k\mapsto C^\infty(\Delta^k_e\times M,N)$, whose vertices are smooth1043maps, whose edges are smooth homotopies, and so on.1044 1045\begin{theorem}[Shape of mapping objects]\label{thm:oka}\Sli[Berwick-Evans--Boavida de Brito--Pavlov1046\cite{BEBP24}, Thm.~1.1]1047For a manifold $M$ and any $F\in\mathbf{H}$ the natural map1048\[\Pi[M,F]\ \longrightarrow\ \Map(\Pi M,\Pi F)\]1049is an equivalence of spaces. In particular $\Pi[M,N]\simeq\Map(M,N)$, the space of continuous maps, for1050manifolds $M$ and $N$.1051\end{theorem}1052 1053For $F=N$ a manifold and $M$ compact this is classical, and it is a parametrized form of1054\cref{cor:homotopy}. In general it is a recent theorem, and it will be used in \cref{ch:bundles} with $F$ a1055stack of bundles. On $\pi_0$ it says that concordance classes of sections of $F$ over $M$ are homotopy1056classes of maps from $M$ to the space $\Pi F$. The hypothesis that $M$ is a manifold cannot be dropped;1057what is used is that $M$ has partitions of unity and is locally contractible, which is where the analysis1058of this chapter enters.1059 1060\begin{remark}\label{rem:sing}1061Concordance is an equivalence relation on the points of any smooth set, but transitivity is not1062automatic: two plots $\R\to X$ that agree at a point need not glue to a plot. One reparametrizes so that1063each is constant near the ends (\cref{exer:sitting}). The same device makes the smooth singular complex a1064Kan complex.1065\end{remark}1066 1067\section{Subobjects cut out by open conditions}1068 1069\begin{definition}\label{def:emb}1070$\Imm(M,N)$, $\Emb(M,N)$ and $\Diff(M)$ are the subobjects of $[M,N]$ (of $[M,M]$) whose plots are the1071families $F\colon\R^n\times M\to N$ such that every $F_s$ is an immersion, an embedding, a diffeomorphism.1072\end{definition}1073 1074For non-compact $M$ this definition of $\Emb$ is the weakest reasonable one, and there are others (requiring1075$(s,x)\mapsto(s,F_s(x))$ to be an embedding, or requiring compact support). For compact $M$ they agree.1076 1077\begin{proposition}\label{prop:Dopen}\Srf[Hirsch 2.1.1--2.1.6]1078If $M$ is compact, $\Imm(M,N)$, $\Emb(M,N)$ and $\Diff(M)$ are $D$-open subobjects of the mapping object.1079That is: in a smooth family of maps from a compact manifold, the set of parameters at which the map is an1080immersion (an embedding, a diffeomorphism) is open.